Christel Stoddard

Hands down the best pizza on the Island! Antipasto is to die for, absolutely perfect! I have yet to be disappointed with anything I have eaten here! It's my go-to comfort food. I could eat here every day of the week, and have a happy belly... Angelo and his team no how to keep you coming back for more!

+3

Melanie Retamar

Everything about this pizzeria is the best! Hands down best tasting sauce, crust, cheese, just everything ! If you want to try something really delicious, my favorite is always a pie with peppers and meatballs ! Angelo is very kind as well and I have never had an issue with this pizzeria. Worth every dime! This place is a MUST TRY AND MUST HAVE! Sincerely one of your favorite customers , Melanie :)

8peasant8

Great food and amazing service! Our waiter, Anthony, was so sweet and so diligent in making sure my family and I were having a good time. The food was very filling but very good.

Jaime Brownell

I've been going to Tony's Brickoven for 20 years. I think they make almost the best pizza East of the S.I. Ferry Terminal on Bay St. They offer delicious deep pan pizzas like Chicken Marsala, and chicken Francaise, Grandmas, and sicilian. The platters and hot heros are just as good. Portions are generous and the service is very pleasant. Angelo, the owner is always friendly, pleasant and easy to talk to you. They have a decent sized dining area with about 12 tables or so.

RIV

I came in about 30 minutes till closing. They were already cleaning up but they had no problem serving me. I was still greeted politely and treated good. They let me know I can still order what ever I wanted it was no problem. Pizza was delicious

Joseph

Pizza is delicious, place is spotless and the staff couldn’t be nicer. Good bet for lunch if in the area

Thomas Boyd

So this place is nice to dine in and the owner is alright. My wife and I had a piece of pizza and I ordered an Italian Panini. My pizza was a thick crust vegetable and it was really good. My wife asked if the Margarita pizza sauce had a separate sauce but the owner played it off as it's normal to use the same sauce for everything as a standard, but we knew better.... The service was ok. The Panini was ok. I've been to Italy 4 times (if that matters). Not as good here but ok. I think you'll be delighted with the specialty pizzas here (except Margarita pizza if you're looking for authentic Italian (at least compared to Italy). Not an expert mind you, but my wife and I have been to Italy more than a few times and are always looking to experience Italy again wherever we go.

Spencer Montgomery

Did not specify on their website that the Tony's special pizza came with any particular toppings on it pre-customization so we ordered it with just pepperoni selected, and it came with a whole bunch of other toppings, including something someone in our household was allergic to. When we explained this to an employee over the phone, the guy immediately asked if we ordered online like this sort of thing happens all the time and said that's just how the Tony's special pizza comes, despite the site saying nothing regarding those toppings coming on the pizza. He was completely blasé and unapologetic about it, and said there was nothing they could do about it. It's completely reckless to have undisclosed toppings when ordering pizza from your website, I don't care if it's an understood thing amongst some of your customers that the Tony's special pizza denotes certain toppings. You can't just not list the other toppings that are gonna be on the pizza, especially if you give us the option to select all your usual toppings to add onto it like it's a blank pizza! Extremely disappointed, my family has had great experiences ordering in the past but a blasé, dismissive attitude about undisclosed allergens are a hard deal-breaker for us.

Matt Silva

I wanted to place an order for pick up. A gentleman answers the phone. I say hello I want to place an order for pick up. I say I want a Margherita but Sicilian. He answers me we don’t have a margherita Sicilian. A margherita is a round pie. Now, correct me if I am wrong but why can’t you make the pie in a square. The same way you would make the margherita in a circle? It obviously shows my ignorance with the type of pizzas they offer. Instead of trying to insult a potential customer and say out right we don’t have that. I said the menu online says the same ingredients as a margherita. I figured I tell him margherita sicilian because I didn’t want a traditional thick Sicilian. Then I said let me look on the menu. And the same ingredients are on the Sicilian as the margherita. I guess in his mind a margherita style can only be round and not Sicilian. It totally baffled me that he couldn’t just have taken my order. I had to hang up and not order and I won’t ever order from there again. I rather drive across the bridge into bk.

Olivia Ortiz

Coming from New York…it sucked, I’m writing this review for 2 people me and my man never again we ordered a buffalo pie not even a full pie it came with 6 slices which is a personal pie came out to almost 30$ and was a weird taste it had a sweet taste I never thought it would have in a buffalo pie…whatever it also was very soupy like they threw some sauce and a chicken and was like here u go, on top of that our total was 44$ I go into my app and it charged me 50$ total and no where on the receipt does it mention those extra charges coming from a local this place is nasty well that buffalo was… go take your business elsewhere to Frank’s pizza and get more for your money I never wrote a bad review on a pizza business but it had to be done to let people know what these reviews really are about Tony you should be ashamed of your business or do better