Wahoo's Fish Taco

I come here regularly. Slice, salad, and drink combo is ALWAYS excellent! Quality ingredients. Service is also great! This place is one of Tustin's best kept secrets. Highly recommend!

Love the pizza here, light not doughy like all other California shops. Good sauce, great toppings! If your from outside of SoCal, you enjoy but if your a local just go to Pizza Hut! :p

Excellent Pizza!!! Really nice people I highly recommend this place to anyone reading this.

For $9.68 you get a large fresh salad, a giant slice of NY style pizza and a canned drink. It's a great deal and good food. I will definitely be back.

Best Brooklyn Pizza.... Best Pizza Period. Better than any Brooklyn Pizza I had in Brooklyn! To Die For!! 💕💕💕💕💕

I went into Pizza Factory with low expectations, I ordered a lage pepperoni and bacon pizza and man was I happy to have had that. It has been a few hours since I ate it but I am still thinking about that pizza. With what I see as the perfectly cooked pizza crust and strong held, but savoring cheese being ready out of the oven, the topings only made the best even better with the bacon tasting like it came fresh out of the pan and pepperoni tasting exactly what I want pepperoni to taste like. This is a pizza that I would take over any mainstream pizza place. My friend even realized that I was writing this review and said "oh yea, that pizza was freaking awesome dude." So there you have it.

Nice little spot, you can get a big slice with a topping or two for less than $5. And it tastes great! Staff was friendly as well. Overall a good, chill pizza experience

New York vibes, amazing pizza and perfect crust

greatest pizza in town. better than other pizza chains. Crust is excellent and taste amazing. it's even great cold. Awesome customer service and they remember how you like your pizza. KOSHER/HALAL

This place never misses, always 🔥🔥🔥 The service is great, the prices are kinda high (much like everything nowadays) but the pizza is the BEST IN THE OC 🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽 Love this place!

Used coupon 1st timer here. 2 Start service v friendly, food really great n price more than reasonable! And n parting this is the first calzone I had in 10 yrs worth it's weight. Greek salad w chkn w yummy too. I'm sold n coming back soon. Should've got a canole also.

Very good was expecting ready made slices like in NY. Had a fresh hot slice made to order giant slice like NY crispy full of flavor closed my eyes thought I was in Times Square for a second that good just like NY if not better.

I got a pepperoni slice and it was legit so good I saved this place in my Google maps, idk what happened to other people's pizzas review but mine was 10/10

HIGHLY recommend this place. Pizza had 0 flop, perfectly cooked and the crust was stellar. Pizza a solid 8.5/10, wings were perfect, and garlic knots were tasty.

Ordered a cheeseless, gluten free pizza. Liked how crunchy the crust was and the toppings were evenly distributed and delicious, they definitely didn't skimp on the toppings like some places do. Pizza was ready in about 10 minutes. Will definitely come back again.

One of the bests NY style pizza out here in the West. Loved that they serve it well done. But albeit, may be too well done. I want to be able to eat the end crust of my pizza but it got too tough at the end. The meat that came with out pizza was juicyyy though, it kept on exploding into my face. Hahahaha Overall, 10/10 will order again.

Murray Frost

HIGHLY recommend this place. Pizza had 0 flop, perfectly cooked and the crust was stellar. Pizza a solid 8.5/10, wings were perfect, and garlic knots were tasty.

Alaina Nunez

Ordered a cheeseless, gluten free pizza. Liked how crunchy the crust was and the toppings were evenly distributed and delicious, they definitely didn't skimp on the toppings like some places do. Pizza was ready in about 10 minutes. Will definitely come back again.

J F

One of the bests NY style pizza out here in the West. Loved that they serve it well done. But albeit, may be too well done. I want to be able to eat the end crust of my pizza but it got too tough at the end. The meat that came with out pizza was juicyyy though, it kept on exploding into my face. Hahahaha Overall, 10/10 will order again.

Superb thin crust pizza. Perfectly cooked, not greasy and fresh ingredients. My favorite pizza place

Fast, solid, good priced pizza. Will be coming back.

I have orders from.this place from Uber eats 4 times. The pizza is great..i highly recommend anything with vegetables on it, it brings out the flavor more. Anything just meat can be overwhelming on the stomach. However, the dough is light, delicious, and the cheese is just the perfect combination. The flavors mix well without feeling too full or overwhelmed with grease or specific flavors. The prices are more than reasonable and the the speed of which ordered are done is incredible. The customer service is on point.

Just discovered this fabulous pizza place offering classic thin crust and offering whole pizza or by the slice. Owned by a father/son duo, they offer a variety of toppings, very reasonable prices, and very fast service. I discovered this place on Wednesday and went back Thurs, Fri, and Sun! I'm taking everyone I know!

Saw a TikTok video about double decker pizza and was inspired for a new York pizza experience! This place didn't disappoint. The crust was perfect and just the right amount of toppings and sauce. Will most definitely be coming back.

I love this place down!!!! The guy at the front is so chill, patent,kind and honest even when I take several minutes to decide on my order and I literally dream about their slices when I'm going about my day. This is definitely the spot!! And the portion sizes vs the price and quality??!! Impressive!

Love their pizza options and their slices are HUGE! The staff is really friendly and the place is nice and clean! Long time customer here for sure!

Love this place! Definitely our favorite!! I only wish they made the NY style double decker pizza that’s all over TikTok….hopefully one day! 😏🙏🏻

We had some time to kill while waiting at another restaurant in the plaza and decided to swing by here for a slice and some garlic knots. I am so happy we stumbled upon New York Pizza! The pizza is so good and made to order. Great undercarriage, no sag, and the perfect amount of sauce to cheese. The lady who works here made us feel like family and was accommodating. It was really great food and I can’t wait to come back for more!

Walked into New York Pizza in Tustin and immediately time-traveled to 1998. You sit, you fold, you question your life choices, and then you keep eating because it actually hits… 🗽

Arturo Palma

Fast, solid, good priced pizza. Will be coming back.

Joseph Tran

Walked into New York Pizza in Tustin and immediately time-traveled to 1998. You sit, you fold, you question your life choices, and then you keep eating because it actually hits… 🗽

Neel D

Love their pizza options and their slices are HUGE! The staff is really friendly and the place is nice and clean! Long time customer here for sure!

Angel Tibeihaho

I love this place down!!!! The guy at the front is so chill, patent,kind and honest even when I take several minutes to decide on my order and I literally dream about their slices when I'm going about my day. This is definitely the spot!! And the portion sizes vs the price and quality??!! Impressive!

K B

Love this place! Definitely our favorite!! I only wish they made the NY style double decker pizza that’s all over TikTok….hopefully one day! 😏🙏🏻

SALIGATOR

Superb thin crust pizza. Perfectly cooked, not greasy and fresh ingredients. My favorite pizza place

BRYAN PENA

Saw a TikTok video about double decker pizza and was inspired for a new York pizza experience! This place didn't disappoint. The crust was perfect and just the right amount of toppings and sauce. Will most definitely be coming back.

Arthur Chen

We had some time to kill while waiting at another restaurant in the plaza and decided to swing by here for a slice and some garlic knots. I am so happy we stumbled upon New York Pizza! The pizza is so good and made to order. Great undercarriage, no sag, and the perfect amount of sauce to cheese. The lady who works here made us feel like family and was accommodating. It was really great food and I can’t wait to come back for more!

Pouyan Golshani

Fantastic food. I've ordered from here dozens of times. This last time, I ordered 15 pizzas, all prepared as ordered and exactly on time. Great service and great food 👌

Eva

NY pizza is the one kids request I don’t say ‘no’ to… it’s always fresh and delicious. And don’t forget the yummy breadsticks and tiramisu for dessert 👍 Always happy with food and friendly customer service!

The service & pizza is good. It tastes fresh as well.

My boys loved the pizza. Thanks. Very delicious

Ramiro Gonzalez

My boys loved the pizza. Thanks. Very delicious

(after reading all 75 of your reviews I'm 100% certain you paid for positive reviews) I've had authentic new York pizza, and this isn't it!! Sure the thin crust was on point, and the cheese was getting there(needed a bit more) but the sauce? Was there any? If there was i couldn't taste it. Sure, go light, but barely existent with no flavor? Come on!! (Original review) Honestly not worth the price. Pizza was bland, they charged $1.50 for a small 2oz cup of hidden valley ranch. It honestly upset me pretty badly. In regards to your response below: from a business standpoint, vague generic promises that you're "fixing it" doesn't exactly win my business back. (This is of course only my opinion). If you're sincerely wanting to gain my business back(which you indicate in almost all your bad reviews), maybe some incentive would be a better strategy? Both from a marketing stand point and integral? Fix the pizza, bring upset customers in for a free slice? Sure you take the loss of what? Maybe $3 for the slice? Not bad seeing i took the loss of $30 for a delivered XL pizza that was awful. Maybe they come in and take you up on it, most people won't, but It wins you more stars, a loyal customer for the ones that do, and shows everyone else reading these reviews that you're committed to customer satisfaction. Sure, you can't please everyone. But what i experienced seems like you weren't worried about satisfying anyone. The Ken's/hidden valley ranch, and bland pizza is the evidence. For $1 a packet, and $2 8oz cup of sour cream i can get 8oz of restaurant quality ranch at the grocery store for half the price of what i paid with you. Same thing with spices in the sauce (which was non existent in the pie). I get it. trust me I do. People go on these reviews to troll, but I don't. I take this time to help businesses strive to become better. But it seems like businesses these days just want to take advantage of people and are satisfied with the people's business that are too ignorant or lazy to go elsewhere. It's in your hands. Fix it, or don't. Either way, until I'm persuaded to, I personally won't be back. Ps i wanted to give you 1*, but the gentleman on the phone, and the delivery man were both extremely customer service oriented. That extra star was for them.

I don't understand why everyone gives it 5 stars. Maybe its because I enjoy making homemade pizzas. But the crust was so thin I couldn't eat it without the toppings falling off and in terms of toppings it was lacking. Total cost was 16$ for a 3 topping large pizza. Also the cheese tasted weird, as if it had this vanilla flavor. I should have taken a pictures. Sorry folks, not worth it. Go to Dominos or Round table in the area they are good.

Friendly staff but pizza is very salty and small, not New York pizza. I bought a large and ate 6 very small slices and I wasn't even full and too salty to eat it all. Price is not good for the size but looks good on menu. Don't be deceived.

Pizza is not the best, some crunch to it. Hardly any sauce, easy on the cheese with a thin crust. 1.9 stars from me but I rounded up.

Sergio L

Friendly staff but pizza is very salty and small, not New York pizza. I bought a large and ate 6 very small slices and I wasn't even full and too salty to eat it all. Price is not good for the size but looks good on menu. Don't be deceived.

Gabino Alarcon

Pizza is not the best, some crunch to it. Hardly any sauce, easy on the cheese with a thin crust. 1.9 stars from me but I rounded up.

Super friendly service but jeez that Italian sub was not great. I’ve never seen an Italian sub served hot, but this one was, and there was absolutely nothing to moisten it up. No dressing or any kind of condiments. I tried to salvage it but I just couldn’t enjoy it. I should have just gotten a slice of pizza and called it a day…

kandyce segovia

Super friendly service but jeez that Italian sub was not great. I’ve never seen an Italian sub served hot, but this one was, and there was absolutely nothing to moisten it up. No dressing or any kind of condiments. I tried to salvage it but I just couldn’t enjoy it. I should have just gotten a slice of pizza and called it a day…

pizza was super salty! nothin like a ny slice. this place has nothing compared to a new york pizzeria. whomever rated this a 4 or 5 star must have been a family or relative because the food was not good at all.

Younger gentleman who took my order was not so pleasant and after tasting the pizza I wont be back. 2 "new york style" pizzas cut into 8 slices. Bad tasting..

Helo guys (Aslam-oAlikm) if some one want to go there for only halal food then let me tell you it's not. We went there bcz which hotel we stayed in Disneyland trip it popped up as halal food but when we been there they served also pork ,bacon & paporni and why on your website wrote all halal then said it's old website. So save your time and don't go there.

Nothing New York. Pizza was extremely salty. Tiramisu was frozen. Why? So frozen it had freezer burn. Nooo come on folks. Don't call it New York!

I am kind of upset I paid $40 a pizza with almost no ingredients. I ordered green peppers, pepperoni, mushrooms and jalapeños.

Gulsoom Alokozay

I am kind of upset I paid $40 a pizza with almost no ingredients. I ordered green peppers, pepperoni, mushrooms and jalapeños.

Disappointing Experience at NY Pizza in Tustin I recently visited NY Pizza in Tustin and unfortunately had a less-than-pleasant experience. The pizza I received had numerous bubbles with uneven cheese distribution, and when I brought it to the attention of the attendant, the resolution offered was a simple apology and a complimentary soda. While the gesture was appreciated, it didn't address the core issue – the pizza itself. Moreover, the french fries I ordered were subpar, appearing half-cooked and resembling something cooked in an air fryer. I expected better quality considering it's a pizza place. Regrettably, I won't be returning to NY Pizza. My hope is that this serves as constructive feedback for the restaurant. It's essential to prioritize quality food and service to ensure customer satisfaction and repeat business. Ignoring such issues could lead to a decline in customers, as not everyone may vocalize their dissatisfaction. I encourage the restaurant to take this advice to heart and make the necessary improvements for the sake of their reputation and customer loyalty. I'm requesting a full refund

King Kong appetite! But left disappointed on ingredients. Hardly any sauce and cheese on my slice. I tried paying several times for extra and still had bubbles(Pizza lovers know what I’m talking about) on my pizza. It’s great here, at least add on for what I ask. I’d love to have a full slice if you know what I mean. Not to mention this place has a small delivery radius. Have to order through a sub-contractor and pizza is usually 2 out of 5 heat temperature. Will continue to order here til otherwise. Thanks Guys.

MIKE S (Mike)

Disappointing Experience at NY Pizza in Tustin I recently visited NY Pizza in Tustin and unfortunately had a less-than-pleasant experience. The pizza I received had numerous bubbles with uneven cheese distribution, and when I brought it to the attention of the attendant, the resolution offered was a simple apology and a complimentary soda. While the gesture was appreciated, it didn't address the core issue – the pizza itself. Moreover, the french fries I ordered were subpar, appearing half-cooked and resembling something cooked in an air fryer. I expected better quality considering it's a pizza place. Regrettably, I won't be returning to NY Pizza. My hope is that this serves as constructive feedback for the restaurant. It's essential to prioritize quality food and service to ensure customer satisfaction and repeat business. Ignoring such issues could lead to a decline in customers, as not everyone may vocalize their dissatisfaction. I encourage the restaurant to take this advice to heart and make the necessary improvements for the sake of their reputation and customer loyalty. I'm requesting a full refund

Joe Rivas

King Kong appetite! But left disappointed on ingredients. Hardly any sauce and cheese on my slice. I tried paying several times for extra and still had bubbles(Pizza lovers know what I’m talking about) on my pizza. It’s great here, at least add on for what I ask. I’d love to have a full slice if you know what I mean. Not to mention this place has a small delivery radius. Have to order through a sub-contractor and pizza is usually 2 out of 5 heat temperature. Will continue to order here til otherwise. Thanks Guys.