Mythic Pizza

Best pizza place on Haight! They're open until 2 AM which is the perfect time to get pizza after getting drinks at Danny Coyle's. Reccomend!

best pesto pizza in the city, vibes are excellent,

Great value, great and clutch hours. I wish they'd be more reasonable with the topping prices but I guess that's how they make margins work. The service is always fast and customized.

Listen here, I absolutely adore Mythic Pizza. You had to be worthy just to taste Mythic’ slices, understand me? This location is not allowed to close… buy a slice! Buy a slice! Buy all the slices!

Always amazing pizza. The dough is cooked to perfection and you get alot out of a medium sized pie. I literally always stop by here everytime i make my way into town. Its my new tradition. And you know the saying that pizza tastes better cold the day after... Well this one actually does!

Super tasty the mythic slice, great price for size of slice. Super fast delivery. Def coming back!

I ordered a half and half XL pizza from here yesterday. This is my new spot from here on. The pizza took about 25 minutes to make, and was perfectly cooked. I’m not typically a pepperoni person but in this case, I was impressed. As for the crust and cheese, I appreciated that it did not have a sour or play dough flavor that I often find. An updated photo for the menu would be helpful. The prices have changed and the XL pizza is now $33.

Great spot for a slice, or a whole pie. Staff is great. Prices are fair, and they're open late. Everything is made fresh, unlike a lot of other places nearby.

I had a great dinner at Mythic Pizza tonight. I ordered two slices, the Tijuana and the Mythic. Both slices were piled high with toppings and I felt like I got my money's worth. To be clear the toppings didn't overwhelm the crust or leave the crust soggy infact its one of the tastiest crusts I've ever had (I normally discard the crust) it was crispy and buttery and reminded me of morning toast I used to have as a kid. The picture is a slice of the Tijuana 🤤🍕 I'm excited to try their other offerings and would recommend their pizza if you're in the lower Haight!

Outstanding large slices at great prices. Can’t ask for much better. Gotta love the local spots.

Amazing experience the food is top-tier and the sauce is a secret ingredient that nobody knows

Mermaid

Super tasty the mythic slice, great price for size of slice. Super fast delivery. Def coming back!

M

I ordered a half and half XL pizza from here yesterday. This is my new spot from here on. The pizza took about 25 minutes to make, and was perfectly cooked. I’m not typically a pepperoni person but in this case, I was impressed. As for the crust and cheese, I appreciated that it did not have a sour or play dough flavor that I often find. An updated photo for the menu would be helpful. The prices have changed and the XL pizza is now $33.

Neal

Great spot for a slice, or a whole pie. Staff is great. Prices are fair, and they're open late. Everything is made fresh, unlike a lot of other places nearby.

Jayden Curry

I had a great dinner at Mythic Pizza tonight. I ordered two slices, the Tijuana and the Mythic. Both slices were piled high with toppings and I felt like I got my money's worth. To be clear the toppings didn't overwhelm the crust or leave the crust soggy infact its one of the tastiest crusts I've ever had (I normally discard the crust) it was crispy and buttery and reminded me of morning toast I used to have as a kid. The picture is a slice of the Tijuana 🤤🍕 I'm excited to try their other offerings and would recommend their pizza if you're in the lower Haight!

Bryce T

Amazing experience the food is top-tier and the sauce is a secret ingredient that nobody knows

Matthew Vitale

Outstanding large slices at great prices. Can’t ask for much better. Gotta love the local spots.

Some of the best, most reliable delivery pizza in the city. Consistently good, and has saved me many late nights. Great salads, too.

I ordered a Meat Lovers Deep Dish! It was Well Cooked, Running over with Meat and Vegetables! The Taste was Very Well Seasoned with a subdued tinge of Sweetness that I found Unique and very Tasty! The Hot Wings were Perfect! The entire meal was surprisingly Satisfying and Delicious! Also; The Delivery Driver was Polite, Professional, Courteous and most importantly.... On Time!! Excellent Service!👍👍👍👍👍

Loved it. Open late. Tasty as can be. Some of the best pizza by the slice I've ever had.

I had to take my partner to the ER and it was really scary for both of us. By the time we got out we needed some food (stat!) but it was late enough that almost everything was closed. We settled on Mystic Pizza and it ended up being the best possible split second decision! It's funny how the best places are always found by accident. True to the name, there is a mystic amount of pizza options including a few veggie options! We, however, opted to try their wings, chicken parm sandwich, and some garlic bread-- I know I was just there but my stomach rumbles whenever I think about it! So good, and made great leftovers-- big portions for the win! Definitely worth the price, we college students thank you, Mystic Pizza. Will be returning on less dire circumstances to try those slices! :)

The meatball sub is *heavenly*. The bread tastes homemade, so fluffy and soft with just enough crunch on the crust. The tomato sauce tastes tangy and fresh. And the size is super generous - at least 12 inches. You won't be disappointed.

I think this is the best by the slice pizza I've eaten in SF so far. They have 10-12 different flavors you can do by the slice. The crust, both the bottom of the pizza and ends, are crispy and light. Excellent lil slice of pizza

Underrated solid slice shop. Hot. Good.

I have eaten her many times and it never disappoints. Absolutely 💯 hands down delicious. I get the majestic slice and it’s loaded with pepperoni, cheese. Salami, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and I added garlic it’s so fresh piping hot and the best thing is that have the guys slice my one slice in two halves because the slices are huge. Thank you guys for delicious flavorful pizza and always wonderful customer service. One of my favorite pizza spots.

Delightful pizza made fresh, even by the slice. I was happy with the recommendation to try the Mythic pizza slice versus the San Francisco. I devoured the Mythic slice, so thank you. I shall return to dive deeper into the menu. Thank you!

I used to write this place off but they’ve changed their firing process and it now hits - near perfect thin crust slices. Best with a beer from toro next door

Angel Robinson-Jackson

I have eaten her many times and it never disappoints. Absolutely 💯 hands down delicious. I get the majestic slice and it’s loaded with pepperoni, cheese. Salami, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers and I added garlic it’s so fresh piping hot and the best thing is that have the guys slice my one slice in two halves because the slices are huge. Thank you guys for delicious flavorful pizza and always wonderful customer service. One of my favorite pizza spots.

Christopher Johnson

Delightful pizza made fresh, even by the slice. I was happy with the recommendation to try the Mythic pizza slice versus the San Francisco. I devoured the Mythic slice, so thank you. I shall return to dive deeper into the menu. Thank you!

Kyle Barlow

Underrated solid slice shop. Hot. Good.

Sage Chilcote-Wade

best pesto pizza in the city, vibes are excellent,

Aditya Mukerji

I used to write this place off but they’ve changed their firing process and it now hits - near perfect thin crust slices. Best with a beer from toro next door

Andy Eblin

Some of the best, most reliable delivery pizza in the city. Consistently good, and has saved me many late nights. Great salads, too.

brookefromearth

Loved it. Open late. Tasty as can be. Some of the best pizza by the slice I've ever had.

Jubin “jpakdel” Pakdel

I think this is the best by the slice pizza I've eaten in SF so far. They have 10-12 different flavors you can do by the slice. The crust, both the bottom of the pizza and ends, are crispy and light. Excellent lil slice of pizza

Lian

The meatball sub is *heavenly*. The bread tastes homemade, so fluffy and soft with just enough crunch on the crust. The tomato sauce tastes tangy and fresh. And the size is super generous - at least 12 inches. You won't be disappointed.

Echo Osso

I had to take my partner to the ER and it was really scary for both of us. By the time we got out we needed some food (stat!) but it was late enough that almost everything was closed. We settled on Mystic Pizza and it ended up being the best possible split second decision! It's funny how the best places are always found by accident. True to the name, there is a mystic amount of pizza options including a few veggie options! We, however, opted to try their wings, chicken parm sandwich, and some garlic bread-- I know I was just there but my stomach rumbles whenever I think about it! So good, and made great leftovers-- big portions for the win! Definitely worth the price, we college students thank you, Mystic Pizza. Will be returning on less dire circumstances to try those slices! :)

Stenis Mingo

I ordered a Meat Lovers Deep Dish! It was Well Cooked, Running over with Meat and Vegetables! The Taste was Very Well Seasoned with a subdued tinge of Sweetness that I found Unique and very Tasty! The Hot Wings were Perfect! The entire meal was surprisingly Satisfying and Delicious! Also; The Delivery Driver was Polite, Professional, Courteous and most importantly.... On Time!! Excellent Service!👍👍👍👍👍

A lovely hole in the wall pizza stop. Slices are generous. Pizza is pretty darn good - not too thin. Not too doughy. And not too greasy. Satisfied for an occasional weekend stop.

Ahhh Mythic. When I used to live in the Haight - this was the end of night spot for me almost every night. The pizza is great. The slices are well sized and it's a walk in walk out kind of place. Mmmm.... I miss me a Mythic slice!

Excellent pizza, interesting toppings. The location was great and the service friendly. Would definitely come back to this place again.

The perfect post-drinking pizza. It's all about the toppings here. They don't skimp, and you can see and taste each individual layer. For ~$5, one slice is enough if you load up on toppings. They have a sign up that says your slice will be ready in 2 minutes. Sometimes it seems that only 2 minutes have passed between ordering and attacking the slice, but other times a little bit longer.

Great place to grab a quick slice. They have a huge menu of pre-made slices or you can make your own. I always see the same people working and every time they they are extremely nice.

Nicholas Carnevali

Great place to grab a quick slice. They have a huge menu of pre-made slices or you can make your own. I always see the same people working and every time they they are extremely nice.

You get a good decent slice of pizza when you want it. Like any other by-the-slice place the pizza tastes much better when it's fresh which you only get if you order your own pie. Why complain? Good pizza, reasonable price, fast service, friendly staff. Who could ask for anything more?

When will I stop being dissapointed by San Francisco pizza? I guess if you're drunk and its late and you just need a slice to soak up the alcohol as you stumble to/from Lower Haight bars, then Mythic will do the trick. It wasn't terrible, its just not great. Pizza in a pinch, but not a destination in its own right.

For some reason all the sandwiches are automatically toasted and burnt

Very Mediocre slices for $5-$6 each. Open late is the only thing going for this place

I honestly ordered it because it had good reviews on GrubHub and Domino's was already closed. The dough is undercooked, and there's too much cheese. Bland even with the toppings I chose.

The pizza was terrible. The crust was poorly made, and when I ordered a slice a few months ago, it fell apart the moment I picked it up. I asked the guy at the counter why it was so sloppy, and he said it was NY Style Pizza, not realizing I used to live there and knew it wasn’t authentic NY Style Pizza at all—just badly made. I never went back and wouldn’t recommend it. Instead, try Seniore's Pizza, just down the road.

A C

The pizza was terrible. The crust was poorly made, and when I ordered a slice a few months ago, it fell apart the moment I picked it up. I asked the guy at the counter why it was so sloppy, and he said it was NY Style Pizza, not realizing I used to live there and knew it wasn’t authentic NY Style Pizza at all—just badly made. I never went back and wouldn’t recommend it. Instead, try Seniore's Pizza, just down the road.

BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE! I hardly ever give bad reviews, but this time... Ordered 2 pizzas, both arrived completely smashed, one had pepperoni on it although we didn't ordered and we're vegetarian. Ended up throwing them both away.. When we contacted them, the said that they can't confirm that and we never got any refund back. So many better alternatives in the city, spare you dollars...

We loved this place until recently. Twice now our order never came leaving us hungry and unhappy. Not sure what happened, maybe new owners or bad driver's but after ordering here for over 6 years we will now take our business elsewhere.

Pizza was horrendous. They did not cook the pizza all the way, it was very doughy. The toppings were not fresh. And the sauce just tasted bland. An extra ranch was $1.00 for gross old ranch. Never again.

I order pizza for delivery and then the guy say they pizza coming in 45 minutes they taking so long after that the driver coming with not correct change and then the pizza coming very cold I live ifive blocks away from the place. Bad costumer service too

i’ve never left a review before but had such an awful experience here that i have to. got food poisoning for a few days from their Mythic pizza. i felt so sick i lost a night of sleep and a day of work. they must have hygiene issues or just don’t care if the meat gets old.

TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!! There was no zero star option so they got lucky with one star. This was my first experience here. I ordered a veggie slice and when I got home and opened the box, my pizza had sausage all over it. I walked back and showed the guy working and he told me I ordered a different slice that came with meat. I've been a vegetarian for 7 years. I clearly didn't order a meat pizza. In his situation the worst thing a waiter can do is tell you you were at wrong and at fault. What a classic childish move. I have zero tolerance and no respect for people who live their lives like that. Especially when you're in the service industry. The pizza isn't even good. Save yourself the trouble and buy some pizza dough and create your own experience at home.

Average food, below average service. I asked if I Could sit and eat around midnight. The owner said I could. I had just started eating a lukewarm chicken parmigiana sandwich when an employee began insisting I leave and when I explained that the owner gave me permission he persisted in demanding I go. As I was leaving , the owner said I could stay but I felt completely unwelcome and walked out and ate my average sandwich on a park bench on a cold October night.

I wish he offered me sauce with my calzone. Or perhaps it wasn’t included. I don’t know. I probably won’t be going back here.

kat kirkland

i’ve never left a review before but had such an awful experience here that i have to. got food poisoning for a few days from their Mythic pizza. i felt so sick i lost a night of sleep and a day of work. they must have hygiene issues or just don’t care if the meat gets old.