This place is awesome! Delicious food, quick service, and friendly!

Lots of choices, perfectly warmed and served. Great place and people

Great thin crust pizza!

Great pizza. Love the big slices!

Love the food only wish they deliver north as far as AACS. It would be easier n faster than delivery to ie.upper college drive dorms.

Best pizza slices around! Great service!

Dropped off my son at Alfred and went to lunch there...really good pizza! Super nice staff!

Best tasting pizza around, huge slices and the meal deals are competitive with places like Subway and the Jet for meal size and price.

Good pizza and huge slices many options to choose from. You should definitely stop by

Great food and staff! The people working today were great! The food was great and worth the money! I highly recommend this place.

Great stuff! Fun staff. And let's talk about cooper buckley.... that guy... wow he saved me once from a burning building.

Great place to grab a pie with some wings on our way to camp. Always delicious

Good selection of pizza and other Italian specialities. Worker was nice and accommodating.

Slices are biggest and best around if you like thin crust.

Good spot for a slice!!

Great pizza, nice staff, would definitely come back again!

Great Slices! Amazing variety of massive slices!

Friendly staff, delicious pizza, and very reasonable prices!

Super huge slices, excellent flavor, try the breadsticks theyre amazing.

The food was great and the people there was wonderful with the people that come in.the prices are nice too.

Huge and delicious pizza slices. Love the owner!!

Good size slices for the price!! Tasty pizza and cheese sticks!!

Great pizza! It is a friendly place!

Amazing Pizza not much more I can say must-try

Always is a pleasure to stop when lm in town. Great people and service

Awesome staff! Great food, slices are huge!

Delicious pizza, fast and friendly staff!

This pizza and the outdoor seating. The perfect place for a summer date!!

Stopped to get a quick bite before dropping off my son and his friend back at SUNY Alfred. Conveniently location close by, the pizza slices are big and absolutely delicious. The kids had meat lover while I had a veggie pizza. They have lunch specials for one slice or two slices plus drink. Definitely will be stopping by again next time I visit SUNY Alfred.

'A blast from the past'! Use to eat here when I attended Alfred State College. I love their 'white feta' veg. pizza. G'son had the cheese n pepperoni with a sprinkle of garlic. So, glad we stopped here. The food DID NOT disappoint us. Win, win.

The gentlemen behind the counter were very accommodating to our bigger party and so extremely nice! The food was very delicious, we highly recommend this place. The pizza is huge too! We loved their wings as well.

Great Sicilian Pizza! Stoped for some slices while in town, amazing pizza and friendly staff. They went out of their way to get a cup for my toddlers drink! Will stop next time in town.

Amazing NY style pizza. Huge slice & delicous breadsticks! The employees were incredibly kind here. Just sitting eating my pizza listening to them talk to everyone who came in made my day that much better. It is rare to see such a kind staff at a pizza joint. 10/10 would eat here again.

As I'm in Alfred once or twice a week due to work, I usually have lunch here once a week. Very good tasting pizza slices of generous size, along with a choice of a side and a drink for a very competitive price. That along with quick, generous service can't be beat. About noon on week days and the place has a line out the door of fellow local blue collar folks and for good reason.

Excellent pizza, freshly baked, and delicious. The slices were a generous size and the staff was both courteous and kind. We definitely recommend Little Sicily Pizza when you’re in Alfred.

Every time we are at Alfred State for a visit we grab my son and his friends and enjoy a thin crust pie. You won’t be disappointed in any of the pizza varieties!!!

I visit almost every time I attend an event at Alfred University. The staff is super-friendly and attentive. This time, we got slices. The slice we were each provided was bigger than our heads, and was fresh, hot, and delicious. This place is my go-to in Alfred.

It's always great pizza, fast, for a decent price, can't complain at all.

Always extremely polite staff and GREAT pizza! Each time I try a new flavor it’s just as good if not better than the previous.

Excellent pizza, terrific staff, and nice atmosphere. During the two years that my son attended Alfred State, this was a regular stop for me before heading back home. I would have a slice, then bring home a whole pizza . for the family, and in the freezer for leftovers. dfddOriginally being from the NYC area &(now a Rochester resident for the past 22 years), and having tasted pizza from many parts of the country, I consider myself a pizza connissiere (sp?; basically, I just love pizza.. and in my honest and impartial opinion , Little Sicily's pizza is excellent ! It reminds me so much of New York pizza, and having lived there most of my life,and I should know!! Peace and Power to the Pizza! Nancy

By far the best place for pizza in the area. Please never change. Since graduating in 2020, everything changed for the worst in Alfred, but Little Sicily's has always stayed amazing!

From Buffalo with extremely high standards for pizza and wings. This is the only place we will be ordering from, from now on. It's great and the price is fair!

This pizza is so good. Given the choice, I would sell my first born for that dough recipe. Favorite slices in Western New York

The staff and pizza here are amazing. Everyone who works there is great and personable. Favorite local pizza place.

True Italian fare @ a friendly, honest price!! * The salads are AMAZING 😇 *The spinach POPEYE pizza is the bomb 💥 *Slices are insanely huge!🍕 *Desserts too!! 😙

Really friendly employees, delicious food! I love that the guy making my pizza was happy and singing :)

Love the lunch options, there are always more then 4 choices of Pizza to pick, Great prices and customer service is top natch.

Employees are great and food is even better. Pizza by the giant slice or 16" minimum size up to 24" or sheet. Would highly, highly recommend.

My husband got pizza and got me triple chocolate cheesecake which was amazing!!! I definitely recommend!

Awesome pizza! One slice would be equal to 2 anywhere else and they use good cheese. Highly recommend.

~Hands down one of the BEST places for pizza! So many varieties! LARGE slices! Desserts are phenomenal!~

Best pizza ever, so consistent and delicious! Slices are the best EVER! So lucky for this gem!

Robert Wise

Awesome subs, especially the chicken parm. Absolutely love the pizza as well. We come to hunt every year late November and always order there at least twice!

Michael Smith

Love their chicken wings crispy on the outside nice and tender on the inside plenty of chicken meat to bite into

Shelby Hackett

Always great food, staff always friendly 🙂 and apparently I order a lot from there 🤣🥰

Melissa Traver

Absolutely amazing we had never been there as we were visiting town , the food was soooo good

Trap man

we had pizza and calzones. delicious.

Annmarie Urso

We grabbed two slices and a drink to split passing through Alfred. Clean restaurant with friendly and professional young men working behind the counter. The pizza was EXCELLENT! Thin crust- not too thin though, with delicious sauce. Well done!

Dak Guy

Hats off to the guy who runs this place. He absolutely tries his best to get the job done and makes, in my opinion, some of the best New York style slice of pizza around.

Carol L. Kelly

Typical college town pizza joint with outstanding food. Lunch special is a drink and extra large slice. The pizza was really great.

Rebekah Kalladeen

Got a medium cheese pizza, it was delicious! Also got some beyond spicy wings which were flavorful and amazing. 10/10 would recommend!

Trenton Green

Very good pizza we got a pepperoni pizza and chicken wings pizza.

Matt Slocum

Little Sicily was recommended by a friend. My son and i both had slices of pizza. The food was delicious and reasonably priced. I look forward to visiting again the next time I'm in the area!

Sean Grohman

Pizza slices were huge at a good price. Also, I don’t think I’ve seen someone behind a counter work so hard and be so friendly in a long time. Super quick service and delicious food was spot on!

John Morrison

As a boy who grew up in Buffalo and has stayed in the BLO for 58 years, i have experienced the best pizza on the planet. First time in 58 years to Alfred, and I saw this place and let me tell you it is outstanding, absolutely outstanding, they do it right! The dude running the place was cool as hell as well.

Jill Mallone

Stopped off to grab slices after picking up family at Alfred State and then heading out For the few hours trip home. Great pizza and wonderful service!!!! We tried many different varieties and each one was delicious!!! I will definitely stop in the next time we're in the area. ❤️🍕

Rachel

This is my favorite pizza place from Alfred to Hornell! Every thing I've gotten from here is amazing. Depending on who's working I get about 20 boneless wings in a dozen order. Their pizza is sweet yet crispy . The only downfall is there's no online menu. Ive had to call multiple times to ask what all they had on their menu besides pizza and how much the items were. Which can be irritating im sure as they are always busy. ....in 2023 that's a major let down. But the foods good and the staff are always very friendly. I asked for a paper menu with my delivery as I have before and none were delivered and I'm not driving to grab one or I wouldn't have ordered delivery. Hopefully they will bring me one with this order ❤️ great job little sicily !!

Mike Smith

Excellent pizza - great flavor. Friendly staff.

richard rygiel

SIMPLY GREAT PIZZA! and delicious Italian food made fresh daily. Or call and ask, very friendly. I love the single pieces of pizza, I usually order 2+ to go. The smell of fresh pizza coming out of the oven is great. That's when I order more pieces. Owner is AWESOME and so is the support staff. Free parking too!

Good pizza not much room to sit

Very large slices. If one likes a thinner crust, but not too crisp, this is very good.

Good place to eat good people didn't care for the pickle pizza though. Have you eaten there many times

This is our go to place for pizza! We have our own special pie and whenever I go in they always remembee what I want but ask just the same.

Finally, a reliablly decent quality pizza again, but still pricy.

Food is delicious. Especially their garlic parmesan wings.

When I arrived to small town Alfred for college, I was to surprised to easily find a decent pizza shop; their own take on NYC style with thin crust, good ingredient proportions, and consistent quality. Looking forward to revisiting!

Delicious thin pizza. Very large portions. Friendly service. Great value. More of a lunch place than a dinner place.

BEST PIZZA OF ALL TIME

Em N

I think they are great! Good pizza, reasonable prices and friendly people! It’s worth the drive.

Wasn't bad but wish it was thicker crust and not quite a expensive.. wish it was Saucy with decent amount of cheese and pepperoni..

I have found this place to be very inconsistent. We have had some great food only to be extremely dissatisfied with the next order. Manager has apologized for the mishap.

Best pizza in the alfred, great portion sizes and quality, fair prices, good customer service, and the would deliver to your dorm hall. Edit: the inconsistent hours and misleading online listing of them has lead me to knock off two stars. Its great food if youre lucky enough to catch them open

Sarah Bogdan

Most other restaurants in the area were closed for New Year’s so we went here as we were starving. I’d say if you’re starving and everywhere else is closed, this pizzeria is fine. Otherwise, not sure I can recommend it. We got a large buffalo wing pizza and it looked and tasted like cheese pizza with a slight hint of buffalo sauce. There wasn’t really any chicken to be seen, although I did crunch down on a weird rubbery cartilage piece of chicken. Maybe it was a bad night for chicken or we should’ve just gotten cheese but it was odd. Also, the worker was using his bare hands to grab very old-looking slices from the warmer and throw them in the oven to reheat, which turned us off a bit. But again, if this is the only pizzeria in the region… it’s fine.

Crimson Øverlord

The inside of the store was really hot, no AC, just a ceiling fan. Granted, we were there only 10-15 mins after 8 o'clock closing time, but they still let us order. The cashier man-handled the spare slices without gloves as she sorted thru a stack of pizza slices. We ate outside but there were no trash cans outside by the tables and chairs, and wanted to throw our box away but when we asked the workers closing up if they had a trash can (while I was holding a pizza box), they said no and went back to work despite the cashier handling clear trash bags shortly after placing our slices in the oven indicating that they already took the trash out to the dumpster (they still could have taken the box from us and just tossed it in the dumpster themselves. Thankfully, the food was really good, even for pizza slices that were likely kept in the display cabinet all day and then stored in a pile for a half an hour.

I stopped because I wanted to take a picture of the pizza floaty to send to a friend. I thought I'd go in for a slice since I was there. The workers were nice but I was very disappointed to see that the pizza didn't look very fresh. I still wanted to support the business so I got a piece of peanut butter pie for a friend. I'm not in that area very often so I'm hoping my next visit will be better.

Reminded me of high school pizza absolutely terrible never again

Horrible, dirty, bad service, Ordered chicken parmigiana, it was frozen chicken fingers of bread. Garbage food.

I literally just watched a cook drop a chicken wing on the floor and pick it up and put it in the frier.. we immediately got up and left. Gross

Ordered pizza was told 30 minutes, we arrived 20 minutes after ordering and they hadn't even started making them. They weren't even busy, nothing was in the oven. Extremely poor service and won't order again!

well ordered 2 peperoni pizza's and thay say ya come on down we have them. so i go there and theres 2 slices of peperoni pizza, i asked wheres y pizza's they reply u asked for 2 slices and sead it was $24.39. i told them i ordered 2 pizzas they sead ok that will be $62.47 so i get the pizza and get home to find tinny maggots on it!?!?!?!?!?! NEVER AGAIN WILL I EVER GO THERE