Tim Boman

It was our first time ordering from Mike's Pizzeria dince we are not from the area. We based it on their Google rating, location to our hotel, and pictures of their food. They did not disappoint. We will be ordering again next time we are in town.

Kim Papciak

The owners were amazing. The food was good and we can't wait to go back and try the pizza.

Gerow Management

Staff was friendly and they were very accommodating. We brought the whole family and took up half the restaurant. They were fast and the service was excellent. Pizza and bread sticks were awesome.

NNC LLC

Today we picked up a veggie cheesy bread because another customer made it sound so good. It was! It's super cheesy and flavorful and the dough is perfect. It also comes with two sauces. Plus the staff is very nice. We'll be back again soon. Thank you!

Jenna Weise

First time getting food was amazing. The pizza tasted great. The bacon was actually cooked and not the nasty stuff sometimes seen. Loaded cheese fries were perfect. It’s hard to find good loaded cheese fries. Will be ordering again and will drive to pick it up!

Lisa Abbott

Had the best experience ever on 6/21/25. It was our first time here. Mike came over, introduced himself and checked to see how the food was, stand up guy for sure. Amanda provided excellent service, very attentive and wants everything to be perfect! The pizza was the best that we've ever had, even ordered a second round to go! The cinnamon sticks won't disappoint. We will definitely be back. Thank you Mike & Amanda!! Lisa Abbott

Daniel Valley

Truly a gem of a small business and feel fortunate such an amazing pizza spot exists here in Alto. We’ve been coming here for a few years and the pizza is always top notch and service is great. You can tell the owner puts a lot of care and effort into delivering the best product. Thank you, Mike, for giving this area such an amazing pizza experience!

Lindsay Mohr

Our family absolutely loves Mike's! We always do take out, and decided to eat in tonight. I didn't know I could love it more! The food is ALWAYS fantastic and the service is top notch. We can't say enough good things about Mike's!

Christa Hagel

Holy smokes! This was the most meat I've ever had on an all meats pizza! SO MUCH MEAT!! And what a deal! $23 for a 16 inch. My husband and I could only eat 3 of the 8 pieces because they were so thick with meat and cheese! Definitely my new favorite! Can't wait to go back!

kevin maynard

Five stars! We visit Mike’s quite often—it's easily one of our favorite spots. Everything we’ve had has been fantastic, from, awesome pizza, lasagna to a good beer, and most recently, the cheesecake (which was absolutely amazing). Mike always takes a moment to stop by and say thank you, which makes it feel personal and welcoming. After a meal there, I honestly feel like I just took a mini vacation. Love supporting a great local business like this. Highly recommend!

Heather Morrison

This place has fantastic food. We usually order pizza to go, but every once in awhile we dine-in. Most recently, I took my daughter and we ordered wings, cheesy bread, and some pasta. The pasta wouldn't be my go-to but the wings, pizza, and cheesy bread are always delicious no matter what you get. The one caution I will provide is they are always busy (due to the delicious food) so if you are eating or ordering at what is considered normal dinning hours, expect to wait. There are some nights we have thought about ordering a pizza and been told it would be an hour and a half before it was ready. I've always appreciated their honesty because sometimes the wait is worth it but sometimes little bellies can't wait that long. Same with dine-in. They are usually packed so sometimes service can be a little slow but they are always kind and helpful. It doesn't deter us from returning.

Nonrevkcin

Mikes Pizzeria & Tavern is one of the best places to get a VARIETY of food. One of my personal favorites is the Detroit deep dish pizza! It is unmatched! Not to mention they have the best customer service and Mike himself is there alot of the time and he is the friendliest and most accommodating person you would every meet. I personally HIGHLY recommend this place!

Michael Zenk

Their pizzas are pretty good. My only complaint is the sausage they use. They do not use fresh Italian sausage. Other than that everything is delicious

Mike Freas

The pizza is overrated. It is definitely solid, but in no way anything special. Nice people working here and it is in fact the best pizza in the Caledonia area now that Fricanos is gone. 7/10 for the pizza, 9/10 for service