The Pub at The Creamery

Bo Kallish-hill

Amazing place. Smells like wood fired heaven. Staff is friendly and helpful and the food is totally amazing. You can taste the oak!

Amy Bohner

Love us some Pub at the Creamery. It’s a regular spot for our weekly date night. We each get a pizza, share the house salad and get a couple of their creative cocktails. My favorite vegetarian pizza is the Greek. The husband likes the classic pizza. My favorite thing about the house salad are the roasted garbanzo beans. Their cocktails are delicious and their ice is huge and clear just like we like em! You can also get the food to go which we did last night. The hostess called when the food was ready so I could pick it up hot and fresh. So great customer service too. 👌🏻

Cyril Oberlander

Great social place for mix of fun drinks and food , I like their outdoor seating. Wonderful hamburgers with Humboldt beef, truffle tots, garlic fries, Tonkatsu Ramen, pizzas, Korean Fried Chicken, and more. Creative and delicious dishes, fun place to take a break from bike riding or walking along the Arcata Marsh, or walking around town. Lunch or dinner, cider and local beers, and more. Check out their yummy menu. Indoor is very nice, but outdoor seating is my favorite, nice lights and outside heaters. Very charming area, plus two very nice shops, one vintage clothes, the other Seapod, hand crafted clothing and gifts, and Arcata Playhouse and dance studio too.

Rick

Great atmosphere, service was pretty good. I enjoyed my Panini, my daughter thought the buffalo chicken fries was delicious. Unique cocktails available. Price is as expected for 2024. I will return.

Brittnell Anderson

There was a bit of a wait, but they took my number and have a call when a table was ready. Food was really good with ample portions, and the service was very friendly, informative and attentive. I had the Buffalo Chicken Fries, which was probably more food than I really needed, but it was super tasty and perfectly hit the spot.

P. S.

This place never disappoints. Their burgers are bomb and their cocktails are strong. They have a variety of brews on tap for the beer connoisseurs. There is a jukebox and the music can be a little too much in the large space with bupkis for acoustics. I sit at the bar or the left hand side (facing the front door) of the place or outside on the fenced patio if the weather isn’t being dumb.

We love this place so much. Perfect for families or date night. They have a cute kids area in the corner that can keep little ones entertained. The food is delicious - burger, buffalo cauliflower, jalapeño popper flatbread were all great. The design is very cozy yet modern. Huge beer list on tap and also lots of mocktails and n/a options. Overall a family favorite of ours!

We absolutely love the pub but are so disappointed right now. We used to go there specifically for the old Rasputin on nitro. It is a delicious beer and it was reasonably priced. The last time we went, it was replaced with a beer from Bend, Oregon. We love Bend, Oregon, but would love them to represent California And one of the best beers from California. Please bring old Rasputin back!❤️ By the way, we like the food too😀

The tots are the best around and a great deal, service is great too just always busy. Servers are very nice and I love them here! The real problem is the food quality of most stuff has gone down so much recently and that’s understandable because of food prices so I just order appetizers now . Also alcohol prices have gone up 30-40% in a very short time. I paid almost the price of an entree for one small mocktail with a shot in it (well shot itself was $9). The drinks used to be great but we’ll all be tightening our belts soon if one drink costs $2 less than a dinner entree.. Still a wonderful place to have in the community ans the pain killer is a few dollars less and an amazing deal!

Food was really tasty. Chelsea was our server and she was very pleasant and service was outstanding. We will definitely be back.

Great staff! We invaded with a large group and were very well taken care of. Food was delicious and the cauliflower wings were surprisingly good.

Kristi Tubbs

We absolutely love the pub but are so disappointed right now. We used to go there specifically for the old Rasputin on nitro. It is a delicious beer and it was reasonably priced. The last time we went, it was replaced with a beer from Bend, Oregon. We love Bend, Oregon, but would love them to represent California And one of the best beers from California. Please bring old Rasputin back!❤️ By the way, we like the food too😀

Courtney Wood

We love this place so much. Perfect for families or date night. They have a cute kids area in the corner that can keep little ones entertained. The food is delicious - burger, buffalo cauliflower, jalapeño popper flatbread were all great. The design is very cozy yet modern. Huge beer list on tap and also lots of mocktails and n/a options. Overall a family favorite of ours!

Chris Hannon

Great staff! We invaded with a large group and were very well taken care of. Food was delicious and the cauliflower wings were surprisingly good.

Anna F

The tots are the best around and a great deal, service is great too just always busy. Servers are very nice and I love them here! The real problem is the food quality of most stuff has gone down so much recently and that’s understandable because of food prices so I just order appetizers now . Also alcohol prices have gone up 30-40% in a very short time. I paid almost the price of an entree for one small mocktail with a shot in it (well shot itself was $9). The drinks used to be great but we’ll all be tightening our belts soon if one drink costs $2 less than a dinner entree.. Still a wonderful place to have in the community ans the pain killer is a few dollars less and an amazing deal!

Came on a Sunday and they have plenty of tvs for Sunday football. I noticed a lot of staff so guessing they get pretty busy. Our server was friendly and refilled my water regularly. They have tons of beer on tap. It's a large building with plenty of seating. There were a lot of flies though, just circling in the middle of room. Anyway the food was good, ordered the artichoke dip and the jalapeno popper flatbread. Both cooked in the wood fire pizza oven. Also ordered the fried cajan chicken thighs which had a nice light crunch and juicy inside. Oh and depending on where you sit the sun shines in and blinds you because the windows are so high.

Update: been coming here more with co workers after work to get drinks and snacks. The service has gotten wayyy better, the portions of food are better for the price. Overall they have gotten better. Impressed on the improvement. Update: Went here for dinner with a couple friends. Literally the worst service I have experienced there. We ordered drinks and a appetizer at first. Did not check back in after dropping of the drinks. Completely forgot to put in the appetizer order. Then we order food along with the appetizer. Only thing that came out was the appetizer. Waited over and hour finally getting the after asking to cancel it to leave. The food was alright a bit over priced for one piece of avocado toast (great presentation though) that states in shareable on the menu (definitely wasn’t shareable). I was a bit disappointed to know they do not serve lunch until 1:30pm on weekends (went in right around noon). The service maybe was spread thin had to ask for water 3 times. Normally I’ve gone in after 5pm and usually have a good experience so I was a bit bummed on the “brunch experience”.

Great atmosphere and good food and drinks! Super family friendly too! I highly recommend the fried Brussels sprouts and pesto veggie pizza!

Lots of great beers and cider on tap. Food was on point. But man is it loud in there. The place seems to echo the noise back onto you you

KD

Came on a Sunday and they have plenty of tvs for Sunday football. I noticed a lot of staff so guessing they get pretty busy. Our server was friendly and refilled my water regularly. They have tons of beer on tap. It's a large building with plenty of seating. There were a lot of flies though, just circling in the middle of room. Anyway the food was good, ordered the artichoke dip and the jalapeno popper flatbread. Both cooked in the wood fire pizza oven. Also ordered the fried cajan chicken thighs which had a nice light crunch and juicy inside. Oh and depending on where you sit the sun shines in and blinds you because the windows are so high.

Ivory Marx

Update: been coming here more with co workers after work to get drinks and snacks. The service has gotten wayyy better, the portions of food are better for the price. Overall they have gotten better. Impressed on the improvement. Update: Went here for dinner with a couple friends. Literally the worst service I have experienced there. We ordered drinks and a appetizer at first. Did not check back in after dropping of the drinks. Completely forgot to put in the appetizer order. Then we order food along with the appetizer. Only thing that came out was the appetizer. Waited over and hour finally getting the after asking to cancel it to leave. The food was alright a bit over priced for one piece of avocado toast (great presentation though) that states in shareable on the menu (definitely wasn’t shareable). I was a bit disappointed to know they do not serve lunch until 1:30pm on weekends (went in right around noon). The service maybe was spread thin had to ask for water 3 times. Normally I’ve gone in after 5pm and usually have a good experience so I was a bit bummed on the “brunch experience”.

Poppys Nursery

Lots of great beers and cider on tap. Food was on point. But man is it loud in there. The place seems to echo the noise back onto you you

Ashlee Bruce

Great atmosphere and good food and drinks! Super family friendly too! I highly recommend the fried Brussels sprouts and pesto veggie pizza!

I’ve been to The Pub a handful of times now and I love the beer and cider selection! The pizza is great! Wings could have some more meat on them. Sunday Brunch was a little disappointing, but waiting for kinks to be worked out. Overall, a nice new place in town to check out and grab a beer and snack!

Talana Barry

I’ve been to The Pub a handful of times now and I love the beer and cider selection! The pizza is great! Wings could have some more meat on them. Sunday Brunch was a little disappointing, but waiting for kinks to be worked out. Overall, a nice new place in town to check out and grab a beer and snack!

Been going for years. Great atmosphere, fine service, but it's really a gamble if this visit the food will be good or bad. Kinda makes you not want to go. I don't know what happened but food was way better and more consistent years ago. Prices for sides are high and they really should just add a dollar to the price of sandwiches and give you the fries.. maybe that's what happened owners got greedy and cut corners who knows. Good place to grab a drink. Pizza good.

OHIOCALGIRL

Been going for years. Great atmosphere, fine service, but it's really a gamble if this visit the food will be good or bad. Kinda makes you not want to go. I don't know what happened but food was way better and more consistent years ago. Prices for sides are high and they really should just add a dollar to the price of sandwiches and give you the fries.. maybe that's what happened owners got greedy and cut corners who knows. Good place to grab a drink. Pizza good.

My husband and I waited over 30 minutes to get our order taken while every table around us who walked in after us got their orders taken. The restaurant wasn't even very busy. Tried to flag a server multiple times while they were standing prepping silverware not even 6 feet from our table but just got stared at so we walked out. At one point a server even pointed at us as if they knew we needed service but still nothing. Not the first time I've had this experience and will not be going back.

We couldn't find anywhere that would allow our 2 little dogs so we called The Pub and they said it would be no problem. We traveled 30 min to have some lunch. When we got there, they immediately sat us down and gave us menus but never came back to the table to take our order for anything! Not even drinks! We literally asked for service 3 times and they kept saying they would be out in a minute but 45 minutes later, we walked out. They had little to no customers so they had more then enough employees to help us, but they decided to lose $400 instead. WE WILL NEVER GO BACK! Customer service sucks!

keith neal

We couldn't find anywhere that would allow our 2 little dogs so we called The Pub and they said it would be no problem. We traveled 30 min to have some lunch. When we got there, they immediately sat us down and gave us menus but never came back to the table to take our order for anything! Not even drinks! We literally asked for service 3 times and they kept saying they would be out in a minute but 45 minutes later, we walked out. They had little to no customers so they had more then enough employees to help us, but they decided to lose $400 instead. WE WILL NEVER GO BACK! Customer service sucks!