Haley S

This restaurant is absolutely a five star experience. It is pricey, but truly you get what you pay for. The service is outstanding. We came here on our honeymoon and we were treated like royalty. The food was phenomenal, it came out beautifully plated and tasted even better. I recommend the gnocchi. And the filet mignon. The popovers that they serve, the table are actually to die for, and we haven’t stopped talking about them since we left. I wish I remembered our servers name, he was amazing. Wine list is abundant, plenty to choose from. We can’t wait to come back next time we take a trip to New York City.

+2

Jennifer Nicole

Beautiful ambiance, excellent service, and delicious food! I was celebrating my bday with dinner & a show... dining here definitely made for a Beautiful night💚

Karlo Majetić

From the outside lowkey, from the inside beautiful and elegant. Extremely pleasant dining room, super friendly and helpful service that made me and the group feel welcomed. Amazing food options - variety is great, good prices with excellent quality. Also the popover bread they serve as a welcome bite is to die for. I look forward to coming back

Lena Breazu

Great place for Restaurant Week with choices of Steak, Sea bass , shrimp tacos, Chicken with capers, shrimp tacos home made pasta lamb ragu- all full of flavor- The desserts done by Danvi were Amazing and not too sweet. Just perfect! Among which was an ice cream sandwich, coffee brulee a delicious gluten free tart. vanilla cheesecake w creme brulee raspberry, blackberry strawberry topped off with flavored whip cream. chocolate cake

+3

Jackie Botelho

INCREDIBLE EXPERIENCE! The cocktails are incredible and we have a tomahawk steak with a few sides. It was an absolutely perfect and amazing experience. We had the best waiter, Sean, and the assistant manager, Candace were so hospitable. I can’t wait to go back!

Richard

Absolutely outstanding experience at Hunt & Fish Club ! My wife and I celebrated a special night, and we couldn't have asked for better service. Our server was attentive and knowledgeable, making fantastic recommendations that truly elevated our meal. The steaks were perfectly cooked, bursting with flavor, and the ambiance was just right for a cozy evening.

+3

Heidi R.

Amazing experience. We went there for dinner before seeing the Lion King. The hostess asked us if we were going to see a show. I don’t know if they usually ask that, but I thought that was so thoughtful. The atmosphere was romantic and calm. Great food and wine!

+1

Tarsha Cobb

Me and a friend who went for my birthday dinner and it was awesome the food was seasoned to perfection. We basically had a menu tasting and it was all amazing. I would highly recommend this restaurant for any occasion or just a nice dinner. Service was excellent and very attentive.ans by all means tip your server!!!

+2

Laci Kim

Nice restaurant near the theatre district. the crab cake was SUBLIME. the ribeye was cooked perfectly. their sides were a little disappointing. the brussels sprouts had a strange tex-mex vibe. the tater tots were huge so you miss out on all of the crispiness that makes a tater tot good.

Yulia Ivanitskaya

Big shout out to oysters 😋. For mains I took swordfish and it was dry. Lots of liquid sauce didn't help really. For dessert I chose triple chocolate and it came as in my picture. A look could have been more refind.

Josh Linder

Food was good but has vinegar in EVERYTHING; French Onion soup was best we've had; pork chop was perfectly cooked; business dinner. Service was kind of slow - there was a NY Mets event and everything basically became a black hole. Some areas of the restaurant are a bit in disrepair - our booth fell apart.

Amanda Labrada

Brought my hubby here for his Bday dinner this year. The interior is BEAUTIFUL! they did an amazing job in there with the layout. our server was friendly and the food was good. With reservation i did mention it was his bday and again when we arrived and thought it was a little weird it was not acknowledged at all but i took him to Junior’s for a bday cheesecake slice after.

Chris Crawford

Nice place for a pre theatre dinner. The high prices keep it a couple notches above the typical places. Food and service are very good, but I’d certainly expect that for the cost. The decor is pretty dated.

We visited this restaurant for Valentine’s Day dinner. My boyfriend made the reservation one week in advance and paid a $100 deposit. We chose this place mainly because of the beautiful photos online, especially the elegant main hall with chandeliers and romantic ambiance. When we arrived, we waited about 30–40 minutes for our table, which we understand can happen on a busy holiday. However, we were seated in a large basement dining area instead of the main hall shown in the photos. The space was not bad, but it was not the atmosphere we were expecting for such a special occasion. Service timing was also disappointing. We waited 30–40 minutes for appetizers and about 1 hour and 30 minutes for the main course. We had already decided on our order while waiting, so the extended delay felt excessive. Our server recommended a large, shareable steak, which we ordered. The steak was big, but for a total of $418, we expected a smoother and more organized experience. Given the delays and service issues, we honestly expected some kind of gesture from the restaurant — whether a small discount, a complimentary dessert, or at least an acknowledgment of the inconvenience. Unfortunately, nothing was offered. The food itself was good, but the overall experience did not match the expectations set by the restaurant’s presentation, especially for Valentine’s Day.

Jada Knight

I had the pleasure of dining at the establishment on Thanksgiving Day and was truly impressed by the exceptional service. My server, Liam, went above and beyond to ensure I was well taken care of, making my solo dining experience feel welcoming and pleasant. I also thoroughly enjoyed the wine selection, which complemented the meal nicely. While the service and atmosphere exceeded my expectations, some aspects of the meal fell short. The house-chopped salad was delightful, though the inclusion of bacon was less to my liking. The Bone & Marrow dish was a highlight, showcasing rich flavors and a satisfying preparation. However, the Bone-In Ribeye, which I specifically inquired about being prime, did not meet my expectations. While it was flavorful, the texture and quality left me uncertain about its prime designation. The most disappointing aspect of the meal, unfortunately, was the turkey dinner. The turkey itself was dry, even with the accompaniment of gravy and cranberry sauce. The Brussels sprouts were inconsistent—some overly dry, others nicely crispy—and the whipped potatoes arrived lukewarm, with the interior notably cooler than the exterior. Their mac & cheese resemblance was to velveta, wasn't too excited about it. Given the high recommendations I received prior to my visit, I had high expectations for this first dining experience. While the service and ambiance were exceptional, the inconsistencies in the food left me somewhat underwhelmed. I would rate my experience a 7.5/10 overall. In the future, I may be open to returning and seeing their kitchen shine.

+2