Kitty Mulligan's

David S

Excellent, local old style bar runs the full length of the place, with tables on opposite side. Very friendly(see Melinda at the bar), nice happy hour items, bar menu, live music(a big plus), karaoke too! Must try...

Becky Pelfrey

Friendly atmosphere, great food. Soft drinks were a bit flat, but everything else was perfect! Definitely recommend the HUGE pretzel!! Delish. We will be back for sure!

Jamie Drew-Burke

My husband and I love family owned places so we stopped here on our anniversary for food and drinks. The bartender was fantastic and made great recommendations plus the drinks were nice and cold! The food was surprising AWESOME!! 100% recommendation for kitty Mulligans

Auny H (AunySillyMe)

Super cool bar with a great atmosphere! Bartender was awesome. Didn’t eat there but the food smelt deliciousssss 🔥

M&M

The person at the bar is friendly,, the place has a very good vibe It was delicious the chicken wings

Rob Sep

The food is outstanding! Fresh, hot & 100% on point. You better bring an appetite expect a nice portion. Salad is crisp & fresh / w several options. Cod beers ,great staff. Compliments to the cook!🤌🏻

We come in every Thursday and Ally Is the best bartender ever! She gets service with a smile! We will definitely be back

Great neighborhood spot. First time there (for lunch). Food great. We will definitely return. Great crowd and special bartender (sadly, I forgot her name) but a special person. Kitty's best ambassador.

I always go here to see Ally she is sweet and pleasant takes good care of her customers

Excellent food, the wings just like they were when it was CooperSmiths pub nice and crispy, the Irish stew and BLT were excellent also great atmosphere had a cool relaxed band playing service was great prompt and delightful definitely will be coming back for more wings!!

Went last night to see a band “The Fuse Relit”. The atmosphere is great for dining and watching a band. Nice place

My first time here and it was AMAZING! The bartender, Jillian was and is an asset to the business. Great recommendations, a positive attitude and a fun personality. The spice and seasoning used on their burgers is so rich in flavor. Definitely come here, especially when Jillian is working - you will not regret it! And be sure to try her martinis (she’s known for those!)

Ally the Friday Bartendar makes the entire experience!! She mixes great drinks and gives you a laugh that makes you want to come back.

We recently hosted a birthday party for my husband at Kitty Mulligans and it was the perfect venue for 60 people. The management and waitstaff were so kind, helpful, flexible, and easy to work with. The guests enjoyed the food and drinks. The atmosphere was perfect for our party! We especially liked the private room located adjacent to the bar.

Ryan

Excellent food, the wings just like they were when it was CooperSmiths pub nice and crispy, the Irish stew and BLT were excellent also great atmosphere had a cool relaxed band playing service was great prompt and delightful definitely will be coming back for more wings!!

Charlie Stengel

We come in every Thursday and Ally Is the best bartender ever! She gets service with a smile! We will definitely be back

Robert RKNY26 (PresRKNY)

We stopped in here for an early dinner and the food was good with a nice atmosphere. They have live music quite regularly although we didn’t get to stay for the performance

THAT 90s’ CHILD

My first time here and it was AMAZING! The bartender, Jillian was and is an asset to the business. Great recommendations, a positive attitude and a fun personality. The spice and seasoning used on their burgers is so rich in flavor. Definitely come here, especially when Jillian is working - you will not regret it! And be sure to try her martinis (she’s known for those!)

Steven Pauly

Had previously provided great review. Last time the fish undercooked, but okay, can happen. Sent my daughter there tonight. Someone forgot to order fish so the fish and chips came out with one soggy piece of cod. The place smelled of smoke and someone was yelling at the owners kids. I feel betrayed. Never again.

Mary Ceramello

We recently hosted a birthday party for my husband at Kitty Mulligans and it was the perfect venue for 60 people. The management and waitstaff were so kind, helpful, flexible, and easy to work with. The guests enjoyed the food and drinks. The atmosphere was perfect for our party! We especially liked the private room located adjacent to the bar.

Eileen Brett

Absolutely love Kitty Mulligans in Bay Shore! The food is always fantastic, and the beer is ice cold—perfect every time. The atmosphere is so much fun; they’ve really created a spot that feels lively and welcoming. Bartender Matt is amazing—always attentive and keeps things running smoothly behind the bar. And Patti is a phenomenal server, always on top of things with a warm smile. I was sad to hear PJ is no longer there, as he was a favorite too. Kitty Mulligans knows how to keep things entertaining with great events like live bands, psychic nights, drag bingo, trivia, and karaoke. I can’t wait to go back!

Really good bar food. Cheeseburger was delicious and the mozzarella squares were house made with a sweet tomato tasting tomato sauce. The bar was on the quiet side but Jacky the bartender was great and very pleasant.

A O

Really good bar food. Cheeseburger was delicious and the mozzarella squares were house made with a sweet tomato tasting tomato sauce. The bar was on the quiet side but Jacky the bartender was great and very pleasant.

Carlo M.

We stopped in on a Monday night to see a friend of our play some live music. They do an open stage every month. It was something I had not seen before and thought it would be interesting. So many people there with their instruments rotating in and out, all playing a variety of songs. While we listened we ordered some dinner. I had the Shepards Pie, my Daughter ordered the Bangers and Mash. Food was really good, portions were good. The Bartender was very friendly and attentive. We have never been here before and didn’t really know what to expect but we would return without a doubt. The atmosphere was really “Townie” which is a pleasure to see now days. Hometown feel and look, good food and great Bartender. Check them out for the next open jam session. I know we’re looking forward to the next.

Still chasing the elusively authentic Shepherds Pie and once again, it’s a no-go! But Karen, the bartender, was great and quite instrumental in getting me another Pie. Here, they serve the dish with a gravy over the mashed potatoes—and it was excruciating salty! Just with one little piece, my tongue was burning. The second pie, was much better, but compared to all my other Shepherds Pies, it did not measure up. First, it was unconstructed at the bottom, and the ground beef did not get the attention it deserved. More attention went into the Guinness-based gravy then preparing the ground beef. Yet, not only the gravy was too salty, it tasted like it came from a jar, ugh. Also to be noted, the top layer of mashed potatoes did not do justice to the failing dish. It has always been my firm belief, every Irish & British eatery should have at least one signature dish. A giant pretzel is way too Germanique for me.

Desiree Agudo

Still chasing the elusively authentic Shepherds Pie and once again, it’s a no-go! But Karen, the bartender, was great and quite instrumental in getting me another Pie. Here, they serve the dish with a gravy over the mashed potatoes—and it was excruciating salty! Just with one little piece, my tongue was burning. The second pie, was much better, but compared to all my other Shepherds Pies, it did not measure up. First, it was unconstructed at the bottom, and the ground beef did not get the attention it deserved. More attention went into the Guinness-based gravy then preparing the ground beef. Yet, not only the gravy was too salty, it tasted like it came from a jar, ugh. Also to be noted, the top layer of mashed potatoes did not do justice to the failing dish. It has always been my firm belief, every Irish & British eatery should have at least one signature dish. A giant pretzel is way too Germanique for me.

Been going here for 4 years. While yes, the food is good (depending on who's working) the Drinks are weak and over priced. Minimum $60 every visit for a few drinks and an app. Unfortunately Kittys has turned into an old man bar, they were closed on New years eve? C'mon!

Over the past years there has been a noticeable shift in atmosphere and clientele. This is expected as ownership changes, however as of late, this place has fallen out of rotation as my go-to. The food has always been excellent, but something is lost in the quality of drinks, which are overpriced especially when paired with the new atmosphere.

M Smith

Over the past years there has been a noticeable shift in atmosphere and clientele. This is expected as ownership changes, however as of late, this place has fallen out of rotation as my go-to. The food has always been excellent, but something is lost in the quality of drinks, which are overpriced especially when paired with the new atmosphere.

Dan M

Been going here for 4 years. While yes, the food is good (depending on who's working) the Drinks are weak and over priced. Minimum $60 every visit for a few drinks and an app. Unfortunately Kittys has turned into an old man bar, they were closed on New years eve? C'mon!