Jean Farrell

The food here is absolutely divine, and the atmosphere is simply electrifying! The live music adds a whole new level of excitement. It's impossible to resist the urge to jump up and dance! We decided to celebrate Valentine's Day here, and let me tell you, it was an exceptional experience. I cannot recommend this place enough.

+14

Vanessa Muurisepp

I have so many fond memories of this restaurant growing up in Brooklyn. It was a place where we had many celebrations. The food is freshly made & traditional Italian. Highly recommend for a family event.

David Velasco

Brought several people here for a business lunch and the food as always was great. The owner gave us a quick tour and history of the place. I’ve come here when I’ve been in the area for years and it’s a Brooklyn institution. Love the photo of Tony Sirico on the wall.

Vlad Nesterenko

Amazing restaurant! Food is super delicious and service is great! At first, we thought that we’d pay more than $100 each because restaurant looked very fancy but eventually prices are reasonable like in other NY restaurants. Restaurant is also available on open table which makes reservation process easy. Also valet parking is available. Definitely try their pasta - we liked it a lot.

I really enjoyed my meal at this restaurant and hope to return for my next trip to NY as I live in Las Vegas. Our waiters name was Emilio. He was very attentive and kind and took several pictures for…

food always enjoyable service wonderfully pleasant and helpful comfortable environment. Have been a frequent guest without regrets. I especially enjoy their accommodating off the menu capabilities …

Food always enjoyable service wonderfully pleasant and helpful comfortable environment. Have been a frequent guest without regrets. I especially enjoy their accommodating off the menu capabilities …

Food always enjoyable service wonderfully pleasant and helpful comfortable environment. Have been a frequent guest without regrets. I especially enjoy their accommodating off the menu capabilities …

My food adventure spirit was rewarded at this spot. Employees deliver highly attentive service with personal touches. Each bite makes you want another. This place has a central position. I'm antici…

The food, service and ambiance has made this legendary restaurant our home away from home!\nI have been a loyal patron since 1982! \nThank you Louis Russo and the entire Russo family!

The food, service and ambiance has made this legendary restaurant our home away from home!\nI have been a loyal patron since 1982! \nThank you Louis Russo and the entire Russo family!

I went here with my boyfriend for Valentine's Day. We had a great time and the food was great. live music and great drinks. I got the chicken parm.

Love their seafood salad and the family atmosphere. This is a Brooklyn staple that has been around.

Located at the bottom of Coney Island. Great food n great service. Lucky to get a reservation last minute on a summer Sunday. This place has been here a long time I remember coming here a while ago…

Fantastic experience for the price. We called 30 mins before on a Sunday night and they found us a spot. They have a dress code - no swimwear or too lax of a clothing. Was immediately seated. Menu …

I would highly recommend Gargiulo's Coney Island to anyone! The service was spectacular. The food was excellent. The restaurant itself is in a beautiful space.

I would highly recommend Gargiulo's Coney Island to anyone! The service was spectacular. The food was excellent. The restaurant itself is in a beautiful space.

I would highly recommend Gargiulo's Coney Island to anyone! The service was spectacular. The food was excellent. The restaurant itself is in a beautiful space.

We had an amazing time at this great restaurant where they truly make you feel like you are family. From the moment we pulled up at the valet and we were greeted with a team of four valet attendan…

The traditional italian food at Gargiulo’s is consistently superb and well-worth the trip to Coney Island. The restaurant is on a quiet side street near the boardwalk, rides, and subway (though …

I grew up in this neighborhood. That's why it's doubly special when I dine here!! The neighborhood memories, And, The delicious food!! Gargulious never disappoints. I've ordered pasta and fish. A…

I grew up in this neighborhood. That's why it's doubly special when I dine here!! The neighborhood memories, And, The delicious food!! Gargulious never disappoints. I've ordered pasta and fish. Alw…

have been going there for 50 years.food and service are second to none, anthony and his brothers are excellent hosts

Fabulous goes without saying. Besides the amazing food, you feel like you are back in 1942 Brooklyn. Amazing service, amazing vibe. So worth it.

Gargiulo's has a very nice atmosphere (4 stars) that makes for a pleasant dining environment. My overall experience was a solid 4 stars, though I found both the food and the service to be more middle-of-the-road at 3 stars each. It's a classic spot with a great feel, even if the meal itself was standard.

Emil

Private party. The staff were limited and did not fulfill the drink orders. Had to ask multiple times. Food was ok, under seasoned. Its Xmas time, yet NO decorations in the private room, NOT ONE!

Richie Giordano

This was my first visit, for a fraternal function. I've had better food, but it was enjoyable. The drinks were strong, but I wasn't driving so I'm not worried. The venue was beautiful, and the staff are friendly and accommodating.

Dan Schwartz

Classic Italian Restaurant in the heart of Coney Island. We went as a large group and quickly found out they are very strict with dress code and who can come in. Several members of our group were not allowed in, which made for some tension at our table. Those who did get in were taken care of with a good meal and service. We started with some fresh mozzarella and tomatoes. To me, it was bland and the cheese rubbery with unripe tastless tomatoes. It needed oil and balsamic vinegar to wake it up. We then had their excellent zucchini fries that were light and sweet and one of the best I have had. Our pasta dish was penne with tomatoe sauce. The penne was cooked perfectly aldante, but I felt the sauce was a bit too sharp. It needed plenty of sprinkled parmasian to smooth it out. I tried the broiled salmon, which was slightly overcooked but good. I thought the egg plant parm I tasted was much better, tender, and very flavourful. The sauce on the parm to me was better than on the pasta dish. We ended with a delicious slice of their cannoli cake. It was light with the perfect balance of cream and mini chocolate chips between the layers. The regular coffee served was strong and a smooth roast but unfortunately served lukewarm. Overall, the food is very good if you choose wisely. But be prepared in this modern day to dress and look, in their acceptable way, or you might not get in.

+2

Lananh Vu

Location : located on a calm street, few blocks to the sea Staff : friendly Food : 4/5. The spaghetti tomato sauce is classic. We don’t appreciate their pasta. They are too thin Linguine white clam sauce : there are so much liquid on the sauce for me and too salty Calamari fried is well cooked Dessert : the texture of the orange sorbet is so hard. I think it is more than a frozen orange juice than sorbet — Nice decoration — 1 start for the toilet: there were so much dirty paper on the floor. Also, the basket for used hand paper was full so the client just threw it on the floor or even worse, on the lavabo to wash hand. They definitely have to improve their restroom sanitary to keep client

+2

We went for my birthday lunch. There were 8 of us. We each ordered an appetizer. I had the baked clams. We had fried zucchini and fried mozzarella and Caesar salads. \nThe main courses were mostly fi…

We went for my birthday lunch. There were 8 of us. We each ordered an appetizer. I had the baked clams. We had fried zucchini and fried mozzarella and Caesar salads. \nThe main courses were…

We went for my birthday lunch. There were 8 of us. We each ordered an appetizer. I had the baked clams. We had fried zucchini and fried mozzarella and Caesar salads. \nThe main courses were mostl…

Pasta pasta. I enjoy eating a really delicious pasta. Rich in flavors \nService was great. Hand down.\nIt was very clean once I got incident

A perfect meeting place when you are coming from Central Jersey and your friends are in Long Island and Brooklyn. Not much has changed here over the years, except no octopus hanging from the ceilin…

Have not been here for 10 years .we went back for a special occasion I was very disappointed with everything stating with the food , service and prices ! I would not go back ! The past Gargiulo's i…

Came yesterday for a party, hadn't been here in a few years . Place is consistently good . clean beautiful place with great service . Food was delicious from their signature appetizers to the lingu…

Enjoyed our evening out with my grandkids and their families. Arrived at 6 pm and utilized the valet parking. We were seated immediately at a roomy table for six. Server very friendly. Rosie and I s…

Lee

My experience at this restaurant has been neutral I can't say that it's great and rave about it like these other five-star reviews because that was not my experience to me the food was mediocre and nothing special. I would not go back for a second time.

No one who knows good Italian food would eat here anymore. Twenty years ago, yes. Now, no. Food is disgusting, overpriced and of a poor quality. The setting is still lovely. The food sucks.

No one who knows good italian food would eat here anymore. Twenty years ago, yes. Now, no. food is disgusting, overpriced and of a poor quality. The setting is still lovely. The food sucks.

No one who knows good Italian food would eat here anymore. Twenty years ago, yes. Now, no. Food is disgusting, overpriced and of a poor quality. The setting is still lovely. The food sucks.

I made an early reservation before a baseball game trying to support a restaurant we have long gone to as a family. Upon walking in, we were ignored and then a waiter looked at my teenage kids in d…

I am still upset, 24 hours later on how poorly we were treated by the Staff. We were a party of 9 with a reservation that was made via the phone since our party was so large. When we arrived we wer…

Had reservations for a Mother’s Day dinner with my husband, children, MIL and Family. We get there and we are denied entrance. Why you ask? Because my boys had khaki shorts, button down collared shirt and loafers. They were dressed very nicely. They said sorry no shorts. Wt….?! As we are standing there in disbelief, a man walks out with dirty jeans, a dirty zip up jacket and ripped sneakers. I pointed to the vagabond looking dude and said, “oh but that’s allowed? My boys looked good, smelled good, and were dressed impeccably. They ruined my Mother’s Day! We had to drive all the way back home to Westchester Bc all other restaurants were booked already. I can only tell from pics that the food looks Meh. In retrospect, I probably dodged a bullet. Restaurants like a Gargiulos get hype (if that) only bc of the iconic rep & name. Quality of food diminishes and they rely on their reputation. Honestly I can’t believe at this point the food is cooked fresh everyday. Just read some of the reviews.

My husband and I decided to try this place for a first try. We’re both big foodies and enjoy delicious foods and dining out. We ordered out. It was absolutely terrible. It was like Italian food made at a nursing home (if that’s even a thing), lol.

D G

Gargiulos is not the same. Meals are below average and price is very expensive. Started with calamari which came out cold and definetly not fresh with no taste at all. Main xourse was stuffed shrimp for $44 which consited of only 4 small shrimps which were overbreaded and tasted horrible served with absolutely nothing was horrible. Finished with tiramusu dessert which had to taste and preaentation was zero. This meal alone with two glasses of wine was over $180.I dont mind paying high prices for a good meal but this meal was below average and not worth the price. You will get a better meal elsewhere. Will definetly not be coming back. Save your money.

Russell G

The place has been mentioned as one of the staples of south Brooklyn, and I really wanted to love it. Nothing special, unfortunately. Everything looks dated, you get mediocre food for a high price. Ordered a seafood platter. Clams had a fishy smell and when I told that to the waiter he responded “it’s the sauce”. The pasta looked and tasted like lo mein from a Chinese restaurant. The tiramisu looked like it was dropped on the way to my table, but the taste was okay.