Mr. Phil's Pizzeria

the upside down is top notch the round is very good great service nice guys

Anthony Gellert

Great pizza. And don’t sleep on the Rice Ball. Loved this place. Best of the Brooklyn old school slices BY FAR.

Brooklyn22

I grew up in Brooklyn and this is one of my favorite childhood pizzerias. Tastes exactly the same as it did when I was a kid. Delicious!

Carson

The pizza is great I like this place but school has been taking me a ton of time but i still come here sometimes

Donald Kaplan

the upside down is top notch the round is very good great service nice guys

JERRY GIARRAFFA

Great local pizza joint.!!! The pizza n sandwiches are great. I usually order from there at least 3 times a month. Phil the owner is a great guy who will accommodate ur needs. Delivery guy is very friendly n fast. Try the fried zucchini n ham n cheese calzones !!

Dawn McLean

MrPhils is our absolute favorite. We only his pizza.Mr Phil is such a great person friendly & kind. Always smiling. His workers are the same. So pleasant. We love going in to eat so we get to see Mr Phil & Jesus

Edith Concepcion

It’s a wonderful family owned business. It’s very inviting to come and eat or order out. They great and treat everyone like they are family. They make you feel like you’re at Cheers where everyone knows your name. The service is great and the food is delicious. Best Pizza in Brooklyn!!

I’ve had this spot a few times now. It won’t knock your socks off, but it won’t let you down. This is a reliable pie everytime. Consistent as it gets. I’ve only gotten regular round pies from here. Sauce is good, dough is good, cheese is good. They do tend to undercook the pie a bit (which I like) but then do a well done pie fairly well too. I’ve had both. In the general area, a lot of the spots seem to be a hit or miss. These guys deliver consistency time and time again.

Great Italian rice ball (Arancini), was moist with the proper balance between rice and filling. Sicilian squares are very good too. Found the shop employees to be quite polite and helpful. Spotless facilities.

Gaetano Di Pisa

I’ve had this spot a few times now. It won’t knock your socks off, but it won’t let you down. This is a reliable pie everytime. Consistent as it gets. I’ve only gotten regular round pies from here. Sauce is good, dough is good, cheese is good. They do tend to undercook the pie a bit (which I like) but then do a well done pie fairly well too. I’ve had both. In the general area, a lot of the spots seem to be a hit or miss. These guys deliver consistency time and time again.

Fred Alluso

Great Italian rice ball (Arancini), was moist with the proper balance between rice and filling. Sicilian squares are very good too. Found the shop employees to be quite polite and helpful. Spotless facilities.

This is a great little neighborhood find. The pizza crust was crunchy. The cheese has great flavor! And They Sell Manhattan Special. I will definitely be going here more often!

Always loved their food for a long time. I also recommended them to everyone. Lately, I dont know why, their food has gone downhill. The meatballs were like rubber bands and the chicken parm was tough. Maybe a new chef. 🤷‍♀️. Have to start ordering elsewhere. It's a shame too. Also, whoever is taking the orders, a little nasty and sarcastic.

karen lamberti

Always loved their food for a long time. I also recommended them to everyone. Lately, I dont know why, their food has gone downhill. The meatballs were like rubber bands and the chicken parm was tough. Maybe a new chef. 🤷‍♀️. Have to start ordering elsewhere. It's a shame too. Also, whoever is taking the orders, a little nasty and sarcastic.

I ordered a grandma pie and they totally screwed up the toppings. I called them and they offered to give me free toppings next time. I explained that it isn’t at all what we want. He said, “ I don’t know what to tell you, we are busy and I’m not going to send the driver out again”. What?!?! Mind you we order from them regularly. Why they would even risk losing a regular is beyond me. To make it even worse, the dough wasn’t even fully cooked and we had to put it in the oven to cook it. There are so many great pizzerias in the neighborhood. I wouldn’t recommend them. They aren’t what they used to be.

this place is disgusting. i found a bug in my food and when i called to let them know, i was gaslit into thinking it was just a “overfried onion” overfried onions don’t have wings and antennas on them.. 0/10 recommended. please be careful if you decide to eat their food

Patri Maniatis

I ordered a grandma pie and they totally screwed up the toppings. I called them and they offered to give me free toppings next time. I explained that it isn’t at all what we want. He said, “ I don’t know what to tell you, we are busy and I’m not going to send the driver out again”. What?!?! Mind you we order from them regularly. Why they would even risk losing a regular is beyond me. To make it even worse, the dough wasn’t even fully cooked and we had to put it in the oven to cook it. There are so many great pizzerias in the neighborhood. I wouldn’t recommend them. They aren’t what they used to be.

Destiny Williams

this place is disgusting. i found a bug in my food and when i called to let them know, i was gaslit into thinking it was just a “overfried onion” overfried onions don’t have wings and antennas on them.. 0/10 recommended. please be careful if you decide to eat their food

Called to order pizza, asked a very simple question. The caller hanged up rudely because I just wanted to make sure. 1/10 costumer service

I called twice to inquire about a catering order and they were extremely rude. No customer service skills and unwillingness to help. I’m very shocked at the treatment I received over simply wanting guidance when placing an order.

Pizza crust was staler than the bread they serve at a shelter. The sauce is a watered down concotion of probably nearing expired ingredients and the service is appalling especially from the cantankerous owner. I don't believe I've ever frequented a pizzeria as terrible as this one, and I have been to them all.

Id rate zero stars if I could. First of all, they microwave nearly everything before it goes into the oven. The bald one almost always has a bad attitude, and I’ve observed him grabbing food from the microwave with his bare hands and straight up just tossing it into the oven like he’s playing a game of cornhole. On top of all that, the pizza is bland. Nearly everything on that menu has no flavor. Id recommend you go to Krispy Pizza on 13th instead of wasting your time and money here.

Read the reviews. Be careful if you dont pay cash. Dishonest owner overcharged me for an out of stock item and then kept the money. I reached out, and at first he said he was sending someone back out to correct the mistake. An hour later I heard nothing so I contacted them again. They had realized they were out of the item, so decided to not come back with the correction (thanks for letting me know). When I suggested they just refund me the item, they declined and said they would let me keep the incorrect item and they were keeping the money. So that's an interesting way of doing business. There's s ton of pizza in the area. Run from this place

Emiljan Bodini

Called to order pizza, asked a very simple question. The caller hanged up rudely because I just wanted to make sure. 1/10 costumer service

Kayla Williams

I called twice to inquire about a catering order and they were extremely rude. No customer service skills and unwillingness to help. I’m very shocked at the treatment I received over simply wanting guidance when placing an order.

Robbie Muniz

Id rate zero stars if I could. First of all, they microwave nearly everything before it goes into the oven. The bald one almost always has a bad attitude, and I’ve observed him grabbing food from the microwave with his bare hands and straight up just tossing it into the oven like he’s playing a game of cornhole. On top of all that, the pizza is bland. Nearly everything on that menu has no flavor. Id recommend you go to Krispy Pizza on 13th instead of wasting your time and money here.

Raoul Duke

Pizza crust was staler than the bread they serve at a shelter. The sauce is a watered down concotion of probably nearing expired ingredients and the service is appalling especially from the cantankerous owner. I don't believe I've ever frequented a pizzeria as terrible as this one, and I have been to them all.

Bekki X

DO NOT ever go to there. There was an older man in glasses who had a racist, very rude tone. I counted twelve one-dollar bills to pay for my wings, and he dishonestly lied that I only gave ten, and I saw that he hid the other two bills in his drawer. Disgusting!!

Kevin Fowler

Read the reviews. Be careful if you dont pay cash. Dishonest owner overcharged me for an out of stock item and then kept the money. I reached out, and at first he said he was sending someone back out to correct the mistake. An hour later I heard nothing so I contacted them again. They had realized they were out of the item, so decided to not come back with the correction (thanks for letting me know). When I suggested they just refund me the item, they declined and said they would let me keep the incorrect item and they were keeping the money. So that's an interesting way of doing business. There's s ton of pizza in the area. Run from this place