George Panagopoulos at Douglas Elliman Realestate

My client in Greenpoint has been raving about Paulie Gee's Slice Shop, so I finally gave it a shot. I’m a regular slice guy, but I was down to try something different. He put me onto the Hellboy—pepperoni and Mike’s Hot Honey on a Sicilian. Insane combo—the sweet heat with that perfectly crispy crust hit just right. The flavors in the sauce were bold and balanced. Service was solid, and the vintage vibe inside adds to the experience. Definitely a solid spot!

+2

Piper Martz

We had to wait almost 30 minutes just to get inside to place our order. But, if you’re with good company, it goes by fast. We observed many people left because they didn’t wanna wait in line friend when we ordered, happy to explain different vegan and vegetarian options. There are so many tasty vegan pizzas here with mock meats and, nondairy cheese. Very vegan friendly we had a bit of wait to get our slices heated, but we waited in the back room, which has such a fun old classic Italian American pizzeria, vibe with bolted down tables and chairs, linoleum floor, and a bunch of TVs playing sports lol. The food took maybe 10 to 15 minutes to come out, and they accidentally gave us the wrong soft drink. But it was still delicious. If you’re looking for a quick slice, this is probably not the place but for a fun New York outing at a classic, beloved pizza joint – this is the spot!

Omg! Got the spinach white and cheese slice and two sodas for $16 including tip. Amazing pizza, location and service. It's self serve but they are sweet, leave you alone and don't rush you. Place i…

They got upset at me for allowing my child to take a piss in the middle of the dining room. Yes the bathroom was open and available and yes I'm a full grown adult who knows how gross that is but …

Quick service (as expected at a slice shop). Strong crunch, good cheese and sauce. Great atmosphere (classic pizza shop booths and decor). Service was surprisingly good as well with slice brought t…

The pizza is phenomenal-service is outstanding. They are kind and caring. Love the Hellboy square with hot honey and the vegan options are outstanding. There are crowds on Friday and Saturday. I kn…

The pizza is phenomenal-service is outstanding. They are kind and caring. Love the Hellboy square with hot honey and the vegan options are outstanding. There are crowds on Friday and Saturday. I …

The pizza is phenomenal-service is outstanding. They are kind and caring. Love the Hellboy square with hot honey and the vegan options are outstanding. There are crowds on Friday and Saturday. I …

Holy moly that was some good pizza. There were 3 vegan options total and I had the vegan special and the vegan Freddy. Every part of the pizza—crust, sauce, toppings—were delicious. Will definitely…

Holy moly that was some good pizza. There were 3 vegan options total and I had the vegan special and the vegan Freddy. Every part of the pizza—crust, sauce, toppings—were delicious. Will definite…

Mike Reviewed It!

Really, Really, Really good pizza. Went with the Hot Boy Pie. Ate at a nearby bar. Not cheap but I guess you pay for quality. $38.50 for the pie.

+1

Clara Whalen

awesome pizza shop near greenpoint that my husband and i got recommended last weekend. it was freezing outside and this place felt like a warm hug with a cozy atmosphere. the ordering process was a little awkward but we got 5 slices to go. their hot honey pepperoni slice was absolutely delicious. they also have more seating toward the back and serve alcohol as well. super old school and awesome vibes for some really delicious pizza

Cos S

It's a nice spot for a quick bite. There aren't many options in terms of pizza, but def what's available is good 👌 Also, I loved the decorations and the general vibe.

+2

Daniel Martinez

What can I say.... This spot is great!... From the old school decor to the fabulous pizza with top notch ingredients you can taste. The crust on their pizza never disappoints. One of the best NY slices out there. If you want some of the best pizza around with a step back in time decor plus, a little bar to have a few brews then Paulie Gee's is your spot to visit. Within a neighborhood that offers many places to enjoy yourself.

CP

Founding place of Mike's Hot Honey, legendary pizza shop that gives you a classic NY slice. Shop was busy but wait times weren't bad. I probably wouldn't come back simply because there's so many pizza spots to try in NYC but I definitely recommend checking it out at least once!

I ordered the Hellboy pizza (triangle), and it was delicious. The hot honey complimentee well with the tomato sauce and the overall flavors perfectly. My only feedback from this visit is that the ins…

I ordered the Hellboy pizza (triangle), and it was delicious. The hot honey complimentee well with the tomato sauce and the overall flavors perfectly. My only feedback from this visit is that the…

I ordered the Hellboy pizza (triangle), and it was delicious. The hot honey complimentee well with the tomato sauce and the overall flavors perfectly. My only feedback from this visit is that the i…

I ordered the Hellboy pizza (triangle), and it was delicious. The hot honey complimentee well with the tomato sauce and the overall flavors perfectly. My only feedback from this visit is that the i…

This is my first time trying their slice shop location! I really like the old 80s vibes in here. All of the slices are very good. My boyfriend and I were originally trying to go to their sit down res…

Great place to grab a slice in the Greenpoint! The waiting time is sometimes a bit longer than in other establishments like this, but the food quality is good.

Great place to grab a slice in the Greenpoint! The waiting time is sometimes a bit longer than in other establishments like this, but the food quality is good.

My friend and I stopped here for a slice of pizza on a Saturday night around 6:15pm. We managed to get a table. I loved the decor; it felt like a classic pizzeria. The slice itself was good.

Small pizza shop in a busy neighborhood. We preferred the slices rather than the pie maybe because the pie was as crispy.

Small pizza shop in a busy neighborhood. We preferred the slices rather than the pie maybe because the pie was as crispy.

Not a fan of the sesame seed in pizza dough. Ordered a margarita and it was luke warm not hot. I should haven't known better. The ambiance is streetwear pizza shop I call it the kith template it's …

Overall good pizza. The vodka was super cheesy and crust was good but could have been better. Nice ambiance and quick service.

Overall good pizza. The vodka was super cheesy and crust was good but could have been better. Nice ambiance and quick service.

Subpar pizza. Social media marketing is one helluva drug. \n\nThere are better pizza places than this joint. $5 for a mini dominos slice and $30 for a pie is crazy. If you are charging that much, a…

I got the vodka slice and a plain slice. The vodka sauce was great but the slice itself was just ok. \n\n$11 for 2 slices and a Diet Coke is always wild. The plain slice was solid though. \n\nThe v…

I dig this pizza joint in Greenpoint serving delicious pizza in a cool retro setting . Got a large pie for the gang and I ,pizza is top notch , from cheese , tomato sauce and chewy crust .Keeping i…

Andy Liu

Rating: 6.5/10 Date Last Visited: 9/5/2025 I ordered a Hellboy Squared slice ($6). The slice itself was decent, didn’t feel special but it was still good. I liked the combination of hot honey on the pepperoni, but the pizza itself had too much crust, maybe because we got corner pieces. The crust itself was good, crispy but not overcooked. I wish there was a bit more cheese. Also, the searing area was a bit dirty. Overall, this is a pretty good pizza slice but there’s too much pizza competition in New York.

There's always a wait but the line moves quickly! \n\nIf you like white sauce pizza, mootz is really good esp when it's hot and fresh! Pepperoni is really good, as well! Sausage and cheese are ok, …

Matthew Morris

I used to go to Paulie Gee's slice shoppe when I lived in Greenpoint. I moved two years ago. Over the last six months I have been to the slice shop three times, and eveytime has been worse than the last... its not horrible, but its nowhere never what it used to be. The first time back, I thought I caught them on a bad day. The second time, I was excited to put the previous and only bad experience behind me, but no... it was somehow worse. And the third, and sadly the last time, even worse. Let me preface this, it was a Sunday at 7:00pm (I'm not sure if that's an excuse) anyway, I walked in and look into the pizza window, every pie looks old as that, the cheese look like it had been reheated several times and left in the fridge. But still, I ordered 4 slices. I was driving back upstate about an hour, so I started to eat the first slice right away, less then 3 minutes from receiving it. The first slice was barely room temperature, so I moved on to the second same thing, then the third. I was hungry so I can see, the lukewarm-at-best, hellboy slice. It was bland, the pepperoni was clearly different than it was 2 plus years ago, the cheese what they thick mat, that I left a clear bite mark in. No, gooey stringy Pizza goodness. Somehow, when I got home and reheated all of the slices, the cheese never returned to anything that would resemble a pizza. I'm not sure what happened over the last year or two, but Paulie Gee's has definitely changed its Cheese, and everything else for the worst. Edit: Thank you for the sincere reply.

J S

Pizza quality has gone down hill over the years. You can tell they put minimal effort into the pies. Slices are warped, dry, burnt and just bland overall. Consistency is gone. It takes forever to place an order. There is zero hustle from the cashiers and they seem so dopey and lost at times. They have very little situational awareness when the line starts to build to speed things up and avoid the unnecessary banter with customers. I partly blame the insanely loud music which makes it hard for them to hear your order. Seriously lower the volume a little. You can tell that the locals have lost taste for the pizza here. The place used to be bumping on weekday evenings, now not so much. I guess the hype is long gone, it sucks because it used to be a decent place …especially with all the good places in the neighborhood having closed down.

Horrible customer service \nI typically don't care about the stuff's smiles, etc but this place is way worse than a random $1 slice shop. \nThe cashier guy was pretending my accent is hard to underst…

Horrible customer service \nI typically don't care about the stuff's smiles, etc but this place is way worse than a random $1 slice shop. \nThe cashier guy was pretending my accent is hard to under…

waited 25 min for a couple slices of cold pizza this place absolutely sucks and customer service sucks even worse