I went there for the first time today and I absolutely LOVED everything. The bread was delicious. The Alfredo pasta with shrimp was incredible. The service was impeccable and friendly, even from the cook. They deserve all the praise! 1000/10! I will return and have already recommended it to others price? AMAZING!.

Justin Mullican

The people working were fantastic. And the pizza especially for the price was amazing

Ilana R

Most delicious thin crust pizza in nyc. Try the veggie.

Howard Abrams

I have been going to Pizza Plus for 35 years. Excellent food, reasonably priced, great service. My favorite dish is the whole wheat pasta primavera with grilled chicken and marinara sauce.

R. Spencer

Highly recommend for anyone looking for some of the BEST baked ziti in Brooklyn! We came here for dinner and ordered the baked ziti dinner which came with 4 fresh rolls of warm bread and plenty of butter as well as small dinner salads! 🥗 🥖 We also got some cheesy garlic bread which was toasted to perfection and so flavorful 🍝 The main course was the cheese baked ziti which was IMPECCABLE! Saucy rich robust and cheesy with a lightly charred topped oven baked. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Everything was so delicious! We can’t wait to come back!

+1

Maryan Dumas

Such a cute place with delicious pizza.

Jason

A neighborhood gem that delivers—literally and figuratively! Pizza Plus has quickly become my go-to spot for comfort food done right. Their delivery service is consistently prompt and friendly, which makes ordering in feel like a treat rather than a compromise. The food? Absolutely delicious. From the crispy thin-crust pizzas to the hearty eggplant parm heroes, every bite tastes like it was made with care. What really sets Pizza Plus apart is the ambiance. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a slice to go, the vibe is cozy and welcoming—classic Brooklyn charm with a touch of modern warmth. It’s the kind of place where locals gather, families feel at home, and the staff remembers your favorite order. If you’re in South Slope and craving Italian comfort with top-notch service, Pizza Plus is a must. Five stars all the way!

csv987

That pizza was insanely good. And the staff were super friendly and helpful—especially the owner, who was outstanding. It really made the whole experience.

Jane Fielder

This is a family favorite for us and our youngest especially loves the Detroit pizza. They also have really great carrot cake.

Eric Finkbeiner

Amazing traditional NY Style pizza right in the heart of Brooklyn! Fast, friendly service and a huge menu. Maybe a TV or some background music would be nice. Highly recommend!