Jason Mcgarry

Visited here twice during our Christmas vacation and absolutely loved it! The service was on point with very clear directions and friendly staff. Had the steak & eggs, breakfast skillet, toasted chocolate muffin and drinks the first time, all very well cooked, seasoned & presented nicely. The chocolate muffin was the best I've ever tasted! Second time we came we had the apple/Cinnamon pancakes, crispy bacon, toast, chocolate muffin & drinks. Again all tasted amazing! Our servers both times we above and beyond with the service we received and were very accommodating to changes with items on our order. We would 100% come back here again if in NYC & would recommend anyone visiting here to try it out for a classic American breakfast with the best service we received for our whole trip.

Sledge Williams

Been some time since I came to a Diner just for the experience of it all and it was pretty solid overall. Moment I came in I was automatically greeted by one of the employees there and was led to a table in the middle of the Diner. From the outside the place looks narrow but it looks a lot larger when inside as there's a lot of seating and plenty of people in the place, probably concluding after a day of Black Friday shopping. A waitress came about a minute after me taking in the sights and she was very courteous and attentive even with the extra crowd traffic in the restaurant. I ordered a special or sorts, a starter, entree & dessert special for $28 and in order that is Onion Rings, a Deluxe Cheeseburger w/ Fries and a slice of Apple Pie. Delicious and filled menup proper. Onion Rings had a nice crisp to them, the burger was prepared good, even presented well, could've done with some less lettuce but other than that, it was delightful in taste and texture. The fries although good, most were crisp and a few were soggy but didn't take away from the side as a whole. I couldn't finish the entirety of the fries and rings because I wanted to leave some room left for Apple Pie and it was otherworldly. Toasty, tender, apple crisp with a hint of Cinnamon, it was grand. As for a drink it was standard, just an ice tea as something to wash down the food. Pretty solid for $28, though fo course the Iced Tea came up to $3 then there's tax and a courteous tip which rounded up to $40. Yeah dining in NYC is not for the financially weak. So yeah, I'd come around again in the future and try out breakfast from there. Once again 2 thumbs up for the servers there, dishing out warm courtesy on a fairly cold day in an even colder city.

+1

Miley Hong

omg！ I love the breakfast here! The steak and eggs is so amazing! And I can’t have enough for their homemade coffee, it’s so yumyum, I will come back every single day, very near to anyone stays in timesquare.

Lauren McAdams

A wonderful cozy stop on a brisk NYC morning! We stopped here for an easy breakfast/brunch. We got seated immediately and were warmly greeted by Charmaine who was so kind and brought us hot coffee within moments! Food came out quick and was delicious. Atmosphere was cozy as we are midwesterners who love a family style diner. A+ for food, service & atmosphere ⭐️

Sportmensch

We went on our last morning to this spot for a very nice breakfast. Our Server was Agnes and she did a tremdously good job. The Hot chocolate was very good and the pancakes were on point, my daughter totally enjoyed. The Hot chocolate was very tasteful. Overall I can recommend this place for their nice options and attentive service. Conveniently located as well. I'd precisely rate it 4.7/5.

Lily Moore

What a classic American diner ! Prices were good and food was exceptional! Ordered the strawberry pancakes and request Nutella and my server was able to do it right away, my mother bought the ham and cheese omelette and very much enjoyed the potatoes on the side. Very fast paced environment but not lacking in customer service whatsoever, lovely warm environment !! Thank you :)

Nekonoe

Ok, hear me out. This place was our lifesaver during our time in NY. We were in a nearby Hotel (Kixby) and when we wanted something good and affordable, we came here. In the week we were in NY, we came here several times. The food is amazing, portions are fresh and huge and of course delicious. Staff was amazing and kind! And anytime we were there the tables were filled well but we always got seats without having to wait. When I return to NY, I will definitely come back here. And I can only talk good and recommend this place to anyone who is there!

+2

Vitor Angelo

Our recent experience at the establishment was highly positive. The event was flawlessly executed, and the culinary offerings were exceptional. It presents a favorable dining option near Times Square, providing value within a reasonable budget.

Crystal Burgess

Andrews NYC Diner was about an 8 min walk from our hotel, which worked because we wanted somewhere close. We were seated right away and the server was quite funny. A middle aged lady with an accent! The food came quickly and was delicious. I don’t recall the price but I know it was cheaper than Carnegie, which we visited a day or so prior. Definitely recommended.

Karen Fleming

Great diner. Had breakfast here twice during our stay, Charmaine served us both mornings, and was so nice! Food was amazing, will definitely be my first stop the next time we're in Manhattan