Fratello’s Pizza Company

Fratello’s Pizza Company in Horseheads, NY, offers an exceptional dining experience that stands out in the local culinary scene. Their pizzas are crafted with a generous amount of delicious cheese and a perfectly seasoned sauce, all atop a crust that achieves an ideal balance of crispness and flavor.  Beyond their signature pizzas, Fratello’s provides a diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options. Their fresh salads, accompanied by a divine Italian dressing, and irresistible garlic knots are noteworthy additions that enhance the meal.  The establishment is known for its excellent customer service, with a friendly and attentive staff that contributes to a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons.  Fratello’s Pizza Company has garnered high praise from its customers, with many considering it the best pizza they’ve ever had. The combination of high-quality ingredients, diverse menu options, and outstanding service makes Fratello’s a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts in the Horseheads area. 

don't trust the bad reviews make your own opinion!!! not like any other pizza around very tasty and the staff was friendly and full of energy and they show you your food before you walk out. large cheese pizza was less than 20 and hevy!!! the cheese was delicious and the sauce is amazing and the dough was good as well. will be my new favorite place to get pies for sure!!!

Great pizza , wonderful service 10/10

I have always gotten pizza from here as its always perfect and excellent.. today i got a sub, oh my goodness, above excellent. was a bit too big for me but was excellent. Im glad you guys are there and also that you deliver to my area! Great job!

Stopped through on my way from Syracuse to Elmira for a quick lunch. The service was amazing, pizza was great! 2 slices and a bottle of soda under $9. Thank you, Fratello’s. Molto bene!

We had gone down to Horseheads for our favorite Pudgies Pizza, but the parking lot was freshly paved and blocked off. It being just around 7pm, we were nervous that no other pizza places would be open much longer. My son suggested Fratello's, so we drove on over. What we experienced was THE BEST PIZZA we have ever had. (And we are big-time Pizza lover's.) The cheese was so delicious and plentiful, the sauce was perfect and that crust.... well, it knocked all our Sox off. Just the exact crispness to the bottom crust and the flavor at the end just made me sad that I was too full for another slice. Our server was very nice and efficient. We will always love Pudgies, but now we have another New Favorite to visit when we are in upstate NY. Highly Recommend Fratello's Pizza Company of Horseheads, NY. A+++++

Or go-to place for pizza, wings, stuffed shells, some times subs, etc. That sauce they have, it makes all the difference. They are friendly, and accurate, they make sure your order is right before you leave if you're picking it up, which we always do. And if something is ever wrong, immediate fixing it with no arguments. They want to make you happy, and serve great food so it's easy. They deliver too, average delivery times for the area, possibly a little bit shorter.

If I could give the service 10 Stars, I would! The person who took our order was super helpful and very kind. The food was fabulous. We had a cheesesteak and zucchini fries. The cheesesteak was flavorful and juicy and the vegetables were great. The zucchini fries were perfect. The breading was light and crisp and the zucchini was tender but not mushy. Will be back!

Excellent food on a cold and wet night. Clemente and Giovanni are super friendly. The pizza was light and tasty as were the garlic knots. The stuffed shells were excellent. Thank you! 🙏

Outstanding pizza. Definitely the best pizza in Chemung County.

Theresa Hulslander

Great pizza , wonderful service 10/10

Nathan Bloom

Outstanding pizza. Definitely the best pizza in Chemung County.

Arkalgud Sitaram

Excellent food on a cold and wet night. Clemente and Giovanni are super friendly. The pizza was light and tasty as were the garlic knots. The stuffed shells were excellent. Thank you! 🙏

Paul Grego

Fratello’s Pizza Company in Horseheads, NY, offers an exceptional dining experience that stands out in the local culinary scene. Their pizzas are crafted with a generous amount of delicious cheese and a perfectly seasoned sauce, all atop a crust that achieves an ideal balance of crispness and flavor.  Beyond their signature pizzas, Fratello’s provides a diverse menu catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options. Their fresh salads, accompanied by a divine Italian dressing, and irresistible garlic knots are noteworthy additions that enhance the meal.  The establishment is known for its excellent customer service, with a friendly and attentive staff that contributes to a welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is also wheelchair accessible, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons.  Fratello’s Pizza Company has garnered high praise from its customers, with many considering it the best pizza they’ve ever had. The combination of high-quality ingredients, diverse menu options, and outstanding service makes Fratello’s a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts in the Horseheads area. 

Jennifer Scheer

Stopped through on my way from Syracuse to Elmira for a quick lunch. The service was amazing, pizza was great! 2 slices and a bottle of soda under $9. Thank you, Fratello’s. Molto bene!

headon

don't trust the bad reviews make your own opinion!!! not like any other pizza around very tasty and the staff was friendly and full of energy and they show you your food before you walk out. large cheese pizza was less than 20 and hevy!!! the cheese was delicious and the sauce is amazing and the dough was good as well. will be my new favorite place to get pies for sure!!!

Carolyn Ackler

I have always gotten pizza from here as its always perfect and excellent.. today i got a sub, oh my goodness, above excellent. was a bit too big for me but was excellent. Im glad you guys are there and also that you deliver to my area! Great job!

KJ Rimbey

We had gone down to Horseheads for our favorite Pudgies Pizza, but the parking lot was freshly paved and blocked off. It being just around 7pm, we were nervous that no other pizza places would be open much longer. My son suggested Fratello's, so we drove on over. What we experienced was THE BEST PIZZA we have ever had. (And we are big-time Pizza lover's.) The cheese was so delicious and plentiful, the sauce was perfect and that crust.... well, it knocked all our Sox off. Just the exact crispness to the bottom crust and the flavor at the end just made me sad that I was too full for another slice. Our server was very nice and efficient. We will always love Pudgies, but now we have another New Favorite to visit when we are in upstate NY. Highly Recommend Fratello's Pizza Company of Horseheads, NY. A+++++

Brittany Smith

My dad and I stopped in this week, he loved the pizza, my hot sub was top notch, and I was served the most perfectly pulled shot of espresso. If I only I could transplant the whole restaurant to Florida. We need some good pizza down south!

Kate Landschoot

Or go-to place for pizza, wings, stuffed shells, some times subs, etc. That sauce they have, it makes all the difference. They are friendly, and accurate, they make sure your order is right before you leave if you're picking it up, which we always do. And if something is ever wrong, immediate fixing it with no arguments. They want to make you happy, and serve great food so it's easy. They deliver too, average delivery times for the area, possibly a little bit shorter.

I don't like rating and restaurant after only one visit. You never know if you caught them on a good day or a bad day. I ordered pizza and wings. The pizza was good, not great but good enough for me to order again. The wings were very good, but like most places these day, their HOT wings are more like medium. Next time I'll ask for extra hot and see what happens. Prices were average for this style pizza shop. PS: place was nice and clean.

Ron M

I don't like rating and restaurant after only one visit. You never know if you caught them on a good day or a bad day. I ordered pizza and wings. The pizza was good, not great but good enough for me to order again. The wings were very good, but like most places these day, their HOT wings are more like medium. Next time I'll ask for extra hot and see what happens. Prices were average for this style pizza shop. PS: place was nice and clean.

Not bad over all was very patient with my child and said nothing even though he was running all over ,we came in and was alone though, got slice special and stuffed shells/garlic knots loved the food but can say more sauce on pizza was needed to meet the cheese/sauce ratio, a little spice in the sauce and minced garlic or extra garlic salt on the knots but it was good! I will order again!

kimmy sue

Not bad over all was very patient with my child and said nothing even though he was running all over ,we came in and was alone though, got slice special and stuffed shells/garlic knots loved the food but can say more sauce on pizza was needed to meet the cheese/sauce ratio, a little spice in the sauce and minced garlic or extra garlic salt on the knots but it was good! I will order again!

We used to order here every week. It's been months since the last time we ordered. Tonight we ordered the Palermo pack and paid extra for jack Daniels wings sauce. It tasted nothing like the jack Daniels sauce I remember as well as the chicken wings appeared to be over cooked yet soggy, the garlic knots were burnt . Between raise in prices and inconsistency I think this will be our last order.

Kim Stehm

We used to order here every week. It's been months since the last time we ordered. Tonight we ordered the Palermo pack and paid extra for jack Daniels wings sauce. It tasted nothing like the jack Daniels sauce I remember as well as the chicken wings appeared to be over cooked yet soggy, the garlic knots were burnt . Between raise in prices and inconsistency I think this will be our last order.

$2.99 per topping. Seriously? MAYBE a dollars worth of chicken, maybe $.75 worth of ground beef… get f’n real with the broccoli, shouldn’t even have been charged for the 18-EIGHTEEN pieces. Lol. What a joke. Dough was barely cooked, not cooked in the center, cheese isn’t even melted…. Also, the sauce has gone down hill. Very disappointed. Terrible. Won’t order again.

Undercooked delivered pizza. This pizza place used to be very good. I am not sure what has changed, but very disappointed and will go elsewhere from now on.

Megan Grace Tuttle

$2.99 per topping. Seriously? MAYBE a dollars worth of chicken, maybe $.75 worth of ground beef… get f’n real with the broccoli, shouldn’t even have been charged for the 18-EIGHTEEN pieces. Lol. What a joke. Dough was barely cooked, not cooked in the center, cheese isn’t even melted…. Also, the sauce has gone down hill. Very disappointed. Terrible. Won’t order again.

Jeffrey McLeod

Undercooked delivered pizza. This pizza place used to be very good. I am not sure what has changed, but very disappointed and will go elsewhere from now on.