Karin Cronk

This is some of the best pizza I have had in a long time! I had a slice with mushroom and garlic, yum! Great job, I loved it and will definitely be back! Thank you!

Kyle Kammer

Great little spot to stop in for some authentic NY style pizza! Amazing pies, even better service and cozy atmosphere. Also, the filled to order canoli was right up there with the best I've ever had!

J Klemann

Accidentally left my wallet and they were wonderful about helping me get it back. My husband's favorite pizza for a quarter century, and fresh cannoli, too! Great place with kind employees. Worth a stop!

Nick Foster

Some of the best pizza around. This place is simply fantastic.

Joey

Best Pizza in Geneseo without question. Definitely the best Pizza I've had in Livingston County. Thin crust with the right amount of sauce and cheese, and not greasy. Never had a bad slice.

Rebeca DePra

I have come here since 1990 when it opened. I was attending SUNY-Geneseo and since I have graduated , had children who grew up eating mama mia, brought my niece and had brought my grandnieces ( they moved to Ohio and when they come to this area they insist that this is a must to get pizza from ), also my nephews have grown up coming here and now I have my grandson who love love loves the pizza. I hope Eddie never changes his formula !!! Is the best pizza in 1990 and still the best today

Lisa Powers

We grabbed slices and drinks and garlic knots and a canoli for lunch and it was fantastic. We ordered for eat in and enjoyed our lunch at their patio tables outside. Everything was delicious. We will definitely come back here next time we visit the area.

Samuel

This is, in my opinion, the best pizza in Upstate NY. Geneseo is a college town and this place is right on Main Street. Sometimes it gets pretty busy but the prices are excellent and the pizza is outstanding. Typical New York, thin crust, pizza crispy crust on the bottom chewy throughout just the right amount of sauce and cheese.

Oliver Philip Babb

Came on Labor Day. Was not expecting a lot and was pleasantly surprised. Pizza is a solid NYC slice. Guy behind the counter seemed like the only one working but was flying around the kitchen and running it like a pro.

Pepper Makepeace

Great food! My favorite kind of pizza! Caprese panini was really good too.

Clinton Seiwell

The place was filled with smoke. The owner is rude to his costumers and i seen him picking his nose make pizza.

James Brunken

Place needs to clean their ovens as it’s a smoke show inside. Smells terrible for a pizza place. Ordered 4 pies at 3:30 for 5pm pick up. Not ready at 5. Told us 6 minutes. After waiting 15 minutes we are told that our other 2 pies were just going into the oven. No recognition of the lie and no clue that these are for a party that we are now late with food for. Go across the street to Pizza Paul’s. This place has lost all its luster.