The Everything wings and Cajun wings are incredible!!! Pizza is great too!!

this was amazing. there food was excellent and warm. the food tasted fresh! come here!

Amazing pizza

The best pizza and service!!

The everything wings were game changers. Exactly what I want in a bbq wing. Spice, sweet and not to saucy.

Great place the eat. Very friendly staff. Best Cajun wings I've had.

Used to be Besta Pizza. Seems to have been an ownership change. Excellent pizza and wings regardless of ownership. Ordered some food from their when visiting out of town and people really enjoyed it.

11/10! The stinger and garlic bread with cheese is so good, and so is the pizza!! The customer service is amazing too. I recommend to everyone I know!

Great pizza, service great, very friendly staff.

Great food, friendly staff.

They are always so kind here we love coming here on our lunches!

Bullseye pizza has very good pizza. The quantity of the ingredients is impressive. In most cases, your wait time for a pick up is 30 minutes or less. They have a very good menu and everything I have had was excellent.

My new favorite place!! Food is incredible and the staff is amazing. The everything wings are to die for!!! Environment is family friendly and always a good time

Excelente lugar y la atención es increíble, quedé encantado con el bacon cheese burger sandwich 🤯🤯 increíblemente bueno

This place is Pizza Works on steroids. Same Lunch Specials but better food and larger portions. Will be traveling the extra couple miles for this quality. Chicken fingers busting out of sub. Large side salads, Un-soggy pizza subs.

The food is fantastic and the staff is friendly! 10 out of 10 recommend 👍🏼

We got a steak specialty pizza. It was really good!!!! We will be back! Super friendly staff as well! 👍👍👍👌👌👌

Great food! The workers are all friendly! Highly recommend!

Great food and service. Would highly recommend!

Pizza was good just wish the crust was baked more

Excellent quality and delicious pizza...so much food with the lunch specials - definitely going back!!!

Great place to grab a quick slice when you're on the go. Savory specialty slice options. Clean and neat dining room.

Awesome food and friendly staff

The food is good, the prices are reasonable, and the staff is so friendly.

Great stuff - the everything wings are amazing!

Consistently good food from subs to pizza to chicken fingers staff is really 👍 good

Great owner! Great food

WOW!!! AMAZING!!! I Hope they stick around for a long time! You have to try the subs!! Sooo good!!!!!

Nice quaint new pizzeria in the area. Family owned and personable

I love it thanks, Nick

Great pizza, amazing wings!!!

Best pizza in town. Always legit.

Finally a good replacement for the besta spot!! REALLY GOOD EVERYTHING 👍

Best around!

Great pizza!

This place rules

The best pizza in Getzville and the immediate vicinity of UB North Campus! They also offer discounts to first responders, which is convenient being located near Amherst Police Headquarters, Erie County EMS and several local Fire Stations.

I always order here and they never fail to deliver good food and service!!

Playoff football goes great with pizza here! GO BILLS AND GO BULLS! Also just a great local pizza joint with decent seating area and great staff.

I so impressed by how friendly the staff was and most of all how couldn’t lunch was. Did not break the bank!! Got a lunch special with excellent wings a big specialty slice and a drink! Thank you Bullseye

Excellent pizza place! It is always consistent and the best pizza and wings in town. Definitely try the everything wings! They are amazing! Great service with friendly staff that is passionate about the quality.

Bullseye is under new management, and it seems to be making a big difference so far. It’s cleaner inside, the fresh paint is nice, and the food quality has stepped up. Always love the service here with the ladies behind the counter.

Omggg The Pizza and Wings are DELICIOUS.!!! I went here 3 days straight for their lunch special!!! Which was very reasonable!!! The workers there are ABSOLUTELY AMAZING AND VERY NICE.!!!

Great food and great leadership. We buy their food once a week.

My wife and I discovered this restaurant today and are so glad that we tried it for lunch. Everything we ordered was excellent including the delicious pizza, the salad, and the wings. For a pizzeria, their menu is extensive. Besides pizza and wings, they have subs, fries, cajun fries, tacos, a wide variety of salads to choose from, and much more. They even offer a fish fry dinner if you're not in the mood for pizza. The service is great, the workers are more than friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. Whenever we happen to be in their area we will definitely be stopping in again. Bullseye Pizza nails the target!

I ordered a turkey sub tonight for the first time. I was hesitant because I hate shredded lettuce. Well, it was delicious. One of the best I've ever had ! I highly recommend this place. The pizza is delish as well and u can actually buy a few wings if u only prefer several. How great, huh ? Thx!

Best wings in Buffalo, you gotta try the Everything Wing!

Stopped in for a ham sub. The lady at the counter was super friendly and helpful, she is awesome. The sub is amazing! Seriously the best one I've had on my visit back town. It's fantastic.

Being a picky pizza person, I was skeptical,but It was so good!! Chewy crust, great sauce, cheesy. Good prices.

Their pizza by the slice and subs are so delicious. Their staff is beyond friendly I can say anything but positive things about my food and experience.

DELICIOUS...That's what I Have to say about Bullseye...so glad to have them in the neighborhood.The owner and his staff are great people and always want to make sure you love your food...and we always do.Stop in all the time for the ready to go slices and wings...always delicious and they have a great sauce.Tammy makes a mean sub always amazing...she is the sauce and sub artist. So if you live near by or pass it by...stop in and give it a try. You will be happy that you did!

Great pizza and even better service!

This is what a Buffalo pizza / sub shop should always be. The menu items you will see are pretty typical for this type of restaurant but it's all bigger and better. Lunch specials until 3pm are a good deal. If you're in the area it's a no brainier.

Grabbed a lunch special of a slice and 5 wings. Pizza was solid, great cheese. But the Cajun wings I got were amazing. super crispy, great seasoning, and juicy on the inside. You keep serving Cajun wings with the lunch special and I'll keep getting it.

Excellent steak sub the steak was moist and not dry or overcooked and the veggies and roll were fresh.. on the lunch special you can't go wrong and great service 👍 👍

Stopped in for a quick lunch break and the food was fantastic. Pizza is high level and might I say the wings are almost as good as Elmo’s. Highly recommended!

First time trying Bullseye Pizza. Disclaimer. **Never order pizza online while driving**. In a last second decision while working. I mistakenly ordered a personal. I didn’t see the large while scrolling and focusing on the road. The crust and dough on this personal weren’t good Great pepperoni. Sauce and cheese were ok. I will be ordering a large next time to give them a fair chance. It’s 100% my fault ordering a personal while driving. So my PSA is. Never ordering pizza while driving

Literally best pizza shop in Buffalo!

Kyle Matesic

First time trying Bullseye Pizza. Disclaimer. **Never order pizza online while driving**. In a last second decision while working. I mistakenly ordered a personal. I didn’t see the large while scrolling and focusing on the road. The crust and dough on this personal weren’t good Great pepperoni. Sauce and cheese were ok. I will be ordering a large next time to give them a fair chance. It’s 100% my fault ordering a personal while driving. So my PSA is. Never ordering pizza while driving

Don Greyson

Playoff football goes great with pizza here! GO BILLS AND GO BULLS! Also just a great local pizza joint with decent seating area and great staff.

Christopher Mekker

The best pizza in Getzville and the immediate vicinity of UB North Campus! They also offer discounts to first responders, which is convenient being located near Amherst Police Headquarters, Erie County EMS and several local Fire Stations.

Bullseye is great. Friendly owner, good people, and the pizza is always solid. Glad to have a place like this in the neighborhood.

Great food. Pizza was great and the owner Corey was awesome. Definitely a place to go to for wings and pizza.

Absolutely phenomenal pizza and wings! I’ve had many kinds wings from many places, and today I tried the Everything wing from Bullseye - and I have a new all time favorite! I couldn’t get enough! The owners are very friendly and welcoming as well. If you pass this place up without trying their food, you’re really missing out!

We absolutely love this pizzeria! The food is awesome and the service is amazing. The staff is so friendly. It’s a must try.

The pizza is amazing! Even the outside crust has an absolutely delicious flavor, like it's brushed with spices. They do not skimp on the toppings, they are fully loaded. Chicken finger pizza is some of the best we've had. It's so great to have an awesome pizza place in this location again!

Bullseye Pizza stands out amidst the pizza scene in Buffalo. And that’s really saying something considering Buffalo is known for its incredible pizza options. But Bullseye does it differently. Not only is their food top notch, affordable, and filling, their management is community focused with a desire to use food to bring people together. If you’re looking for a great, reliable food option for a large event, need a family-friendly place to take the kids, or just want a couple slices for yourself, I can’t recommend this place enough.

Yesterday after a doctors appointment I ordered from here for the first time. The customer service was excellent. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. My pizza was delicious. It was layered just right. Equal amounts of cheese to crust ratio and the perfect amount of sauce. It's now on the top 3 of my go to pizza places. I'm looking forward to trying it again, but next time I'll order their special with chicken wings. It's hard to find a pizzeria that crisps up the wings to perfection and I think this place can live up to my xx crisp chicken wing standards. I recommend this place.

Different pizza than everyone else. Threw me an extra wing and free drink. Definitely going back regardless of the freebies!

We ordered fish frys this past Friday and they were absolutely incredible! Amazing beer batter and perfectly cooked pieces of fish. The sides were top notch and their fries are always quality. Great start to fish fry season!

We had a great experience here! The restaurant has a modern, Italian pizza house vibe with a clean and welcoming atmosphere. The staff was friendly and attentive, even on a busy day (Halloween). We ordered a sheet pizza with pepperoni, a double order of chicken fingers, and a chef salad — everything was fresh, and delicious! It’s clear they care about quality, even during high-volume times. Highly recommend this place for anyone craving great pizza and excellent service!

great little local pizza place. thinner crust pizza. not super sweet sauce like typical buffalo pizza. highlight of it was the garlic butter parm crust. so good! we dinned in. one of the owners even came out and sat down with us for a minute. very nice guy. recently purchased the place. highly recommend the white pizza and everything wings. add hot honey to the pizza. will dine again or order takeout! new go to pizza spot

EXCELLENT food and service. I ordered a small pizza for pickup. The woman I ordered from was lovely, and when I went to pick it up, the man working the counter was extremely friendly, and really a pleasure! The dining area was clean, and I was extremely satisfied with the quality of the food. Even though this is not my first time ordering from Bullseye, I am super impressed!

My kids and I just picked up Bullseye supreme sheet pizza. Even though I live on the east side of Buffalo by ECMC I would definitely go out there and buy my pizza again. The kids and I found it quite tasteful The service was great very clean restaurant. Five stars all around and they will be seeing us again.

Bullseye Pizza is a true gem in the Buffalo area. I’ve been coming here for a few years now, and the quality never wavers. The food is always hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. What really sets Bullseye apart, though, is the management and staff — they work tirelessly to keep everything running smoothly and make every customer feel valued. You can tell they really care about their community and the people they serve.

Addie Marfo

great little local pizza place. thinner crust pizza. not super sweet sauce like typical buffalo pizza. highlight of it was the garlic butter parm crust. so good! we dinned in. one of the owners even came out and sat down with us for a minute. very nice guy. recently purchased the place. highly recommend the white pizza and everything wings. add hot honey to the pizza. will dine again or order takeout! new go to pizza spot

Marlane Benning

My kids and I just picked up Bullseye supreme sheet pizza. Even though I live on the east side of Buffalo by ECMC I would definitely go out there and buy my pizza again. The kids and I found it quite tasteful The service was great very clean restaurant. Five stars all around and they will be seeing us again.

Avery Blaszak

EXCELLENT food and service. I ordered a small pizza for pickup. The woman I ordered from was lovely, and when I went to pick it up, the man working the counter was extremely friendly, and really a pleasure! The dining area was clean, and I was extremely satisfied with the quality of the food. Even though this is not my first time ordering from Bullseye, I am super impressed!

Bambi Akright

We had a great experience here! The restaurant has a modern, Italian pizza house vibe with a clean and welcoming atmosphere. The staff was friendly and attentive, even on a busy day (Halloween). We ordered a sheet pizza with pepperoni, a double order of chicken fingers, and a chef salad — everything was fresh, and delicious! It’s clear they care about quality, even during high-volume times. Highly recommend this place for anyone craving great pizza and excellent service!

Caroline Bishop

Bullseye Pizza is a true gem in the Buffalo area. I’ve been coming here for a few years now, and the quality never wavers. The food is always hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious. What really sets Bullseye apart, though, is the management and staff — they work tirelessly to keep everything running smoothly and make every customer feel valued. You can tell they really care about their community and the people they serve.

carson ransom

I so impressed by how friendly the staff was and most of all how couldn’t lunch was. Did not break the bank!! Got a lunch special with excellent wings a big specialty slice and a drink! Thank you Bullseye

John Perry

Absolutely phenomenal pizza and wings! I’ve had many kinds wings from many places, and today I tried the Everything wing from Bullseye - and I have a new all time favorite! I couldn’t get enough! The owners are very friendly and welcoming as well. If you pass this place up without trying their food, you’re really missing out!

Leeann Roland

Omggg The Pizza and Wings are DELICIOUS.!!! I went here 3 days straight for their lunch special!!! Which was very reasonable!!! The workers there are ABSOLUTELY AMAZING AND VERY NICE.!!!

Solomon Leatherland

Bullseye Pizza stands out amidst the pizza scene in Buffalo. And that’s really saying something considering Buffalo is known for its incredible pizza options. But Bullseye does it differently. Not only is their food top notch, affordable, and filling, their management is community focused with a desire to use food to bring people together. If you’re looking for a great, reliable food option for a large event, need a family-friendly place to take the kids, or just want a couple slices for yourself, I can’t recommend this place enough.

Ashley

The pizza is amazing! Even the outside crust has an absolutely delicious flavor, like it's brushed with spices. They do not skimp on the toppings, they are fully loaded. Chicken finger pizza is some of the best we've had. It's so great to have an awesome pizza place in this location again!

Molly Armbruster

Excellent pizza place! It is always consistent and the best pizza and wings in town. Definitely try the everything wings! They are amazing! Great service with friendly staff that is passionate about the quality.

Johnny B. Goode

Bullseye is under new management, and it seems to be making a big difference so far. It’s cleaner inside, the fresh paint is nice, and the food quality has stepped up. Always love the service here with the ladies behind the counter.

Diana W

Yesterday after a doctors appointment I ordered from here for the first time. The customer service was excellent. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. My pizza was delicious. It was layered just right. Equal amounts of cheese to crust ratio and the perfect amount of sauce. It's now on the top 3 of my go to pizza places. I'm looking forward to trying it again, but next time I'll order their special with chicken wings. It's hard to find a pizzeria that crisps up the wings to perfection and I think this place can live up to my xx crisp chicken wing standards. I recommend this place.

Got a couple C&P slices for lunch, lowest price you'll see for decent fresh-made typical Buffalo-style pizza.

I've been there twice now. Food has been good and very good service. I hope it does better than its predecessors.

PAY ATTENTION- I will say this for everyone in the back! For good NY pizza, the sauce is NOT supposed to be sweet! I recently moved to the area and there is nothing around (beside one of the Duffs) that have regular pizza sauce. This place is the closest to a regular NY pizza taste. The "sweet sauce" thing they have going on in the area blows my mind(step away from the sugar). I would say this pizza is pretty good, however there needs to be a better balance of cheese to sauce ratio. Either slightly less on cheese, or more on the sauce. I will continue to order from this spot to have a regular cheese pizza, which is apparently hard to come by. [Side note, if you leave a review- leave a solution] <-read that again. Rant over.

Convenient and Affordable Lunch Spot! This place is perfect for a quick and budget-friendly lunch during workdays. The prices are reasonable, and the welcoming atmosphere adds to the enjoyment of the meal. It's become a staple among my colleagues and me, and we make it a point to visit at least once a week.

Bullseye Pizza stands out for its exceptional convenience, delectable food, and outstanding service. The location is easily accessible, making it a perfect choice for both dine-in and takeout. The menu offers a variety of delicious pizzas, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The service is consistently excellent, with Amy being particularly notable for her friendly demeanor and excellent customer service skills. Her attentiveness and warmth significantly enhance the dining experience. Overall, Bullseye Pizza is a top choice for anyone seeking great food and impeccable service.

Daniel Sciascia

Bullseye Pizza stands out for its exceptional convenience, delectable food, and outstanding service. The location is easily accessible, making it a perfect choice for both dine-in and takeout. The menu offers a variety of delicious pizzas, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The service is consistently excellent, with Amy being particularly notable for her friendly demeanor and excellent customer service skills. Her attentiveness and warmth significantly enhance the dining experience. Overall, Bullseye Pizza is a top choice for anyone seeking great food and impeccable service.

Ed

PAY ATTENTION- I will say this for everyone in the back! For good NY pizza, the sauce is NOT supposed to be sweet! I recently moved to the area and there is nothing around (beside one of the Duffs) that have regular pizza sauce. This place is the closest to a regular NY pizza taste. The "sweet sauce" thing they have going on in the area blows my mind(step away from the sugar). I would say this pizza is pretty good, however there needs to be a better balance of cheese to sauce ratio. Either slightly less on cheese, or more on the sauce. I will continue to order from this spot to have a regular cheese pizza, which is apparently hard to come by. [Side note, if you leave a review- leave a solution] <-read that again. Rant over.

They’ve done a nice job making the place look nicer than it’s predecessor. I’d imagine it would be hard not to be compared however. My friends supreme sub looked fantastic and he said it was great. My other friend said his sub was OK, but that the slice of pizza he had was fantastic. I was craving a chicken finger sub for a few weeks and I’ve noticed a lot of places are putting less chicken fingers on there subs, but that was not the case with bullseye. But I’m ahead of myself. Rewinding back to being at the counter, the way the specials were listed was confusing. The person ordering before me also seemed confused, so I’m not alone. He was charged wrong, it seems and argued that the board indicated it should be cheaper. Same happened to me. The impression I got was that a half sub & fries was $7 (which is a really good deal considering prices these days). It also appeared to indicate a whole sub was $7 (which didn’t make sense to me). It also says lunch specials come with a drink. So I saw a half chicken finger sub was $8. I didn’t want to argue and I wasn’t thirsty so I just said “I’ll just take a half sub, nothing else”. My total was over $10 and she handed me a cup. I said “is this mine?” She said “yes.” Confused, I went and got myself a drink and sat down. I figured “maybe she rang me up for the lunch special anyway.” I got half a sub delivered to my table but no fries. So…no lunch special? No matter. My friend handed me the take out menu which made way more sense. Don’t think the lady at the counter was confident, however. Anyway, the half chicken finger sub was more than enough and had two good fingers on it. It definitely was more hearty than most places have been lately. However the fingers tasted either overcooked or they were cooked in grease that was not very fresh (I used to work at a pizza shop). So the taste of the fingers was not great and later I did not feel well, at all. I will stop back sometime soon though, as their supreme steak sub looked delicious, as did their pizza. Also not sure what is up with their website, but it doesn’t seem to be working for placing online orders.

Stopped in for a lunch special, slice pepp, chx finger and a pop. Over 9.00 so already over 2.00 more than my reg place, dough was not right, real heavy, too much chz but the sauce was the worst I’ve ever had, Im mad at my husband so he can have the chx finger, hoping it’s just as bad. Im sorry guys, respect the hustle but there are too many good pizzas around. I really am sorry 😕 oh but the wings looked good but I didn’t get them. and plz put the fan on it smells like deep fryer really bad, pet peeve of mine. Sorry again!

Ordered a cheese pizza and cheese and pepperoni. About an average Buffalo pizza. Not as good as Besta in that location was. Too saucy, too cheesey (for a non-extra cheese pie), not baked enough (no crispness or body to bottom crust).

Ordered food online for pickup. Cheese steak subs were very basic and bland. Pizza was ok nothing special very little sauce and little flavor. Paid extra for sweet sauce tasted like store bought canned sauce. Wings were ordered half Cajun half medium and extra crispy what we received was all Cajun I think very little seasoning and far from crispy. The gentleman who took care of me was nice and polite looked like the family was all hanging out in the seating area which would be cool if you actually nailed the order but you didn't. After getting home and eating my thoughts were either they didn't care when they made it because it was Interrupting their time or they think they have a solid product. 80.00 for 2 subs a small specialty pizza and 20 wings for what we received was definitely not worth it. Really like to support small businesses but this one needs a lot of help. Sad to say this is one place we will not be returning to. Another waste of money which is sad.

Over the course of a year we went from stopping in for lunch twice a week to now never going back again. This place was great when it opened but after a few ownership changes it seems to have completely fallen apart. Now they serve half cooked slimy slices and barely sauces wing.

Wanted to try the Pizza, stopped in for a couple slices. The slices I saw in the display case were tiny, the guy who helped me got slices for me from the back that were bigger. I still felt the slices were kinda smallish compared to other area pizza places and other places prices. Pizza is so so at best, sauce is pretty nice. crust was more chewy than I expected. Its more like Buffalo style crust rather than a true NY City thin and crispy crust. I'm unsure about the rest of the food.. won't be back for slices and won't order a whole pizza from bullseye. I can make better pizza at home.

Nick Cook

Over the course of a year we went from stopping in for lunch twice a week to now never going back again. This place was great when it opened but after a few ownership changes it seems to have completely fallen apart. Now they serve half cooked slimy slices and barely sauces wing.

chris hayes

Wanted to try the Pizza, stopped in for a couple slices. The slices I saw in the display case were tiny, the guy who helped me got slices for me from the back that were bigger. I still felt the slices were kinda smallish compared to other area pizza places and other places prices. Pizza is so so at best, sauce is pretty nice. crust was more chewy than I expected. Its more like Buffalo style crust rather than a true NY City thin and crispy crust. I'm unsure about the rest of the food.. won't be back for slices and won't order a whole pizza from bullseye. I can make better pizza at home.

Ordered a large cheese and peperoni pizza and wings. Thats was by far the worst food i ever purchased. No flavor wings were like rubber. Horrible and would never recommend im shocked they are are still open.

Advertising lunch specials. Slices... go in and no slices

No pizza at lunch time. No air conditioning, no ice. Apathetic staff.

Waste of money…garbage

They are new in the area so we thought we would give it a try since my daughter came from LA and was having friends over. Stick to who u know! Bread sticks were just a thin pizza base that was rock hard. Noone ate it. The pizzas had NO taste. I offered everyone salt and pepper flakes which everyone jumped at but was to polite to say anything prior. It had NO TASTE! Never again!