Sandra Valdebenito

Posto Pazzo was absolutely amazing! This old-school Italian restaurant has been around for more than 20 years, and you can taste why — the food is always fresh and delicious. I love the cozy, welcoming vibe, especially seeing the ingredients displayed like in a traditional Italian eatery. It truly feels like home every time. Staff is very nice.

Xiomara Penafiel

Today I was craving Italian food, and my partner and I went here for the first time. It was a cozy place, everything was clean, and a nice place. The service was very good, and the food was good. The dress code was semi-casual. If you want something different, come and visit this place. I recommend it.

+3

Tommy D'Alessio

The food was excellent. Appetizer spread had a lot of variety. Dinner options are excellent, portion sizes didn't disappoint.

AClayton

Across the street from the water this restaurant has great food. Started off with a free basket of bread that was out on table with small rice balls and breadsticks. Waiter attentive and great service. Pasta was homemade and very tasty. Salads were awesome. Great dessert choices. Nice bar area to wait or hang out by. Gets crowded on a Saturday night so be sure you make reservations.

+8

My wife and I went to Tutu Pazzo with another couple and had a very nice dinner. It all started with a nice bread dish but also had rice balls in it. For starters my wife and I shared artichoke hearts with goat cheese and it was excellent. My entrée was the risotto with sausage and broccoli Rabe . I really loved it. My wife Had fettuccine with shrimp and she really enjoyed it. Overall it was a very nice meal and I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Courtni Hale

Nice bar and wine selection. They have a deal where you get a small portion (about 1/4 a normal portion with 2 ravioli) for $25. If you’re a light eater or trying to lose weight, it’s potentially a good option.

Monica Marinelli

I went on a Sunday for lunch and as soon as you enter the location is really nice and elegant. I ordered a negroni and it was really good. To start we ordered french fries and they were tasty, I also ordered a cold appetizer and the presentation is really scenic but if you look carefully there is some plantain and dried oranges and I don't think they are a good choice for an Italian appetizer. The staff was very professional and welcoming. All in all it was a positive experience, I will return soon.

+1

M Scotto

Food and service were very good! Bar area is great with a nice friendly bartender who did a great job with my negroni. Also a nice amenity was home made potato chips on the bar. The food was nicely prepared and presented. Reasonably priced as well. I ordered the linguine with grilled shrimp which was good but lacking depth of flavor. I had to dump lots of grated Parmesan cheese on it too give it a semblance of salt since there was no salt and pepper on the table. Other than that, the choices are excellent and I will go back to give it another shot.

+6

Kristen Slevin

This is a place that I’ve been meaning to try forever. However with so many Italian restaurants on Long Island it kept falling off the list. We arrived at noon on Saturday and the place was empty. We were greeted and immediately shown to a beautiful table with a harbor view. The menu is extensive, featuring a smaller portion lunch option. We started with clams oreganato. My husband thought it was the best he has ever had. I thought they were good but preferred something a little less saucy. The petite clams had a crisp breadcrumb topping under a rich lemon cream sauce. We certainly enjoyed soaking the sauce with the bread. This isn’t just any Italian restaurant. The star here is fresh house made pasta. If you have never had fresh pasta before you must try! It is a completely different experience than fresh made and refrigerated or box pasta. We finished with in house made tiramisu. It was awesome and tasted just like our Italian friend makes homemade for special occasions. Fresh cake and solid espresso warrants a crowd just for that. I usually keep my reviews simple. This is a MUST for anyone who truly appreciates authentic Italian cooking. Fresh pasta and fresh desserts. You swear there is an army of Nonna’s in the back. PS: our waiter was first class and there was a changing table in the women’s restroom.

+4

Goddess80 1980

If you are looking for a nice place to enjoy dinner with friends or grab an appetizer with a drink, check this place out! The food was good! But! The hidden gem was the Dubai Bar! You know the one you see being eaten on social media that you can't get in the US, we'll now you can! It was delicious! Plus it has a view of the water! Plenty of parking and away from the busy village if you are looking to go to dinner before a show.

Joseph Colacicco

For non-italians, this restaurant would probably receive a positive rating. For those of us who appreciate excellent Italian cusine, this place is seriously overpriced for mediocre food. Most of the waiters are professional, some need more training. The noise level is a little to high. The owner is not very pleasant. A friendly smile to greet customers would be helpful. If you are in the area, go to Piccolo's or even Sal D's for better food.

Jacob

The restaurant itself is a very nice set up. I used to go here years ago and comparing it to now it has definitely gone down hill on certain factors. Service was not great, took so long to get bread after asking multiple times to the staff, drinks were decent but they had brought over the wrong drink originally and had to correct it. Food was ok, it was honestly a bit cold by the time it got to the table. Our party all left feeling unsatisfied with the entire visit. Everything was just ok and for the price you expect to get hot food and the things you ordered without so many issues. No one wants to have to keep asking the staff for the same things multiple times. If it was just the bread they forgot to bring one time it would be not even a thought. But the amount of time we asked and then the drink issue and then on top of that the food coming out not even hot was very disappointing. Used to love this place but I most likely won’t be back after this visit.

Gloria Valentino

Called and made reservations arrived and got seated very quickly they didn’t have the table set for 11 people drinks took long to refill drinks and ask for refill on bread which we never got the food was very good but the service wasn’t good