Read's Ice Cream

Jamie Francis

Great selection of homemade ice cream with dairy free options! Great prices, customer service, and free samples. There was a coloring contest for kids and Jenga games to play too! Coconut and Coffee ice cream were great, along with the root beer float, cookie ice cream sandwiches, and freezer pop! We love supporting small businesses. We will definitely be back 🍦🍧🍨

Elise Harris

Kid friendly with coloring, tumbling towers, and small handmade trinkets for purchase. Several dairy free options as well. Owner makes all the ice cream himself and it tastes great!

Amber W.

HOMEMADE AND GLUTEN FREE AND DAIRY FREE OPTIONS? OKAY I SEE YOU! Often times, ice cream places have ONE dairy free option and a few gluten free options, but here, EVERY SINGLE FLAVOR is gluten free, even the oreo and cookie dough. Now THIS is my dream come true. There's even a few dairy free options beyond just boring vanilla. The homemade ice cream is thick and creamy, and the serving sizes are amazing for the price. My favorite is the oreo, which has big pieces of oreo blended into the sweet cream flavor and the dairy free chocolate which is so good, you cannot believe it's dairy free! There are also gluten free cones available. All the staff is super sweet, especially Norah who remembered me from the last time I was there. HIGHLY suggest checking this homemade delight out!

Sally Kamprath

My homemade cherry cheesecake ice cream was some of the creamiest I have ever had. YUMMY

Jill Burress

Wow! Creamcredible is absolutely delicious!!!!!! I am so excited that Henrietta has someone making homemade ice cream with fresh ingredients. I had the best Oreo ice cream and it was made gluten free! So good. The owner was right there, he was friendly and welcoming. The prices were great! You have to stop by this new gem, it is definitely worth the visit. I will be back a lot!

Sean Morrison

Pretty good ice cream, but highlight was being able to get two flavors on a “single” size cone.

Brittney Roman

Delicious homemade ice cream, amazing service very friendly staff. Will definitely be coming back for more

joy

Absolutely amazing!! The owner was wonderful and told me how each flavor was made. They are also all gluten free which is great, and they taste amazing! Super welcoming and tasty icecream, I couldn’t ask for anything else!

Very nice, friendly people. Great prices too.

Homemade, thick and creamy. I wanted to get a second one.

Best banana ice cream ever!

Great ice cream :)

Super ice cream stop!!

Delicious ice cream

Excellent!!!

Awesome flavours! Knowledgeable owner and great portions! Easily the best ice cream I've ever had!

Great ice cream and friendly staff. Most flavors are gluten free, even the Oreo cookie.

so out of all the ice cream places in henrietta this is the only place that makes there own, and the price is very reasonable.. surprising it has been open 2 months and i only just found it recently. i wish them the best of luck

Visiting only once you can tell they care a lot more than the previous owner that took over Read's. Great ice cream, look forward to coming again with my family.

I got the waffle and cookies & cream ice cream and they were gluten free! It was delish. Staff was awesome too :)

I bought a quart of vanilla ice cream for fresh picked strawberries and the vanilla is delicious! We will be back! Good customer service too!

First Experience was Exceptional . Customer Service from the owner was a delite. And to top it off the Shake hit the spot! Highly Recommend =)

Great staff , good variety , must be good , they keep emptying containers , hope they have Black Cherry Bourbon next time , grand baby likes that they have crayons and pictures to color.

I just had the BEST pistachio ice cream EVER! Creamy and so many nuts!! Thank you 😊 ~ Janet

It was one of the most best ice cream I have had! And those popsicles are so big I would eat all of them if I could.

New favorite place in NY for icecream. Really good ice cream & waffle cone. Friendly staff

Talk about homemade and local, this place makes their own ice cream! It was DELICIOUS

Amazing place. Amazing ice cream. The staff is nice and nice environment 👍🏻

Great Ice cream. New flavors! Owner is awesome

The Chocolate/Vanilla twist is off the charts creamy. Some of the best I have ever had.

Very nice, good icecream definitely will be returning to support this small business.

incredible yummy. The best ice cream I ever had!

Love Creamcredible! My husband is hooked on their banana ice cream!

Great service and great tasting ice cream.

Great ice cream and service, and very friendly staff!

Very good ice cream. Pleasant people working there.

Friendly, clean, great ice cream and service!!

Creamcredible is my new favorite ice cream spot!

New management...cool dude. Think he stole the recipes from Mr. Reed

Great ice cream at a good price.

They loaded pumpkin ice cream into a cookie for me.

Delicious, creamy home-made ice cream!

Some of the best ice cream around!

Fresh ingredients, friendly service and good prices

Best chocolate peanut butter I’ve ever had! And they do free doggy ice cream days so my pup can join in. Lots of parking and plenty of space to sit outside. Love it here. Staff is always pleasant.

This is the best ice cream shop around. The staff and the owner are incredibly nice and always are offering samples. The amount of ice cream for the price is amazing. Everything I have tried so far has been wonderful.

1st visit, impressed!! Very good ice cream, very friendly service, we will be back. We tried rum raisin, mint chocolate chip, and coffee toffee. They were all excellent, creamy and not too sweet.

Just yesterday we discovered Creamcredible - Ice Cream & Desserts in Henrietta in the former Read's Ice Cream location. The ice cream is made in house, and you can taste the difference. We each tried the ice cream, a sundae, and a milk shake and they all were delicious!!

The place to get your ice cream fix! Just came here tonight as my wife had been trying to get me here for sometime, and let me tell you. The options are plentiful, gluten free, dairy free, ect. Hands down the price is unbeatable and the ice cream tasted extremely fresh. Better than abbots and lugias. Will be coming back again!

Their ice cream is so good.and they have dairy free and coffee ice cream my granddaughter loves coffee ice cream she says it is soooo...... good

The ice cream here is great and the service is wonderful! we will definitely be back again. i got the oreo cookie and LOVED it and my boyfriend got an orange soda float and it was also amazing!

YUM. Hardpacked quart of chocolate/peanut butter ice cream. It was very tasty and good to the last spoonful. Highly recommend. Activities for kids in the middle of the seating area = crayons and coloring pages.

This place is truly incredible! I love the vibe, prices, employees and I'll be dreaming about the cheesecake ice cream until the next time I get it. Everything is homemade, love this place!

They have great ice cream!

Wow! Great ice cream, great service, great prices! They offer gluten free cones, and the cookies and cream ice cream is gluten free. We'll be returning very soon.

Dairy Free Options-Check Plenty of seating, including picnic tables and a cute pond- Check Delicious soft serve with real vanilla and chocolate-Check In store made waffle cones with a hint of cinnamon-Check Plenty of flavors by the scoop and toppings-Check This place is a delight!!

Boyfriend and I stopped in on a Monday evening. Two really sweet ladies treated us. Ice cream was delicious, will certainly be back!

My 7 year old demanded I leave a 5 star review as "this place is the best" and has "the best ice cream that [he's] ever had." Creamy and delicious!

Delicious! First ice cream of the season. Homemade ice cream on site with homemade fresh waffle cones! Very friendly.

Great flavors with a quality only homemade ice cream can have! We had the strawberry and rum raisin and would recommend both! The family that owns it is super sweet and really care about making a positive impact on the Henrietta community. Highly recommend! 👍🏼

Their ice cream is really good! They make it in-shop, so it’s fresh and great quality. The staff is so nice and checked in on us after we finished our ice cream to make sure we enjoyed it since it was our first visit. We will definitely be coming back!!

Delicious ice cream accompanied by fantastic service in a timely manner, I can't wait to go back! Not only are all of their ice creams gluten free, but homemade as well. As a college student I am used to minimal effort when being served because a great many of us are rude, rambunctious, and frankly mediocre tippers. However, I was met with no such assumptions, only genuine kindness when serving me, and for that I am delighted.

We tried this place during a weekday. It wasn't crowded and the service was fast. Our server was very pleasant and helpful! We tried a couple of flavors and settled on 2 small cups. The toppings were plentiful! Although the ice cream tasted good, it's not one of our favorites. You must try it though and decide for yourself, I'm sure you won't be disappointed!

My family loves this place. Ice cream is always great and the people who work here are very nice. Ice cream is homemade and GLUTEN FREE! EVEN THE COOKIE DOUGH! I have celiac so to find this place is amazing.

On the day we were there, the soft serve ice cream machines were down. Not McDonald's "down," but in pieces down. That said - the staff was very friendly and helpful. Bring the kids! It is adult friendly as there are coloring books and Jenga games out to keep the kids entertained. There is plenty of seating inside.

Cute ice cream shop with actual handmade flavors. You won't find freezer level ice cream here and I'm thankful for it! They have some truly fun flavors - pumpkin spice, banana and... spicy chocolate? The last one isn't for the faint of heart but you definitely can't find it anywhere else around here! If you're a fan of hot peppers, you gotta try this flavor. It's made with ghost pepper and left my mouth tingling for quite some time. If heat plus ice cream isn't for you, you can go wrong with any of their more tame flavors - they're all solid.

Super friendly even when they are slammed. I had the spicy chocolate and wowow hot and delicious. A unique ice cream experience. I loved it in a way an addiction starts. I have had their other flavors and they were all creamy and delicious. But I think I found my destination.

Gladys Kime

Their ice cream is so good.and they have dairy free and coffee ice cream my granddaughter loves coffee ice cream she says it is soooo...... good

FRANKLYN COWLES

On the day we were there, the soft serve ice cream machines were down. Not McDonald's "down," but in pieces down. That said - the staff was very friendly and helpful. Bring the kids! It is adult friendly as there are coloring books and Jenga games out to keep the kids entertained. There is plenty of seating inside.

Niki Lindquist

Cute ice cream shop with actual handmade flavors. You won't find freezer level ice cream here and I'm thankful for it! They have some truly fun flavors - pumpkin spice, banana and... spicy chocolate? The last one isn't for the faint of heart but you definitely can't find it anywhere else around here! If you're a fan of hot peppers, you gotta try this flavor. It's made with ghost pepper and left my mouth tingling for quite some time. If heat plus ice cream isn't for you, you can go wrong with any of their more tame flavors - they're all solid.

DNA Digital Marketing

Super friendly even when they are slammed. I had the spicy chocolate and wowow hot and delicious. A unique ice cream experience. I loved it in a way an addiction starts. I have had their other flavors and they were all creamy and delicious. But I think I found my destination.

Jackson Guthrie

Delicious ice cream accompanied by fantastic service in a timely manner, I can't wait to go back! Not only are all of their ice creams gluten free, but homemade as well. As a college student I am used to minimal effort when being served because a great many of us are rude, rambunctious, and frankly mediocre tippers. However, I was met with no such assumptions, only genuine kindness when serving me, and for that I am delighted.

Soumiea Abushagur

Their ice cream is really good! They make it in-shop, so it’s fresh and great quality. The staff is so nice and checked in on us after we finished our ice cream to make sure we enjoyed it since it was our first visit. We will definitely be coming back!!

A Ha

This is the best ice cream shop around. The staff and the owner are incredibly nice and always are offering samples. The amount of ice cream for the price is amazing. Everything I have tried so far has been wonderful.

James Taylor

We tried this place during a weekday. It wasn't crowded and the service was fast. Our server was very pleasant and helpful! We tried a couple of flavors and settled on 2 small cups. The toppings were plentiful! Although the ice cream tasted good, it's not one of our favorites. You must try it though and decide for yourself, I'm sure you won't be disappointed!

Tama Jansen

Great flavors with a quality only homemade ice cream can have! We had the strawberry and rum raisin and would recommend both! The family that owns it is super sweet and really care about making a positive impact on the Henrietta community. Highly recommend! 👍🏼

Needs some updates but has a friendly staff.

The soft serve is pretty good. They are however missing Mr Read's secret waffle cone ingredient.

Went here for the first time and the family really liked it. While there were a lot of people there, there wasn't much of a wait. Good selection of flavors, including non-dairy options. We'll definitely go back.

Esperaba un sitio mas califo, colorido, acogedor, pero no lo es. La decoracion es muy impersonal, fria, incolora. Tenian a la entrada un refrigerador abandonado, sucio y en desuso. No hay mucha variedad de sabores, como claman otros comentarios. Pedi el cheesecake flavor y eso salvo la tarde lluviosa. Estaba super delicioso. Generosa porcion. El servicio excelente, calido, amable. Amplio estacionamiento.

Average ice cream place. Nothing spe ial. This place replaced Reeds Ice Cream. They are nothing like Reeds. Not sure if I'd go back

Service was very slow. Workers were simply not strong enough to scoop the ice cream so had to call for help. Outside seating leaves something to be desired. But the ice cream was good!

We got a 1-scoop and a 2-scoop cone . The cost was $11.43 ! Ice cream was very good but portions were small . Selection also could have been better .

The day we went on there wasn't many flavors in regular ice cream. I order oreo cookie and it didn't have any flavor. There was a decent amount of dairy free selections. My daughter had sorbet which was pretty good.

Service was fine, very nice people. But they really need more flavors. How does an ice cream shop not even have cookie dough?! Honestly, none of the 9 flavors really were anything I was craving. So I just got soft serve which was like cold cool whip. The cones were also clearly store bought out of a Joy brand box. They are new so I'm hoping to see their menu build.

Bruce Schaefer

The day we went on there wasn't many flavors in regular ice cream. I order oreo cookie and it didn't have any flavor. There was a decent amount of dairy free selections. My daughter had sorbet which was pretty good.

Jenette Gammiero

Service was fine, very nice people. But they really need more flavors. How does an ice cream shop not even have cookie dough?! Honestly, none of the 9 flavors really were anything I was craving. So I just got soft serve which was like cold cool whip. The cones were also clearly store bought out of a Joy brand box. They are new so I'm hoping to see their menu build.

Just got here at 6:20pm on a Sunday which says they are open until 9pm on Sundays and it was confirmed by the owner for Google 5 weeks ago. As I just found out that happy days down the road stopped selling waffles and crepes I was very excited to find that this place has waffles. They were closed with no sign on the door explaining why after we drove all the way over just to get some waffles from them. Disapointing- I hope they update their hours or put a sign on the door if they will be closing unexpectedly

Milkshakes were very watered down. The facility inside was not well kept. The seating outside was dirty. Their ice cream selection was lacking, on top of that, their soft serve was not functioning. Not worth the drive. Try somewhere else.