heyits angela

Visited Holbrook on a whim tonight looking for a quick place to eat and Joe’s pizza & pasta exceeded my expectations. The staff, specifically Jeff, went above and beyond to make this a delightful experience. Will be visiting again!!

Steve Kowalski

I've been coming to this place for years, the food and service is always top notch. Great pizza, a fun atmosphere, and quality service. Franny and Jeff make a great team up at the front counter and they made my experience quick and easy. It's nice when you go to a place where they have good employees who care about what they do. Overall, a 10/10. Definitely will be back soon

Jessica Green

Shout of to Jeff for making these amazing ham and cheese pinwheels. We have become regular patrons of Joe's and come all the way from Bay Shore for their amazing food, service and friendly atmosphere.

🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️i've been trying all the pizza spots in the area to try and find the best one and this one as of today is my new favorite so far. The grandma slice that I got from there is the BEST version of the pie i have ever had hands down. The inside was beautiful with a large bar and they also offer table service. Outside was a decent sized eating area for when it's nice out. The staff was also extremely friendly and all the prices were very reasonable. I'm bookmarking this place because I'll definitely be returning!!

Walked in first time to pick up takeout, when I saw the pizza display I had to take some slices home as well. The portions were large, and the food was great. And the service was exemplary, thank you, Logan. Good job and good luck guys.

Maddy Matthews

They are very busy but take the time to help you. Service was great. There's something from everyone here. We wish we had more time to try everything! If we are ever back in the area we will be stopping by Joe's! Perfect way to pick up food and enjoy it back at your hotel.

Ryan M

Joes pizza was great, fast service and very fresh and the portions are large, I could’ve just had the BBQ chicken slice. And the price is great too.

Shane Dowd

Joe and Logan behind the counter were so accommodating and could tell my wife and I were overwhelmed with the options lol… We tried their recommendations and they were def right. Food here is phenomenal and will definitely be back

Corinne Mulligan

I ordered a NYE package for 12-15 people. Everything was delicious and the trays were stuffed! We had the chicken parm/sausage and pepps/penne ala vodka with some garlic bread. Price was very reasonable. This will be my go to place for catering! Their chicken rolls, pizza and friendly staff is another plus!

Olivia Motta

Excellent food! Every time I visit LI I always look forward to going to Joe’s. My boyfriend lives down the street and I make him take me to get a slice of the grandma pie and rigatoni vodka slice my absolute favorites! The service is always fast and super friendly greeting us when we walk in and out. I’m not typically always down to eat pizza but for Joes I could eat it everyday! 10/10 would recommend!

Ricky Cormio

Excellent Italian restaurant with huge portions! They start you off with delicious garlic bread, and most of the main dishes come with a fresh salad. The chicken cutlet parm dinner came with 4 large pieces of chicken and pasta. More than enough for 2 meals. The staff is quick and on top of everything. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Lawrence Gaddis

Got a pizza today half pepperoni half regular. Must say it looked like Stevie Wonder himself cut this pizza. Honestly words can’t even describe the absolute puzzle of slices they bestowed upon me. The pie itself was very chewy undercooked and the kids said they rather have gone to Domino’s! This place has been on a huge decline in quality since they opened up the new spot and honestly, Only reason I still went there was the Branford and at this point I’d rather drive to the Seaport diner for volka, Godspeed. Please hire somebody with eyeballs to cut pizza.👀. I spent $80 today and was the last $80 you’ll see. 0.2/10

+4

Tara Payne

Every time that I have come here for the last three years, I order the same thing which is a dinner item and it comes with a salad and with a pasta today I came to pick up my order and the salad was a quarter of the usual size and when I said something about it, I was up charge $12 I have never had this problem here. The only thing in the salad that we eat is lettuce and mozzarella cheese, and we understand when they charge us extra for the cheese but you all of a sudden downgrade the size of the salad after three years and then charge me an extra $12 when I say something about it really left a bad taste in my mouth. We eat here sometimes 4 to 7 times a month and we do all our catering here. I don’t know if it is the young children they have working in the front or what but I am utterly. flabbergasted at how they treated us as customers and then they tried to to tell my husband that he is wrong and we don’t get the large salad with our order every time, but that’s a lie. I order here all the time and the salad is always the same size 1st time they’ve ever handed me a salad that was tiny. You would think for a $38 meal. It would come with a nice size salad, but I guess they decided today I should pay more. I do not know if I will be coming back. I do not know if I will be ordering my catering here anymore. I am disgusted. Their salad that is small with everything on it they charge eight dollars for I have no idea what they are doing today, but it really left a terrible taste in my mouth……

Tree Made

⚠️FOOD POISONING⚠️ Been coming here for years now and the food has always been great, I regularly get their penne allá vodka. Just this past Sunday (1/18/26), I went here with my family and unfortunately me and another family member got very very sick after consuming their vodka sauce. Be warned.