Menu
Islip Pizza and Pasta
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Holbrook

Islip Pizza and Pasta

★★★★ 4.4 · 100 reseñas

Islip Pizza and Pasta in Holbrook offers a welcoming and relaxed dining experience. We pride ourselves on providing fast and friendly service, ensuring every guest feels valued. Our menu features classic Italian-American dishes, with generous portions of pasta and pizza, includin...

Islip Pizza and Pasta

Italian, pizza · Holbrook

4.4 · 1,120 reviews Google

Deals available

Be flexible, save more

Be flexible, save more

www.joespizzany.com
Yelp 3.5 (232) TripAdvisor 4.3 (53) Uber Eats 4.7 (2,000)

About Islip Pizza and Pasta

Islip Pizza and Pasta in Holbrook offers a welcoming and relaxed dining experience. We pride ourselves on providing fast and friendly service, ensuring every guest feels valued. Our menu features classic Italian-American dishes, with generous portions of pasta and pizza, including local specialties....

Islip Pizza and Pasta in Holbrook offers a welcoming and relaxed dining experience. We pride ourselves on providing fast and friendly service, ensuring every guest feels valued. Our menu features classic Italian-American dishes, with generous portions of pasta and pizza, including local specialties. Customers rave about our grandma pie and rigatoni vodka slice, as well as our delicious cannoli and sandwiches. Many appreciate the complimentary garlic bread and fresh salads. The atmosphere is vibrant and clean, with options for outdoor seating, dine-in, takeout, and delivery. We are wheelchair accessible.

What Customers Say About Islip Pizza and Pasta

Islip Pizza and Pasta (Joe's) is a local favorite known for its large portions, delicious food, and friendly service, especially from staff like Jeff and Charlie. Customers rave about the pizza, garlic bread, and pasta dishes. A few negative reviews mention inconsistency in quality and portion sizes.

Popular Dishes

pizza (7) garlic bread (4) chicken parm penne ala vodka chicken rolls grandma pie rigatoni vodka slice ham and cheese pinwheels

Best For

Families Groups Locals Casual Quick Bite

Tip: The restaurant is great for catering and large orders. Be sure to try the pizza and garlic bread, but be aware that some customers have experienced inconsistent quality.

Features

📶 WiFi 🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian Coffee
🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy Trendy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about Islip Pizza and Pasta

Islip Pizza and Pasta is located at 346 Union Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741, Holbrook.
Islip Pizza and Pasta offers italian;pizza cuisine.
Islip Pizza and Pasta has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Islip Pizza and Pasta offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Islip Pizza and Pasta based on customer reviews are: pizza, garlic bread, chicken parm, penne ala vodka, chicken rolls.
Islip Pizza and Pasta is ideal for families, groups, locals, casual dining, quick bites.
Islip Pizza and Pasta (Joe's) is a local favorite known for its large portions, delicious food, and friendly service, especially from staff like Jeff and Charlie. Customers rave about the pizza, garlic bread, and pasta dishes. A few negative reviews mention inconsistency in quality and portion sizes.
The restaurant is great for catering and large orders. Be sure to try the pizza and garlic bread, but be aware that some customers have experienced inconsistent quality.
1,120
Reviews

Islip Pizza and Pasta Holbrook Reviews

4.4
1,120
5★
73%
4★
12%
3★
4%
2★
3%
1★
8%
Reviews (100)
N
Nico

The food and service were great. Everything came out quickly, tasted great and everyone had a good time. Jeff and Brady helped us and they were incredible!

S
Sara Johnston

My first time in NY to do training for work. The food was AMAZING and the staff was wonderful. I hope I get to go back!

J
Jamie P

Joes pizza is phenomenal. Charlie and Jeff provide outstanding costumer service . I will continue to be back weekly !

C
Courtney Weiss

We’ve been going here for 25 years, wouldn’t go anywhere else. J & J are the best, keep you entertained while you wait and the service is 10/10

D
Donna Guida

Just celebrated my son’s engagement party on sat it sure was a hit !! The compliments from my family and friends just could not get over the food !! Thank you Phil for making this party unforgettable from start to finish ! The pizza appetizer was the best idea than getting heros ! Truly are the best place to cater and dine love the Guida family

S
Shawn Tester

Visiting from Lexington, KY and wanted authentic NY pizza and this place was amazing! Charlie and Jeff were top notch and made feel like I was back in the south with the hospitality

R
Running Sparrow

Good food, good price, goos employee etiquette Purchased: Pepperoni Pie w/ Nutella Stuffed Zeppoli $30 The pizza and service is top notch, the only minor issue is the bar next to it which isnt terrible but could make for an unruly crowd Considering this is word of mouth from a local resident, I can't honestly add that into consideration. The food was delicious and fresh, they have my favorite beverage: Manhattan Special Espresso Soda, I didnt pick any up due to the high amount of caffeine I had already consumed. Would 100% recommend for good food and devent prices along with the food variety.

G
Gary Axisa

As a new resident of the neighborhood, I naturally had to find a pizzeria I could trust. Joe’s has quickly become that pizzeria. Fast and hot, every time! The fact they aren’t cheap with their toppings makes me comment every time I get take out. Looking forward to dining in for a date night!

K
Kirsten Degen

Food is delicious. Portions are large great for next day meal

J
Joe Primerano

Great atmosphere, TV for sports food was delicious and service was awesome! Very clean, food was quick and service was excellent! We will be back!

P
Pat Gall

Moved apartments today, never ate all day and was in a new area at 11pm. Everything was closed and Joe’s was just about closed, but I took a chance and called. Best move, I could’ve made! Food was fabulous, very homemade, authentic delicious. Jeff and Kaiden were so positive and couldn’t have been nicer. Big smiles, friendly, waited for me to drive over. I assumed Jeff was the owner because what employee picks up the phone, represents a business that well and really cares?! Clearly Jeff and Kaiden! So Joe, awesome food and fabulous hires. Give those guys a raise please because they are truly keepers!!!

J
Jay Abra

The pizza is so good. We also got the zeppolis and garlic cheesy bread and both were amazing. Highly recommend.

T
Teddy Bruckner

Hands down best pizza in Holbrook wouldn’t go anywhere else. My favorite is the grandma pizza, but honestly everything is delicious from the pizza to the Italian food. They even have my favorite beer on tap so I like to stop in for a pint while waiting on my pizza pie to go.

M
Muhammad Madni

Everything was soooo good I think one of the best pizzza spot in Long Island buffalo chicken grandma Sicilian

M
Mike Scic

Everyone at this establishment is always so friendly and helpful, especially Jeff and Charlie. On top of this, THE FOOD IS GREAT!!! GET THE BRANFORD!!!

L
Lee F

Great pizza, service, and atmosphere. Honestly the pictures don't do the food or seating justice. Staff was polite, helpful, and attentive. For the love of god don't get the cheesecake... because you'll have to come back for more.

M
Michael Reyes

One of the best slices I have had in all of ny

N
Nicholas Maniscalco

They were open late pizza was great. They gave us a couple free Zeppoli’s. Highly recommended. What more can you ask

M
Miha Gianacopoulos

I have been going to Joe's pizza for years and I always recommend this place!! Everyone here is so kind and the food is always 10/10.

J
Joe Grassi

Place is Incredible... Beautiful ambiance and Excellent Pizza🍕 Most importantly. Have been travelling the country for business for the past few years and was GREAT to come home to some authentic True Italian/American excellence, EXACTLY What this country needs today. I mean, they named the joint after me... How could you ask for any more!?! 👍😜👍

J
Jason Dinner

Ive been getting takeout from Joes for at least 6 years. My family loves it. They treat you like family. The food is great. Always my go to spot for big catering orders. Last time was for my daughters communion & everyone was raving about the food. The chicken francese was my favorite and the penne ala vodka is insane too. They also make killer chicken rolls. My kids go crazy over them. And they come thru with the gluten free pizza for my gluten allergy having family members. Joes for the WIN!!

G
Gigi Hachtel

Great place, I had the baked pasta special and it was nothing short of amazing....and the service! My server Michelle was so nice and extremely attentive, anytime I needed something she was just there. Hands down, she was an absolute delight.

S
Sean Harnett

Food is always amazing. We love the broccoli and spinach roll. Jeff and Charlie are always happy and give great service whenever we go in. Can’t say enough about this great place.

Z
Zedekiah The Sage

I had an amazing experience with the customer service here, & Jeff really made me feel like a valued customer. Not only is the food great but the environment is clean & relaxed but also full of culture. I even end up having a laugh with other customers there while waiting for my food. This place is definitely exceptional. They're doing things right, & I'm glad to be a customer for sure!

R
Robert Ambriano

Joes Pizza & Pasta is above all the other pizzerias in the area. They have a full bar / restaurant with a variety of different slices you can't find anywhere else! Must try if your in the area

J
Jack

Never have had bad food from Joes. My family’s been coming here for a couple of years now and we have a great meal every single time. Pizza, Pasta, Calzones, they do it all, and they do it fantastically.

D
Daniella Reid

Great establishment amazing food great service yo if you live in Long Island this is definitely the best pizza spot out here 10/10

G
Gabriel Lantigua

Really cool and inviting atmosphere, staff is quick to acknowledge you, Lots of food choices and creative food choices at that! Great pizza/pasta/desert place, one of the best in Long Island!

R
Ryan Hubbard

The food was great! We came from Albuquerque New Mexico, Jeff and Jesus were super nice and helpful. The nutella zepole was amazing!

A
A K

This place is the best! Pizza, zeppoles, and all the other food they serve rocks! Jeff and Antonio give top notch service! Love coming here!

T
Tina Duncan (Duncan3)

I would recommend this place over & over. Pizza so good, down to the crust. And I never eat the crust. The hospitality is wonderful. Xoxoxox

L
Luiza

Cute place with great atmosphere! The selection of pizza it’s amazing, and Jesus and Jeff were of amazing help, super friendly!! Super recommend it.

A
Ari Ballesteros

J&J killed it tonight, serving up slices for our family. They always have a smile on their faces and are always so welcoming when we walk in the door!

S
Sharda Kalladeen

We had a great experience at Joe's. We were a group of seven grabbing a work lunch. The staff was great, the food was delicious, the atmosphere was very nice. The staff even gave our group a complimentary order of zeppolis for our first visit. A co-worker recommended this place to us and I'm really happy that I listened to him. I was so hungry that I forgot to take photos but everything looked so appetizing. I will visit again.

I
Istiaq Samin

We went in and ordered the personal pizza. The pizza itself tasted amazing and the service was great. Thanks Jeff & Brady for the free dessert.

D
Danielle

This is our new favorite place for Italian takeout. Food is delicious overall, the marinara sauce is divine! I would swear it's some grandma's old school recipe 🤤 nice balance of acidity and sweetness imo. Do not miss out on the stuffed artichoke & eggplant parm hero, meatball hero is good as well says my other half. Prices are awesome especially for the artichoke! I loved the eggplant hero so much I've gotten it 3x in a row, the artichoke 2x 😂. We got Broccoli rabe side dish once. It might have been a little overcooked but it was absolutely loaded with fresh garlic, I think I'll try a side of spinach next time. Overall the food has been solid and we are going to be back soon I'm sure.

A
Anthony Cap

Tried the 1978 slice at Joe’s Pizza in Holbrook and it was epic. Perfectly crisped pepperoni piled high, melty cheese, and a dough that strikes that perfect balance between chewy and crunchy. A true masterclass in how a pepperoni slice should be. Just look at this picture—loaded with pepperoni! Easily one of the best slices I’ve had on Long Island.

M
Mrs. Mars

Always an excellent meal at Joe’s! Whether it’s take out or dine in. The portions are generous, delicious, and the staff are attentive. We had an issue with a missing item from our take out order and they made right by us. Great food, great people. Highly recommend!

M
M Oz

Nice atmosphere I like that they have self-catering option for those who wouldn't want to tip. I had their shrimps and NY cheesecake. Extreme portion size but it was tasty. The cake was too sweet for me.

D
Damarcia Reyes

Great place out in long island, slices are cheap and the staff are great! J & J helped us out & they were so nice. Would def come back here when I’m in the area! :)

L
Lissette Chao

The pizza here is amazing! Also had a nice hot bowl of chicken noodle soup! Jesus and Jeff were so friendly, really made my night after a long flight from California. Highly recommend this place! :)

J
Jonathon Wenke

To Lauren Marmol,, As someone who has also visited this restaurant, I feel it’s important to keep reviews constructive rather than personal. The way this review singles out April is unfair and unnecessarily harsh. Hospitality is one of the toughest industries, bartenders and servers work long hours, juggle multiple demands, and still show up every day to create a welcoming experience for guests. I’ve interacted with April myself and never found her to be anything but professional and attentive. Everyone has off moments, but publicly belittling someone in their line of work doesn’t add value for other diners it only tears people down. Constructive criticism is useful because it gives the restaurant something to work with. Personal attacks, however, reflect more poorly on the reviewer than on the staff member being targeted. The food here is excellent, the staff overall works hard, and I think it’s only fair that reviews highlight experiences without crossing the line into bullying. Respect and kindness go a long way, in restaurants, and in life. Take some notes. Have a great weekend

L
Lou Sorrentino

Stopped in for lunch today Wed.!Food is always fresh and tastes great. It’s like grand central station with people going in and out. Staff is very pleasant. The cashier is very nice and friendly. She is always running around when she’s not answering phones she’s helping out taking customers orders. Cleaning tables, collecting dishes and utensils. Definitely a go to place.

A
Alexander van Deurs

Went into Joes for the first time, Jeff, Zeus, and Charlie were extremely kind and helpful. Showed me some of the customer favorites slices, as well as some of their own personal choices. Great Spot, Great people, and some of the best Pizza on Long Island!

k
kathleen vallario

Love Joe's. All their pizza is great, but our faves are the 1978 Sicilian and Chicken Bacon Ranch. Their meals, soups and salads also delicious.

D
Desiree Ladd

Great experience at Joe’s Pizza. J&J behind the counter were super friendly and accommodating. Amazing pizza selection that was fresh, hot, and delicious. Can’t wait to come back.

J
Jenelle Ayala

Every slice was perfect. Nutella stuffed zeppole was delicious!

R
Rachel Kapllani

Had a great meal here last night! Food was delicious and dine in service was very attentive. Our waiter, Brandon, was especially great, extremely friendly and accommodating of our large party. Will definitely be back!

R
Rumeal Mckinney

I stumbled across this bomb pizza spot in ny Long Island and I’m upset I didn’t order more slices! The cheese to crust ratio was so perfect! I was hungry and debating on pizza and the other spots on the strip. But once I went in to inquire about the menu Jeff the guy at the register was cool and knowledgeable about all the pizza in the world. So I had to try it. Can’t wait to go back!!

K
Kimberly Winfield

We’ve gone here several times customer service is always great. The undercarriage for the pizza is awesome. The Zeppoli is good just make sure you ask for the powdered sugar sometimes that might be left out other than that great pizza and pasta spot!!

S
Shannon Welch

I've lived in Italy for 3 years and it is so hard to replicate the fluffy dough that they do without messing up some other component of the pizza like the sauce or cheese. Joes is damn near close to a true Italian pizza! And don't get me started on the cannoli!!! I had a bunch in Italy too. Absolutely did not disappoint

m
mr&mrs willis

My boyfriend wanted pasta tonight, I went to the google maps & I saw the reviews & had to try it for myself. As a pizza lover, I will say that they deep dish pizza was def this ishh!! Jeff & Charlie are amazing, they helped my boyfriend choose this amazing Brandford meal 😍😍😍😍 10/10. & I didnt get to get the girls name, she was very pretty & helpful. Thank ya girl, cause I love chicken pesto pasta

g
gigi lama

Loved the vibe of this place! Super classic Italian joint. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. 10/10 experience. Great stop before heading to the train. Will definitely be coming back. 😋

W
William Stout

This place! Not a bad thing on the menu. You can walk in and order a slice to go, or there's plenty of seating. The service for lunch was fantastic, from seating through to the end. The Branford Sandwich is a specialty, and it was awesome. The roll was toasted perfectly, with chicken in a vodka sauce, topped with mozzarella... Another visit I had the stuffed rigatoni! So good! Excellent choice to eat if you are looking, definitely recommend!

R
Rebecca Dolan

Joes pizza is my favorite!! They are all so friendly and caring. Their food is absolutely amazing. It’s a safe delicious choice for anything on the menu. I eat something from Joes pizza every saturday.

S
Stephen Bauer

Great pizza and even better service. The crust was perfectly cooked, toppings were fresh, and everything came out hot and fast. You can tell they care about quality here. Definitely coming back.

C
Cathy-Sue Emerson

Can't say enough about them. I ordered food for Catering - everyone raved about it. They delivered it hot. The 1/2 trays overflowed. They gave us way more than we needed. I will definitely use them again!!!!!!! PS I always dine in with them and their food is OUTSTANDING

V
Victoria

This is my new favorite pizza place Its so friggin good I'm eating the crispiano which is so so so good. I even ordered a artichoke for later bc they just looked so good. Jeff really was a doll behind the counter. Will def be coming back

k
kayla espana

Ended up here because I wanted some Italian food with a friend and we got the stuffed pizza and regular slice and penne allá vodka with chicken cutlet… I loved the pizza so well seasoned very tasty. Was accommodated by the lovely Francesca… her customer service was excellent. Very sweet lady. Would definitely come again.

Ben Chen
Ben Chen

Joe’s Pizza! How glad I am to have stumbled upon this hidden gem establishment. Service: 11/10 Food: 10/10    Overall atmosphere and cleanliness also 10/10. Didn’t get the names of the servers but everyone was so kind and friendly. They saw that we’re a couple and offered to cut our slices into halves without us even asking— such attention to detail and excellent service! We left with a full belly plus some more items in our hands because this pizzeria has a reputation of being generous. Shout out to this place; big thumbs up!!

Mileyka Valdez
Mileyka Valdez

Absolutely loved my experience at Joe’s Pizza & Pasta in Holbrook! The pizza was delicious, fresh, and exactly what you want when you’re craving a great slice. What really made the experience stand out though was the service — Jeff and Charlie were amazing 🫶🏻. Super friendly, welcoming, and very generous. I will be back. ☺️

Matthew Potoker
Matthew Potoker

We always make a stop for pizza on our way out east! Jeff and Jesus are the so nice and create the best atmosphere inside!

Justin Timbon
Justin Timbon

wow, this place smells looks great and the food is spectacular. Thank you Joe Jeff and Amy, the cannoli was great and wow that sandwich. I’m still dreaming of it till now I can still taste it. It looks just as good as it tasted Only complain I have about you guys is that you don’t have a location near me dammit instead of six stars I’ll give you Five wow I definitely gotta come back here again. Highly recommend this place.

Grace Jenkins
Grace Jenkins

Joe’s Pizza and Pasta is nothing short of a culinary gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the warm, inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements the delightful food. The pizza is consistently exceptional, with a perfect blend of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings that make each bite an unforgettable experience. The pasta dishes are equally impressive, featuring rich, savory sauces and perfectly cooked noodles that showcase the chef’s expertise. What truly sets Joe’s apart, though, is the incredible service. Charlie, who is often found behind the counter, is a wonderful human who adds a personal touch to every visit. His genuine friendliness and attention to detail make you feel like part of the family. It’s clear that Charlie takes immense pride in his work, and his passion is reflected in both the quality of the food and the warmth of the service. In short, Joe’s Pizza and Pasta is more than just a restaurant; it’s a place where great food meets great people. If you haven’t been yet, you’re missing out on one of the best dining experiences around.

Jack Murray
Jack Murray

Joe’s Pizza & Pasta is a place I plan on visiting again. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and relaxed. Jeff and Charlie were great! Friendly, attentive, and genuinely made me feel welcome. The team takes great pride in making sure the restaurant is clean and presentable. Service was smooth and food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. It’s the kind of spot that feels comfortable whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or sitting down for a full meal. Overall, a solid experience with great service. I definitely recommend!

ZMAN C
ZMAN C

This restaurant/location is excellent in every way. Greeted right away and their order pickups are usually ready as soon as you arrive. Plenty of employees serving customers and food is excellent. Garlic bread and pasta is so damn good here. Highly recommend. Busy shopping center in Holbrook and high quality italian food options Thanks Joes team!

Ron Jacobs
Ron Jacobs

Great pizza on the island. The speed of service was quick and the atmosphere was relaxing. The restaurant is clean and spacious, not like the restaurants in the city.

heyits angela
heyits angela

Visited Holbrook on a whim tonight looking for a quick place to eat and Joe’s pizza & pasta exceeded my expectations. The staff, specifically Jeff, went above and beyond to make this a delightful experience. Will be visiting again!!

Steve Kowalski
Steve Kowalski

I've been coming to this place for years, the food and service is always top notch. Great pizza, a fun atmosphere, and quality service. Franny and Jeff make a great team up at the front counter and they made my experience quick and easy. It's nice when you go to a place where they have good employees who care about what they do. Overall, a 10/10. Definitely will be back soon

Jessica Green
Jessica Green

Shout of to Jeff for making these amazing ham and cheese pinwheels. We have become regular patrons of Joe's and come all the way from Bay Shore for their amazing food, service and friendly atmosphere.

A
Andy

🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️i've been trying all the pizza spots in the area to try and find the best one and this one as of today is my new favorite so far. The grandma slice that I got from there is the BEST version of the pie i have ever had hands down. The inside was beautiful with a large bar and they also offer table service. Outside was a decent sized eating area for when it's nice out. The staff was also extremely friendly and all the prices were very reasonable. I'm bookmarking this place because I'll definitely be returning!!

J
Joe Bitterman

Walked in first time to pick up takeout, when I saw the pizza display I had to take some slices home as well. The portions were large, and the food was great. And the service was exemplary, thank you, Logan. Good job and good luck guys.

Maddy Matthews
Maddy Matthews

They are very busy but take the time to help you. Service was great. There's something from everyone here. We wish we had more time to try everything! If we are ever back in the area we will be stopping by Joe's! Perfect way to pick up food and enjoy it back at your hotel.

Ryan M
Ryan M

Joes pizza was great, fast service and very fresh and the portions are large, I could’ve just had the BBQ chicken slice. And the price is great too.

Shane Dowd
Shane Dowd

Joe and Logan behind the counter were so accommodating and could tell my wife and I were overwhelmed with the options lol… We tried their recommendations and they were def right. Food here is phenomenal and will definitely be back

Corinne Mulligan
Corinne Mulligan

I ordered a NYE package for 12-15 people. Everything was delicious and the trays were stuffed! We had the chicken parm/sausage and pepps/penne ala vodka with some garlic bread. Price was very reasonable. This will be my go to place for catering! Their chicken rolls, pizza and friendly staff is another plus!

Olivia Motta
Olivia Motta

Excellent food! Every time I visit LI I always look forward to going to Joe’s. My boyfriend lives down the street and I make him take me to get a slice of the grandma pie and rigatoni vodka slice my absolute favorites! The service is always fast and super friendly greeting us when we walk in and out. I’m not typically always down to eat pizza but for Joes I could eat it everyday! 10/10 would recommend!

Ricky Cormio
Ricky Cormio

Excellent Italian restaurant with huge portions! They start you off with delicious garlic bread, and most of the main dishes come with a fresh salad. The chicken cutlet parm dinner came with 4 large pieces of chicken and pasta. More than enough for 2 meals. The staff is quick and on top of everything. I highly recommend this restaurant.

L
Leo Escoto

Ordered here for the first time and read that the portion sizes were big and they were right! So much food for decent prices can’t really beat it, you get one meal and it’ll last you a couple meals. Me and my girlfriend loved it and the guy Jeff at the front tied everything together with his great service and happy attitude. Will definitely eat here again .

S
Strife

If this was about their pizza slices definite four stars. Alas this is about the sit-down restaurant. At first the good news huge portions I'm a big guy and it filled me up and had enough to take home. My wife like what she got said it's always a positive it was a calzone. Okay now the other side of the coin. There are two waitresses working a blonde energetic quick to service chatted with the customers and I could say she was working the floor. A very good waitress and unfortunately she wasn't my waitress. I had the older brunette waitress that I barely saw and I know I look like a scrub but it doesn't mean you don't check in on the table. The other waitress is doing three tables as the brunette was working ours, and they got more service than we did. Even though they were large portions I got the chicken parm with penne alla vodka my pasta was a little bowl on the side and the vodka apparently went through a stage of prohibition in the sauce. Again huge amount of chicken parm but the sauce was sickly sweet I don't know what it is with pizza places that have to serve sickly sweet sauce.

a
anna Smith

Love the pizza,pinwheels. But was very disappointed with my spaghetti dinner ,it was so over cooked it lost all its flavor ,meatballs were very tough. Hate to leave a bad review considering most is good. Will try again .

J
James “PoloBear”

7/27/25 Wild update to this review. I went there at closing time and ordered what was still on the shelf. The counter guy was overly nice and accomodating. He even offered up a meatball slice at no cost since it was at closing. I thought that was nice. I waited for my slices to heat up for a few minutes. When I grabbed the box from him he said something that didnt register at first about Google. As I ate my slices I realized he was referring to my negative Google Review! lol That was cool that he recognized me and said something but I wish we could have discussed it at more length while I waited. I will do that next time if I go and the shop isnt too busy to explain better what I meant below. I added a star to the review for the encounter. Very cool that this spot takes the reviews seriously and are paying attention to their customers. Old Review = $4 dollars for a regular slice is insane. Highest ive ever paid for a regular slice and i go everywhere from LI to NYC to Upstate. Also there is 1 counter guy who cant handle the simple instructions of I dont want the slice "too hot" It is a simple request for my expensive slice and he cant get that right. I was trying to avoid the pool of grease and that is exactly what I got. This is not a bad place in general I will admit that. And I have been going here since the early 1990s for pizza. But if you charge top dollar I need you to at least listen to the customer's preference and not get so easily distracted. The slices of PB pie looks like they are cutting a slice...in half. The counter girl was not friendly this time either. Overall just a bad experience today and now Im gonna chill on this spot for a few.

L
Lauren Marmol

I will not be returning to this restaurant. The bartender, April, was not only unpleasing and miserable to interact with, but she carried herself with such negativity that it ruined the atmosphere. On top of that, I overheard her belittling one of the waitresses, which was uncomfortable and unprofessional to witness. I actually felt terrible for the waitress, who handled the situation with professionalism and grace by not lashing back, even though she was being spoken to so poorly. Staff should uplift each other, not tear one another down in front of customers. Frankly, someone with such a sour and unpleasant attitude should not be the face of the bar, let alone the first impression for guests. That kind of toxic behavior has no place in a hospitality setting, and it left me walking out the door knowing I won’t be back. Very shameful because the food is good.

C
Corey

This place always lets us down. We live nearby and give them another chance every few months and we always regret it. Tonight, one of the things we ordered was their Italian cold cut hero. It cost $15 and I have had sandwiches at airports that were cheaper and better, with more meat on them too. There was no prosciutto on it as advertised, the bread was stale, the cheese slices were all mangled up. There were 2 slices of cheap ham, 4 slices of salami, and 6 pizza-sized pieces of pepperoni ON THE WHOLE SANDWICH. The chicken parm and chicken francaise were passable but nothing remotely special. Oh, and when I tried to call for a refund, the phone went immediately to busy signal 5 times over the span of 20 minutes, so I gave up and wrote this review instead. I never write reviews and I’m a fair person so if someone bothers to reach out and make this right I’ll probably take this review down.

J
Jmg0398

Not usually one to complain but for paying almost $30 for lobster ravioli and I only get 5 raviolis and a ton of sauce.. when I pay 60 bucks for dinner I expect to get a decent amount. When I order the penne al vodka and the cover is popping off cause how full it is I kinda expected the lobster and ravioli to have more then 5 small raviolis… note to self never getting the lobster ravioli again.

G
Greg Mehrhoff

Just ordered a Pizza for pickup from Joes. The pizza is delicious however it was not cut fully if at all. Very annoying. I had to the shoot up to the stire to spend $10 on knives in my office just to eat. Terribly inconvenient. Bad Job 👎

D
Dan Blafford

I specifically ordered a dish I made sure they had instructions I wanted my dish al dente it came out like a puddle of mashed potatoes terrible when I called I was told unless I brought the food back which is about a half hour away they wouldn't do anything for me no future credit nothing terrible service usually very good food unfortunately I will never go back and I recommend if you want good service somebody who truly cares about the customer go elsewhere

L
Lucia

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! This left wing establishment has no problem being rude to anyone- women, children doesn’t matter. Their food is mediocre at best and declining the past year. Usually it’s the heavyset man who can only move one side of his mouth. But tonight it seems as though even the young staff has no problem showing they’ve been raised wrong!

K
Km

6.25 for a single pain slice of pizza? I’ve ordered from here for over a decade no reason prices are this high. Very disappointing

S
Sergio Levi

Ordered 2 marinara slices to go, and I couldn’t even hold them because they were like rubber, the crust was soggy and the pizza cold too. Not good, on top of that, it was $12 for the 2 slices 🤦‍♂️

S
Stacy Cammaratta

Terrible food. Ordered a baked ricotta ziti. Cheese cyrdeled. Pepperoni pinwheel burnt to a crisp. Rice ball so chewy and hard, I broke my tooth.

D
David Montalvo

Usually an exceptional experience, disappointed in the response to a LOYAL customer. I called ahead and ordered a large amount of food. I arrived when they stated it would be ready. Not only did I wait an additional 25 minutes, but the food was burnt. I understand things happen, so I called to make them aware and allowed them to rectify the problem. Their response was, “come back in, all I can do is make you another.” As a family that’s supported Joe’s for almost a decade, wrong answer.

S
Shawn Evanson

Disappointing & dishonest. They forgot a Branford hero from my order. After I called they promised a fresh one. However, they clearly just reheat the same sandwich. After sitting & reheating the bottom was soggy and ripped when you picked it up. Top was twice burnt to a crisp. Don’t buy here. Your money is better spent at Gino’s in Ronkonkoma.

B
Bamzzz1

I was recommended to go here and boy oh boy, it will be my first and last time. I was starving so decided to give this spot a try and the chicken parm had absolutely no flavor and barely any sauce. Everything else we ordered was just not good at all. I should have gone to McDonalds...

N
Nicholas P

I ordered a quart of vodka sauce with meat and it cost $18. For any sauce that’s a ripoff but it had basically no meat in it. So little in fact that I thought they made a mistake with the order. And the workers were very rude about it when questioned. Never coming back.

T
Tom

Pizza is awful! No flavor crust is dense with cardboard texture. Nothing special at all! I will no longer go here! One of the worst I’ve had. Overrated. Sorry Joe need to get it together. Losing the reputation.

J
J C

DO NOT get the penne allá vodka my husband and I tried it for a second time the first time we thought maybe something else made us sick and last night we tried again and have been violently sick since. Seems like this place is going down hill in general.

Lawrence Gaddis
Lawrence Gaddis

Got a pizza today half pepperoni half regular. Must say it looked like Stevie Wonder himself cut this pizza. Honestly words can’t even describe the absolute puzzle of slices they bestowed upon me. The pie itself was very chewy undercooked and the kids said they rather have gone to Domino’s! This place has been on a huge decline in quality since they opened up the new spot and honestly, Only reason I still went there was the Branford and at this point I’d rather drive to the Seaport diner for volka, Godspeed. Please hire somebody with eyeballs to cut pizza.👀. I spent $80 today and was the last $80 you’ll see. 0.2/10

Tara Payne
Tara Payne

Every time that I have come here for the last three years, I order the same thing which is a dinner item and it comes with a salad and with a pasta today I came to pick up my order and the salad was a quarter of the usual size and when I said something about it, I was up charge $12 I have never had this problem here. The only thing in the salad that we eat is lettuce and mozzarella cheese, and we understand when they charge us extra for the cheese but you all of a sudden downgrade the size of the salad after three years and then charge me an extra $12 when I say something about it really left a bad taste in my mouth. We eat here sometimes 4 to 7 times a month and we do all our catering here. I don’t know if it is the young children they have working in the front or what but I am utterly. flabbergasted at how they treated us as customers and then they tried to to tell my husband that he is wrong and we don’t get the large salad with our order every time, but that’s a lie. I order here all the time and the salad is always the same size 1st time they’ve ever handed me a salad that was tiny. You would think for a $38 meal. It would come with a nice size salad, but I guess they decided today I should pay more. I do not know if I will be coming back. I do not know if I will be ordering my catering here anymore. I am disgusted. Their salad that is small with everything on it they charge eight dollars for I have no idea what they are doing today, but it really left a terrible taste in my mouth……

Tree Made
Tree Made

⚠️FOOD POISONING⚠️ Been coming here for years now and the food has always been great, I regularly get their penne allá vodka. Just this past Sunday (1/18/26), I went here with my family and unfortunately me and another family member got very very sick after consuming their vodka sauce. Be warned.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Holbrook →
📸

95 Photos

Explore Islip Pizza and Pasta's photos

Islip Pizza and Pasta
Islip Pizza and Pasta
Islip Pizza and Pasta
Islip Pizza and Pasta
Islip Pizza and Pasta
+90 More
📍

About Islip Pizza and Pasta

How to get there

346 Union Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741

Loading map...
Islip Pizza and Pasta
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.4/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
1120 reviews
💰
Budget Friendly
Price level
👨‍🍳
italian;pizza
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarian Options
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11AM-11PM
Rating
4.4/5
💬 Reviews
1,120
💰 Price Level
$
⏱️ Typical Visit
People typically spend 15 min here
📞 Phone
+1 631-981-3029
🌐 Website
www.joespizzany.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

📶 Free WiFi
🅿️ Parking
🌿 Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

346 Union Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
13°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Islip Pizza and Pasta and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Islip Pizza and Pasta!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Islip Pizza and Pasta

🏆 Rewards at Islip Pizza and Pasta

💰

10% Discount

At Islip Pizza and Pasta

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it