Great food! Great service!

Went out for a Seniors luncheon with some friends. The staff was friendly and polite. They always are. I'm already planning another lunch with a friend. The restaurant has become my favorite place to eat.

Our group of 4 to 6 gathers there every Wednesday for lunch. Our waitress is magnificent, the food is always delicious and very satisfying!

My favorite local spot, usually here every Friday night! Great fish fry and now a new menu! Try the pretzel appetizer or while it's a Friday special the Haddock French! Great craft beer selection. Friendly staff!

Almost left a bad review as Google picked up my location and I thought it was the HFD where we had just left due to poor service. Anyway, what a pleasure to be greeted properly with friendly, attentive staff. I wish we had made a mental note of our server's name as she didn't miss a beat. We had a giant, well-made pretzel, salad and Reuben that hit the spot. Thank you for saving our night. Kudos to management and staff.

I had been waiting all day for there fish and chips and unfortunately they ran out, but the saute guy came out and asked me if I would be interested in there shrimp and sea scallops Pomodoro. After it arrived and I took a bite I was glad that they didn't have the fish and chips that night! Definitely will order this next time!

Excellent restaurant and pub. Very good value for the moderate pricing. Food is excellent and the staff is professional. I always feel welcome; alone or in a large or small group. The atmosphere is as much to go back for as the food. From large groups, and events to a take-home lunch, so many possibilities that never disappoint...

Good food, reasonable prices, and a solid beer selection. It's large enough that you can usually get a table with little to no wait. There's a dining side with no televisions and the bar area (which has plenty of them). Both sides are a treat. The real joy is eating out on the covered deck. You can sit and watch the water running in the creek while you enjoy your meal (or some drinks).

My sister and I went here for lunch....it was AMAZING. We got the lobster 🦞 bisque...the best we've ever had. We also got the artichoke french and the reuben sandwich. It was all fresh and hot. They were extremely busy...and we can see why. We'll definitely be back.

Truly a great experience. A vast menu for food and drinks. Specials beyond the Friday fish fry. Sitting outside on the patio or deck makes it a vent better. Our server (AJ) had great enthusiasm, food was correct, and allowed some time to talk. Highly recommend!

Stopped in for lunch and what a great decision it was. We ordered the pork tacos, chicken quesadilla, and a cheeseburger. Lunch was served fast and hot. We had a very attentive waitress and had everything we needed. Without a doubt a great lunch location.

We just decided to stop in and grab a bite during our travels and what a great decision!! Great food, service, and pricing. Located right on a creek with outdoor seating available. It looked very packed, but we were still able to get a table right away.

Great atmosphere. Awesome food!

Food was awesome, service was great! Will definitely be back!!

Ordered the grilled chicken Pecan wrap to go. I love their chicken pecan salad, but I like it even better as a wrap with the craisins and blue cheese crumbles. Also one of my favorites is there pulled pork quesadilla. There lunch menu is a little pricey for this. Usually lunch is less expensive than dinner. Have seen their rates go way up.

Our kids and grandkids met us for a celebratory dinner Friday night. The menu lists a wide variety of interesting dishes, truly something for everyone. Our appetizers and dinners were so delicious! Our attentive waitstaff made sure we had everything we needed for a wonderful meal. The space seems designed to accommodate large families comfortably. Fabulous restaurant, highly recommend the short drive.

Plenty of parking, adorable seating outside by the rocky stream, beautiful landscape as you walk onto the porch. Seated right away, the waitress was quick to offer us beverages as we looked at the menu's. Loaded nachos were delicious 😋. We had soups for entries all are very hardy and filling, perfect on a cold day. We had a great experience and enjoyed our food.

Service pace was acceptable albeit slightly slower than I liked. Was not inside so can't comment on it. If it is as good as the spacious porch. Nice layout and view and I'm certain that on a day with a breeze it would be more comfortable so slow moving ceiling fans might be an added touch for a breezless day. Reasonable prices. Good food quality food. Pet friendly.

Stopped in here with friends while visiting the area. Food was great. Everyone left full. Onion rings were really good!

Had dinner here last Friday and it was wonderful as usual. We were disappointed that the Shrimp / Scallop Pomadaro is no longer available. This is one of the main dishes that we look forward to having. Please reconsider at least for Fridays

Our weighter was a great guy. Great Energy and great attention and attitude twords us. A+++

I go here every now and then when I’m up in that part on NY. Food has always been as expected, service is always great, and it has plenty of seating indoors and outdoors. Beers are always nice and cold too :) If you never been, go, you won’t be disappointed.

Awesome food nice place friendly staff would recommendous this place for food and family time and good drink

In my five years living in the area, I haven't heard a single person say they didn't like Flaherty's. The pub atmosphere may not be for everyone, but the side dining room accommodates that, and the food and service are always good, with classics as well as rotating specials. This well-kept restaurant is a great place for a meal with family or friends.

Well prepared American food. We've done here several times. They have a unique central bar set up. Booths, high top and regular seating available. Kid friendly, free fresh popcorn, friendly service. Short waits on the busy nights. Food comes out well prepared. Out of all the times we've visited only once did we have a slight miss and the server was very empathetic and quickly corrected it. To me this is more important than getting it right 100% of the time. Everyone has an off day, myself included. Also, try the chicken chili nachos, we just tried them last night and were very impressed.

Friday fish fry is great! Bring your appetite!

It was amazing service. The food was pretty good. We've been there once before and the second time around was much better. It was a quiet evening and the server was amazing. The espresso martini was super strong so no complaints 👌 I had chicken and biscuits and it made me feel at home.

Met friends for lunch & had a tasty lunch with some serious cosmopolitans! Our bartender & waitress were most accommodating and we will be back again!

We had a very competent and attentive young server named Matt. The food was delicious and the portions were generous. My eggplant parm was enough for three meals! My husband ordered the prime rib. The cook was as requested and the meat was tender and well seasoned. The only criticism I have is that the booth we sat in was kind of dirty. There were some cobwebs on the wall next to me and the seat needed to be wiped down.

I met my God daughter for dinner here. Everything was top notch . From the atmosphere, dinner, waitress, dessert ,check . I definitely recommend it. And come with a little bit of extra time to sit outside and enjoy the relaxing view .

Absolutely the BEST fish fry I've had in ages! Huge portions, perfectly cooked, fantastic service. Great tap list, came in earlier for lunch and had an outstanding burger. This place is fantastic!

We had such a nice 45th Anniversary dinner, sitting on the lovely porch, overlooking the creek. Absolutely delicious scallops and chicken French dinners. My husband loved the lobster bisque as well. Our waitress was awesome, which added to the great experience. We'll be back 💕💕💕!

We had a large party of 20 yesterday which included 5 little kids. Our waiter was GREAT!! I wish I remembered his name to shout him out because he was fantastic. So patient and personable. The food was also great!

A lively restaurant with great food and service! Everything that I've ordered there has been delicious! Mojo Pork bowl is my favorite but I also enjoy their Chicken French, Shepherds pie, onion rings and salads.

Stopped on Saturday for lunch after having a difficult time finding something child friendly and open. Best service we’ve had since preCOVID. Quick, attentive, brought or 2 year old his meal minutes after we ordered. Will definitely be back.

The food was good. Staff was very attentive. Eating outside with that view was assome.

Good atmosphere and service. Pub food and friendly people in the heart of Honeoye Falls.

+4

Good food, lots of menu options and reasonable prices. Service has been good all 3 times I have eaten there while visiting. Patio is large and a great option in good weather.

Awesome spot! Everything we ordered was on point.....artichokes frenched, white bean chicken chili,pretzels etc. Highly recommended.

Excellent meal, reasonable prices, plentiful portions, great service

We had a family gathering at Flaherty's on Thursday night. We loved our food, the atmosphere, and our waiter and wait staff!

Sat out on the porch on a perfect summer day for lunch. Salad was fresh and chicken was cooked perfectly. Split a piece of Italian lemon cake, delicious!

Very friendly top notch quality tasty food. Reben closed faced sandwich and Sheppards' pie. Generous portions and delicious.

We called in and they held a table for 8 last night. The service was excellent the drinks and appetizers were spot on! We all ordered wonderful dinners and they were the best. This is such a great place to bring family and friends. Thank you so much for Bryan Russell

Dannielle Hackett

The food was good and the service is great. Our waitress was very friendly, patient and kind. All around a good experience.

Cindy Jones

Had dinner here and it was delicious! It wasn't too loud, but it was early. Our waitress was super great. I would recommend this place to go with your family or friends.

Joyce Bufano

First time there for the four of us and everything was wonderful. The food was amazing with large helpings. The wait staff did a great job with our orders and being attentive. I would definitely go back there and recommend them highly.

Jaclyn Chelenza

Incredible lunch here with some coworkers. I wish I got our waitresses name as she was fantastic! Food was delicious and came out quickly. Very nice atmosphere and the building and restrooms were clean.

Jacqueline Midlam

It Is our favorite go to place because everyone is so welcoming. The food is always great. A very relaxing and fun restaurant!

Dick Menke

A real treat to enjoy. The fish fry was crispy on the outside and tender within. Our server was pleasant and attentive. The atmosphere is quite nostalgic and worth a gander.

Craig Moore

We came here to watch the Eagles game as it was recommended as a sports bar. Well were we surprised with the whole experience that was above just your average sports bar. To start Frank the bartender was amazing. Being from the Philly area and coming to Bills country he was very accommodating trying to get the eagles game on tvs we could see. Then I asked which dish he would recommend and he ran into the kitchen to see exactly how fresh the pot roast was and recommended that. It was amazing. He was also an amazing person considering it was my 40th birthday trip and made it that much better. Will be back next time we visit the area. Trust me just get the pot roast cause it's better than your mom's best!!

Brian Pettit

We asked for a quiet table and were very pleased that the music was listenable but not blasting. We were also far enough from other guests that we heard our conversation, not theirs. The artichoke heart appetizer was fabulous. My wife didn't think she'd want any but she ate several. I drank Guinness southwick for the first time. It was wonderful.

Sara Yantachka

Was working near by so, went in for the (pricey, but worth every penny) lobster bisque "To Go" for hubby an I. Did not disappoint. Huge chuncks of meat!!! Got a cold drink at bar to order for take out. Bartender was lovely, friendly, made suggestions but not PUSHY about them. Ended up ordering the burger special (×2 for hub.s also). DELICIOUS. Never fail, anytime in the area, driving by, or get to pick a place (without distance from home restrictions); MUST!

Hannah Elizabeth

Great place to sit outside on a nice day. The view from the porch is nice. I had the flank steak salad and it was delicious. Definitely plan on going back.

Doug Scheer

We came here to watch the Detroit Lions on our road trip and the place is perfect for that. Lots of big screen TVs and the bartender was very happy to change the channel for us. Definitely the best place in town to watch sports.

Charles Ippolito

First time at this location.service was good.actually quiet for a Saturday evening.outdoor dining was available but we chose the indoor dining for the A/C.the server was prompt and very friendly.meal was delicious and filling.really enjoyed our time there.

+2

Tim Mickelsen

Excellent food and service! Nice sports bar and restaurant! Good selection of food.

+3

Xandra B

The food was so delicious 🤤😋. The lobster bisque was creamy and there was so much lobster in it! Our waitress was on it and very kind.

Tow Doctor

We e joyed this place alot. Visiting from Pittsburgh we were to get a good meal and nice atmosphere.

Brenda Richey

Flaherty's is a gorgeous and popular restaurant in Honeoye Falls. It is set right beside the creek. Seasonally there is outdoor porch and patio seating. Also chairs along the creek to view ducks , geese, and other wildlife. Beautiful view. Inside there are 2 large dining rooms, a beautiful full bar, booth seating, TV's and a lovely fireplace around the edges. The food is wonderful. I had the largest side salad I've ever seen, with generous blue cheese crumbles, delicious Mac and cheese and a glass of wine. It was fabulous. The take out container was so nice you can reuse it and add it to your plastic storage containers. If you come for St Patrick's day you will see some wait staff in kilts and a live bagpipe performance! Currently there are really classy classic Christmas decorations up all around. Very festive and beautiful. It is a great place to celebrate a special event or birthday also. You will love Flaherty's. It is one of our gems in Honeoye Falls.

+2

Matt

Lobster Bisque, Pulled Pork Nachos, Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich and Chicken Macaroni & Cheese were delicious. Staff were fast,friendly and helpful!

+2

Raynelle Hart

We love Flags, the BEST bar staff and servers. Food is amazing and atmosphere fantastic. Since it's Christmas time, I have to mention how gorgeous the decorations are, from the dining room to the bar and outside. The indoor tree's are decorated perfectly, the lighting and the mantels are exquisite. You can tell that a lot of time goes into it.

Friendly and professional. Gorgeous location next to the water. Hope to return in the correct season to enjoy the deck and the Adirondack chairs watching duck and geese. Beautiful decor for St Patty's day!!! Good lunch. Good beer.

Nice and cozy place for lunch or dinner, we had lunch with a nine month old. Our waitress was excellent with kids and very attentive and positive. The food is average.

The food was very good with a varied selection to appeal to every taste. The service was excellent. They don't rush the dining experience. The atmosphere is pleasing. You can eat inside or outside. I prefer outside on the porch overlooking the creek. I would recommend this restaurant.

I arrived late meeting my party. I ordered later than them, but I was served my food just a little later than them. My food was good and I ate the rest the next night. It was just as good. A few of my friends were very disappointed.

This is one of the best places to eat in the area. Also a great bar with EXCELLENT craft beer selection. You won't find cheap dive bar prices, but you also don't have to empty your wallet to dine here. Can get busy, call for reservations if you can.

How come the broc cheddar soup is only available 1 or 2 times a month? This is a pretty common soup to only offer a few times a year in which you have to call everyday to find out if it magically made the cut for the day.

This place is your run of the mill restaurant in our small town that does a good job of serving good food with a decent draft beer selection. It can get pretty busy on Friday and Saturday nights so make sure you call ahead!

I usually have a good food experience but this time I ordered something I wouldn't normally. Wasn't impressed and really didn't like it. I guess I need to stick to my usual.

Stopped in for a quick bite. The mushroom Swiss burger was terrific as were the chicken fingers! Drinks were good and so we're the prices. Their dinner menu looked good. Will go back again and try it! Only thing I didn't like was that fries were an upcharge for the burger? Weird, but good!

His is a great place for lunch, dinner or to just grab drinks. It's got plenty of parking and outdoor covered porch seating as well. Service was a bit slow when I went (a Saturday in the early afternoon). The place was practically empty, but our server seemed to take a long time to make her way to take our order. She was very pleasant and the food was good.

Clean inside. Outside seating on a good-sized porch. A couple of things that are disappointing, during the week the dining room is closed so you have to sit in the bar area, and they do away with some of their most favorite foods.

Very good. I thought food was not as good as last time I was there but still very good. Service was good. Our server Ethan was very pleasant and responsive to our needs. We had a party of 8 on a busy Saturday night and wait time was reasonable. Manager kept telling us what was going on so wait didn't seem as long. Overall would really recommend this restaurant highly.

Love the location and the building. Excellent place for a meal outside on a nice day. Service is generally very good. Prices are reasonable, however I find the food just ok. There always seems to be something worthy of nitpicking. That being said, I still enjoying dining here.

For large group, slow service. ( better each table order separately) Free popcorn is a plus! Stick with traditional dishes…

My wife and I enjoyed a meal here in their outside dining area. We were there with our young kids. The service was very good and the drink were well made! I personally thought my shrimp dish was underwhelming but I would go back and try something else! My wife got the steak and it was very well made! For kids I’d recommend bringing a little activity book or something as they did not have kids menus like other restaurants have. (This was not a big deal for us as we tend to come prepared.)

Great setting by the creek for this restaurant. Beautiful building with a nice and deserted dining room and bar area. They have bands play on the weekends. I used to love the food here, but unfortunately the last few times I have been here, it seems the food has gone downhill.

We went for lunch. Service was fast but they did not rush us. Business was steady and seating was available when we arrived. The menu is American but had lots of options. The food was tasty and decent portions for the money. We both took some home. The restaurant was clean. There was plenty of parking and is handicapped accessible (not sure of the ease of the rest room).

It was quiet on a Sunday afternoon. Staff were pleasant. I was disappointed in the selection of Irish food. I had Irish stew. My son had a beef pie. When our order came we discovered that the only difference between our meals was my son's had a crust on top. I don't know that I would go there again. I have relatives in Honeoye Falls so it would have been a nice place to gather.

I don’t know what happened but for years I would enjoy my Friday night prime rib. I would typically spend over $100.00 for our dinner. The French fries were the best part of our last meal. The artichokes French was cold and the prime rib was like shoe leather. I refused to bring it home to my dog.

Service was pretty slow not very busy when we went. Server did not check on us often also kept forgetting items in our order

I'm very disappointed. Clearly, they have cut quality and raised prices to increase their margin. They used to have burgers of high-quality sirloin. My burger last night was obviously cheap ground beef. It was the first time in my life that I didn't finish a burger- and I hadn't eaten all day! Further, the previous week, what was touted as "fish and chips" was a few pieces of pre-formed, pre-packaged breaded fish and run of the mill French fries. Finally, I won't tell you what the charge was, but it was sinful. It's a shame. It used to be a great place, I doubt I'll ever return.

So I usually dont have a problem with this location but clearly this was not the night to come first of there wasva clear problem with me coming with my blended family they sat us way in the back where no one was and basically forgot about us but food came out cold and unequipped with the condiments we asked for several times we went without refills for over 45 minutes and just felt uncomfortable and unwelcomed will not return to this location and I've been coming here for over 2 years sad one experience ruined it for me

Ryan Schmitt

I went with a group for lunch. One person had dietary restrictions. The waiter emphatically made it clear that they would NOT work with us on dietary needs. Strange because the menu had gluten free symbols all over it. The service was slow for how empty it was. The waiter was unattentive. Tables and chairs were sticky and had crumbs on them. Maybe they care more about dinner service. The food was unremarkable but at least the chicken was moist. We may try one more time...fingers crossed.

+1

Made reservations set at the table for over 45 minutes before anybody even came to offer us water. After a long process of ordering half the food showed up at the table cold. Tried to get a second round of drinks they did not show up until after the meal was over. Waiter never even came back to ask how the food was or if we needed anything. It was a special dinner for a college graduation , Extremely disappointed.

I called on a Friday night to see about how busy you were with reservations. My family and I were planning on coming in to make a reservation tonight Friday night and a woman named Roxanne answered the phone and every time I went to ask her a question she cut me off three times so we are taking our business elsewhere no time for that

Came in for dinner and the hosts were very rude. Scuffing, rolling their eyes and just being very snotty and rude. We’ve been coming here for years and first time we’ve every been treated like that. Yall need to not but those girls up front if they are gonna treat people like that. Very immature

I arrived at 4:40 for dinner with my family of 5, 2 adults, 2 kids, and a toddler. There was a sea of open tables. I told the hostess the restaurant looked beautiful, and she replied with an exasperated “it doesn’t feel that way tonight.” Great greeting. I thought maybe because we were 5 she was overwhelmed, even though the place looked more than half empty. I said my toddler is small and we can easily fit in a 4 top. She said she would get her manager. The manager came out, also as rude as can be, and said that “tonight, absolutely not!” I had no idea what she was talking about. I said than can we split into two booths? She refused us. She refused my family because we were a party of 5 and the restaurant was half empty! I still don’t understand what happened but I am utterly appalled by the horrible (lack of) service, kindness, or explanation. They only take reservations for parties of 6 or more, and when I checked as we were leaving the website still said there was no wait. So the manager gets her wish I guess. My family of 5 will never return. Merry Christmas.

Julie Chung

The waitress was friendly but the eggplant sandwich and onion rings were terrible. Hardly any eggplant on the $18 eggplant sandwich. Ridiculously overpriced food.