Tony's Pizzeria

We love Tony, and we love Tony's Pizza. Not only is the food delicious and affordable, but Tony creates an environment that's very friendly for our kids. Tony makes Irvington great!

Ordered for the first time at Tony’s and got there a little early, not a problem. Just waited for my food to take home. It came out of the oven piping hot. Got home and it was delicious - we got 2 pizzas and the zucchini sticks!!! Not one complaint at home! Will be recommending this place to near by friends! Thank you

In town for a meeting, ordered from here. The chicken parm is absolutely amazing! Garlic bread delicious. 5 stars all the way!

Just passing thru town from NH and staying over ... ordered by recommendation from hotel, delivered hot and in short time, delicious! And so nice to eat a good dinner without having to go back on the road after a long day in horrid weather!!

This place is outstanding the chicken parm wedges the chicken pies I'm a chicken Guy The Best I ever had I highly recommend going there or ordering delivery from there you won't be upset quality food beautiful food 🍕🥰💯

Picked up a large pepperoni. Delicious - lasted all of two minutes before it was devoured. Friendly fast service. Greeted as soon as I walked in the door The and the pie was hot and ready. Would recommend and will come again.

Marvin Riviere

Pizza was delicious. And they delivered in the blizzard! Thank you!

Paul O'Reilly

We love Tony, and we love Tony's Pizza. Not only is the food delicious and affordable, but Tony creates an environment that's very friendly for our kids. Tony makes Irvington great!

John

In town for a meeting, ordered from here. The chicken parm is absolutely amazing! Garlic bread delicious. 5 stars all the way!

Barbara Yurkshat

Just passing thru town from NH and staying over ... ordered by recommendation from hotel, delivered hot and in short time, delicious! And so nice to eat a good dinner without having to go back on the road after a long day in horrid weather!!

Patrick Rooney

Great food, great people, and great service. What else can you ask for!

Andrew Indellicate

Excellent food and friendly staff. You wouldn't think it when you first walk in, but this is a hidden hole in the wall gem.

Gianna Taddeo

One of our go to places to order from in the area. Food is excellent every time !!!

Kelly Snyder

Ordered for the first time at Tony’s and got there a little early, not a problem. Just waited for my food to take home. It came out of the oven piping hot. Got home and it was delicious - we got 2 pizzas and the zucchini sticks!!! Not one complaint at home! Will be recommending this place to near by friends! Thank you

megan mcnutt

We love Tony’s! Great food! Friendly and fast service

MAD

They make a killer buffalo pie and are very very nice people! will definitely be ordering from them again

Jeff Kearns

Tony is very personal and makes great pizzas! We especially like his veggie pizza with BLACK OLIVES added! 🍕

hope

the best pizza spot in irvington! the workers are very welcoming and provide a great atmosphere to be in. the pizza is very good and fresh and there other appetizers are very good too! i go quite often and highly recommend if you’re looking for great pizza and great service from the workers! tony knows how to make a pizza<3

Will Raymond

Unlike Erwin, I don't copy and paste negative reviews based on your competitor! Tony's WIPES IPC anyday. NOT TOO MUCH ON DEZ NORTON AND TONY!!! <333

Gehw Bewha

Picked up a large pepperoni. Delicious - lasted all of two minutes before it was devoured. Friendly fast service. Greeted as soon as I walked in the door The and the pie was hot and ready. Would recommend and will come again.

Cori James

Had a pizza and gnocchi with meat sauce delivered. Food was delivered faster than expected and was still very warm! As someone with a dairy sensitivity I often have a hard time ordering from pizza places. The gnocchi was a very good portion and was so good- I can’t wait to order from here again! I could get it every time and not be sick of it. Boyfriend said pizza was very good as well!

Excellent plain cheese slices here. Big slices with a nice crust. 4 slices and two sodas came to $22 (Hello, Westchester pizza prices!) I noted no price menu in in store (1 point deduction) and the place is very tiny with zero attention to ambiance (cough). Really built for takeout.

Agile Dodger

Excellent plain cheese slices here. Big slices with a nice crust. 4 slices and two sodas came to $22 (Hello, Westchester pizza prices!) I noted no price menu in in store (1 point deduction) and the place is very tiny with zero attention to ambiance (cough). Really built for takeout.

Ordered DoorDash and this shows up. The pizza is cold, and they did not cook the ingredients into the cheese. I’ve never seen this before, it’s like putting a cold salad on top of a cheese pizza. I also ordered two cannolis as in the photo, and they only brought 1 for $6! I am requesting a full refund. Get a new chef

Eric Wilson

Ordered DoorDash and this shows up. The pizza is cold, and they did not cook the ingredients into the cheese. I’ve never seen this before, it’s like putting a cold salad on top of a cheese pizza. I also ordered two cannolis as in the photo, and they only brought 1 for $6! I am requesting a full refund. Get a new chef

Never had a worse customer service experience in my life. Called an hour after I place my order just to check in (1 large pizza, 10min from my house). The system was down so my order hadn’t gone through, good thing I called! They said it would be another 45min. I asked if I could get some sort of discount for the inconvenience and they laughed at me and said “no, other orders have arrived much later than this”….Don’t order here if you’re hungry lol!!!

Pizza isn't good and it isn't fresh either. I don't know why I listen to their customer recommended this place other day. Irvington Pizza Co has better pizza than this shop to be honest. What doesn't make sense is that how is this pizza shop are "local favorite"? They are the only one that has slice apps and other pizza shop don't?!? That literally false advertising, no shame and lost respect for it.

Ordered Delivery through the slice app, food arrived more than an hour and a half later. My gluten free pizza was delivered with the wrong topping and the food was cold and needed to be reheated. They did offer a refund of 5 dollars for the wrong topping but I couldn't remake the pizza at home, so that was 25% of original price. There seemed to be issues with the slice app, it took 45 minutes to acknowledge the order was received in the app even though Slice customer service told us it was in progress and would arrive in 20 minutes. 1 hour and 15 mins after we ordered, still no pizza, slice customer service checked in and said it was delayed because it was busy and out for delivery. After the pizza was delivered we got the automated notification from slice that our pizza was in the works. The pizza was fine but not remotely worth the headache. Not likely to get the gluten free pizza here again and definitely not through the slice app.

Makak Salopri

Pizza isn't good and it isn't fresh either. I don't know why I listen to their customer recommended this place other day. Irvington Pizza Co has better pizza than this shop to be honest. What doesn't make sense is that how is this pizza shop are "local favorite"? They are the only one that has slice apps and other pizza shop don't?!? That literally false advertising, no shame and lost respect for it.

Frank Fidelman

Went in with my kids. $17 for 3 slices, not good slices but the dry, brown ones you see after they have been sitting around. He had them hidden behind the counter, disappointing. A 1liter bottle of water for $4.50 which Tony rounded to $5. Hardly feels like a good experience. Inflation is no excuse, he definitely did not get a return customer.