My favorite restaurant. Service is always top notch and the food is always excellent. Highly recommended

My favorite restaurant. Service is always top notch and the food is always excellent. Highly recommended

My favorite restaurant. service is always top notch and the food is always excellent. Highly recommended

We had dinner here last evening and it was a great experience! The food was great, the atmosphere was great and the service was great! Our server, Nancy, was polite, attentive and friendly! Highly …

So the food is decent, but I give this place 5 stars mainly for the atmosphere and historic story behind the inn. \nThe property dates back to 1653 and was a place for settlers and british soldiers…

Milleridge Inn Went Above and Beyond When my elderly mother passed away, we knew we had to honor one of her final wishes: to celebrate her life with a gathering at the Milleridge Inn. She had cheris…

Absolutely phenomenal Irish celebration.saw it on news12 and finally a place that honors my heritage.there were bagpipes, Irish dancers,great food selections and wonderful staff to enhance the expe…

Absolutely phenomenal Irish celebration.saw it on news12 and finally a place that honors my heritage.there were bagpipes, Irish dancers,great food selections and wonderful staff to enhance the expe…

Great service, nice varied menu, excellent food. The ambiance / atmosphere is unique, with the theme of historical American Revolutionary War. Drinks were delicious. So was the food. The table go…

Great service, nice varied menu, excellent food. The ambiance / atmosphere is unique, with the theme of historical American Revolutionary War. drinks were delicious. So was the food. The table got …

Well worth the money, great ambiance and better food! Joe has done an outstanding job making sure everything is perfect after the substantial renovations this past summer. We will definitely be bac…

Well worth the money, great ambiance and better food! Joe has done an outstanding job making sure everything is perfect after the substantial renovations this past summer. We will definitely be bac…

Priya Thapa

The Milleridge Inn feels like stepping into a charming historic home warm, beautifully decorated, and full of character. The food has that true house‑made taste, the kind that feels comforting from the first bite. Portions are big, so come hungry. I had the roast pot and the chicken lemon piccata, and both were flavorful, tender, and clearly made with care. And the bread… they give you so much of it, fresh and perfect for soaking up every sauce. The décor is another highlight cozy, detailed, and full of that homey, nostalgic vibe that makes you want to linger. It’s the kind of place where you instantly feel relaxed and taken care of. I loved the atmosphere and would definitely come back.

+1

Kimberly L

Went for a friends Christmas party, some of my party had an issue at the bar, being overcharged for happy hour drinks, service was nice but slow, Carolers to request from our table and sang, very festive. I got a breadless Brigade Eggplant sandwich. It was fine but portion was small. Someone else got the price fixed Yankee Pot Roast dinner which came with soup and dessert. It was tasty as was the bowl of mushroom soup.

+6

The service is VERY slow. Each course took a long time to be brought out. We needed to remind them twice about bringing the martinis to the table. The decor is cute and the food is good. But overal…

The service is VERY slow. Each course took a long time to be brought out. We needed to remind them twice about bringing the martinis to the table. The decor is cute and the food is good. But overal…

It was my birthday today (11/9/25, Sun) and I was so excited to spend my day at Milleridge, that is until we had the most awful waitress & manager to speak about the luncheon. First, they refused to …

It was my birthday today (11/9/25, Sun) and I was so excited to spend my day at Milleridge, that is until we had the most awful waitress & manager to speak about the luncheon. First, they refused t…

It was my birthday today (11/9/25, Sun) and I was so excited to spend my day at Milleridge, that is until we had the most awful waitress & manager to speak about the luncheon. First, they refused t…

I had a party of 16 for lunch. The reservation process was good, and the table setup was done well. However, they are short-staffed, and some were very inexperienced or just not accustomed to custo…

We have had dinner here many times over the last 38 years but not recently. The atmosphere and service were great. The Christmas carolers were charming. The baked clam appetizer was excellent. My…

Juliana Maantay

Been going here since a child with my parents, over 50 years, I guess. You go there for the atmosphere and surroundings, especially at the holidays, and it's very beautiful and nostalgic. The food used to be much better than it's been the past few years. For the price, the food and service are not that good, just adequate. But, as I said, the main attraction is just being there.

Mel PS

A fun, and free family outing. During the holidays The Milleridge Inn comes to life with a holiday display walk through. The event is free, and anyone can visit. If you have small kids, this is perfect for them. There's a cute little train to drives around the lot, the kids would love it. The shops around the walk through are heavily lit up and stocked with all things holidays. The area is not big, and displays are close to one another, expect a crow and expect the stand on lines for shops and even to get pictures with the tree and the artificial Santa's. Over all, it's a nice little outing, it may take about 15-20 min to walk through if you don't stop at every display to admire or take some pics.

Went New Year's Eve for the price fix menu...not realizing we had option otherwise. No matter the food was very good until we got to dessert. My husband took one bite out of his dessert and I notic…

I've been going here since I was a kid. I went today and I ordered prime rib well done. It came out with a heartbeat. It went back and came out still more pink than brown. It wasn't even medium w…

Food was pretty good. The short rib was not as tender as it should be but flavor was ok. The decor was pretty old school but I can tell it can look really nice over the Christmas holidays. Servic…

tl;dr I do not recommend. The food is awful and way overpriced. I really wanted to love it. The atmosphere is so cozy and welcoming. It's early February here in NY and they really capured cabin comfort, with valentine's decorations and a wood burning fire place roaring. The staff were ok, not very warm, but not totally standoffish either. The issue I had was the food. It was terrible. They had an impressive spread for brunch and every single item (that I tried) was a disappointment. The chicken franchise, eggs, quiche, waffles, chicken fingers, fries, biscuits and gravy were dried out and clearly sitting around for way too long in the warming dishes. The melon was under ripe and the strawberries were going bad. The desserts were just not good. At over $60 per person (drinks not even included), I don't know what they are thinking. I will never come back, which is so sad because this place truly is adorable.

Theresa Monastra

Place is not great! All of our food was cold. It took 20 min to get our drinks. The waiter S Danish said the bartender was slammed. We ordered apps. Salad, entries and dessert and coffee. We were told the apps and salad had to come out together. We could have the apps then salad , then entre. Spinach was so salty, risotto tasted like success rice boiled. String beans some were crunchy, others mooshy and they were not dressed. Just plain. Salad had no walnuts or cranberries as described, just plain lettuce. Dressing tasted like it was from a pouch, the kind you get from a deli for lunch. When told the waiter did bring us some walnuts and cranberries to add to the salad. Atmosphere wonderful. Food not so much. Next time I'll just go for drinks.

Betty P

Really disappointed with my experience here. Busy Thursday with only one bartender and charged almost $18 for a generic chardonnay!!?? Outrageous! Four Seasons prices without the quality. People working our event were like deer in headlights when we needed something. Waited very long for water and coffee and needed to be reminded. Food mediocre except for the cheesecake. The village looks like it used to be nice, but no carolers, no cheerful greetings, even the merchandise looks like it was just put out without care for the display and experience. The Santa posting for pics looked grumpy and disheveled. Sad.

Food was cold service was poor. We go every year such a shame because the atmosphere is good

Food was cold service was poor. We go every year such a shame because the atmosphere is good

food was cold service was poor. We go every year such a shame because the atmosphere is good

Food was cold service was poor. We go every year such a shame because the atmosphere is good

Yes, it's lovey (a bit run down) at Christmas. Yes, the staff is pleasant and accommodating. And yes, the food is underwhelming and overpriced. A group of us have been going at Christmas for many y…

An INCREDIBLY disappointing evening that was meant to celebrate two birthdays. We waited an hour for our drinks to arrive. Then another hour for our food. Every dish was cold, the soda was flat, …

Sat down at my table, didn't have a waiter come over for 20 minutes. Came over asked for drinks, after having to wait we ordered everything at once, we then sat for another 20 minutes. Finally we g…

An INCREDIBLY disappointing evening that was meant to celebrate two birthdays. We waited an hour for our drinks to arrive. Then another hour for our food. Every dish was cold, the soda was flat, th…

Sat down at my table, didn't have a waiter come over for 20 minutes. Came over asked for drinks, after having to wait we ordered everything at once, we then sat for another 20 minutes. Finally we g…

A 6:30 reservation and didn't get seated til almost 7:30. Lots of other groups with 6:30 reservations were still waiting outside too. The hostesses said that the chef told them to stop seating peop…

What a money grab.!!! \n On site Milleridge Restaurants must have a daily delivery from Restaurant Depot. Pre-processed servings were obviously micro wave "stuff" with poor quality and little taste…

2 \n\nFamily visiting for my birthday. Reservations at 7. Get seated right away. Waiter comes over after 5 minutes & takes our drink order. We wait 30 minutes for our drinks. Place our food order a…

Had dinner there yesterday, Thanksgiving Day, 12 noon at the Buffet. Very disappointing and OVERPRICED. They advertised prime rib but had something that loked like a large top round OR EVEN LESS …

The service by Amanda, the hostess, at The Cottage at Milleridge Inn on Mother’s Day was a complete disaster. She was rude, dismissive, and completely unfit to be the first face guests see. We waite…

The service by Amanda, the hostess, at The Cottage at Milleridge Inn on Mother’s Day was a complete disaster. She was rude, dismissive, and completely unfit to be the first face guests see. We wai…

Don't waste your money or time taking family to this dishonest restaurant. We took our family of 10 for a Christmas dinner on December 8, 2024. I had to give them $100. deposit for the reservation…

I had high hopes for Santa’s breakfast at the Milleridge Inn Cottage, but it was a complete disaster. I’ve had better Christmas breakfasts in high school cafeterias! Charging $50 per person for thi…

Short version: In summary, I DO NOT recommend going here! * wait times outrageous * food is NOT edible * staff is rude * Carolers? What carolers? Long version: Arrived for reservation on time. …

Short version: In summary, I DO NOT recommend going here! * wait times outrageous * food is NOT edible * staff is rude * Carolers? What carolers? Long version: Arrived for reservation on time. …

Horrible experience. Myself and my family have been going to the Millridge for years. 17 of us went Easter Sunday and none of us will be going back ever again. We got waited over 4 hours to get se…

We went to dinner for an early Christmas family celebration. The service was poor. drinks came quickly, the food took forever and the waitress never returned to ask if everything was okay. The f…

So disappointing. We made a reservation on Saturday for 8 PM. WE finally got seated at 8:30 pm. The waiter took our order and served us cold bread that was supposed to be warm. We placed our order…

They knew they were short handed. They not only continue to take reservations, when you arrive they know they can’t accommodate you but don’t tell you! We waited one hour (with a reservation) only …

⭐ 1-Star Review: Deeply Disappointing Valentine’s Day Experience I came to the Milleridge Inn for Valentine’s Day, and I should have known things were off when I waited 30 minutes past my reservation time. When I finally asked about it, I was told they had forgotten about us , even though our table had been ready the whole time. We were seated, only to wait another 30 minutes before a server finally came over. When she did, she gave my wife an attitude, which was completely unacceptable. I asked for the manager, who apologized repeatedly for his staff and assured us he would assign a new server who would be more attentive. That never happened. We waited another 15 minutes with no server in sight. At that point, we got up and walked out. We ended up having a far better experience at the Broadway Diner — which says a lot considering Milleridge was charging $89 per person for a pre-fixe Valentine’s menu. I’ve been dining at the Milleridge Inn for over 25 years, and I can confidently say this will be my last visit. It’s a shame to see a place with so much history and charm go so far downhill.

My experience at The Milleridge Inn was beyond disappointing. We were charged $325.62 for a dinner that was truly subpar — the food was poorly prepared, lacked flavor, and felt low quality across the board. For that price point, the meal should have been exceptional. Instead, it was comparable to something you’d expect at a casual chain, not a restaurant charging premium prices. I’ve genuinely paid less at major theme parks for far better food. The service only made things worse. Customer service was rude, inflexible, and completely unwilling to take responsibility. When I reached out to address the issue, I was either ignored or met with dismissiveness. There was no effort to resolve the situation or show any care for guest experience — it felt entirely about keeping the money. After getting nowhere directly, I disputed the charge. Regardless of the outcome, the fact remains: the food was unacceptable, the experience was overpriced, and the way it was handled afterward was unprofessional. I would strongly caution others before dining here.

My experience at The Milleridge Inn was unacceptable. I was charged $325.62 for a dinner that was genuinely disgusting and wildly overpriced for what was served. THEY CHARGED ME $325 BASE AND THEN THERE WAS AN UPCHARGE FOR CHEESE ON THE FRENCH ONION SOUP!!! The food was poorly prepared, low quality, and absolutely not reflective of the price point. I have paid less for lunch for 6 and DISNEY WORLD — there is no justification for what we were charged here. What made the situation worse was the customer service. It was rude, inflexible, and completely dismissive. There was zero accountability and no effort to make things right. It felt very clear that the priority was keeping the money, not caring for guests or standing behind the experience they provide. I attempted to resolve this directly and was ignored, which left me no choice but to dispute the charge. While the charge was ultimately upheld, that does not change the fact that the food, service, and overall experience were unacceptable. For the amount charged, this experience fell far below even basic expectations. I will NEVER return and would strongly caution others before spending their money here.

We had to wait twenty minutes beyond our reservation to be seated. Nobody took our drink order for 40 minutes. By the time they took our order, they were out of many food options so we had to go with our second- and third-choices. All the food that we received was under temperature or cold. The flavors were okay, but the temperature made most of the food inedible. This was easily the single worst meal I've ever had at a restaurant, and I paid $110 per person for it.

Evgenia Soldatos-Mouzouris

After many years of hearing about the breakfast with Santa event, I decided to book the experience for my children. To say this was a disappointment was an understatement. I paid 260 dollars for three adults and two children. My public school growing up had better food than what was served at this event. First, Santa was miserable. The face painting was sub par and the woman making the balloons kept yelling at all the children. The food was HORRIFIC for the price we paid. Everything was cheap. The orange juice was in a plastic cup with the foil pull back- reminded me of lunch at school. And it smelled like a cafeteria school. Save your money. The winter village also was terrible. Stores with barely anything inside. Staff that was rude. Don't waste your time or money. Truly disappointing.

Theresa P

Had our office holiday party last night. Set menu. Waitress was by herself for 24 people but did a great job. We were upstairs in a private room. Asked for Music and said she could give us a speaker to set up with our phone . We agreed then told we would have to rent it? No longer the well known pop overs but a cold roll Already at the table. Marinated skirt steak was recommended to us. All but one at our table of 8 ordered it. It was like a piece of old shoe leather. Well done and not sure what they used as marinade. Didn’t even taste salt and pepper. Such a disappointment. Barely anyone brought leftover food home due to poor quality food. Run, don’t walk away from this place. Ruined many happy and delicious meals I have had there in the past. Decorations lovely , maybe they should have better people in the kitchen so the food is palatable.

Michelle C

Went my birthday night, am a frequent customer. Signed up for the birthday club. Took a smaller purse as I usually do when I go out to an event. I forgot to put my license in it from my larger purse. The email for the birthday certificate stated to print out the certificate. I printed it out. I couldn't read the fine print on the certificate in email. When time to pay, they asked for ID, said the certificate states I need ID. Having this instruction in the email would be beneficial to customers, not just the cerificate. So I didnt have my ID but did have it on my phone. Manager told me if I email it to him, he'll honor the certificate. I don't ever email my ID so the certificate was not honored. It wasnt ok to just see my ID and that it was valid and was my birthday. Meanwhile, so many eyes were on my table as manager came back and forth twice. Was not a pleasant birthday dinner. Regret going there for my birthday.

Lauren Skelly Bailey

It’s beautiful but if your party is upstairs just know none of it is coming to you hot or warm at the minimum. Went for a holiday party every appetizer and entree came out cold. Super disheartening. I have loved this place since I was a kid but last night for a dinner party apps at 630, dinner at 845 — somehow everything COLD — just Ewww!!