Broadway Pizza

Everybody in my house agrees. Best wings in Kingston. Good pizza. Not too greasy and reheats well for breakfast. Good pricing. Nice people. We'll be going back.

Whew let me tell you , the first night I had this pizza… I came back for a second time with a colleague to get more !! Not only was the environment relaxing and clean, the service was out of this world. I would highly recommend trying the pesto artichoke pizza(not sure what else may have been on it for it was gone in a minute). *garlic knots are a definite must

We ordered the chicken parm pizza, the white pizza, and a couple of canolis. It was delicious! The pizza had a crunch in every bite, neither the cheese or sauce overpowered the other, and very filling for being on the thinner side of crust. The canolis had just the right amount of sweetness. We will definitely be ordering again!

We do takeout pizza here and it’s terrific. Classic thin-crust oven pizza. OK, not brick oven, but excellent of this type. Ingredients are fresh, toppings are generous, price is right. This is NY City- worthy pizza right here in Kingston. Go for it!

Amazing pizza, friendly, wings were delicious. Highly recommend. Accommodated a big order everything was on point. Highly recommend.

Food is great and customer service is excellent! Grubhub dropped the ball on delivery of my sandwich and they personally brought my order that Grubhub never picked up. The chicken parm sub was amazing! Highly recommend this place! Pro tip: order directly from them and skip the delivery app! They have their own delivery drivers. Thanks again for delivering my food!

the best and freshest pizza in kingston to be more specific MIDTOWN KINGSTON. but they also have empanadas..need i say more. atmosphere perfect and with seasoning at every table..well that allows me to get straight to business which i appreciate.

This new pizza spot is the best one to come along in Kingston in a long time. My family and I are very picky when it comes to pizza especially. We love city pizza so its hard to find any that compare in upstate Ny but this new little cute place to grab a bite is the closest one to city pizza in years when it comes to Kingston. They also deliver I will continue to order from them. The customer service is also good. They have a family deal that is good on saving money and allowing you to get wings, pizza, and a drink. Love this place!!

We were driving through the neighborhood and stopped in for a quick bite to eat. The specialty pizza we ordered was very good. Will stop there again next time we're in the area.

Staying at a local hotel and ordered the GF pizza (as a non-celiac). It was 10/10. Really delicious. Delivery guy was also great! Highly recommend.

Honestly one of the best spots to get a slice! Dont let me forget the Pupusas! They are made fresh and were just as good if not better than the Pupusas I get back home in Los Angeles, Ca. Where else in the world can you get an authentic New York slice and an authentic pupusa in the same restaurant? If you’re in the area definitely check them out! The owner and staff were really friendly! The next time I’m in this area I’m coming back for a slice and pupusa 👍🏽

I love Matteo's! The pizza is great. If want something really tasty, stop by in person and get a couple of fresh-made pupusas. They come with curtido (cabbage salad) and tasty salsa and you won't find a better deal on a meal anywhere.

I’ve been having a hard time finding wings I like, they’re usually small, greasy and not worth the price. These are worth the price, large chicken wings. I hope they never switch vendors.

Very good pizza by slice, good tomato sauce, nice staff, nice interior, clean. Def will go back to try non pizza foods.

Julian Guevara

Honestly one of the best spots to get a slice! Dont let me forget the Pupusas! They are made fresh and were just as good if not better than the Pupusas I get back home in Los Angeles, Ca. Where else in the world can you get an authentic New York slice and an authentic pupusa in the same restaurant? If you’re in the area definitely check them out! The owner and staff were really friendly! The next time I’m in this area I’m coming back for a slice and pupusa 👍🏽

Larry Legend

I love Matteo's! The pizza is great. If want something really tasty, stop by in person and get a couple of fresh-made pupusas. They come with curtido (cabbage salad) and tasty salsa and you won't find a better deal on a meal anywhere.

Gabrielle P

I’ve been having a hard time finding wings I like, they’re usually small, greasy and not worth the price. These are worth the price, large chicken wings. I hope they never switch vendors.

Uli Ku

Very good pizza by slice, good tomato sauce, nice staff, nice interior, clean. Def will go back to try non pizza foods.

Best pizza and wings in Kingston and the staff is so friendly. Delivery is always fast, accurate and still hot. Prices are great. Everything we have ordered we've loved!

Matteo's had delicious pizza. I had the peperoni with pesto, the ham and pineapple, and the BBQ chicken and broccoli with sesame crust slices. All three were amazing. Perfect thin and crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and the perfect flavor combination. While I was ordering i noticed they had pupusa, so I ordered a shrimp pupusa to go. Also delicious. I definitely recommend Matteo's.

Well, this is a quiet little gem. I was actually on my way down the street to eat at another more loudly advertised pizza joint but stopped in here on a whim. First of all, the pizza was really good. I mean, that’s what really matters. But second of all, it’s got that local neighborhood feel. They keep their relationship with the community honest and down to earth. That’s the kind of place I like to spend my money. Of the people, by the people, for the people.

My man and I went out to dinner in kingston late one sunday, and nothing was open. Matteo's was closing down, the pizzas where all put away, and we walked in hungry. We asked the man behind the counter if he would serve us, or if we missed our chance? The man behind the counter ( who i assume was Matteo) smiled, and proceeded to take out the pizzas he had put away for the night, and asked us what we wanted out of the selection he had. Being hungry and grateful, we ordered several slices (to go) with a few drinks. Meanwhile Matteo had turned his oven back on, heated our slices and even threw one in for free! He was so kind and generous and we where so thankful! 10/10 service and the pizza, turns out, was FANTASTIC! We will be returning at a reasonable hour for more pizza soon! Thank You Matteo <3

The owner/worker was very kind and helpful. Also have many specialty pizzas that all sound good

Very good, got a buffalo chicken slice, mozzarella sticks and eggplant slice.. it was so amazing.. I don’t usually like places blue cheese but I’d come back just for the dressing lol definitely will be back. It’s a place I tumbled across but have now added to my favorites .. 💕

Forget the pizza, the latin cuisine is amazing. Steak tacos, pappusas, house hot sauce, nachos, that's the secret in this place. Pizza gets you in, the tacos make you stay!

A good casual family place to get a New York City style pizza slice as well as delicious pupusas!

I ordered takeout and got one of the best Baked Ziti w/ meatsauce that I've had from a public joint! As close to authentic homemade as I've seen outside of the City!

Sarah

A good casual family place to get a New York City style pizza slice as well as delicious pupusas!

Marcello Gros

The owner/worker was very kind and helpful. Also have many specialty pizzas that all sound good

Dalton Jones

Well, this is a quiet little gem. I was actually on my way down the street to eat at another more loudly advertised pizza joint but stopped in here on a whim. First of all, the pizza was really good. I mean, that’s what really matters. But second of all, it’s got that local neighborhood feel. They keep their relationship with the community honest and down to earth. That’s the kind of place I like to spend my money. Of the people, by the people, for the people.

Goddess

My man and I went out to dinner in kingston late one sunday, and nothing was open. Matteo's was closing down, the pizzas where all put away, and we walked in hungry. We asked the man behind the counter if he would serve us, or if we missed our chance? The man behind the counter ( who i assume was Matteo) smiled, and proceeded to take out the pizzas he had put away for the night, and asked us what we wanted out of the selection he had. Being hungry and grateful, we ordered several slices (to go) with a few drinks. Meanwhile Matteo had turned his oven back on, heated our slices and even threw one in for free! He was so kind and generous and we where so thankful! 10/10 service and the pizza, turns out, was FANTASTIC! We will be returning at a reasonable hour for more pizza soon! Thank You Matteo <3

Jon Towers

I ordered takeout and got one of the best Baked Ziti w/ meatsauce that I've had from a public joint! As close to authentic homemade as I've seen outside of the City!

Amani Stevenson

Very good, got a buffalo chicken slice, mozzarella sticks and eggplant slice.. it was so amazing.. I don’t usually like places blue cheese but I’d come back just for the dressing lol definitely will be back. It’s a place I tumbled across but have now added to my favorites .. 💕

Cara Grimm

Best pizza and wings in Kingston and the staff is so friendly. Delivery is always fast, accurate and still hot. Prices are great. Everything we have ordered we've loved!

Steve Flynn

Matteo's had delicious pizza. I had the peperoni with pesto, the ham and pineapple, and the BBQ chicken and broccoli with sesame crust slices. All three were amazing. Perfect thin and crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and the perfect flavor combination. While I was ordering i noticed they had pupusa, so I ordered a shrimp pupusa to go. Also delicious. I definitely recommend Matteo's.

August Monterrey

I don't like the taste of eggplant, which I hope means something when I say this is the best eggplant parm pizza I've ever had, let alone in Kingston. The pizza was crispy on the bottom, the eggplant was crispy, the veggies were fresh and not soggy, and there were hunks of ricotta. Very clean inside, and the cashier who helped us very kindly let us know the Yosy coconut strawberry drinks (nondairy) were 5$/ea, which is pricey, but we went for it and they were also very good. Third time getting eggplant pizza here and it's been great each time! Their buffalo chicken pizza is also very good. Garlic knotts are tiny as a heads up, but I'd still get them again. Only thing I'd note is dine in and take away that's not going very far def stays crispier (vs delivery, which is to be expected). Consistent vegetarian options that aren't bland or boring. 4 specialty slices and 2 fancy beverages was 25$ (total, for two people) and I would do it again.

Definitely not your average Italian pizza spot. They have good deals on slices for lunch. The food is meh, but the price makes it okay. Lady at the counter forgot to give me my change and had to ask for it back. Not exactly the experience I want, but not bad.

Food was good a little sweet on the slices but got a funnel cake and that was amazing very nice location great customer service

Raymond Suarez

Food was good a little sweet on the slices but got a funnel cake and that was amazing very nice location great customer service

Crust was ok, sauce had little to no flavor. To many other places that offer far better pizza to order again from here. The former place, Broadway Pizza, was much better. Broadway Pizza’s problem was inconsistent hour of operation.

Bland Pizza. I won't try it again. Dough and sauce were tasteless. Felt like eating a heft of cheap cheese on a stack of napkins. Service was fine, and the price wasn't outrageous.

Ordered a sub like I have in the past. I asked them please see if there is enough meat. Past subs only had about two slices. They charged me $5 dollars more, so $15 dollars. When I simple asked, why? They said because we put extra. And said "do you want it or not"!

If you're going in an order or picking up your order you'll get faster service than trying to get delivery their delivery is too long it shouldn't take an hour and a half for one order of calamari and fried dough and you're only around the corner from them but what I figured out was when I called back they made my order which was an hour after I initially called because the ticket says 6:39 and that was an hour after my initial call so my ticket was in printed out until I called back the second time and I prepaid for my food so basically if I wouldn't have called back I'd still be waiting for my food which thank God it's hot because that it was just cooked an hour after I ordered

Good place if you pickup. Delivery is a disaster. Called and was placed on a long hold with no response Called back and she asked to put me on hold again Then she LOST MY TICKET for the pizza so I ended up waiting almost 2 hours for the pizza after calling them and was Only given 7 dollars off for the inconvenience . The pizza itself is great but this place is an absolute nightmare to order delivery. It’s disappointing because I like their food and the owner but this is unacceptable

Shelby Ome

Good place if you pickup. Delivery is a disaster. Called and was placed on a long hold with no response Called back and she asked to put me on hold again Then she LOST MY TICKET for the pizza so I ended up waiting almost 2 hours for the pizza after calling them and was Only given 7 dollars off for the inconvenience . The pizza itself is great but this place is an absolute nightmare to order delivery. It’s disappointing because I like their food and the owner but this is unacceptable

dianna scriber

Ordered a sub like I have in the past. I asked them please see if there is enough meat. Past subs only had about two slices. They charged me $5 dollars more, so $15 dollars. When I simple asked, why? They said because we put extra. And said "do you want it or not"!

I ordered for the first time for delivery, they are about 3 blocks away, but wasn't feeling well enough to go out.. Ordered two hero's.. first off, on the small side, secondly the eggplant hero were 2 paper thin slices of eggplant, barely any cheese... VERY salty and the sauce was VERY acidic, the meatballs were enough, but bland and tasteless, sauce also acidic... also the cheese tasted off.. They said 40 minutes for delivery, only 3 blocks away remember... but it took 55 minutes and our hero's arrived COLD... These are supposed to be hot hero's... Never again. Aren't there any good Pizza places in this City? Cause I haven't found one yet, ordered from another place nearby and got sick for 2 days.. shame.

Cockroach 🪳 Found In the box after going back to work! Got to slices of pizza with a cockroach 🪳 in the box Gross Owner would even open the box when I took it back in because he had to have known he has cockroachs! Glad it was seen before take in to my work place or home! Got pictures but they will not let me post them! Don't Eat Or Bring Anything Home From This Place! It was $9.10 He gave me back $9 to much of a tip! CITY OF KINGSTON NEW YORK NEED TO DO BETTER

I have been ordering from Broadway Pizza as long as I have been in Kingston. The last order I made was for a sicilian pizza, a garden salad, and boneless wings (almost 50 dollars). My pizza was delivered without salad or wings. I called back the delivery guy came back with chicken nuggets, and no salad. I called and spoke with the owner Bill. He sent the delivery guy back out with the wrong salad. I called and asked him not to send the young man out again (which he didn't). Bill said "I will take care of you on your next order." Which I took to mean the next order would have been free. I called tonight and ordered the exact same order and explained what the owner said. Eventually Bill got on the phone and told me he couldn't give me a 50 dollar order for free, that my previous order was right, and that he said I said I would take care of you... after going back and forth and was arguing with me and he said yes, but you can not get your order for free. So I said okay what are you offering he said uh...10%. I said okay thank you and hung up. Tonight is the last time I will patronize this establishment. It is really disappointing because I love Broadway Pizza but if this is coming from the owner I will not support a shop that goes back on its word and is unwilling to even hear what I have to say around customer service. So, so disappointed.

NEVER AGAIN I ordered delivery through Uber Eats and got the chicken parm and tuscan panini. The chicken parm was weirdly lemony (like it had been sitting in a lemon bath for a few days) which clashed with the cheese making a nauseating combo like curdled milk. The pasta along side the chicken was rich with ricotta which would’ve been great if it didn’t have a spoiled, almost barf-like flavor. I wish I was joking…. The garlic bread was nothing special and the side salad was fresh but very very small, even in the smallest plastic container it was small. The tuscan chicken panini was supposedly one of the best and most popular dishes on the menu. It was better than the chicken parm which isn’t saying much but lacked flavour and the chicken was quite dry, not at all fresh. Even the french fries were soggy and completely under seasoned. They tasted like fry oil. MMM 🤨 I will not order from here again, giant waste of my time and money as now I have to cook dinner.

Just terrible! I waited almost 2 hours for my food after they said 45 mins.. Then when the driver finally showed up he gave us another persons order!! On top of that one of our pizza was burnt! My chicken Alfredo pasta came with literally 10 noodles and when I called back the guy said that was all they had left he will give me credit! How do you sell your loyal customers (because I order from them often) pasta without any pasta !

So bad. Just got our order. The chicken Ceasar wrap is hot. The lettuce is wilted and soggy due to the wrap being hot and drowning in Ceasar sauce. No forks. French fries are stale. Just not good at all.

Terrible. From start to finish. The lady answering the phone, Hailey, on 1/16/25 refuses to provide her name. We called at 5pm for a 830pm delivery. No food ever showed up. Never had such a bad experience. This business needs to fire Hailey right away.

Ordered delivery with 3 hour advance notice, and followed up to make sure they were on track to deliver our food by 8pm. Never showed up. Called the restaurant multiple times to see what the deal was and the girl answering the phones refused to give us her name and she said “they are only an hour late what’s the big deal”. They were more than an hour late they never showed up. Don’t waste your time

We called 3 hours in advance and then we called again 1 hour before to remind them. They told us delivery was in route with Milton and he never came. The girl who answers the phone wouldn’t give us her name. They did not want to refund our money and we had to call the credit card company. Save yourself the time and effort go somewhere that can do what they say.

Every time I order I get less and less. Your meatball sliders are delicious but each time I order it I get 1 less slider.

Crystal Fitzpatrick

Every time I order I get less and less. Your meatball sliders are delicious but each time I order it I get 1 less slider.

Rocky Chanana

Terrible. From start to finish. The lady answering the phone, Hailey, on 1/16/25 refuses to provide her name. We called at 5pm for a 830pm delivery. No food ever showed up. Never had such a bad experience. This business needs to fire Hailey right away.

David Johnson

We called 3 hours in advance and then we called again 1 hour before to remind them. They told us delivery was in route with Milton and he never came. The girl who answers the phone wouldn’t give us her name. They did not want to refund our money and we had to call the credit card company. Save yourself the time and effort go somewhere that can do what they say.

Katie Chanana

Ordered delivery with 3 hour advance notice, and followed up to make sure they were on track to deliver our food by 8pm. Never showed up. Called the restaurant multiple times to see what the deal was and the girl answering the phones refused to give us her name and she said “they are only an hour late what’s the big deal”. They were more than an hour late they never showed up. Don’t waste your time