Peppino’s in Park Slope is absolutely fantastic. The food quality is A+. For starters, it was the best bruschetta I’ve ever had - no exaggeration. The pizza was perfect. I’m not a big pepperoni guy but this place does it right 👌. Pies cooked to perfection. Cheesesteak hoagies were excellent. Oozing cheese, peppers, onions 🤤… wish I took more photos for this review. My group had a small feast and everyone was happy. Delicious food and even better customer service. Must go. 5 stars!!

On a whim we hopped down here just before the storm . So happy we did what great food and service . So much fun too.

Jimmy Liang

Came highly recommended by fellow pizza lovers and Peppino’s did not disappoint! Their pizza was light, crispy, and the cheese had plenty of pull. Very flavorful from the sauce to the crust. Very comfortable dine-in spot for an easy night, since everything is a stone throw away. Very family and children friendly. Easily up there with some of the best slices BK has to offer! Try for yourself and bet you’ll agree.

Brooklyn PC

I came to Peppino’s for the 4 Stagioni and left genuinely impressed. The pizza was outstanding — fresh ham, mushrooms, olives, and artichokes layered over a rich tomato sauce with perfectly melted mozzarella. Every ingredient tasted clean, authentic, and perfectly balanced. The brick-oven crust had that ideal mix of crisp and chew with just the right char. You can truly taste the pride and tradition in every bite. The service was great from start to finish — friendly, welcoming, and attentive without being overbearing. And one of the most unique touches is the candy wall. It’s filled with classic and nostalgic treats, adding a fun and memorable vibe that you don’t see in most restaurants. It gives the place so much personality and makes the experience even better. Peppino’s is exactly the kind of neighborhood spot that reminds you why family-run places matter: great food, great people, and an atmosphere that feels like home. As Joe always says… God bless you, and God bless America.

+1

Ernest Chan

We used to go to the Peppino's in Bay Ridge all the time when we lived there. So when we visited a friend near this location, we decided to try it out, and it did not disappoint. The food and staff were just as great at this location. Best pizza in BK in my opinion and the service is quick.

Amie Smit-Green

Our go-to pizza spot in Brooklyn. Great take out that is fast, super fresh and everyone in the family eats. We probably eat here at least once a week.

Ian Ellison

The pizza is so light & crispy with great sauce and cheese. The lasagna tastes homemade! The service was awesome! Brought the family here and everyone was pleased! Will be back! Update: recently came back and everything is still on point! Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Atmosphere: 5 Seating type: there is plenty of seating and this restaurant is great for groups Vegetarian options:there are some solid options Dietary restrictions: the staff is very accommodating Parking space: this restaurant doesn’t have designated parking spaces Parking options: plenty of street parking (meter and free) Kid-friendliness: every kid I’ve seen in here was in pizza heaven lol Wheelchair accessibility: this restaurant is wheelchair accessible

+1

R. Spencer

Incredible and authentic baked ziti and bruschetta 🥰 Always a generous portion that’s full of flavour and impeccable ingredients 🍅 🌿 🧀 As a vegetarian I’ve been coming here for years since 2013 and the quality and consistency has stayed the same. Thank you peppinos for being a staple of the neighborhood since the 60s, don’t ever change 🙏💝

Alberto Hernandez

This spot was recommended by a very special person who lived in Park Slope — and I have to say, it was well worth the drive. After 5 PM, they don’t offer slices, but they do have small personal pies at very reasonable prices, with plenty of topping options. The staff was extremely polite, and I even had the chance to chat with the owner, who mentioned their other two locations. Parking is available nearby, and if you’re taking public transportation, the subway is just about a block away. There’s plenty of seating, making it a perfect place to enjoy a meal with family or friends. The warm, welcoming atmosphere will leave you wanting to come back. If you’re looking for great pizza in Park Slope, definitely make it a point to stop by — you won’t be disappointed!

Doreen Ferguson

The pizza and customer service are amazing! My friend and I discovered this place yesterday while looking for a quick bite before boxing class. I ordered a personal pizza, and as we sat down, they brought over garlic crisps and bruschetta for us to try. I thought it was such a nice touch, especially since I changed my initial ordered because I was shocked by the price(I’m used to old school Brooklyn pricing). But after tasting everything, I wouldn't mind paying for it next time. The customer service is top-notch, and I’ll definitely be back!