First time trying this place. Liked the pizza and the wings. We will go back!

All I cam say is Yum!

Great food and deals personally I would recommend not eating at any of the locations outside of Liverpool however due to the staffs general demeanor

Great pizza and wings! I always enjoy the char wings with extra sauce on the side :) the staff were also very friendly. Just wish the price of wings were better.

Recently, including last night I have ordered from OIP in Liverpool to be delivered. The order is always delivered sooner than the time frame given for delivery and ALWAYS arrives hot!! Last night I got the Steak Sandwich with the Works.....Incredibly Good....Also got the wings and they were awesome. I have never been disappointed in the service and food from OIP!!

Wanted to try something new and was able to come here. I was very impressed by the pizzas themselves and how much it filled me and my wife. I was able to try the chargrilled wings and I had to have more!

I love food at OIP! This Liverpool location is now my favorite. Char grilled garlic Parmesan wings cooked to perfection. Garlic knots are a must have

Excellent wings. I ordered the honey garlic wings perfect flavor. Just the right heat. It is finger licking good. Will go back.

Super nice staff. The wings is why I go. Char grilled, all day.

The best steak sandwiches made on homemade cibatta bread. Awesome wings. Great service and impeccably kept restaurant. Fast service and pleasant employees.

I went to this location on 11/8/21 @ 630 pm and let me tell you , this pizza was amazingly good !! Staff was super friendly . I’m so happy I went here !

First time eating at any OIP. The pizza is fantastic! Great N.Y. thin style pizza. Daughter had a sub. It looked great. She said it was awesome.

Great char-grilled wings and pizza. The grilled chicken salad was huge and the sauce used on the chicken was delicious.

I'm from down state. This is the closest thing to real pizza I have ever had. 5 stars!!!

Really nice guys they give you change if you need to or you know you need change for a 5 or anything to do your laundry right next door they'll help you out they're really good people I like this location

Excellent pizza...I'm use to LI Pizza and this is the best in liverpool. Delivery is great as well. Cindy

The food here is quality. It’s not cheap but they make up for it. They have the best chargrilled wings hands-down with good sauces. Everything else I’ve tried is good including the subs, calzones, Stromboli, and pizza. Take out or dine in.

Always my go to place... I can never leave without getting some garlic knots!

Huge, fresh slices! Friendly staff

The pizza and wings here are unmatched. It is so delicious I will never go anywhere else for pizza and wings! The service was amazing and the people there were extremely outgoing, nice and welcoming. I highly recommend OIP!

It was nice for the first time to come into this restaurant with my friend. We had hot fresh pizza in a matter of minutes. I enjoyed relaxing and catching up with my friend as the manager greeted us with a smile. I can see she is a great asset to the OIP establishment and can offer a peaceful setting to have dinner. Thanks for your time.

I love those wings Edit: These wings deserve a longer discussion. The textures are spectacular. If you order the the char grilled wings extra crispy, they come out extra crispy (Gino and Joe's on Old Liverpool Road and Twin Trees in North Syracuse also consistently produce extra crispy wings upon request). They also get little concentrations of crisp where they hit the grill. The flavors are incredible. If you like both Cornell chicken and Buffalo wings, you will love their hot flavor. Spicy and salty, plus a little bit aromatic and herbal. It's one of the few sauces I'd prefer to have on my wings instead of Frank's RedHot. I'm always expecting more smokiness from the char grilling, but it has never approached the level of disruptive. It's the kind of recipe that creeps into your daydreams. They've also improved their dough process recently. We usually go on Mondays, so maybe we're just getting weekend dough that's had bonus day to proof, but the crust has been pretty chewy recently. When the crust gets those crispy little blisters the size of a pinhead on the bottom and maintains some stretchiness in the crumb, I'm going to be a happy camper. But OIP adds lots of salty mozzarella and just the right amount of herbal tomato sauce on top of that dough. So, I love it. A couple of years ago I swore off this place because I had to wait 90 minutes for a pickup order after being told "25 minutes." The wings are so good that I had to abandon my boycott. No regrets. Thank god for hot fryer oil, hot ovens, and fast staff turnover.

We go here almost every Monday for the large cheese pizza special. The crust and sauce at OIP are great.

Love OIP! I come in and eat slices of chicken bacon ranch ( best in syracuse) almost every week. I love the staff there, its always clean, fast and efficient. then the honey garlic charred wings! YUM! All around good pizza joint

Perfect stop after a long day for delicious NY style pizza at a great price! We called ahead and it was waiting on us. We decided to eat there and it had a couple great long booths for our fam of 6!

The staff went above and beyond. My fiance and my work schedule did not allow us to share lunch together for Valentine's day. In the few minutes I had, I placed an online order with comments about dietary restrictions and asked that a special message be sent with the delivery. My fiance loved the food and the message was written right inside the box. I cannot say how impressed and thankful I am that the folks at OIP took the time to make our day special. Thanks again. And the leftovers tasted just as great reheated!

Love their grilled chicken wings! Usually get them medium with a side salad and fountain drink (Pepsi products). Clean and friendly. Quick service and professional staff. Reasonable prices.

Mike Fletcher

Great pizza place, recommended from another. Pizza is fresh, crispy and great on the sauce. Ordered wings to go. Got charboiled honey garlic. Banging wings. Had to sneak one for myself before sharing.

Kurt Neidlinger Jr.

We recently placed a large order with the Liverpool OIP for my fathers retirement party (70 people) and it was GREAT experience. Food was ready exactly on time, all the food was still hot and everyone at the party loved it. Will be ordering again. Thank you OIP team!

Tristan Valdez

Never disappointed with anything we order, everything is delicious!

Sarah Taylor

We've been fans for a long time, but most recently discovered they have the best garlic knots on the planet.

Elise Mazzoni

My husband and I love OIP! The people are super friendly and kind. He goes often on his lunches, we order pick up and we did a larger order for our son's birthday. Everyone loved the pizza, wings and salads (even our guests from NYC who are pizza picky)! If you're thinking about using them for a large party of any kind they do an awesome job!

Kyle Ecker

Great tasting food. They are very pleasant and polite workers everytime I've gone. The prices are decent. The garlic knots are incredibllleeeeee. Also, just tried a slider, incredible. Habanero honey I believe it was. Fireeee

J Stevenson

Sheet pizzas are the best!! Delivered on time for a party, hot and absolutely delicious! You cannot compare their homemade crust to any other sheet pizza. Huge hit every time!

Abraham Almagrabi

I've ordered from this place several times; usually take out, but also dine-in. They have never disappointed me. Their timely cooking (fast and as promised), their friendly staff, and their great and great and delicious pizza, calzones, and wings just make it the perfect pizza shop in the area, if not the whole county. I specifically love their charbroiled wings and Buffalo chicken calzone. Both area must try if you're dropping by to get some pizza.

Abe Al

Not sure why I haven't ordered from OIP much in the past, but ever since we got a taste of their charcoal grilled wings, we try to order from them every time we get a chance. Those wings are second to none and we could rip through them in a heartbeat. Their pizza is also very good, but you could find better in the area. Would recommend them though.

Attilio Lospinoso

OIP is consistently great. It does not matter which location you go to, the pizza is going to be good! I had a medium pizza with eggplant, and it was tasty! The eggplant is nice and crispy! My only complaint is that it was a little light on the eggplant, normally it covers most of the pizza, but it did not this time. Either way the pizza was great, and I am always willing to come back!

Ontario Go Local

Delicious pizza, and the garlic knots are really good and potent (if you like garlic these are for you!) Highly recommend and will return when in Liverpool!

Their bathrooms always smell so good! What are you guys cooking in there?! Yum! Pizza's not bad either!

Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza really good. The Chicken Wings pizza not so much. Clean restaurant. Great service.

Good pizza for a 'chain' restaurant. Can't beat Mon-Tues Large cheese special .

Good pizza with varied toppings. Grilled wings are great.

Great chicken wings. We got them extra crispy with a side of hot sauce.

The staff is great & there's always a great selection of pizza ready

Food was great but staff were yelling and swearing at eachother... super cringe. Do take out instead I guess 🤷

I never cared for the pizza, the grilled wings are the best anywhere however. A bit pricey for wings and they did away with the Wednesday promotions for half price wings. They deliver very fast and food is always fresh.

A semi thumbs up and worth a stop if in the area and having pizza hungries. Very clean and easy access. Having tried an OIP further south and giving it 5 stars we wanted to try an OIP closer to us. This OIP had ok wings but they were small. The pizza was the same toppings we had at that first OIP, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOMS, AND PEPPERONI, WITH EXTRA SAUCE, and while ok it was not as good as the OIP we stopped at before and why only 4 stars.

Great pizza, really hit the spot since I’d been missing real New York style, and it’s nice to see the real thing upstate. The cheesesteak was a decent sandwich but wasn’t really what I’d consider a cheesesteak

I love how they put the chicken from the char grilled wings on there chicken pizzas. Far better then other pizza joints that do frozen tenders on them.

Workers were fairly nice but the food did come out a little slow. Worth it though because it's fantastic food and I could have just hit it at a bad time. Work trying I recommend it fully.

Quick turnaround, right near the laundromat in the village of Liverpool. Fast service, friendly folks, all around decent pizza. OH! GARLIC KNOTS ARE A MUST TRY!!

Pizza slices were awesome. The Philly cheese slice was very solid crust. It was a bit better than the everything slice. Wings were good, but the mango haven't had no kick to it, just sweet.

The past 2 Fridays I ordered chargrilled wings and both times received fried wings. They were still good but I can get fried wings anywhere I come here for the chargrilled. @$!# happens which is why 4 stars and not less. More attention to detail please

They were accommodating with the seating. Char wings were tasty. Pizza a little sloppy to eat. Hot sauce could be hotter or offer a really 🔥 choice with a warning.

Pizza is basic New York style. Char grilled wings are my favorite style. Some folks hate them. To each their own. Service was fast and friendly. Exactly what I wanted!

I tried their margherita pizza, and it was simple yet delicious—the fresh mozzarella was creamy, the tomato sauce tangy, and the basil added a nice touch of freshness. The service was quick and the staff was friendly. The atmosphere was casual and cozy, perfect for a laid-back pizza night. If you’re looking for a satisfying and authentic Italian pizza, this place is definitely worth checking out.

Carrie Luther

I ordered delivery at 940pm and received my order by 1010pm! Best and possibly only option for late night delivery! Medium sausage pizza with 10 wings came to $35.08 with tax and delivery fee. I love the Mango Habanero wings Buffalo style! They are saucy sweet and packed with heat! They also offer chargrilled wings. OIP for the late night order again! Fast and friendly service as always’ I called OIP on a Saturday evening just before 8pm and luckily they were still taking orders and delivering, my go to take out had closed their kitchen. I ordered a large pizza with 20 wings for $30.99. I added double sausage and split the wing order which upped the price to $56 and change. Wow that was some expensive sausage! The wings were split order of garlic parm and habanero mango. Delivery time was 45 minutes, received delivery in about twenty minutes! Fast, friendly, delivery. With tip I spent $65. Everything was hot the pizza was good, though a portion of it had maybe slid in the box. Habanero mango wings were hot and tangy super saucy and delish. The garlic parm wings were charred badly lacking sauce, and flavor. They were incredibly hard and crunchy. Despite the ten wings that were charred to chicken heaven, the availability and quick delivery was still a win for my guests and myself.

+2

Stephen Swahn

Pizza was good, simmaler to Cams. Got a slice, cheese and sauce were excellent. I thought the dough could use some work the crust was tough.

Good isn't bad, but I asked for their spiciest wings they had... I'd give them 1/10 on spiciness.

Pizza and service are good. Size if pies not so good. Small pie is basically for one person.

Decent pizza. But the garlic knots could have been more buttery.

While their food- especially their wings- have always been a huge hit in my family, OIP has recently made some changes that insure I will NEVER be ordering from their again. Not only have they raised their prices tremendously, but they have also skipped out on their typcial quality. Their pizza and wings are now smaller, the pizza tastes much cheaper, and my chargrilled wings that were once a family favorite were burnt. If I had written this review a few months ago, I would have selected excellent in each section. However, I am currently VERY disappointed in OIP and will surely never order from there again.

Ordered from OIP because our usual place was closed. It has been a while since we had ordered from there. Pizza was just ok. Probably will stick with our usual place and time pizza nights to when they are open.

Tom D

If looking for a cheese pizza I definitely recommend, but if you want toppings, I would go somewhere else. The price for adding toppings is crazy.

Gabby Ross

The guy who makes the pizzas is wonderful this review reflects the girl who makes pizzas on occasion the pizza is always overly sauced and almost burnt I will take my business to Mattydale for a guaranteed good product

Melissa Duprey

The pizza and garlic knots were mid at best. The cashier was really helpful and sweet/friendly.

Nancy L

Ordered a slice and a tossed salad. Friend ordered a cheese steak. The salad and slice came out immediately. Waited 25 minutes for the cheese steak. Had to ask for it. It had been wrapped up to go. Rolls were different than we had the last time and the steak was not the quality it used to be. Girl at the counter thought it was very funny that it had been mistakenly packaged to go. We did not! Probably will not return.

Chris G

A couple weeks ago I ordered a buffalo chicken wing calzone and it was way too salty for some reason and I couldn't even finish it. I've ordered from here multiple times and overall the food is decent but recently you guys have been mixing ranch in with the blue cheese. It is disgusting. If I order a side of blue cheese I expect to get blue cheese. So please stop mixing blue cheese with ranch. Thank you.

Got too slices of buffalo chicken wing pizza to go . Chicken was so dried out and tough I couldn't chew it . Crust was crunchy though . lol

Wings have been good but more times than not the chicken wing are either over cooked with not enough sauce or 1 step away from being raw eat here with caution

Fantastic NY style pizza. The issue is the terrible service at the Liverpool location. I went there twice within a week and the young team that works there could care less about the restaurant customers. The second time I was there I wasn't even greeted or acknowledged. I had time to wash my hands in their bathroom and it still took them a while to acknowledge me, when I came back. There were no customers in the restaurant at the time of this poor service.

I hadn't had wings in awhile so decided to go to OIP as I have often done before! Got a half order of Medium Grilled and a half order of Garlic Parmesan. The wings were just awful...extremely dry and extremely small. I ate 2 of each and could not eat anymore! I did order a cold ham sub which I will say was very good!

I just had the dryest wings I ever got from OIP and they put my large pizza into a medium box so the pizza was folded over and there was grease everywhere. I had to put something on my carseat so it didn't leak through..Disappointing this time.

Grabbed 2 slices of pizza out of the box. I noticed one had a hair on it so I went to pull it off. Turns out the hair was baked into the pizza, like under the cheese, and stretched into the other piece I had taken out of the box. Ended up having to toss 2 pieces in the garage. Sad I only got to eat 75% of the pizza I paid for because someone wasn't wearing a hair net.

I placed an order online 9:30 in the morning for a 150 pick up get there and still had to wait 15 minutes before it was ready and the servers were so rude about the order I think if you’re going to order online online it should be ready on time

Left expensive remote start car keys on the counter when I walked away from picking up my take out. When I went back they said they never saw them and were gone. I won't be going back ever due to the lieing staff.

There is nothing Original about the pizza here. It is mediocre at best. The cheese is oily, sauce is tasteless and the dough would be best used for the sole of a boot. Oh and the delivery service sucks.

Sad excuse for chargrilled wings they were rubbery and no flavor

Horrible not sure what's up but I drove about 10 miles cause they're suppose to be open, even have updated Corona hrs and light up signs saying open, I think the crew just up and left...

Had the worse experience. Called in my order 45 min before I had to go on my lunch break. I told the person who took my order that I wanted boneless wing medium not char. I go in to pay and she has't put in my order and it took 25mins and it the boneless was char and it didn't taste great char. Very disappointed that they got my order wrong and I couldn't even finish them because it taste weird char. Never going back there. Not going to recommend this place at all quality has dropped not what it used to be when it open.

My husband and I ordered a jumbo order of char grilled garlic parm wings and when we got home they were not char grilled. My husband called and told them and they didn't even care. Probably won't go back again.

The staff was unfriendly. The pizza was way over priced and it was not what good. The wings sucked. IDK what all the hype is. Oh this is the Syracuse area people have no clue how to make pizza or wings.

Stood at the counter being ignored for 5 minutes. Also, no slices available? What kinda pizza shop has no slices available? Save yourself the disservice and skip this place.

I used to really like this restaurant, but the last few visits have been really bad and I will not be returning. I have it 2nd chance and then a 3rd chance hoping for the same quality but it was not there. Today was the last chance when I received another pizza that had a few slices that were terrible and hard. Char grilled chicken wings were uncooked.

Ordered a pizza online yesterday at 3:15pm to be picked up at 5:00pm. Arrived only to find out my order had not been prepared yet! The girl blamed it on the "morning" crew!! I am not sure what that actually means. The place was not even close to being busy! After a 25 minute wait...the pizza was done. As I walked out....the girl who claimed to be the manager told me to grab a soda from the cooler...no thanks!!

Thought we'd give it another shot after bad quality food, wrong choice. Chicken wings still had feathers on them! Those that didn't were way too dry and crunchy. Calzone was simply dripping grease... Don't bother, quality was good 5 years ago but it's trash now. Addition: An HR after eating I became very sick and 12 hrs later I still have a horrible morning because of it. Never again.

Pulled up to do laundry next door. Went in at 8:45. They close at 9:00 but I was told I could order fryer items only as they had already turned the oven off. I was going to order 2 large specialty pizzas and a cheesesteak but instead I went across the road and got $50 worth of BBQ.

Super Bowl wings way over cooked and tasted hard now my stomach hurts it’s not just now it’s the pizza thier is not good all other oip are finominal it’s just this one . I d k why it’s just not good ..

Mike Whitney

1 star just for the same girl cashier. Always in a bad mood. Not very friendly.

c s

Horrible customer service ! Don’t eat pork or beef ordered a chicken sandwich was sent a steak sandwich with a freezing cold slice of pizza was told i have to get store credit instead of a refund the delivery driver told me my total was more then what my receipt says i will never order from here again !! Sound like a bunch of kids working