Jennifer Patti

We’re new to the area and John’s was recommended to us. Food is great and the employees are very friendly. We’ve probably have ate their food 5 different times at this point and it was delicious every time.

Natasha Hughes

Delicious alternative style pizzas. Mac and cheese topped with BBQ brisket on a pizza, what?! Pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey. It is amazing. Crust has a nice crisp in the bottom. Thank you for a great slice!

Jason N

Always thought this place was mediocre, but the last 2 pizzas this summer were awesome! Not sure if it's a new pizza person, new owners, or new recipe l, but they definitely changed something for the better! Pricing is a bit high but definitely worth it in Milford. Thanks for the solid pizza!

Raul Martinez Jr.

During a recent visit to John’s of Arthur Ave. in Milford, PA, my family and I enjoyed a truly memorable meal rooted in authentic Bronx-style Italian cooking. The welcoming atmosphere made it an ideal place for a relaxed family outing, and the food lived up to its reputation. We started with the Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce, which was a hit—simple, fresh, and classic. The pasta was perfectly cooked and generously coated in a house-made tomato sauce, sprinkled with just the right amount of cheese and herbs. One of the highlights was the Eggplant Parm Hero. It came out hot and hearty, with thick-cut eggplant fried to perfection, layered with rich marinara and creamy mozzarella on a fresh Italian roll. A must-try, especially if you love traditional Italian sandwiches. To finish, we shared a Cannoli for dessert. It was everything a good cannoli should be—crispy shell, sweet ricotta filling, chocolate chips, and a dusting of powdered sugar. Light yet satisfying. The service was friendly and attentive, and the portions were generous enough to please everyone at the table. From the warm hospitality to the quality of the dishes, John’s of Arthur Ave gave my family a dining experience we won’t soon forget. If you're looking for authentic Italian food in a family-friendly setting, John’s of Arthur Ave is a gem. Great for locals, travelers, and anyone craving real-deal Italian flavors.

Anna Rose

I’ve tried all the other Pizza/ Italian spots in Milford and haven’t been in a few years and noticed this place opened. Great spot. Had their Detroit style pizza. I was expecting the dough to be thick but wow it was airy and crispy, it was very good. Got my Dad a Grandma slice and he said it was very delicious as well. Tried their garlic knots, also was expecting the dough to be dense but it was light and chewy and there was good garlic and parm flavor in every bite. We sat outside on the patio, seats are very comfy and there’s shade so you aren’t burning up in the sun.

Sylvia Moya

Finally, a place that feels like I'm having BX pizza. They do seem to be understaffed. Maybe calling ahead of time before stopping by! Tuesday afternoon seemed super crowded, and I waited about 45min for my order. Other than this, the staff is friendly, and they seem to try very hard to get everyone's food out. Check them out and try the Graffity pizza.

King Cool

Everything here is phenomenal. The place has consistent traffic in and out, and it's because their food and friendly service is out of this world. The menu is super extensive, so you'll need to return here often if you want to try several different options. Pictured here is the "Hot Combo" of their Pasta Shop. "Hot Combo" is: 👉Baked manicotti, eggplant rollatini, meatballs, tomato sauce & fresh mozzarella. The different pizzas and subs are exceptional, but don't forget about everything else they offer, as well. Five stars, and BUON APPETITO!!! 🇮🇹 😋🍝🥖🍕

Lilia K

So good and so many original flavors to choose from. The lady behind the counter was very kind and patient while we decided what to get. Definitely recommend the graffiti pizza, was a fan favorite in my party.

Jake Lamb

The best Calzone and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had!! So cheesy and soft and perfect flavor combos. The place had a great aesthetic and super friendly staff as well! My only complaint is how hot it was in the restaurant due to the ovens- making it an ideal takeout/delivery place but not good for sit-in in hot weather. Probably fine in the winter though! Was the perfect road trip rest stop- will be making coming through Milford to stop here a travel priority in the future when possible.

Jenn Y

I want to say a huge Thank You to Colin the owner!!!! You and your staff are amazing!!! We were in Milford again for work from Wisconsin. The staff provide the best customer service so I will always come here to eat!! The pizzas are pure artwork and I highly recommend a slice of the Motown Detroit pizza. I also love the ‘salad’ bowls!!! It does not disappoint! Again, love this place and thanks!!! 💕💕💕