Picked up dinner for a family of 3 for under 20 .00 great deal. Love there food

The bathroom was clean the food was amazing and the service was great.

1st time here. Wow. That's good pizza!

Delicious pizza and wings, and the service was excellent!

Good pizza, friendly staff, great atmosphere, and caring about the community.

Garlic pizza and 5 cheese pizza was excellent!

Such great people and hard workers their food is great and so is their service I would recommend them

Hands down one of the best pizzas I've ever had.

Great pizza, huge slices at very reasonable prices

I just had a buffalo chicken wrap and it was perfect. Will definitely go back for another.

Love this place- they are heavy handed on the extra toppings for your pizza which is great. I love the Greek pizza! Consistently cooked food so far. :)

Always delicious, had to try the big Mac pizza. Love the inivative minds and I have to tell you I've tried pizzas from all over ny and this place nailed the big Mac pizza.

Outstanding pizza and garlic knots stop by after visiting my mother in law in nursing home great food great price Outstanding service would give this 10 stars if was available very impressive will be back many more times.

Best pizza and garlic knots around! Excellent prices! Pair it with the Hillcrest chocolate milk from the fridge and you have the perfect meal!

A lot of places say NY style pizza, but this spot is the real deal. The pepperoni slice was just like what I get in the city. Moravia, NY, who knew? Thanks to the nice pizza lady!

Couldn’t be happier with the pizza and garlic knot! Just like some of the best pizza I’ve had in Manhattan! Don’t sleep on this place!

Large, fresh, delicious slices of pizza. Great service. Clean facilities. What else can you ask for? The place was packed for lunch with locals.

Great food, nice atmosphere, very friendly staff!

Amazing food!! Fast service and excellent staff!! Been going there for years and they're incredible overall service plus great food make a prefect night out!

Love their pizza and wings. My GF loves their antipasto salads. Gotta be the best slices available. Big, crunchy, mmmm

One of the best slices of pizza I've ever had!!! Great and friendly staff!

Their pizza is delicious. There are a lot of toppings. They don't skimp on the toppings. I highly recommend this place.

Amazing pizza wonderful staff. I grew up spending my summers in NYC and this brings back such fond memories!

Always is great food, never can go wrong with NY as a food choice if you dont want to leave town

Great service, short wait times for a whole pizza (~20min) even on Friday nights, friendly folks, good pizza.

Amazing food and service will drive out of the way for their food every time! The garlic parmesan wings are amazing

The pizza is so good and the slices are huge. Great selection! The workers are very nice. We stop every time we pass through Moravia.

I lived in Moravia when the place was just getting started and Sal and his family were wonderful. I weorked around the corner at UPSCO and would eat there at least once a week.

Excellent quality pizza. Very friendly owner and staff. The crust is brushed with a delicious garlic butter, so it can be a bit messy. Small price to pay, for a fantastic slice.

They are amazing I love going here anytime I want pizza or wings or chicken tenders there food is amazing

If you've never tried the Calzones or Stromboli you're really missing out. As others have said, great slice selection when you want to walk in for a quick bite. Friendly hometown staff and the owner cares about a quality product, a real upstate gem.

The Pizza's are the best in town and beyond! It's the only pizza I can eat ,others bother my stomach. It always fresh and the perfect ratio of ingredients, and they use the best cheese's ever. Very high quality and worth every penny!

Slices were excellent. Calzone and stromboli were very good. Garlic knots were larger than I expected but delicious. Will be coming back to try more slices! Friendly staff!

Excellent service and the food was AMAZING.

These guys are great!!!! Went in yesterday and had their sicilian pie. It was wonderful! But then.....................they brought out a BLT pizza! We tried that and I have to say it was nothing short of INCREDIBLE!!!!!! I highly recommend this place and HIGHLY recommend the BLT pizza!!!!!

I fish in the Moravia area April-Dec. This is my go to spot for after im done. Excellent pizza and its great that they have a large selection of single slice choices. Friendly atmosphere and the pizza makers very friendly too.

Slices are Amazingly Huge & delicious! Place is cozy and clean. Garlic knots are delightful. 3 giant slices, a huge garlic knot with sauce and two bottles of soda for thirteen dollars. Hidden treasure 💜

My husband and I are pizza snobs and we are both in love with this place! We eat there multiple times per week. The homemade desserts are also fantastic.

Best pizza for miles an miles. Always great pizza, subs and they always make something different all the time. Love this place. Owners and staff are awesome.

Always excellent service here. We have another pizzeria in town which i refuse to visit due to terrible food and unsatisfactory service!! I've been a customer of NY Pizzeria since I was in high school and to this day love their food. Highly recommended!!

What a great pizza place in a sleepy little town. We've come here for several years after visiting Filmore Glen and the pizza has always been delicious and the service excellent.

The original New York Pizza in Moravia is a excellent place for pizza. If you are a local camper staying at the beautiful fillmore glen state park this pizza shop is a must try. Massy and his family make true Italian pizza made from the heart as well as a veriety of other awesome foods.

Great pizza and wings! The staff was very friendly and they have a nice clean dining area. Thanks!

I placed an online order with a note asking if the Bleu cheese dressing was pasteurized. When I got there, the woman showed me each part of my order and had a picture ready on her phone to show me the ingredients of the Bleu cheese. The pizza, garlic knots, and wings were all delicious and the attention to detail and customer service was wonderful!!

This place has always been and will always be my favorite place to get pizza wings or subs from since I was about 12 years old. From sal to Vinny to the owners now the quality has stayed the same! Any time Im anywhere near Mpravia i have to make a stop in NY Pizzeria for the best BEST pizza possibly in the USA. The place down the street ain't far behind but still won't ever touch the pizza from here! Nice work over 25years I've been in and out of this shop.

When i went to New York pizzeria the stuff was really nice and friendly and they will give you a family like feeling. The pizzas are refreshing and Italian, with extra toppings and a thick crust. The subs are very good no complains and they also have specials that are only on Tuesdays that are the best, going from Italian goodnesses to a variety of stuff. I’ll for sure go again.

The hype is real! This pizza is amazing!!! Easily some of the best in Central NY. I'm from NJ and am very particular about pizza but this is up to par with some of the best I've had. First time customer ready to become a lifetime customer. Also the staff was SO NICE and sweet. Thank you!!!

No nonsense good pizza! The real gem here is that slices are $2 +50¢ per topping and they are huge, 2 slices almost didn't fit into the to go box they have. The pizza itself is the thin floppy New York style pizza you would expect with a perfect sauce to cheese ratio and everything tasted amazing.

Always a great selection of slices at a really affordable price but the garlic knots are the surprise (no longer) deal with 5 large knots for $3. This spot is always busy and the service is fast and friendly with more than just pizza!

Great selection of pizza and wings made to order (correctly). Also some of the best sandwiches in the area made with fresh bread and meats.

Sicilian pizza was delivered. Monia is so welcoming.

David Paniagua

The crust of this pizza is just fantastic, it's crunchy, and soft inside. This place is a top recommendation!

Angelo Garcia

I came all the way from Toronto Canada in order to be able to taste the amazing food of this place!!! Lots to choose from and prices are modest. I did enjoy the Stromboli and the pizza!!!

+7

Dale

Delicious food! Great Hot Pizza and Garlic Knots! Great Service!

Jonathan Stephenson

Love the food, staff were great what's not to love, centrel New York pizza at its best

Dwight M

Very good pepperoni pizza! Hard working family run pizzaria. I was traveling through town and was very pleased with this restaurant. It's worth a visit!

Buzz Vincent

One issue, they are in Moravia and my home is in Sennett and only there during daysM-F. Absolutely best pizza in the area Really does taste like NYC pizza.

Brittany Anne

I'm particular about my pizza and this was the best I've had in months!! I'm from long Island and this it like long Island and NYC Pizza!! Service was friendly and attentive. Tables were clean, as was the bathroom. I wish I lived closer!! It would be my go to pizza place for sure! Lots of friendly smiling customers, lots of options too!

Donnie

Absolutely amazing pizza! I'd have to say it's some of the best pizza I've ever had! It's also very reasonably priced. I've had their chicken bacon ranch pizza twice and it is so good! The building is clean and the employees are very friendly.

M Mason

I ordered an eggplant Parm and an Italian sub today. Both were excellent. The best subs we've had in a long time. We ran a deli, sub shop for over 20 years and know a good product.

Ockenblock77

Delicious pizza!! Loved the crust. Wings were excellent. We also had the antipasto salad, which had generous portions of meat and cheese, delicious!! Ordered everything through their website and it was ready for pickup on my way home from work.

Peggi Wiiki

Ordered take out on Friday. Large Supreme Pizza, and an order each of naked chicken wings and an order of boneless chicken. It all was delicious but that pizza was the best ever! I was very impressed and will spread the word!!

Cindy LeFever

New York Pizza in Moravia has best pizza and subs around, probably because the owners are from Italy. They happily make everything made to order. My friends will drive to Moravia for this pizza. My favorite is their thin crispy crust pepperoni with their delicious pizza sauce. Their subs are also amazing; toasted fresh sub rolls loaded with fresh deli meats and cheese. We eat-in with food delivered to our table or order-out at least once a week. My school-age grandchildren love the chicken tenders and fries.

Patrick

Some of the best pizza for the price and the size is huge! Only one or two specialties are not the best but still amazing, and garlic knots are amazing too! The people that work there are lovely and friendly to the point they are like family. And the atmosphere looks like a top pizzeria, very clean.

Michael “Floyd”

Excellent food with indoor/outdoor dining. Spacious banquet room. Outdoor band entertainment with ample room both on shore and off shore viewing. Drop an anchor and enjoy.

+4

Jeremy Lloyd

I drove about 90 minutes to try this place and holy heck is it ever some good legitimate pizza!! I got 5 slices and the variety, especially on a Sunday at noon, was huge. This place is a true gem and I will definitely be back! And yes, I at all 5 slices. I got to meet Massimo too and the young kid that was working the counter (wish I grabbed his name) was super friendly and did an excellent job!! Keep it up!!

Dean Griffith

A 6. This was absolutely the best pizza on the planet!! Uses Grande cheese, best sauce, best crust !!

+5

Place is very good and food is as good as the employees! Always seem very nice and accommodating

Picked food from the counter, came out hot. Prices were great food was good! Next time I am in Moravia I will stop in. 2 pizza rolls up and a drink $7.56

Good place. They don’t screw your order up like the other place in town usually does. Only downside at this place is their wings.

The sub was good-the right bread, amount of meat & cheese but I prefer finely shredded lettuce. There were no chips available which I found disappointing. Service was excellent and my sub was freshly prepared and I did not wait long.

The pizza was not the best but everyone expects something different out of a pizza. The service was 5-star and fast.

It was ok. Sub roll was hard.

I got a slice of pepperoni pizza and to my surprise there was a piece of metal in it, about half the length of my pinky finger but very sharp! I'm not sure exactly what it was from but I will not be going there again. Very dangerous.

I would have given this place 5 stars as this is the best place for wings and the prices are awesome. I didn't particularly care for the sheet pizza and I was pretty upset that the women answering the phone was so rude. Will definitely order from there again hopefully she was spoken too.

Pizza is ok, staff is rude. Go up the street to Giuseppe's Pizzeria instead.

The French fries are my son's favorite however the employees were rude And seemed put off because we called to place an order just for french fries. I also felt the attitude coming from the employee was rude and I'm glad my young son didn't go in to help pay and pick up his order.

French fries are great my son loves them. The employee we spoke to on the phone was rude and they were rude when we went to pick up our French fries and pay.

Ordered a slim crust, got it home before discovering. It was not done. Ugh.

Husband and I ordered subs,mine was a roast beef and that was good. My husband ordered a Philly cheese steak. It was in a hot dog roll with onions and one pepper, mostly cheese and very little meat. Worst sub ever! A few months later ordered a medium pizza and that was so thin and greasy the cheese was sliding off. Never plan on going back.

The pizza tastes absolutely delicious, but when I bought a couple slices the cashier was on a personal phone call rather than helping me, the pizza was cold when I got it, and I found hair all over it. Good tasting pizza can't make up for these problems

Gayle L

The place was super clean but all of the toppings seemed to be cheap. Cheese was rubbery, pepperoni was limp and flavorless. The veggies were good, but the way they prepped it made it so when i opened the box there was a puddle of water in the middle of the pie.

We ordered pizza for dinner and it was the worst pizza ever!!! If I could I’d give it 0 stars.

Ordered a mac and cheese pizza and a calazon took 2 hours for delivery food was cold never again pizza had no flavor very bland

Husband and I ordered a large and small cold sub, 2 slices and 2 cans of pop. $25.26! My sub had a long black hair through the whole thing. Never going back!

Ordered pizza and boneless wings today, 11-24-21. Used to be good place for pizza and wings, not anymore 🙄

Rubber pizza today. And not so friendly. I dont ever leave bad reviews but its disappointing when you work hard for your money and get RUBBER PIZZA!

Lisa Teeter

We ordered 2 small pizzas and a meatball sub. The pizza was cold and not cut through. The "large" meatball sub was all bread and cheese with 3 small meatballs and sauce in between. Very disappointing for the price they charge.

Donna Hatch

Accidently ordered over the phone from them instead of the other moravia pizza place. The pizza was burnt on the bottom pretty badly and wasn't that great. However their wings were pretty good

Scott Leonard

Ridiculous you don't know how to make a canzone. It was thinner than the pizza my parents received.