Karsen Yeung

Great atmosphere. Mr Mauel had been really friendly and helpful. His advice on the food and wine pairing are perfect. It was the best meal of my New York trip, definitely worth coming back again!

Bill Barnett

Manuel and his team took great care of us. We had a group of 12 and the food and the service was excellent. It was a little warm in the room but overall very good!

Melissa Brewer

Manuel is the best! He made us feel special during our lunch visit. He and his team checked on us regularly and our meals were perfect! Order your own and DON’T share!!! 🤣

Jessica Monge

Great service from the very beginning. Food was excellent, but my favorite part was dessert! Apple crumble and tiramisu. I think our server was the bartender and he was amazing! There was a wonderful woman (server) walking around making sure we were also doing well. Super sweet!

Níamh Mc Ardle

We had a lovely meal tonight. Rib Eye steak was huge and the sirloin. The sautéed brocolli was amazing. For us the price was reasonable for NYC. Would recommended.

Pawel

Benny Johns exceeded expectations. The pasta was perfectly prepared and full of flavor, while the bottle of wine was both outstanding and priced very fairly. Service (Manuel) was warm, attentive, and created a truly pleasant atmosphere. A superb dining experience I look forward to repeating.

Neff Hudson

Exceptional service, incredible quality and consistency across the menu: steaks, seafood, pasta (including a killer Bolognese). Decent wines by the glass. Midtown location! What’s not to love!!

Maan AlTelmesani

I had a great experience at Benny John’s Bar and Grill! The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and the place is spotless. The service was top-notch – friendly and attentive staff who make you feel right at home. The food was absolutely delicious. Their steak and grilled meats are cooked to perfection and packed with flavor. But the standout dish for me was the Cacio e Pepe spaghetti with grilled shrimp – it’s a must-try! To top it all off, the owner is a genuinely kind and respectful person who personally makes sure guests are satisfied. A wonderful spot that I’ll definitely be visiting again!

Dwayne Blackwell

Excellent service at Benny John's!!! Just take my word for it and get the LUMP CRABMEAT COCKTAIL!!!! And ask for some melted butter and go to TOWN! The CAPRESE with fresh mozzarella & tomatoes & homemade pesto was so refreshing. Perfectly grilled shrimp on the for the lunch salad! And that NEW YORK STEAK SANDWICH medium prime NY sirloin, mozzarella cheese, peppers, onions, potatoes, on a disco romana bread was AMAZING!! 😋😱🥰 HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

+15

Martha Ward

Excellent experience @ Benny John’s. Food was excellent! We started with a Steak Tartare and the Tropical Salad and both were delish. Our entrees were the Filet Mignon and Ribeye. They were cooked to perfection and excellent sized portions for the price. We ended the meal with the Carrot Cake and combo of the Mango & Raspberry Sorbet with coffee. Our server Shereen topped everything by being amazing our entire evening. She was the sweetest and even sang “Happy Birthday” to me. We shared a few laughs and even took a pic to commemorate the evening.

+3

Andreas Mouyiannides

The best restaurant i had the pleasure of going to in NY. Huge steaks, cooked to perfection, innovative cocktails and delicious pasta. The staff is welcoming, professional and attentive. The price you pay totally reflects what you get.

ken EDGY

We had the best post-birthday brunch here! Shereen took the best care of us, and we had the best amaretto shots at the end 🩷 The lobster bisque was delicious and the sour dough bread complimented it perfectly~ The steaks were both phenomenal as well! We’ll be back whenever we’re in NY again!

Josh O'Berski

From the outside this place looks a bit like a dive bar but the inside is nicer than you would think, but not pretentious, so dressing up isn’t required. The food is delicious. We had the tuna tartar and the calamari for apps, and it was the best calamari I have ever had. Not rubbery, not too chewy, just perfectly breaded and cooked. I had a steak for dinner and ordered it rare, and it was cooked perfectly. The drinks were delicious but leaned smaller, but I still left with a nice buzz so they weren’t skimping on the alcohol. I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone looking for a lower pressure, high quality steak house.

We went to Benny John’s for a nightcap since it was close to our hotel and advertised all day happy hour. The happy hour drink selection is somewhat limited, but they still offer a good variety at a great price. I had the sauvignon blanc & my wife had the sangria. The sauvignon blanc was as expected & sangria was a dry sangria & not overly sweet. I had the apple cobbler for dessert which is really the reason for my review — and it was delicious. It was served warm and paired with vanilla ice cream. The staff was pleasant. Overall, a great spot for a casual nightcap and dessert.

Robert Ambriano

Good spot, but not sure about all the hype We stumbled into Benny John’s after spending the day in the Diamond District, and overall it was a solid experience — definitely worth trying, but a few things didn’t fully match the hype. We split the porterhouse between three people, and for $120 it was honestly a great value. The steak was cooked well and tasted great, but I’ve definitely had better porterhouse at higher-end steakhouses (not naming names). Still, for the price, no complaints at all. Appetizers were the biggest letdown. For three people, the portions were extremely small — definitely not shareable, which was surprising. The bread didn’t come with anything special, so I skipped that and went straight to the apps. The drinks were a big highlight — they took a little bit of time to come out, but once they did, they were absolutely phenomenal. Really well made and definitely top-tier quality. Dessert was another strong point. The tiramisu was phenomenal — perfect portion, great flavor, and prepared really well. The Key Lime pie, on the other hand, was tiny and not really worth it. Overall, it’s a nice place with some standout items, but expect smaller portions.

+2

Stefan C

Lovely services. Orlando was the best servant. Seafood is really fresh and the cheesecakes and carrot cakes are excellent. Just a little thing, our steak should be medium-rare but was overcooked probably because the large portion we ordered. But beautiful atmosphere and services.

Miracle Reason

Great customer service, okay food. Good specials. Oyster rockerfeller - 3/5 temp was cool.. oysters were so small, it was mostly creamed spinach. Chicken skewer - 5/5- juicy flavorful and onions are a good compliment Beef skewer -3.5/5 cooked well, not as well seasoned. Bolognese - 3/5 Carbonara- 3/5 Caesar salad 2/5 Mixed green salad 4/5 Ribeye- cooked well and offered to be cut from the bone. Underseasoned. Carrot cake 4/5 Complimentary dessert (the name is slipping my mind) - 3/5

+6