장가희

The pizza and the spaghetti with meatballs were really good. The spaghetti and meatballs come with a free extra, and the meatballs were especially delicious. The sauce was great, and I’d recommend the Margherita pizza. The brownie was good, and they have lots of other desserts. Overall, it’s a great value!!

Angelica Carrasco

Best pizza I’ve ever had. No question. If you want the best pizza don’t waste your time anywhere else. La Pizza Italia is a name I’ll remember when I come back to NY.

Michael Gordon

My first NYC pizza experience and it was truly amazing. I got cheese, burrata and square vodka pepperoni slices and all were absolutely delicious! My wife ordered the chicken parm and had to wait 20 minutes and it was well worth the wait because it was made fresh! Due to the wait they gave us a free drink and some garlic knots! The food and service was 10/10 and we highly recommend!!

W X

Pizza is delicious with a variety of toppings. They have a Gluten free pizza which cannot be ordered by the slice—it is delicious!!!! Not a sit down restaurant but perfect if you are just looking to take a bite and continue with your day.

The legendary Lobid

East or west this La Pizza place on 2nd ave Is the best. Their meatball spaghetti 🍝 is just amazing as their pizzas are

Antonio Altamirano

La Pizza Italia hits that rare Midtown East note: zero pretension, all flavor. You walk in expecting a quick slice and end up staring at the counter like someone handed you a memory from Naples. The dough has that honest chew — not the Instagram fold, the street-level one — and the sauce tastes like somebody’s uncle actually cared. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why New York still wins the simple things. No theatrics, no “elevated” nonsense. Just heat, tomato, cheese, and the confidence to let it be what it is. A slice joint built for people who’ve lived enough life to know when something’s real.

Angela Ford

As a tourist, I loved this experience. I got the best service and what must be a traditional New York experience! I'll always love my Chicago pizza better, but this pizza is FANTASTIC!

Michael Polec

Straight to the point. Good Ingredients Great Service. Some Room To Seat. Slices Heated to Perfection. Right Smells & Respectable Prices. 💯

+2

Tyii Jones

Stopped By LA Pizza While Visiting NYC & It Was Not A Disappointment. There Was So Many Pizza Options To Choose From. Slices Were Big & Still Warm, Very Thin & Delicious. I Recommend Dining It Because There’s A Nice View Of The Hustle & Bustle City While You Eat!

Christopher Lau

Loved the pizza! Did a midnight run with my son and he loved it too! Can’t wait to come back! 🍕

Kiersten S.

Delicious pizza! Cant go wrong with any of the flavors. The rainbow pizza was amazing, but really every slice we got was delicious. Would definitely recommend!

Laugh and Live Paxtons

Such nice guys! We love the deep dish with the hot honey! That dessert! 😋🤤 We got our food quickly. We loved having a place to sit and eat. It’s hard to find that in the area. We’ll be back!

Emily Christine

I had such a great, quick, and easy experience here at La Pizza Italia located on E 51st Street and 2nd Ave! The service is great here. Everyone is fast and friendly (just how we like it in New York City). And huge shoutout to Rafael for letting me know about the BOGO FREE pasta deal they have!! Such a steal and so worth the money! I got a burrata basil pizza slice and the BOGO vodka pasta deal all for ~$23. Solid food for great prices. Definitely take advantage of this deal while it lasts. Thank you Rafael and La Pizza Italia! I will be back!

+2

Lita

This is our first trip back to NYC in a while, and pizza was our first lunch option. La Pizza Italia did not disappoint! The crust was textbook perfect, ample toppings, and just enough cheese and olive oil to balance out every bite. The staff were super-friendly, and the constant foot traffic was a testament to this location's popularity. Excellent pizza!!! 🍕

Great late night pizza! Stayed at a hotel down the street perfect service and amazing food. Very quick.

Great late night pizza! Stayed at a hotel down the street perfect service and amazing food. Very quick.

Great late night pizza! Stayed at a hotel down the street perfect service and amazing food. Very quick.

Great late night pizza! Stayed at a hotel down the street perfect service and amazing food. Very quick.

Amazing food, and customer service. I would come again if I lived closer lol. Got the penne vodka and it was buy one get one free!

Amazing food, and customer service. I would come again if I lived closer lol. Got the penne vodka and it was buy one get one free!

Amazing food, and customer service. I would come again if I lived closer lol. Got the penne vodka and it was buy one get one free!

Amazing food, and customer service. I would come again if I lived closer lol. Got the penne vodka and it was buy one get one free!

Best pizza in Midtown East hands down. Do yourself a favor and grab a slice of the pepperoni burrata when you're in the area. Staff is amazing and Raphael is the greatest person in the entire world.

Best pizza in Midtown East hands down. Do yourself a favor and grab a slice of the pepperoni burrata when you're in the area. Staff is amazing and Raphael is the greatest person in the entire world.

Best pizza in Midtown East hands down. Do yourself a favor and grab a slice of the pepperoni burrata when you're in the area. staff is amazing and Raphael is the greatest person in the entire world.

Great pizza with great owners. Extremely kind. Get the vodka pizza and burrata. Will be back

The food was so good! Would definitely recommend the vodka pizza. Service was quick and ambiance was a quick one stop.

The food was so good! Would definitely recommend the vodka pizza. Service was quick and ambiance was a quick one stop.

Food was awesome and service was great! music kinda loud but not in a bad way. Would absolutely come again! I had the white with garlic pizza

Great pasta . I was surprised by their creamy vodka pasta. Their pizza is really good too and at a great price.

the pizza and rolls and nice vibe and the music is great, the location was also amzing

Dudes working here are hella chill and super friendly. The pizza is delicious AND they're open late asf. Korean Fried Wings are a must and well worth the price with a selection of flavors, my favor…

I looove the pizza here! You can't go wrong with the burrata or margherita. The red sauce is savory and incredible (I try to choose which of the two pizza slices ^ based on how much red sauce I see…

Best pizza I’ve ever eaten - thin crust that was light and tender but deliciously crispy on the edges. I had the burrata and basil slice (the thin one not the square slice) and it was amazing. Genero…

Best pizza I’ve ever eaten - thin crust that was light and tender but deliciously crispy on the edges. I had the burrata and basil slice (the thin one not the square slice) and it was amazing. Gene…

We loved this place, so went back a second time. Crispy crust… heated up nicely, great varieties to choose from. We didn’t try pasta dishes. Service was outstanding. Very friendly and fast.

We loved this place, so went back a second time. Crispy crust… heated up nicely, great varieties to choose from. We didn’t try pasta dishes. Service was outstanding. Very friendly and fast.

We loved this place, so went back a second time. Crispy crust… heated up nicely, great varieties to choose from. We didn’t try pasta dishes. service was outstanding. Very friendly and fast.

Ordered two pizzas. Pizza crusts were spot on and tasty...overall some good pizzas. The sauce though. A previous review mentioned the sauce was sweet but that they probably don't add sugar to their tomato sauce. I would disagree with that assumption. Half way through the pizza ... The sweetness kinda took over for me. And that's just a personal preference maybe? Service was cold and not the friendliest. The set up itself was decent enough and clean... They had some latin music playing which was ok. I'm not sure I'd come back if I was in New York next. If you enjoy sweet pizza sauce you'll love this place because the crust was really good :) Just the sweetness of the sauce was not to my taste.

Moon Ciofalo

Pizza was amazing. Service was adequate. She kept forgetting items ordered and we had to keep clarifying what we wanted. It really wasn't complicated and writing it down would have been way easier for everyone. But the food was delicious once received. I wish all pizza tasted like this. Thin, crisp, and flavorful, with just the right amount of everything! Also, turn the music down just a tad. Had to yell across the table because the music was so loud.

Jimmy Lee

Since the slices were reheated, their crusts are not as good as those just come out of the oven. For whatever reason, the pizzas are kind of sugary. There are better shops.

Excellent pizza spot in midtown east. I ordered a margherita pie and it was fantastic. Will definitely return and try their other pizza next time. Service was quick and prices are reasonable.

Excellent pizza spot in midtown east. I ordered a margherita pie and it was fantastic. Will definitely return and try their other pizza next time. Service was quick and prices are reasonable.

I was disappointed by the over doughyness of the margherita slices, lacked taste as well. Super friendly staff and convenient location. Economic pricing.

I came here for dinner last night and ordered 3 slices of pie. My favorite was the "grandma's pizza " it was absolutely delicious and so were their garlic knots. I ordered a slice of their rainbow …

There is nothing terribly special about this new pizzeria. The slices are based on traditional pies and traditional flavors. Will we be back, no!

Maira Perez

I am visiting this city and looked to order pizza near by our hotel(Westgate). Chose this location for the close proximity and good reviews. Well, completely disappointed with their delivery and service. I placed the order at 10:58pm. Received text stating delivery would be between 11:15-11:20pm. At around 11:35pm I called for a status update. I was told " my delivery guy" was not there yet. I didn't use a delivery service, it was ordered through their delivery. At midnight, I called again and at this point requested a refund. This was not given as an option. The man on the phone apologized and said he would get another delivery service on it. I received a message stating delivery would be around 12:08am. My poor husband went to the lobby to wait. I fell asleep and next I'm woken up by my husband's call stating he is still waiting. It is nearly 1am. I call them again, the man again apologized, but did not accept my request for a refund. At this point, I'm no longer hungry, and definitely not for cold pizza. This ended up being delivered around 1:15 am. And yes, cold pizza and chicken wings were received. Super disappointed!