Ryan Crimmins

Perfect NYC Irish pub not far from MSG/Penn, but far enough to keep the tourists away. Really solid char broiled burger and friendly and attentive staff. You'll never have an empty glass here and when you're gone, you'll wish you were back. Cheers

c roy

Stopped by for lunch and everything was great. Mozzarella sticks very good. Bacon mac and cheese I could eat every day amazing. Staff very friendly would come back to.

+1

Virginia Riley

Great vibe! Friendly bartender, delicious brunch, and good prices.

Stephanie Bilicki

For being so deep in the city near Hudson Yards it was a great little bar. We went about 30 minutes before the kitchen closed and got amazing nachos. Highly recommend, it wasn't overly noisy or boisterous. You could talk with who you came with and have a couple.

Johnny Zawacki

We were looking for a quiet place to grab a decent beer and happened upon Maggie Reilly's. Maggie's Lager wasn't the best bet I ever had but it was perfect after a long day. The friendly bartenders were even better than the beer and the ambiance was comfortable and inviting. I'll return, if back in the area.

John Arehart

I have this habit of walking into the first pub, diner or restaurant that is closest to me when I get hungry and I am out exploring. That's what happened yesterday and the closest place was Maggie Reilly's. I got hungry and literally looked up and there it was. I'm so glad i stopped here! It was not crowded at all (but did start to fill up after I arrived). I sat at the end of the bar and ordered a diet coke and Maggie's House Burger (burger stuffed with finely chopped onion topped w/ cheese and bacon). The burger was HUGE and delicious, as was the bacon on top. You don't always get a good burger when you are picking random restaurants in the city... but this burger was GREAT. The steak fries were great, too (my favorite!). The bartender was very friendly (love that Irish accent) and he refilled my drink each time it got low. Great place, great food. So glad I stopped here while exploring the city. Prices were very reasonable too. The same exact meal in my town in Jersey would have been more expensive...

+1

Brette Grice

It all depends on what you’re looking for, but this place has a neighborly feeling. The owners daughter even bartends. My server Eimear had a beautiful Irish accent and she was friendly and efficient. I had a tuna melt with side salad. A little too much cheese on tip for my preference, and I would have liked the bread to be more toasted. I added pepper and enjoyed every bite. I had the cocktail that’s like an Arnold Palmer and it was good. I tried another that I liked but can’t remember the name of it now,, it was a vodka drink. I would go again. It’s an odd ball location but it’s near MSG so go before or after a game or concert! 👍🏽😁

CJL - G

Celebrating St. Patrick's Day, super friendly staffs, fresh and creamy Irish Guinness beer. We ordered fish and chips, which were good but a little oily and the portion of fish was too small. The fries are golden ratio in size and very delicious. We definitely will go back to try other meals!

+4

Marc

Pretty chill bar with good food and drinks. Burger was pretty solid and juicy. Staff and bartender were very friendly. Great hang out spot that was off the main path so wasn't too crowded.

The Bartender was a solid champion no doubt, but what I couldn't understand was how an Irish pub could produce such bad fish n chips and have such a poor selection of Irish whiskeys

Luka Vrljić

I saw Irish flag, I knew that they had some good beer. Coming inside, regular small nice pub, dark atmosphere with nice decorations. Sitting at the bar, I expected little bit more draft beers but they had Guinness so we got that one of course 😁 Food was ok, nothing special, I would say just like street food.