So fresh & inviting! We got the Love Boat for 2 and was so surprised by the quality and thick cuts of the fish. Give it a whirl

Food was very good - great spicy ramen broth, delicious steamed dumplings, and awesome presentation for all! 10/10

Connie was amazing. Food was great. I forget what we ordered but the photos say it all !

Absolutely fantastic experience! The sushi was fresh and beautifully presented. The staff was welcoming and attentive, creating a warm and comfortable atmosphere. The variety on the menu, including creative rolls and traditional favorites, was impressive. Highly recommend this spot for anyone craving high-quality Japanese cuisine! Will definitely be back.

Stopped by Otani for the first time today and I will definitely be recommending this place to my friends!! Let’s start with the atmosphere - when you first enter, you’re greeted with a bunch of cute LED lights, very cute backdrop if you’re into taking photos. Staff is very welcoming and I was greeted with warm smiles the minute I stepped downstairs. To your left, there is an alcohol bar and a sushi bar. The bar is stacked with everything, so if you’re up for a drink, this place won’t disappoint!! I would recommend going for sake as it is a perfect pair for sushi. The place was extremely clean, even the bathroom was well decorated and spotless. Service - The servers were phenomenal! They are well educated on each dish and will explain in depth if you are new to Japanese cuisine or have any questions. I’m not able to eat raw fish and they explained all available options to me patiently. Although it was very busy tonight, the servers took time to check in on us and made sure we were good as well as constantly filling our water cups. Towards the end, the owner himself came to our table and greeted us and made sure we enjoyed the meal. You won’t get this type of hospitality anywhere else. The owner seemed very passionate about the food and it goes to show how much love they put into curating each dish!! Food - oh my, where do I even begin. Everything was amazing, flavors were all on point, fish was extremely fresh, and the flavor palette blended so well with each bite. Here are some of the dishes I would recommend and I think is a must try. - Foie gras eel (perfect for eel lovers) - Rock shrimp (fried to perfection) - A5 Waygu (for my beef lovers) - Uni (straight from Japan - freshness overload) - Spicy miso soup (paired great with the curly noodles) - Botan ebi I cannot rave enough about how good the food was. This is by far one of my favorite Japanese restaurants. Very high quality food but still at a reasonable price and won’t hurt your wallet. This place has well exceeded my expectations, it is truly a hidden gem. If you’re ever in the area, definitely stop by and experience the hype for yourself!

+6

Our server was so kind! The food and drinks were delicious, and there was a lot of variety on the menu! The atmosphere was also really nice. Would eat here again.

10/10 sushi spot! Great service, sushi and energy. Had no reservation for New Years and waited no longer than 10 minutes. A highlight if you’re planning that nyc trip for good sushi.

This place was so cute inside! The food was delicious and the staff were very friendly. Would definitely have to go again!

This was such a cute hidden gem to run into. They have the best lunch deals and the best service! I enjoyed the sashimi lunch and everything tasted so fresh and delicious. This will definitely be my new go to lunch spot in FIDI! Can’t wait to come back soon.

+2

New to the neighborhood and so happy we found our new go to sushi spot. The service was amazing, prices are great and the quality of the fish is unbeatable. Will be back to try the ramen next!

This place is amazing!!! Service was great, food came very quickly. The place itself is so pretty and cozy, we loved it! Below are pictures of the avocado sushi, veggie miso ramen, and green tea tempura cheesecake; they were delicious. :)

Dining at Otani on Wall Street is an absolute pleasure. From the moment you step inside, you’re welcomed with a modern, elegant atmosphere that perfectly balances sophistication with comfort. The staff is warm, attentive, and truly goes out of their way to make sure every guest feels taken care of.

Delicious sushi and ramen! The atmosphere is great. Also the yuzu tempura cheesecake was amazing. A great night out for the family

Everything was amazing‼️ Very inviting atmosphere. Staff are nice and catering! I highly recommend ✨✨✨✨✨

+1

Friendly staff that was very attentive. Tonkotsu broth was rich and the cuts of porks were very tender.

I had such an awesome experience! It was so delicious to have dinner here and I really appreciated the maki rolls!

The food is amazing and everyone is super friendly. The service was A1. Our water glasses were never empty. Wait staff was very attentive. Cute ambiance.

Food was excellent. The Eel Avocado maki roll was very good and it was the first time I tried. The Donburi Rice Bowls are huuge. Getting appetizers, 1 roll, and donburi is a lot of food

Down the street from my dorm and this is me and my friends fav place. The mochi is amazing.

Got the love boat for 2 and thoroughly enjoyed our meal! Will definitely be coming back when I’m in the area and craving sushi.

I recently visited Otani with my friend and it we had fantastic experience. The sushi were fresh—each piece melted in my mouth. I highly recommend the beef ramen and salmon tartare. Service was great. The staff was knowledgeable and happy to make recommendations based on our preferences. Definitely come again!

Amazing and tasty sushi!! We ordered the rock shrimp appetizer, Lion King, and Dancing Eel sushi, it was amazing.

The service was quick and everyone was very kind! The crazy dragon roll was the highlight of the night!

Guys, this place is soooo good! I gave 3 stars for the ambiente cause it is looking like a rather simple place but it‘s well kept and clean. The food here is absolutley amazing! We‘ve had Snow crab tacos, sushi on fried rice and we came back for the Miso Ramen. Fun fact: A lot of people working here are Chinese and not Japanese, but they can def. Cook Japanese!

I had the Chef Omakase plate and it was super delicious. The ataff went over and the main highlights were the toro hand roll, the toro belly, uni and salmon! The fish was pretty fresh. The wagyu beef was also a nice treat towards the end and super tasty. The staff were awesome all around and got my order in a reasonable time. The location is pretty convenient near the World Trade Center Station/Fulton if you're in this end of the city. If you're in the area I really recommend it.

Connie was our server and she was so nice and sweet. The ramen and sushi is so delicious! They also give you an entire marinated egg unlike other ramen spots that only give you half.

Absolutely loved this place! The vibes were incredible, relaxed yet lively. The food was great, especially the fresh fish. The staff were super friendly and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to!

Looking for a good place to eat after visiting a museum and stumbled across this hidden gem. Atmosphere and service is great. The food is tasty! Definitely recommend if you’re in the area

Sometimes you discovered gems by luck. I was starving and Otani was in my way back to the hotel. And I didn’t regret to stop, staff is discreet and kind, the menu is so diverse and the food is really fresh. I really enjoyed my time alone in this peaceful space in an intense city like NYC. Recommend 💯

This is my first time here and the ramen is incredible! I love the entire vibe of the restaurant and the service was super quick!

OH MY! This place is a hidden gem! I’m glad that my boyfriend and I decided to give this place a try! The ramen was amazing and the sushi even more! Fast and great service, and tasty food, what more can you ask for?!

Same here on a whim with some friends. Friendly staff and food came fast and tasted amazing! Would recommend.

I was in the mood for sushi and stumbled upon this newly opened establishment. Absolutely satisfied my craving. The sushi was tasty and fresh. Fried rice was good and a great value for a whole lobster tail. I liked that the chicken karaage was meating without a lot of extra breading. The place was esthetically pleasing and very comfortable. Lots of different cool light fixtures. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. Overall value was great. I would definitely return and recommend.

+2

Randomly looked up a ramen spot in this neighborhood but so glad we came here over all the others. Lovely quiet space with beautiful decor, calm ambiance, soothing music, and delicious food. It is everything you want in an intimate restaurant. The cocktail was also so tasty! Would highly recommend for anyone, but especially for a getaway from the city!

Great food with great service. Very chill and calming atmosphere. The waiters were great at refilling my drink and the wait time for food was not long. Would recommend to anyone who loves japanese food. Good presentation of dessert.

Very good customer service. Food was very delicious and affordable. Would recommend!

Amazing food & atmosphere, good fish quality, clean environment, with friendly staff. You will find something to like here as there is many variety of what to order.

Food was amazing here! Fish was very fresh on the sushi and the shumai was very soft and flavorful. We got the pink lady, crazy New York and 59 Nassau.Staff was also very helpful and even showed us images of sushi options and recommended some options.

This place is so cute! Not enough people go, the food was good and the staff is attentive. It's quiet and the perfect spot for a little lunch/dinner date. :). They gave my friend a tissue when she sneezed I call that 10/10 service right there.

Great food, great drinks! I recommend the lychee martinis and the new york roll and the tonkutsu ramen! Staff are super friendly and have great recommendations. Highly recommended!

I thought this place was so cute and the food is really good! I had no idea where I was walking down into, but the atmosphere is so nice and it’s so cute down here!

I am so happy we found this place! The atmosphere is beautiful and comfortable, the service was fantastic, but the FOOD. The food was insanely good. We ordered a lot, but here are the highlights: -spicy edamame— I’m so sad I’ll never be able to recreate this dish. It was indescribably delicious. -spicy crunch tuna roll was fresh and perfect. -tonkatsu ramen was everything I want ramen to be. The broth was savory and perfectly balanced. -chicken karrage don— wow. Wow. Wow. This was unexpectedly amazing. Go here 1000%.

The food and drinks are amazing here. I would highly recommend here. It's such a nice place, with cute decor and peaceful atmosphere.

Service was amazing. We had multiple waitstaff taking care of us- refilling drinks and taking orders as needed, including by the chef when he had spare time! I had the sashimi and sushi entree, which was absolutely outstanding and fresh.

I came twice and both the times service and food were excellent! I loved the ramen and dancing eel!

Incredible experience! The sushi and tuna tataki were beyond perfect — so fresh, delicate, and full of flavor. Honestly, the best I’ve ever tasted!

Stumbled across this gem and wow! Where do I begin? Amazing service, the hospitality is A1… and the drinks? Mind blowing, had the beef ramen and a few other things and left so happy!

9/23/25 My coworker and I were just wandering around looking for lunch and a man was coming up the stairs when we pass by and out of the corner of my eye I saw him. And I was like wait is there a subway station here? I turned and looked and saw the lights and was like wow nice subway station but then my coworker realized it was a restaurant lol So we said let's try it hehehe. It was such a good choice! My coworker got Sushi and I got the Tonkotsu Ramen. I loved the ramen and she loved the sushi. We are definitely going back!

krishma sachayansrisakul

A new hidden gem! Genuinely some of the best Asian cuisine I’ve had!! Staff is super friendly, space is beautiful, and food is phenomenal. Definitely recommend, prices are very reasonable as well :)

Such a good spot!! Amazing food quality; the service was incredible, everyone is so friendly!! Really relaxed atmosphere, perfect for a date or get together with friends. Cannot recommend it enough!!

Came here to celebrate my birthday with friends and the staff were so lovely and fun!! Highly recommend the ramen— was delicious and really large portions!

betty pierre

Treated myself to this resturant that has changed over the years. It seems to have gotten so much better. The meal and drinks delicious. A good lunch menu and other wonderful dishes. The martini put of this world service top notch!

+3

Nirmine

I recently visited Otani, a sushi restaurant in New York, because I wanted to treat myself to some really good sushi. I went there alone, but the warm and welcoming atmosphere made me feel completely at ease. The service was excellent attentive and the staff was incredibly friendly. The sushi itself was outstanding: fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Every bite felt like a little masterpiece. Overall, my experience at Otani was wonderful. I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for delicious sushi and top-notch service in New York!

I may be a little biased being from Arizona and it being harder to find great sushi but the food was so fresh and well prepared. Great lunch menu and a nice quiet annd relaxing atmosphere to go with it. Highly recommend coming in and giving Otani a try.

Me and my friend didn't go during a busy time ramen was so delicious and just what I needed after dance practice ☺️!! The mango crepe cake is really good to have to eat here again and try something new🤗

Very welcoming environment, we got the sushi and sashimi for two and the presentation is absolutely gorgeous! Came here after a hard hot yoga and it’s absolutely filling. Would highly recommend coming here!

Amelia H

Got takeout sushi combo from otani - highly recommend their sushi! Everything was really fresh and flavorful. I loved the variety in the combo. Miso soup was good, not super warm so needed to reheat. Pickup was easy and staff was friendly. Inside looked nice, I would like to come back and dine in.

Sophia Pariani

Otani is hands down the best sushi in the city. Every piece was incredibly fresh, beautifully prepared, and full of flavor. What truly sets this place apart is the amazing service—attentive, warm, and genuinely welcoming without ever feeling rushed. You can tell they care deeply about the experience they’re creating. If you’re looking for top-tier sushi and outstanding hospitality in NYC, Otani is a must. I can’t wait to come back.

David Pubby

Our server was very kind! The restaurant has a very nice vibe. I ordered the tri color sashimi deluxe off the menu, the miso soup it came with was delicious one of the best I have ever had and sashimi itself tasted delectable. My girlfriend ordered the crazy dragon roll and she said it was amazing. I would come here again for my anniversary!

This place is amazing, the food is gorgeous and delicious. We had ordered the steak fried with the seafood Udon and we were floored. To top it all off we had beautiful desert cakes.

Meghan CU

Great restaurant. Sushi was so fresh and very generous portions. Everything was delicious and the service was great.

+6

ManhattanNYC

Walked in without a reservation; the restaurant was almost fully packed, but the staff managed to get us a table. Service was pretty good. Food was great, with good flavor and decent portions. Prices are also reasonable. Great place for ramen lovers.

Dee Dang

We stumbled upon this hidden gem while walking around NYC. Since it was close to our hotel, we decided to give it a try without even checking reviews, and we’re so glad we did. It turned out to be one of the best Japanese restaurants we’ve ever visited. The service was excellent. The sushi was incredibly fresh and flavorful, the raman was rich and delicious, and every dish was prepared perfectly. Even our picky eaters loved it here. Highly recommend!

+1

Gessica Ni

This is the best sushi restaurant in FIDI hands down. Our favorite place to go for dinner and also to take-out. The staff are lovely. 10/10 - a great dining experience

Kiley Price

When this restaurant opened up, my boyfriend and I had to try it since we love sushi. This place is so great and we’ve come back multiple times because the sushi has always been delicious and reasonably priced. This time we ordered miso soup, spicy edamame, two maki rolls, and their special Tiger roll. Hits every time

Ashlyn Koga

My friend and I went to Otani around 5:30pm on a Monday. I was shocked that there was a decent amount of people in the restaurant when I checked in, so I would recommend making a reservation. They are located at a lower level, which is nice because it provides a bit of waiting room. The interior has a fancier ambiance, with a mix of tables and cozy booths. We started with an order of harumaki ($6). I liked that they cut this up in halves, so it was easier to split. It had a nice natural flavor, and the sauce definitely has a kick! I got a tonkotsu ramen ($18) and my friend got one signature roll and one regular roll, though I forgot which ones. It may have been the pink lady ($20) and yellowtail avocado ($9). It is rare for me to finish the entire bowl of ramen (broth specifically), but this bowl was delicious. It had a good ratio of broth to ingredients, and the noodles had a good texture. My only critique is that the chashu could be a tad more moist, but it still had nice flavor. My friend enjoyed her sushi, though I would still want to go back to Otani to try their sushi and update my review accordingly. Service was great! There were multiple check-backs and water refills. We did get rushed out at 6:50pm, and I had made a 5:30pm reservation, but they gave us a nice booth that would be suited for a party of 4, so I get it. Overall, I enjoyed my experience, and I will be back to try their other offerings!

Panuwat Wijan

I celebrated my birthday by myself at Otani Restaurant and had such a great experience. The Sushi Deluxe I ordered was fresh, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious. The Takoyaki was also amazing — definitely one of the best I’ve ever had. The staff were friendly and the atmosphere was calm and relaxing. Highly recommend this place for anyone who loves quality Japanese food!

Sarah Heinz

Delicious Gyoza and sushi / sashimi at this place, probably the best I’ve had. Great selection of rolls, sashimi, ramen bowls, rice bowls and appetizers. There is a great drink menu as well. Prices are reasonable, not overly expensive for NYC. Highly recommend!

Diego Silva

Tried the Love Boat for two platter, and it was amazing. Fresh sashimi, well made sushi and Nigiris. The staff was very friendly and attentive checking on us more than a couple of times. Definitely coming back!

Excellent hidden gem of a sushi restaurant right in FiDi. The sushi sashimi for two was amazing and perfect for me and my partner! Can’t wait to come back. We even got this nice mochi dessert!

Melody

Found this place while trying to find an area that sells ramen and it’s a bit hidden near Fulton st. But I love the interior decoration when entering the restaurant. Our server was accommodating and nice. Tonkatsu Ramen was the perfect amount of noodles, I chose thick while my friend chose curvy. The broth was super yummy and the pork was thick but juicy. A bit charred round the edges but I kinda of love that. Mango Crepe was alright, was missing some fresh and juicy flavors but it was ok. Still soft and edible. I hope to get the chance to try the sushi options they have but lots of dishes to choose from. Pretty affordable for 2 people as well. Wait time was 12 mins

+1

Royya Osouli

The food was incredible. I ordered the Tonkotsu Ramen, my friends had the truffle beef fried rice, and a few sushi rolls. The service was just a little slow, but when they were around, they were incredibly respectful and kind.

Maya Graham

It was lovely experience! The staff were kind and knowledgeable. They were so inviting and the food itself was fantastic. The portion sizes are large and in charge! Their drinks were fresh and delicious. Will definitely be visiting again.

I love Japanese food and couldn't wait to try! When I arrived I parked on the street and the parking was very hard in this area. When I finally found parking I walked into a cute restaurant. I was greeted and sat and served by Jimmy and he was good. I ordered the cab and that was good. For food I got: Chicken Karaage Bun Chicken Yakitori seafood ramen shrimp teriyaki The food was tasty. I loved the chicken karaage bun the most. The ramen was good but the noodles were a tad chewy. All in all I had a good experience!

+6

Had the sushi deluxe nigiri set. The fish was decent. Solid option for a lunch or dinner if you’re in the area, but wouldn’t come downtown specifically to go here.

Had lunch at this sushi spot and really enjoyed it. The food was fresh and well-prepared, and the service was friendly. The atmosphere was peaceful, making it a perfect place to relax and enjoy a meal. All in all, a very good experience—I’d definitely recommend it to anyone looking for quality sushi and a calm lunch environment.

Food was pretty good, definitly excel in the appetizers, sushi, ramen department much more than other departments but definitely a vibe. everything else is just there to have a bigger menu but, great service, good atmosphere, not too loud, and the food arrives very quickly. Drinks are also wonderful and not a steep price

The food here is magic, the service was rushed and a bit rude. Overall the food is worth the money

+3

Came for ramen and sushi on Christmas day. The crunchy scallop roll was delicious! The ramen got positive reviews as well. The bathrooms were gross and the water in the sinks wasn't working.

Great nigiri & eel sushi was amazing, worth the price. Nice black cod. Would come back for sure!

Solid 4.5 here for the somewhat-hidden gem down-the-stairs underground sushi spot. From the Miso to the tea and everything in between we came away impressed. The Sushi bar entrees excellent, super-fresh, quality fish exceeded our expectations. Recommend the Tricolor Sashimi Deluxe Combo. Come hungry, sashimi servings on the larger end. I'll be back to try more items on this menu. Odd neon signs galore in the entrance, but could be the landmark "just walk along Nassau St until you hit the multiple neon signs in the lobby" :-) Back a few days later. Ramen very good, and sashimi combo excellent. Confirmation of my earlier rating.

+1

Nice spot that’s open until 10. Cool entrance that gives a fun vibe. Staff were friendly and on top of things, food was good and the atmosphere was nice.

+6

Jed Thompson

Excellent. I'd return. I was wise enough to just order the tonkatsu ramen, nothing else. That's plenty for one person, i barely finished it. It's a very creamy broth and they nailed the sodium level perfectly. Pork is tender with a great char. And the eggs? Gel, which is great. The problem is there's only 1 egg and i wanted to eat 12 of them. Restaurant is downstairs so you occasionally get the rumble of the subway below you! Staff was very nice and attentive.

+2

MITARTH VAID

I am a fan of Japanese food and recently got the chance to have dinner at Otani. The food was quite good. The gyoza, spring rolls, and ramen were all flavorful and satisfying. The ambience was comfortable enough to enjoy the meal. Service was just okay, not terrible but could definitely be more attentive.

Walked past this new Japanese spot multiple times on our way home and finally decided to give them a try. A cool entrance, walk down a flight of stairs to a very spacious basement restaurant. Greeted by friendly staff and seated promptly on a Sunday night. Had the Spicy Miso Ramen and chicken bao buns. Both were good, not great, but good. And considering an expansive menu with very reasonable prices during these inflationary times, and stellar service, but ultimately it is the food that drives a rating, that said is more like a 3.5. I wouldn't exactly rush back, but in a pinch, worth a 2nd visit since they are within walking distance. Guess it's all relative to one's own palate and range of dining experiences based on fellow yelper's reviews. But do give them a try, always want to support small business restaurants.

Chili Tan tan ramen was good! Seaweed salad also tastes exactly how you expect. Would come again. Suggest slightly warmer lighting, feels a bit too blue/cold right now.

+6

Katsudon is different it tastes like fried pork with sunny side up egg on non-japanese rice, not authentic. provides unmatched cutlery 🤔 2 flies around my table hovering my food.

The food was amazing, but the Place was freezing like Alaska in a winter day this Facility/)restaurant had the heating system off during the coldest days of Winter !!!! what kind of restaurant owner Does that to his Customers!!!!? And the worst part that I was told that in summer he/she does the same with the AC system?????You can’t pay for the heating during the winter just close the place look for a different career!!!! When people go to eat out and spend good money they wanna feel comfortable while they’re eating good food not feel uncomfortable and that is the basic of great restaurant business and hospitality!!!!Shame on whoever allowed that!!!!

Came here for the first time because of the high ratings, but the experience was very disappointing. I ordered the Unagi Don, and it was honestly disgusting, the unagi tasted like it came straight from the fridge, just placed on top with pickled radish and seaweed. That is not a proper meal, that's a SCAM! I've never had a dish prepared like that before. My friend ordered the Tonkotsu Ramen, which tasted fine at first, but she later got sick in the afternoon. This made me worry a lot about the food safety in this restaurant. The only positive part of the visit was the lady who served us, she was very friendly and polite. We were happy to tip her for her service, but certainly not for the food. Will not come back!

One of the worst ramen bowls I’ve ever had in my life $18 for ramen that tasted like processed food. The meat tasted like plastic, and I left most of it on the plate.