Toasted Events

toadbear

Great cocktails and a very good- ever changing beer program. Some of the best shows I’ve seen in Newburgh have been here. The quality of artists has been mind blowing, and DJs always know how to work a room. Sam, the owner or manager, I’m not sure, makes me the coolest cocktails, new stuff every time, and remembers what I like to make new stuff. Man earns his tips.

Steph Alexis

Came here for lunch with my 5 year old daughter. Off the bat not a great place for a little person as the options are totally more geared for adults. However, the waiter was able to accommodate her as best as possible. So we had the fried chicken sandwich and it was amazing. We opted for regular Mayo and fresh mozzarella. I think when we go again I may need to opt for slice bread as well cause the baguette was to big for her mouth. Other then that it was great. Sam was super friendly. I will totally come back with my daughter.

JL I

Wow what a great little restaurant this is. Stopped by for lunch today and had the vegetarian fried oyster mushroom sandwich. This was perhaps the best surprise meal I have eaten this year. Really amazing. Friendly staff, cute little cafe. Definitely put this on your places to try out!

Tracy Hurley

Stopped in for a mid-week lunch with my husband. The food was amazing. I had the sliced hanger steak sandwich and he had the cubano. Both were great as was the charred gazpacho. Looking forward to a return visit.

Emily Stout

Stopped here for lunch while driving up 87. The staff was so friendly. We had the vegetarian fried “chicken” (mushroom) sandwich and the peach salad. Sandwich was a little on the salty side but otherwise very good. Cute place.

Brett Miller

An incredible culinary experience. At the suggestion of the chef, I chose the grilled chicken sandwich. It has only four ingredients, which is risky because there's no margin for error. Execution was flawless: tender chicken, creamy hummus, flavorful red cabbage slaw, on a daily baked local baguette. Beautifully simple.

James Sanders III

The decor of this place is on point. The food was too. Try the Fried Oyster Mushrooms and Brussels Sprouts. Trust me, you won't be disappointed. The only thing that was a bit concerning was the service. The waiter is a bit chatty and needs to do a better job of checking in with the customers.

Arlene Owens

We randomly went here on our walk home from the Airbnb. This place is totally something you would see in Seattle and/or Ithaca, I live right outside of there. I had no idea what to expect when we entered. There was a band playing with some interestingly looking patrons that could have all passed for 18. Not a bad experience, but it was definitely an odd experience. Considering I love both Seattle and Ithaca, that says a lot. Probably would have enjoyed it more if it was a different band and crowd.

Ronald J Wells

Tried to order my sandwich with something other than focaccia bread and there were no other options causing the bread to diminish any tenderness or texture the beef on it may have had. Also, they don't have a paper menu or something posted makeing it difficult for people not having mobile devices or perhaps a little bit older (like my dad) to order. Decor is cute and is is very clean. Staff is very nice.

Kaylin Isaac

My friend and I wanted to grab lunch, so we excitedly decided to try Toasted for the first time. Unfortunately, we both left knowing that we would not return. (1) My friend mentioned to the waiter that the tomatoes on her sandwich did not taste fresh and was not offered a replacement. The waiter responded saying that he just bought them yesterday, yet that response was not a solution to the problem. (2) I originally wanted the asparagus soup, however it was seemingly only a seasonal soup and therefore was no longer an option. Being that the establishment only has digital menus and wouldn’t have to waste money on printing, it may be wise to keep them updated so that guests aren’t disappointed and the menu is accurate. (3) I found a short, straight, blonde/brown hair underneath my shrimp. (It was too late to send it back, I ate them) My hair is dark brown, medium length and extremely curly and my friend’s hair is dark brown, long and wavy. The waiter didn’t apologize, he just said “That’s weird, the cook is bald so I don’t know how that got in there.” He was very nonchalant, and the hair actually looked like his. (4) I brought in these flyers to receive 10% off of my meal and the waiter didn’t allow me to use them because he had already taken 10% off because of the hair in my shrimp. I understand that this is a small business and they may not be able to comp whole meals. But in most restaurants, much more than 10% (a dollar and 80 cents in this situation) is taken off in cases like this. The least he could have done was accept the flyers I brought in. He told me to just use them for next time, but I already knew I wouldn’t be back. (5) The waiter didn’t ask if we were finished or ready for the check, he just brought the check out. Then got sassy when we asked him to split it, telling us that we should’ve said that beforehand. But he didn’t even ask if we were ready for the check to begin with. Overall, it just was not the experience that I hoped for. I know things happen, people have off days, etc. But nothing about this trip today motivated me to want to come back! The only good thing I can say is it is visually and aesthetically pleasing in the inside. But decor doesn’t retain customers, great customer service and great food does.