Stellina Bakery & Café

As a coffee connoisseur, I came here to write a review for one reason only, Stellina has the BEST iced lattes I’ve ever had in my life. They are consistently delicious. Best place on the island to grab a coffee (specifically an iced vanilla latte!!!)

We really liked the food, breakfast is wonderful and so fresh, the avocado toast was delicious, so was the coffee! I really recommend it. You’ll find a few good options even if you’re gluten free, would be happy if they’ll have a bit more variety for GF.

I love Stellina Bakery! It is a perfect place for a breakfast, lunch or even just for some sweets. I find their prices to be super reasonable and the location is very cute too! I also wanted to write that Victoria is so kind, Stellina Bakery has a real gem in her. She is always so sweet and helpful!

The food here is incredible! I probably take out 3-4 meals a week! Staff is super nice and friendly. And love walking here to grab a coffee and croissant in the morning as well.

We had Stellina in Oyster Bay cater our Holiday Party. Everything was fantastic. Patti was extremely kind and helpful. She is one amazing employee. Thank you 😊. Happy Holidays.

Such a welcoming atmosphere, the breakfast lunch and dinner options are amazing, the desserts are so delicious you can’t miss out on their speciality donuts! Also offers rewards program for every purchase made in store, it’s worth every penny.

Ozzy Canales

Kathya our server was unreal ! Always making sure we were okay . Super friendly and nice . I want to go back just to see her again! Five Stars

Christina Meno

We had Stellina in Oyster Bay cater our Holiday Party. Everything was fantastic. Patti was extremely kind and helpful. She is one amazing employee. Thank you 😊. Happy Holidays.

caroline c

As a coffee connoisseur, I came here to write a review for one reason only, Stellina has the BEST iced lattes I’ve ever had in my life. They are consistently delicious. Best place on the island to grab a coffee (specifically an iced vanilla latte!!!)

Demi Love

Such a welcoming atmosphere, the breakfast lunch and dinner options are amazing, the desserts are so delicious you can’t miss out on their speciality donuts! Also offers rewards program for every purchase made in store, it’s worth every penny.

Lady Greens

We really liked the food, breakfast is wonderful and so fresh, the avocado toast was delicious, so was the coffee! I really recommend it. You’ll find a few good options even if you’re gluten free, would be happy if they’ll have a bit more variety for GF.

John Litke

The food here is incredible! I probably take out 3-4 meals a week! Staff is super nice and friendly. And love walking here to grab a coffee and croissant in the morning as well.

Caroline Green

I love Stellina Bakery! It is a perfect place for a breakfast, lunch or even just for some sweets. I find their prices to be super reasonable and the location is very cute too! I also wanted to write that Victoria is so kind, Stellina Bakery has a real gem in her. She is always so sweet and helpful!

The pastries are delicious The owner is very nice. I think they should play Italian music. The atmosphere must be more like Italy. The colors in the decor should be more vintage , darker and warmer like a quaint Italian atmosphere. The pink flowery look isn’t the right one The seating is uncomfortable This cafe and bakery could be huge if they would stay with the Italian look

Adrienne Kinch

The pastries are delicious The owner is very nice. I think they should play Italian music. The atmosphere must be more like Italy. The colors in the decor should be more vintage , darker and warmer like a quaint Italian atmosphere. The pink flowery look isn’t the right one The seating is uncomfortable This cafe and bakery could be huge if they would stay with the Italian look

I loved the place, 🤩the decoration and the lights are very nice, very cozy. I went with a friend. We ordered 2 coffees and some desserts. I must say that the croissant was delicious. The girl forgot to make our coffees and we waited a maximum of 12 minutes for it, unfortunately our coffees arrived cold. I understand if the girl was tired or busy with another order. I needed another plate for my coffee. She was kind when serving us and apologized. 😊 But it is a very bad first impression. But, We will be back soon.

Kristy Roxana Ponce (Roxy)

I loved the place, 🤩the decoration and the lights are very nice, very cozy. I went with a friend. We ordered 2 coffees and some desserts. I must say that the croissant was delicious. The girl forgot to make our coffees and we waited a maximum of 12 minutes for it, unfortunately our coffees arrived cold. I understand if the girl was tired or busy with another order. I needed another plate for my coffee. She was kind when serving us and apologized. 😊 But it is a very bad first impression. But, We will be back soon.

The decor and atmosphere of the cafe was very cute. They had a mural of coffee mugs on the wall that I thought was beautiful. I ordered a latte and tiramisu for myself and some coffee and other pastries for my parents. The coffee was very good, however the desserts varied. For instance, the tiramisu was nice but the pistachio mouse was a little too sweet. Overall, a very nice bakery and cafe to chill in.

Fabliha Hossain

The decor and atmosphere of the cafe was very cute. They had a mural of coffee mugs on the wall that I thought was beautiful. I ordered a latte and tiramisu for myself and some coffee and other pastries for my parents. The coffee was very good, however the desserts varied. For instance, the tiramisu was nice but the pistachio mouse was a little too sweet. Overall, a very nice bakery and cafe to chill in.

This was our second time at Stellina Cafe, and unfortunately, the service was disappointing both times. Tonight, our waitress seemed disinterested, didn’t smile, and barely acknowledged us as she dropped off our food and shuffled away. They initially brought out the wrong dish, and when our correct order finally arrived, the food was not hot—some of it was actually cold. The wait was also rather long, which made it worse, especially since the restaurant wasn’t even busy tonight. If this is how they operate the day before Oyster Fest, a lot of people are going to be disappointed. The staff clearly need better training to handle service and create a more pleasant experience. We probably won’t be back, but maybe they’re better off sticking to their bakery goods. Overall, it’s been a letdown.

Great food, but weird girls at the front 1 pm on sunday, definitely need better customer service training. I got a burger and forgot to ask for onion rings instead of fries, however she didn’t ask which ones I would like, I got it and realized my mistake and asked if I could swap and was waiting for their response but they didn’t tell me so I asked them and it was then that they told me it wasn’t possible. Ok- no problem. After I got a normal latte and the person who made it decided she would make it with oat milk for no reason. Off vibes, won’t return or recommend.

Went there today, they messed up my order and didn’t bring out someone’s order. They offered to make it or refund it. We then went up after the fact to get a coffee before leaving and the 2 girls working the register whispered in each others ears and rudely said “we already gave you a refund” when I went up to get my coffee. The food we got was good but the terribly service was really off putting for the whole experience.

Ordered two hot chocolate but got cold chocolate instead. Very disappointing. However, their cookies were fantastic

Shannon Sullivan

Went there today, they messed up my order and didn’t bring out someone’s order. They offered to make it or refund it. We then went up after the fact to get a coffee before leaving and the 2 girls working the register whispered in each others ears and rudely said “we already gave you a refund” when I went up to get my coffee. The food we got was good but the terribly service was really off putting for the whole experience.

Rule Brakers

Ordered two hot chocolate but got cold chocolate instead. Very disappointing. However, their cookies were fantastic

Kristin Tudor Da Silva

This was our second time at Stellina Cafe, and unfortunately, the service was disappointing both times. Tonight, our waitress seemed disinterested, didn’t smile, and barely acknowledged us as she dropped off our food and shuffled away. They initially brought out the wrong dish, and when our correct order finally arrived, the food was not hot—some of it was actually cold. The wait was also rather long, which made it worse, especially since the restaurant wasn’t even busy tonight. If this is how they operate the day before Oyster Fest, a lot of people are going to be disappointed. The staff clearly need better training to handle service and create a more pleasant experience. We probably won’t be back, but maybe they’re better off sticking to their bakery goods. Overall, it’s been a letdown.

Terrible customer service, and the food has only gone downhill. I have no interest in interacting with 16 year old girls who would rather be anywhere else. Honestly, can only hope that others start feeling the same and we can get a decent mom and pop sandwhich place in Oyster Bay in that location in the future. Dont eat here. Also its almost $20 for a mediocre sandwhich.

Well , where to start? We got some cookies, tres leche cake , cheesecake and jelly croissant to go . Cookies were so dry , not enough butter for sure . Mini Cannoli someone forgot to put cream through the whole thing. It had more than an inch of no cream …. I have tried so many tres leches in my life and this one was really bad . Just whipped cream without flavor , merengue on top was off . I heard it is a viral thing ? What ??? Unbelievable. Cheesecake was normal . Croissant was suppose to be Nutella ,instead It had jelly from a jar . Please make your own jam, It is basic when you have a bakery . Not good . Keep a small menu and then you can have good quality on your product . Visit some local bakeries and see the difference .

Natalia H gomes

Well , where to start? We got some cookies, tres leche cake , cheesecake and jelly croissant to go . Cookies were so dry , not enough butter for sure . Mini Cannoli someone forgot to put cream through the whole thing. It had more than an inch of no cream …. I have tried so many tres leches in my life and this one was really bad . Just whipped cream without flavor , merengue on top was off . I heard it is a viral thing ? What ??? Unbelievable. Cheesecake was normal . Croissant was suppose to be Nutella ,instead It had jelly from a jar . Please make your own jam, It is basic when you have a bakery . Not good . Keep a small menu and then you can have good quality on your product . Visit some local bakeries and see the difference .

Taylor Berke

Terrible customer service, and the food has only gone downhill. I have no interest in interacting with 16 year old girls who would rather be anywhere else. Honestly, can only hope that others start feeling the same and we can get a decent mom and pop sandwhich place in Oyster Bay in that location in the future. Dont eat here. Also its almost $20 for a mediocre sandwhich.