Eric A.

Imagine your mom and your favorite aunt owned a restaurant. The sandwiches and salads are delicious. The portions are not huge, so we ordered an extra full salad to share between us in addition to our sandwiches. Excellent food and also a fantastic setting. Make sure to get there early before it closes at two.

+3

John Windsor

Whenever I’m in cozy Palmyra NY, I try to make a stop at Muddy Waters Cafe. The food is amazing, and the service is always excellent.

Elaine Morris

A very relaxing atmosphere. The food is excellent, I had the Berm on a spinach wrap. We sat out on the deck. Just beautiful.

St V

This place has a restaurant upstairs and a rental room downstairs. The restaurant has very nice people. Both staff and regular customers were all very friendly. Very good food. Very nice location. Very nice view of the canal. It has been recently renovated and is very clean and cozy. The owner also has a room she rents downstairs. We rented the room for a few nights and it was very well appointed. It has a small kitchen and roomy bathroom attached to an aircondioned bedroom with sitting area and private patio on the water. We will be recommending it to friends.

Dan Wilding

Nice little place.... really good sandwiches. Very friendly service. I would certainly recommend the Muddy Waters Cafe. When asked if we'd been in before, we had not, so she recommended her #2 and the #4 paninis.... they were the very best paninis that I've ever had.... juicy and chewy.... the bread was wonderful and the sauce was off the charts good. If I'm ever in the area again, I would not hesitate to go back and take friends.

+4

EMB

Amazing food! Great location and view. Nicely decorated and incredible staff. Great tasting water as well. Would return.

Karol Bugaj

Tasty fresh sandwiches highly recommend no 2 and no 4 from menu. Ingredients are organic and delicious. The owner is friendly and helpful. You can also engage in an interesting conversation while waiting for your food. 5/5

Cyrus A

Nice local brunch store. The vibe is amazing. Chicken breast in the sandwich was dry but overall was good.

Jim Riley

This is a very cool little place. It has a vast sandwich menu, prices were reasonable. Lots of drink options. The nautical and canal theme was very unique. The view from the deck was great. I would have given this place 4 1/2 stars if that was an option. The only negatives... The server was mixing up orders and the business hours are odd.

Emily Napierski

Outside is beautiful! This genuinely looked like a wonderful place to eat. However, our family of 14 was too overwhelming for the staff and they were frustrated at the children who were asking questions to decide what to order. I think it must’ve been on off day for the staff because we have never received service so unkind:( We ended up eating elsewhere, but I’m sure it would have been a great place if they hadn’t been so stressed about the order.

M.C. Siar

Rude staff (the old lady). The young one at the register was nice even though she didn’t told me about the “included-optional” ingredients (I’ll come to that). I asked for a sandwich called “navi”. It was a ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo sandwich. I waited a good 20 minutes (no sorry about the wait for me like she told everyone else) and noticed that the lettuce and the tomatoes were missing when she dropped it on my table. I politely asked her why my sandwich did not come with the lettuce and the tomatoes and the old lady responded to me that I was supposed to “ask for them”. Ask for ingredients that were supposed to be in the sandwich in the first place. It does make sense, right? I dropped the sandwich at the counter like she told me to so she could add the missing ingredients and she rushed back to my table after 2 minutes and almost threw the whole thing on my table like I was a dog or something. I took a picture of how half of my sandwich looked like when she put it on my table. Really? Do another job if you can’t handle rush hour. Service jobs are not for you. You don’t even deserve one star. Nasty people don’t. I don’t care whether you had a bad day or not. You should never take your misery on your customers. Or maybe that was due to my French accent and my afro hair. I guess I’ll never know.