Maryann M.

Great food! Been coming here since I moved from Brooklyn. Great breakfast sandwiches/sub sandwiches and not to mention the delicious free coffee with any breakfast sandwich. I had a last minute luncheon at work and I ordered from here & everything was so yummy! The sandwiches, macaroni & potato salad.

Igor Gritsan

Love this place! 🔥 I got the pastrami on rye, and it was hands down one of the best I’ve ever had. The staff is super friendly and makes you feel like a regular, even if it’s your first time. You can tell they care about quality and keeping things authentic. Portions are generous, and the prices are just right 👍

Joseph Kinsley

Best sub around.... foods great, owner really nice! Good family owned small business.

Mora

This place is a GEM! Ordered the Majestic and classic Italian! First off, the customer service was great. The gentlemen was welcoming and patient as we had never been here before. Their menu is large, but they also can make anything you want from all the ingredients on hand; so feel adventurous. The Majestic (chicken cutlet, bacon and garlic bread was an absolutely masterpiece 😍 Attached is a photo of the Italian sub, which was also good. I couldn't put down the Majestic sub so no photo of that one. I will absolutely return to the shop! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND ANYONE IN THE AREA TO EAT HERE!

Barbara Rooney

A friend decided to use Agamie to cater a party we were hosting this weekend. Specifically from here we ordered assorted types of 6 foot subs, wraps, macaroni salad, coleslaw, and a cheese & fruit platter. I can't rave enough about everything we received! The food was delicious, nothing was missed, they provided all the extra things we would need like salad dressing, mayo, etc, and it was all very nicely plated and well packaged. It was obvious that everyone enjoyed it because there was not much left over after the party. The pricing is very fair and we highly recommend them!

Gabrielle Roman

Subs are huge, prices are right, service is great. Stop debating! Just go & experience it for yourself - you won’t regret it. Best deli in town.

Joe Brassell

In town from Michigan for work and a friend suggested sandwhich for lunch. We were going to a subway originally but it was closed and what blessing in disguise that was. Agamie makes SUPER good food. It was truly spectacular. Fresh sliced meats, fresh produce, fresh, beautiful mozzerella..all of it...fantastic! The staff was very friendly and helped us pick something great. I got the real Italian and it was quite a hefty sandwhich. One that I shouldn't have taken on in 1 sitting. No regrets. I'll be back again without question. The picture doesn't do that thing justice it was so good. A unique thing that I noticed as well was that the bread got even better as it absorbed some of the moisture from the sandwhich. Mmm. Hopefully I have the chance to stop by again before heading back to Michigan. I may just have to volunteer for another business trip

Ivana Strahija

Love being able to order online for pick up. The staff is extremely nice, and my greek salad was fresh and delicious. They have all of the deli staples, a bunch of sammiches, salads etc. Highly recommend checking them out if you're in the vicinity. A bonus is the hilarious sense of humor of the staff or the owner who put up this little gem 🤣

Burt Shoobs

Agamie Gourmet Delicatessen and Catering, a part of the Market Street business district in the Allwood section of Clifton, is back, and reopened under new management. I have loved this place the few times I have been there, so I was willing to give them a shot. While the sandwich was good quality, I did not find it quantified enough to be worth the price I paid. There was also another very glaring misfire in this. Looking at a couple of my pictures of the menu board, what don't you see on it? Yes, NO PRICES ON THE MENU BOARD! I HAD TO GUESS WHAT THE PRICE OF WHAT I WAS BUYING. Glaring Red Flags and Blaring Alarm Bells! Not a good read at all. So for all the friendliness and service, next time I come back, I will do so with caution. I hope that adjustment will be made.

+2

Bernice Griffo

I ordered two sandwiches One was a roast beef and Swiss club The rye bread was terrible stale The tomatoes mushy gross The roast beef was fatty. Tough and tasteless. Horrible. Will not be getting delivery from here again.

Michael Nielson

I feel beyond disrespected after visiting this "deli" yesterday. I grew up for 25 years in the Bronx and visited Arthur Ave quite frequently even after moving to the city for 6 years before heading to New Jersey, ordering the same sandwich at every real Italian deli I have ever frequented just to come here and get told "that's gross and won't taste good" and have my sandwich request questioned. The level of unprofessionalism and lack of respect from this organization is uncalled for. I don't care if you think my sandwich is the worst combination ever made (which it is not, it's actually a speciality menu item from Mike's Deli on Arthur Avenue) as your paying customer you should never make judging comments and act rude. I was happy when I found the place because their online menu had everything I was looking for but some of the items aren't even available. To top it off, they didn't even add all of the items I asked for (which I think they did on purpose). Wish they had better customer service because the food is not horrible, I just won't ever return after being disrespected. In the end I am extremely open to suggestions but the way the comments were made as bold judging statements were not a suggestion. It makes me miss Arthur Avenue even more now and I know the next time I want a REAL Italian deli sandwich I just have to make the trip back to the Bronx where I won't be judged and get what I ordered. Learn how to treat your customers if you want to keep returning clients.