Rich Layman

Grew up in Peekskill..joined USCG, lived in VA most of my career. VA pizza is so awful. Forced to order Dominoes. Retired & moved back, this place is exactly what you want in NY pizza. Tonight tried arugula & prosciutto..its always on food network...so I gave it a try. Amazing. Got 2 other pies (cheese & s&p) & they kill it, great pizza.

Joann Fuentes

We had our daughters 2nd Birthday at Amici's Restaurant. We had the Best Experience the Service & Food was Outstanding. Albin & his Brother Andi were So Kind and were So Helpful with Everything and so was Nick. Definitely Will be Back. A Definite place to Book your Party.

+1

Meg Karasinski

First time here. Was very impressed with the food. Will definitely be back. In pictures below are Chicken Picatta, Chicken Sorrento, Cheesecake (Rogatta), and a Tartufo.

Kristopher Gaffney

It's a dope spot. And the food on top of Kelz, and Andi is a experience that everyone should have!!!👍🏽👍🏽. Just a little add on. The sweets are from Arthur Ash in the Bronx, and the garlic knots are ba banging. They have a dining room and a atmosphere of romance 😍. Come check it out. Plus they do special pizza, like American cheese, pepperoni, and chop 🥩

+1

Esmaili

My new construction project just started next to here. I got their chicken Parm and pepperoni pizza and tastes great! Been going there multiple times by now and won’t be going anywhere else for the time being. Would probably be gaining a few pounds after a while, but who cares the food taste great! Sincerely, Atrin H

Stone Per

Reg cheese Pizza is very good. My kid also enjoyed the chicken parm. The Ceasar Salad pizza was delish. This is our go to spot for pizza now.

Laura Murray

Love the pizza in house or delivered to us. Wonderful, friendly service. Had a large delivery order recently and service was so professional

Bass Head

Food is good but EXPENSIVE. A large sausage and pepper pizza, 1 cheese calzone and a 2 liter of coke cost $44!!! 44 dollars is insane for that

After frequenting this business for over 20 years including a change of ownership they finally decided they don't care anymore. Food quality has fallen off, quantity decreased, prices increased and the last straw was being called a liar when it was explained they failed to add the chicken to two consecutive online delivery orders. They are worthy of going elsewhere less convenient.

Matthew Steenburg

Asked to use the bathroom and the guy really rudely said no, they didn't have one, it doesn't work. I wanted to wash my hands to buy pizza. The girl behind the counter wasn't interested in serving anyone pizza anyway.

Bobby Lou

Ordered a Hawaiian pizza through Uber Eats. The restaurant was closed when the driver arrived, which should never happen if you’re accepting orders on the app. Complete waste of time and very poor service coordination. Definitely would not recommend ordering from here.

Demo Account

I ordered pizza at around 8:50pm waited one hour And some change to not even receive my food I had called this place multiple times and no one answered the phone when I just want to simply tell them I never received my online delivery order when it said it was complete , I'm very frustrated that I had to wait this long for food I didn't receive I wouldve been better ordering gleasons or Antonio's which mightve tasted way better ..mind you this is the first time attempting to try this place out and I'm already disappointed

Dominique

First of all, to write a review I had to give this place 1 star, but they deserve ZERO stars. This was my first time ordering since the menu was in my mailbox, so we decided to try it. I ordered a large cheese pizza at 6:30pm and received it at 7:45pm. I called the pizzeria at 7:30pm to check the status of my pizza. The woman was EXTREMELY rude, yelling and told me “this is Saturday night, and online it states that deliveries can take over an hour. If you would like to speak to a manager, that can happen. But your pizza is almost there”. I waited and it came at 7:45pm. BTW- nowhere on the website states that it takes that long for 1 item. When I finally received my one item, it was ice cold, hard as concrete, and had at least five burnt bubbles on top of the pizza. I actually had no dinner and chopped it up for the birds. I will NEVER EVER recommend or order from Amici’s AGAIN.