Jenna Brousseau

My husband and I love Tommy’s! My mother- in- law and her family are all from Italy and make phenomenal homemade pies, so Tommy’s had some seriously high standards to meet with us. Tommy’s exceeded those standards, and we order from there almost every Friday now. Tommy’s sauce is delicious- not too sweet- and so flavorful. I also love that they are very generous with the cheese (my favorite part). Our son, without fail, gets the wings, but begs me to save him the crust, which he says is the best crust around (again- he has high standards considering his Nonna makes her pizza, dough and sauce from scratch). You just can’t beat a family owned business who makes great food and cares deeply about their community. Keep up the great work, Tommy’s!!

Amy mogulnicki

Having lived in Portland CT my entire life Tommy’s Pizza is ALWAYS my go to spot for great pizza, grinders, burgers and chicken wings!!! If your looking for a delicious meal in Portland or any other town Tommy’s Pizza is the place to go!!! They listen to your order (I like my pizza cooked a certain way and always cut in squares) Tommy’s ALWAYS listens to my out of the ordinary orders and always gets the order right and it’s DELICIOUS every time!!! I would recommend Tommy’s to anyone!! Not to mention that even in a pandemic their prices are some of the best around!!! Tommy’s is a staple of Portland and a great family owned restaurant that treats ALL OF THEIR CUSTOMERS AS FAMILY ALSO!!!

V.D.C & C Lopez

Tommy’s has to be one of our favorite places! The meatball grinders are the absolute best, the sliced meatballs are a huge hit in our house! My moms favorite is the clams casino pizza, she always says be sure to tell Sarah it was delicious, this is coming from a lady who has made clams casino most of her life! My favorite is the bonless Buffalo chicken salad with their amazing Vasili Greek dressing, my go to for sure! Well worth a visit or two or three! Family run, and our family favorite!

Erika Tucker

I absolutely love this place! I used to live in Portland and have since moved out of town. I travel back to Portland just for the delicious chicken! The grilled chicken salad is our favorite, and the house dressing is SO yummy. The portion size of the large salad is perfect for sharing and the price is quite reasonable. The staff is friendly and has never messed up our order! We also love that the chef is so grateful every time we mention how much we love the chicken. It’s juicy, and seasoned just right. You will not be disappointed, delicious food and great staff.

SilverCoast Rentals

Super fresh, high quality, flavorful ingredients on their pizza. Excellent thick crust pizza with just the right amount of crunch. Plenty of full-fat, real mozzarella. You can taste the fennel in the chunks of real italian sausage and the oregano in the pizza sauce. And we worked with a pizza owner in the past, so we know the differences that can exist in the quality of ingredients used. Reasonably priced. Friendly staff. It's our only go-to for pizza now! Just get some!

Tommy Campbell

Not bad the chicken is good. The pizza is a little hot. My friend really liked his gluten-free pizza because it tasted like pizza.

Evan LePage

$22 for a small 12 inch pizza and you have to pay for ranch/bluecheese. Very loud in there too with their air conditioner. Should have gone somewhere else

Margaret Hicks

It was the first time I had visited this restaurant in decades. When I was a child my family ordered from them often. I ordered two grinders: one meatball and one sausage. Unfortunately, I was disappointed by the meat in both sandwiches. The meatball did not resemble any I had seen before—it came in large slices similar to meatloaf, yet lacked any real meat texture and flavor. The sausage, while shaped correctly, also failed to taste and chew like sausage. Despite my dissatisfaction with the meats, I found the bread, cheese, mushrooms, onions, and peppers to be good.

Nich P

I ordered up a pickup order through Slice. I ordered a medium buffalo chicken pizza for a total of almost $30, which is a pretty steep price for a 14 inch pizza even when compared to the overpriced places on Main Street in Middletown. The description for my pizza on Slice said it included blue cheese (photograph of menu included.) When I went to pick up the pizza, I was met by an annoyed sounding working rolling her eyes telling me “we will be with you in a minute”. Being stressed/rushed is understandable, but the place was empty so I’m not sure what the attitude was related to. Maybe they had a lot of takeout orders for dinner rush, not sure. After waiting a bit in the (empty) restaurant, my pizza was handed to me. At which time they tried to tell me blue cheese wasn’t included and wanted to shake more money out of me for it. No thank you. I’m not paying extra for an item listed on your menu as included…especially when your pizza is already overpriced as it is. Beyond the false advertisement on the menu, the pizza was…mediocre and small. The crust and cheese were on the border between okay and good. However, the chicken was an inedible level of dry. Had one slice and that was enough for me. The trash bin can have the rest. Overall, definitely won’t be going back here. For the price, you can get something significantly better without being nickled and dimed every step of the way. Sad because I heard good things about this place too.

StarKnight88

Despite my low rating, I am attempting as a long-term customer to be as fair in this review as possible, and cover both the upsides and downsides of this place based on my own experience. I can't speak for anyone else. I almost always order, and have only rarely dined in the actual restaurant. I don't know for sure what goes on in management, and would advise my review be taken with a grain of salt. I can share only what I've seen and what I can guess is happening based on it. Over the long time I've lived in Portland, I've watched this restaurant decline. It used to be THE place to get pizza in town since Russo's closed all those years ago. However, recently they appear to have moved to a nonsensical cooking methodology, whereby instead of having a dedicated cook or cooks so that food quality is consistent, they simply have whoever is available cook. This leads to the place seemingly playing Russian Roulette with your food quality. You never know whether your food is going to be of decent quality, or whether it's going to end up tasting like flavored cardboard (which it usually does, at least with my orders). Their wait staff appears to cycle out so quickly that it's become common practice to see a new person taking your order every week or so, and turnover appears high. And after *two years*, they still can't seem to hire a delivery driver. Everything has to either be eat in or pick-up. For handicapped people or those that otherwise can't get to the place, you're S.O.L. unless you want to further risk food quality drop by ordering from a delivery app. And then there's the problem of being left on hold. The service is mildly frustrating at normal times, and ATROCIOUS when they're busy. Oftentimes, I have been left on hold for up to ten minutes, sometimes with them not even getting back to me at all. On the plus side they're at least friendly and the restaurant is clean and has a good atmosphere, so I imagine that all of these problems with service and food quality are due to hard financial times and inexperienced staff rather than any sort of malice. I do get the impression they're trying their best. Even so, I find it hard to want to order from here anymore. I've held out hope things will improve. But they don't seem to be.