Jerseys Pizza

This place is great. The atmosphere is great, pizza is perfectly delicious, the selection of beer is awesome. Darn, I should of gotten a pic of that!! Anyways, go there . You will not be disappointed. Pizza, grinders, ravioli, spaghetti salads, everything made to order.

Kathy Tee

The pasta combo came with a large garlic bread and dinner salad for $15! Pretty good amount of food! The meat sauce was delicious! So good with the garlic bread! The garlic bread had a crispy crust and soft bread! Every bite was soo good! Jersey’s pizza was yummy and fluffy! I like it when there is a crisp in the crust and the dough is soft! Very fresh out of the oven! The guy at the bar as really nice! He’s so friendly and upbeat! Really good service and helpful! The ambiance is very relaxing! We sat st the bar and I love that there’s a raised step for our feet!

Rayge87

Great local pizza joint. We had the pepperoni pizza and cheese bread. Good times with family and Great food.

Jacob Moreno

We originally we’re going to another place a few doors down, but the wait was extremely long, so we opted for Jerseys and it was delicious! Hands down, a great pizza! We’ll definitely be back.

Ryan Solorio

Comfortable spot located in a great location. Inside is clean with plenty of seating at tables or a well stocked bar. Owner is friendly and quick to whip up your order. Ordered a calzone and it was great! Not too busy on a weekday afternoon so it would be a great place to stop on your lunch break.

Dana Gonzalez

Amazing place for quality pizza. The Jersey’s special is fantastic! The linguica sausage is so delicious. Staff is wonderful! So friendly and accommodating.

miguel perez

I liked the pizza really good, doughy .... the one with more toppings was way better the plain was ok .... if I had to compare it to the other locals so far I'd say 1 romanos 1- gourmet could be either or 3- jersey 4 strongman depending on ur preference spent 33

Adelina Flores Merrill

Mr. Dave and his pizzas will always be the best. The drive from Indio to Redlands for good tasting pizza is worth it. Such a kind and personable person. Chorizo pizza is delicious 🤤. Not too greasy. Pepperoni pizza is always fresh. Antipasto salad is always filling.

Cheyenne Navarre

Great place to come and get some great pizza.

MeFreakenOw (Fifi333)

This place is great. The atmosphere is great, pizza is perfectly delicious, the selection of beer is awesome. Darn, I should of gotten a pic of that!! Anyways, go there . You will not be disappointed. Pizza, grinders, ravioli, spaghetti salads, everything made to order.

Jesus Reyes

Definitely one of the better local Italian places. Had the calzone, chicken pasta and salad. Worth trying out

Annmarie

Delicious pizza, fresh salads, great beer on tap options, locally owned, welcoming feeling, friend staff. It’s our go to pizza!

Rachel Bordeaux

Love the pizza. The dough and tomato sauce taste good and they are generous with the cheese. Nice place for pizza and beer. Nice owner.

Love the Crust on this pizza and how cheesy it is, But the flavor was a bit blend…Still really good Though I would come again. The marinara sauce that came with the cheese bread…OH MY it was one of the best Ive had. That marinara sauce is definitely tasty and most likely homemade

This was my very first time coming here and I am from out of town so I was very open minded coming here because sometimes small business like this are very hot or miss and I can tell you from my point of view the food was EXTREMELY GOOD. I did have some problems with the service taking longer then most people would like; I was actually very close to getting up and asking how much longer, but then my order of cheese bread with marinara sauce came to the table and shortly after my pizza. The ingredients used on the pizza was clearly fresh adding a nice touch to a traditional Italian pizza place so it was enjoyable to eat. The one other problem I had was it was very clear from my stand point that as a new unfamiliar face I was not treated as friendly as there other guest. There were multiple workers going out of there way to talk amongst people how there week had been going and catching up on general things and I was only approached to receive my food and that was it. Another thing to keep in mind is I would more define the atmosphere as an Italian sports bar and grill. There is a lot of sports memorabilia and flat screens around and half of the place is a bar so I wouldn't consider it necessarily family friendly but there wouldn't be anything wrong about bringing your child here either if you didn't mind that. All together is actually rate this place a 3.5

Tania Orozco

Love the Crust on this pizza and how cheesy it is, But the flavor was a bit blend…Still really good Though I would come again. The marinara sauce that came with the cheese bread…OH MY it was one of the best Ive had. That marinara sauce is definitely tasty and most likely homemade

Tracy Yniguez

This was my very first time coming here and I am from out of town so I was very open minded coming here because sometimes small business like this are very hot or miss and I can tell you from my point of view the food was EXTREMELY GOOD. I did have some problems with the service taking longer then most people would like; I was actually very close to getting up and asking how much longer, but then my order of cheese bread with marinara sauce came to the table and shortly after my pizza. The ingredients used on the pizza was clearly fresh adding a nice touch to a traditional Italian pizza place so it was enjoyable to eat. The one other problem I had was it was very clear from my stand point that as a new unfamiliar face I was not treated as friendly as there other guest. There were multiple workers going out of there way to talk amongst people how there week had been going and catching up on general things and I was only approached to receive my food and that was it. Another thing to keep in mind is I would more define the atmosphere as an Italian sports bar and grill. There is a lot of sports memorabilia and flat screens around and half of the place is a bar so I wouldn't consider it necessarily family friendly but there wouldn't be anything wrong about bringing your child here either if you didn't mind that. All together is actually rate this place a 3.5

We love the pizza, but service is sub par. Came to pick up our order, paid, even left a tip, AFTER this we were told the “ticket didn’t print” and they were just starting it. I’m still waiting 25 minutes later… an hour since we placed the order. No offer for a discount, free dessert, coupon for next time. Nada.

Lisa Bowers

We love the pizza, but service is sub par. Came to pick up our order, paid, even left a tip, AFTER this we were told the “ticket didn’t print” and they were just starting it. I’m still waiting 25 minutes later… an hour since we placed the order. No offer for a discount, free dessert, coupon for next time. Nada.

First time here after probably 15 years of moving out of the area. Was looking forward to a pizza that used to be delicious. Unfortunately, they changed it-wasn't even close to what "used to be". Hardly any chicken on the spicy bbq chicken pizza. Plus, we were there during lunch hour on a Thursday and there were 4 other diners there. The whole time we were there, 2 more diners came in and ordered. Plus, one of us ordered a glass of red wine and it was the smallest pour we'd ever seen. Small glass, half full. MAYBE 2-2 1/2 ounces. Everything seems overpriced and not that good

The last time I had Jersey's pizza was over 20 years ago. The cheese, sausage, and Canadian bacon have the exact same flavor. It was nice to see they offered alfredo sauce since I remember I didn't like the sauce since they put a lot on and it was chunky. My only gripe is that they are extremely expensive, I had just missed the lunch special, and they still skimp on the meat.

Ron West

First time here after probably 15 years of moving out of the area. Was looking forward to a pizza that used to be delicious. Unfortunately, they changed it-wasn't even close to what "used to be". Hardly any chicken on the spicy bbq chicken pizza. Plus, we were there during lunch hour on a Thursday and there were 4 other diners there. The whole time we were there, 2 more diners came in and ordered. Plus, one of us ordered a glass of red wine and it was the smallest pour we'd ever seen. Small glass, half full. MAYBE 2-2 1/2 ounces. Everything seems overpriced and not that good

The service was great, unfortunately the pizza- not so much. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it came with a lot of cheese, it looked like it was going to be good. But when I tasted it, all of that cheese that they put on it- was flavorless! The cheese didn't taste like anything, it was a let down for sure. I'd recommend for them to get a better mozzarella, because what they loaded on that pizza tasted cheap- it tasted like nothing.

Scar Moto

The service was great, unfortunately the pizza- not so much. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and it came with a lot of cheese, it looked like it was going to be good. But when I tasted it, all of that cheese that they put on it- was flavorless! The cheese didn't taste like anything, it was a let down for sure. I'd recommend for them to get a better mozzarella, because what they loaded on that pizza tasted cheap- it tasted like nothing.

Worst pizza in redlands. Tastes like cafeteria or hospital pizza. Dough isn’t cooked thoroughly so it tastes doughy and it doesn’t have any good flavors. Tomato sauce is sour. Cheese tastes processed. Typically when you walk into a restaurant, it should smell good and be inviting. This restaurant had the smell of something rotting and I should have left just based on that. But Instead, I endured a terrible pizza and generic cheese garlic bread instead.

Ash T

Worst pizza in redlands. Tastes like cafeteria or hospital pizza. Dough isn’t cooked thoroughly so it tastes doughy and it doesn’t have any good flavors. Tomato sauce is sour. Cheese tastes processed. Typically when you walk into a restaurant, it should smell good and be inviting. This restaurant had the smell of something rotting and I should have left just based on that. But Instead, I endured a terrible pizza and generic cheese garlic bread instead.

Terrible Service - Owner/Manager seems overwhelmed Sunday 12/28…After 45 minutes no salads no pizza. I realized everyone that ordered after us had been served and one table had already left. My husband went to the register to complain. He said it was obvious the staff forgot about our order and that we would have to wait “a few more minutes.” No apologies and still no urgency to rectify the situation. They didn’t even bring us our salads. From our table we could see one of the employees discussing our receipt with another employee. They both looked at us and immediately turned away. It was clear they forgot about our order. At this point, it’s well over an hour. My husband went back, canceled the order and asked for a reimbursement. However, they were unable to reimburse us without a manager or owner’s approval. As they weren’t able to get in contact with the owner we decided to leave. The next day, Monday 12/29, my sister called and spoke to the owner/manager. He was apologetic and explained he gets so many people asking for their money back that he had to set a pre-approval policy before any refund is issued. Hmm, this is not a good policy and why would so many people want their money back?? Instead of changing his policy he needs to change whatever is causing the problem. Anyhow, he said he’d reimburse us. Three days later, Wednesday 12/31, I checked my account and no reimbursement. My sister called him again and he said, “I’m busy and haven’t had time to do it. It’s on my list and I’ll get to it later!” She tells him he’s had 2/3 days to do it and he has our money. It should be a priority! He says “you know what, I’m busy right now and I don’t have time. Do what you want, write your review and say whatever you want. I’m not giving you a refund. I’ll give my feedback too.” She hung up on him. I believe it was never his intention to reimburse us. So we did a chargeback. As an owner of a business, we thrive on our reputation for great customer service. We want to make our customers happy by providing quality product and service. This guy was unprofessional, rude and obviously lacked the slightest bit of decent customer service. Now I see why his staff are rude, they take after the owner/manager. His problem with so many unsatisfied customers is him…he’s an unprofessional business owner that doesn’t know how to manage a business…terrible customer service. I’m curious to see what his response will be.

Not even close to as good as it used to be. I've been coming here after sports events since the late 90s. Any Redlands native will tell you that the pizza is nowhere near as good as it used to be. It's clear to anyone with taste buds. The owner says that they use the same ingredients and everything is exactly the same, but that's just a bold-faced lie. The crust is thinner, and the sauce is bland and doesn't have the herbs or tomato chunks like it used to have (there's also a lot less of it). They also give way less cheese. It's clear there have been corners cut. The pizza is nowhere near the same. Also, they took down 90% of the memorabilia and charm of what made Jersey's a local staple. Now it looks empty, like it has no soul, which is fitting, considering. The service is terrible. The new owner loves to stand behind the bar and play bartender to all of his drinking buddies while a line of disgruntled people waiting for their orders piles up. I've witnessed this on multiple occasions. He doesn't help or ask any of the customers; he just walks by as if they don't exist. Then it's straight back to behind the bar while his kitchen staff are clearly in over their heads. I called in an order, and Tiffany told me it would be ready at 8:15 PM. I purposefully delayed until 8:20 PM to even show up because I know how notoriously bad this place is with service nowadays. I stood there and waited for 20 minutes before having to actually go back into the kitchen and ask them what was going on. This was the second time I inquired about my order, mind you. The first time they told me they were "working on it." Not one time did an employee or the owner come to check and make sure everything was going smoothly; nobody asked my name or even acknowledged that any of us were there waiting. The owner actually walked by multiple times and just walked by the line of annoyed customers as if they didn't exist. Imagine my surprise when the girl walks over to where they keep the pizza heated while it waits to be picked up and pulls out my order... IT HAD BEEN SITTING THERE THE WHOLE TIME. What a joke. Don't be surprised if you show up to this place and there's nobody working the front desk or answering the phones. The staff always seems extremely run thin and like they don't have the necessary people or leadership to make things work. You can't help but feel for them, but ultimately it's not the customer's job to service themselves. (No pun intended.) Everybody I've talked to about Jersey's has said it's gone downhill. They weren't wrong.

Monica

Terrible Service - Owner/Manager seems overwhelmed Sunday 12/28…After 45 minutes no salads no pizza. I realized everyone that ordered after us had been served and one table had already left. My husband went to the register to complain. He said it was obvious the staff forgot about our order and that we would have to wait “a few more minutes.” No apologies and still no urgency to rectify the situation. They didn’t even bring us our salads. From our table we could see one of the employees discussing our receipt with another employee. They both looked at us and immediately turned away. It was clear they forgot about our order. At this point, it’s well over an hour. My husband went back, canceled the order and asked for a reimbursement. However, they were unable to reimburse us without a manager or owner’s approval. As they weren’t able to get in contact with the owner we decided to leave. The next day, Monday 12/29, my sister called and spoke to the owner/manager. He was apologetic and explained he gets so many people asking for their money back that he had to set a pre-approval policy before any refund is issued. Hmm, this is not a good policy and why would so many people want their money back?? Instead of changing his policy he needs to change whatever is causing the problem. Anyhow, he said he’d reimburse us. Three days later, Wednesday 12/31, I checked my account and no reimbursement. My sister called him again and he said, “I’m busy and haven’t had time to do it. It’s on my list and I’ll get to it later!” She tells him he’s had 2/3 days to do it and he has our money. It should be a priority! He says “you know what, I’m busy right now and I don’t have time. Do what you want, write your review and say whatever you want. I’m not giving you a refund. I’ll give my feedback too.” She hung up on him. I believe it was never his intention to reimburse us. So we did a chargeback. As an owner of a business, we thrive on our reputation for great customer service. We want to make our customers happy by providing quality product and service. This guy was unprofessional, rude and obviously lacked the slightest bit of decent customer service. Now I see why his staff are rude, they take after the owner/manager. His problem with so many unsatisfied customers is him…he’s an unprofessional business owner that doesn’t know how to manage a business…terrible customer service. I’m curious to see what his response will be.

Nobody Jones

Not even close to as good as it used to be. I've been coming here after sports events since the late 90s. Any Redlands native will tell you that the pizza is nowhere near as good as it used to be. It's clear to anyone with taste buds. The owner says that they use the same ingredients and everything is exactly the same, but that's just a bold-faced lie. The crust is thinner, and the sauce is bland and doesn't have the herbs or tomato chunks like it used to have (there's also a lot less of it). They also give way less cheese. It's clear there have been corners cut. The pizza is nowhere near the same. Also, they took down 90% of the memorabilia and charm of what made Jersey's a local staple. Now it looks empty, like it has no soul, which is fitting, considering. The service is terrible. The new owner loves to stand behind the bar and play bartender to all of his drinking buddies while a line of disgruntled people waiting for their orders piles up. I've witnessed this on multiple occasions. He doesn't help or ask any of the customers; he just walks by as if they don't exist. Then it's straight back to behind the bar while his kitchen staff are clearly in over their heads. I called in an order, and Tiffany told me it would be ready at 8:15 PM. I purposefully delayed until 8:20 PM to even show up because I know how notoriously bad this place is with service nowadays. I stood there and waited for 20 minutes before having to actually go back into the kitchen and ask them what was going on. This was the second time I inquired about my order, mind you. The first time they told me they were "working on it." Not one time did an employee or the owner come to check and make sure everything was going smoothly; nobody asked my name or even acknowledged that any of us were there waiting. The owner actually walked by multiple times and just walked by the line of annoyed customers as if they didn't exist. Imagine my surprise when the girl walks over to where they keep the pizza heated while it waits to be picked up and pulls out my order... IT HAD BEEN SITTING THERE THE WHOLE TIME. What a joke. Don't be surprised if you show up to this place and there's nobody working the front desk or answering the phones. The staff always seems extremely run thin and like they don't have the necessary people or leadership to make things work. You can't help but feel for them, but ultimately it's not the customer's job to service themselves. (No pun intended.) Everybody I've talked to about Jersey's has said it's gone downhill. They weren't wrong.