Delish pasta. Prices were good for Cali life. The garlic bread was awesome. I recommend going early cause parking can be a while as it’s near a movie theater and other shops. But I’d go back just for those tasty pasta. Staff were nice and you can seat outside and place an order on the app and they’ll bring out your order so it’s worth it.

Lisa Kennedy

There is an open kitchen concept, so you can watch all the work going into the food. Place is good for "medium-sized" groups of 8-16 in the dining area with booths for smaller groups. The wood fired pizzas are nice and tasty, recommended over the pasta. Service is average, where you may need to ask for water if your glass runs dry

Steve Lisowski

Went here for dinner. The minestrone was okay. The kitchen got my calzone order wrong substituting Italian sausage for pepperoni. The onions were fairly undercooked. So why 4 stars? Excellent service. My waiter was very attentive and the very kind manager when she heard about the kitchen’s error immediately took off the calzone from my bill. I would probably go back next time I’m in the area.

Pisacha Srinuan

Good food, reasonable price. Good service minded waiters, but no free WIFI for guests is minus. The location is clean, the atmosphere is good, but a bit noisy from kids. Plenty of parking spots.

Usha Dawn

I was here with my friend to celebrate her birthday. We decided to come here so that after dinner we can go and watch a movie at AMC. We were seated at the booth which we asked for. Since the time was limited we decided to give our order - brussel sprouts, for appetizers, salmon fry as main entree and chocolate tiramisu for dessert. Before all that we ordered red wine. After selecting between two samples the Pinot tasted good. The service is great and I was surprised when the salmon came with fresh cheese grated on top of it. I do not like cheese and hence I had to tell the server. He was nice and took it and got me the order without cheese. Lessons learned, don't assume and call it out at the beginning itself to be safe. We enjoyed our dinner, the brussel sprouts was delicious and with dry fruits and dried cranberries it tasted awesome. The tiramisu cake was so delicious we both finished it quickly in no time. The vibe was cool and quiet inside the restaurant. It seemed like other servers were busy packing takeout food items. It was good to experience here. I will recommend this place for sure.

Daze

Food was OK even though I've had better Italian food. Some dishes were better than others. Bruschetta was fine same as pizza both were from Happy Hour menu. The spaghetti with pesto sauce was flavorless. Salmon plate was fine but salmon was tasteless so I looked for salt and pepper to add but there were none. Service was prompt and nice although at one point waiter forgot my inquiry of coffee. Overall it was a pleasant experience and would probably give them a second chance, hopefully food would taste better.

+1

VAPA Jeannine

Went to celebrate a birthday and had a great time and a great meal. I love the chopped salad. They made the meal special for the birthday. Always nice. A bit slow service but food was good and hot

Christina Ng

Came on a Friday for lunch. Not busy so no waiting for a table. It was empty and they said to sit wherever we want. We all ordered the pick 2 for $11.95. Menu is a QR code and you order from there but we stilled ordered with the wait staff. Food was good. Nothing spectacular. If you are catching up with friends it’s nice because you can hear them talk.

+1

Anaya Puranik

We visited Tomatina and tried their “Make Your Own Pasta” option. We went with the Veggie Alfredo and the Creamy Pesto with veggies. Both dishes were flavorful and the portion sizes were generous, which we appreciated. However, the pastas were noticeably oily and buttery — a little too heavy for our taste. Well, unlike many Italian restaurants, they don’t offer complimentary bread, which was a bit disappointing. But, overall, it was a decent experience.

George Karounos

12/24/2025: I'm on a medical team for a local ICU and this order was for the nursing staff as we are all working Christmas Eve and Christmas morning. Ordered through EZCater (unsure how much they make or how much they "middleman" the purchase). For $306 and change (not including tip as the delivery driver was great, tipped him 20% on card and $20 in person and that card tip better go 100% to him and not to Tomatina), we received two trays of food that could fit into a brown paper bag your local grocer might offer at checkout (one tray per paper bag). Fettucine Alfredo with chicken and the other tray was chicken parmesan. The total food may have been enough for ten people, as there were about eight or nine cutlets (some much smaller than others) and maybe one piece of grilled chicken cut up into the fettucine (scarce chicken in an order of fettucine alfredo with chicken, where the pasta and sauce are much cheaper than the chicken itself). The salad that came had a small cube of feta chopped up into it and one or two kalamata olives sliced vertically into small pieces as if there were onions (instead of throwing a bunch of olives into the bowl of salad). Otherwise, it was just spinach leaves. Also checked off that we needed plates and utensils and never received those. Overpriced for mid-tier quality food and not enough of it. A fair deal would have been $150 - $180 for what we got, $220 - $250 would have been a stretch, but $300+ was egregious. Will not be ordering from or recommending Tomatina. To those reading this, Merry Christmas and Happy New Year! Be sure to take care of your health (and wallet).

Jhonatan Ojeda

I’m really disappointed with my recent experience at Tomatina. I ordered my food online so it would be ready when I arrived to eat in the restaurant. When I got there with my girlfriend, we were treated very poorly. We were left standing for a long time with no help, and when we were finally seated, they put us at a different table away from everyone else. After all that waiting, our food came out about 20 minutes later than it was supposed to. The customer service was terrible, and the whole experience made us feel unwelcome. This used to be one of my favorite restaurants, but after this visit, I don’t think I’ll be coming back. Really unfortunate because I used to love this place. They also served us on togo boxes very very bad