It is still the best pizza I've ever had!

Delicious pizza. Very generous with the 60s prices today for their 60 year anniversary

Great spot. We like how they re-did it! It's cool, fresh and the kids liked it too!!

Newly updated.. Owner was on site and allowed early access. Food and service is still great.

Awesome specialty slices! I dont go anywhere else for my pizza.

Specialty slices are amazing. Many different choices and they are all delicious!

They make the best pizza over the last 20+ years! ..thank you!

Excellent pizza, but a tiny dining area. Be prepared to compete for a table.

GREAT food , fast service and the staff is always pleasant.. My go to for a quick bite in town...

Very clean the service very good the workers very very nice and the food was great

Very accommodating about making a custom gluten free personal pie!

Had grandma slice today, very good had to have another slice!

New ownership pizza is great very clean hood pasta

The best! Whenever I come back home to the island I get a half dozen pies to bring to Ann Arbor .Michigan can't tell the difference between a slice and bathroom tile. I also grab afew lasagna and the garlic knots. Family owned and operated. Ther at least 10 other pizza joints I can go to but I always choose Sayvill pizza. I'll be seeing you in October guys....cant wait

Great Pizza! The atmosphere is nice and the staff is Awesome. If your looking for really good pizza in the area than this is it!

Spinach artichoke slice was huge and delicious. BBQ pizza was sweet and tangy. Original was crispy and so good!

Not sure if they have same owners or new owners haven't been there in awhile. Was one of my High School hang outs, lots of memories. Was and probably still is the best pizza in Sayville. Johnny

Best place in sayville for a good time the food is amazing the staff is on point very friendly great atmosphere all around plus they have a bar you can’t beat that

Pizza and cuisine here is fantastic and delicious!! The new owners know exactly what their doing and it is authentic Italian as can be! Obsessed with the new menu and will dine here frequently!

Nice people, delicious food. NY style pizza, crisp crust, flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Chicken parm hero, generous portion.

Great food and I’m so appreciative that in these Corona times they take care of their seniors by offering a big discount. It shows they really care about the community. Thank you sayville pizza!!

Such a nice vibe and delicious food, very cozy and has live music! Will definitely be back!!!

The food was amazing! Chicken caprese was made of all fresh ingredients. So good. The place is immaculate. Best of luck to the new owner.

From the pizza connoisseur: also known as pizza cowboy on youtube (search it) ;-) a+ 5 star review. Their gourmet slices are amazing.

Such good pizza ! Just moved to the neighborhood and I have tried many different pizzerias but this knocks them all out of the park !!! Sooo happy I found this place 😍😍

Best slice of pizza iv had in a while. Never been here before. Sat outside and had a perfect grandma slice. 10/10

Been coming here most of my adult life and am always happy with the food. I make special trips to Sayville to get the pizza here.

Love how friendly and creative they make all their pizza’s! Sooo hard to choose from their meals! The dilvery guy mike is sweetheart! Love all their food❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

I have gone to Sayville Pizza for over 45 years. Tonite I chose a large pie wit sausage and meatballs... they made one heck of a pizza this time ! Dee-lish!!!

They make the best Grandma Pizzia ! Their regular Pizzia and garlic knots are pretty good too .

This place has been around longer than me. I go here often with my friends during the week, and I haven't had anything bad from here. The buffalo chicken slice is REALLY spicy, so beware, but I still recommend it anyway. Since I was a teenager l, I get something different almost every time I visit here and am never EVER disappointed. I go with the grandma slice as of lately, but the chicken parm slice is my other go-to. Fantastic service, always friendly, great food and really good atmosphere!

Above average regular pizza. Some really nice specialty pizzas, and incredible garlic knots. This place is just good all around. The delivery drivers are always quick, as well!

Great place to have a slice.. My wife and I had never been there; so we gave it a try. They have a great weekend lunch special: 2 slices and a soda for $5...This is a great deal for the variety of pizza they offer for that price. It’s a great local fixture in the town of sayville. 5 stars!!

Ideal Long Island pizzeria experience. A wonderful place to eat lunch in the heart of Sayville. Very personable workers, not too expensive, top quality pizza, and a classic Italian-style dining room. Sayville Pizza has also introduced me to fried Oreos, and I can confidently say the bar has been set very high

Sayville pizza was amazing! They hand toss there pizza which gives the dough a nice feeling in your mouth. The prices were very resonable, we got a 2 liter of mug cream soda and a large pizza for about 20 bucks!

Had lunch with my friend Lorraine today everything was delicious. First we shared a pepperoni and a spinach pin wheel.( I think that’s what they are called) Then we both had a salad with a nice glass of wine. For my main dish I ordered shrimp Parm and my friend ordered a veal parm. It was so good. The shrimp was so tender and so was the veal. The sauce was finger licking good. It wasn’t my first time there and it won’t be my last. Thank you Sayville pizza.

Brian Donlan eats here. he usually gets the buffalo chicken pizza and mozzarella sticks. says it’s the best pizza on long island!

Pizza was absolutely amazing. Tastiest pizza I've eaten anywhere in New York State. Slightly long wait time, but damn is the food worth it's time and every cent you spent on it.

Me and my daughter have been twice already and will keep coming back. We come from out of town just for this pizza. We always get the Spinach Alfredo and it is the best we have found🥰

At 8:00 pm on Friday. Nice kid works there. Very very nice and made me feel welcome. Pizza a little oily, but very good. Paper plates if your into that...

I'm from the city so I do not like over done or lavishly styled pizza. I like traditional NY Style pizza and that's exactly what the guys in Sayville Pizza offer. I regularly visit there and will continue to do so.

From the moment you walk in, it smells delicious. My husband had baked ravioli and loved it. I had a super fresh house salad and a gluten free pepperoni and fresh mozzarella pie. The gf pie came with it's own wrapped pizza cutter! I was so impressed. Their customer service is phenomenal! They really know what they're doing!

The staff here is extremely generous, the food is amazing, and the atmosphere is as well. I will be going back

Hormuz

Tried for the first time. Buy 1 large regular pie get 1 free. Also tried the cheese calzone. For the price, will definitely try again. Well worth it and quite tasty.

Legend Turner

My new favorite spot. Absolutely delicious, great location and amazing staff

Emma Gilligan

I ordered on doordash two large cheese pizzas and over an hour went by and no one picked it up (fully dordashes problem) and i ended up calling and asking if i could just pick it up myself. The owner gets on the phone and is the sweetest man i’ve ever had the pleasure of speaking with, the man prior to him was so sweet and attentive as well. They were just as upset as me and were like yes please come get it! and we arrive and go in and i tried to tip them and they wouldn’t accept it, gave me a card for money off my next order AND some garlic knots for the inconvenience and i need everyone to know… the pizza was the most amazing pizza i’ve ever had. i recommend 100%!! 10/10. Thank you sayville pizza!!

Diana

Got the mini white pizza and oh my god delicious dough, they have their recipe down. Haven't had anything like it, the cheese is also very good. Amazing garlic knots as well. I highly recommend.

Sharon Holzman

My daughter goes to school in the area, and I found this pizza place on the Slice app when wanting pizza for her class for her birthday. Not only did everyone LOVE the pizza, I can't get over the service. The first year I ordered, I made the mistake and ordered personal pizzas, but they noticed and called me to fix the order. This year, they were running late and were so nice to communicate. My daughter's class and teachers were so happy.

Sophie

I recently did a collaboration with Sayville Pizza. My best friend and I absolutely devoured our margarita pie. It was delicious and just the right size to split with two people! The staff was very friendly and attended to our every need. There’s also plenty of free parking behind the restaurant. It’s decorated very cute and the atmosphere is nice. A perfect little restaurant!

Lauren Oakley

My favorite pizza place! Wonderful customer service and delicious pizza! Every employee is kind and if anything’s ever not right they fix it no problem. Cannot recommend enough!

Melanie Disilvestre

I moved to the area recently and recieved a coupon in the mail for a free cheese pie to try out from this pizzeria. I finally used it today and ordered a cheese pie, zucchini sticks, garlic knots and a house salad. Everything was delicious! The pizza was hot and delicious, fresh, and the salad dressing was SO good. I'm so glad they sent this in the mail or else I wouldn't have even known about the pizzeria. I can't wait to come back.

Donna Johnson

Sayville pizza is my families first stop when we come back to Sayville! They have the best tasting pizza and the best service!

Good pizza. Great atmosphere. Prices moderate. Clean.

The food is always pretty good here. Fried oreos shouldn't be missed.

The owner was friendly and worked hard to be sure I had what I needed. young staff hanging out, apparently getting trained.

The staff here is nice to my kids. That's really important and I appreciate their kindness. Good menu with alot of choices. Clean, safe neighborhood vibe.

Love the pizza. Thought i'd venture out. Delivery was super fast. Future orders however ,will only be for pizza.

It's been a while since I ordered from Sayville Pizza, but I was running errands right nearby and decided to go there for ease. The pizza was much better than the last time - cheese seems to be a higher quality and I like the sauce much more now as well.

The veggie pizza very good. Pepperoni pizza good. They should improve the dough as very thick and bland around edge with no sauce or cheese.

Delicious Buffalo chicken slice, love that it didn't have ranch or blue cheese on it. Hard to find that these days. And my fiance loved their spinach pinwheel.

Timothy Laffin

Order came in time and it was correct. The delivery instructions were followed perfectly.

Robert R

The place is small and you have to walk through a bar to get to the pizzaria . Besides that it is very expensive but the pizza was very good. had good flavor and has taste

George Church

I ordered their special of 10 meals for $50.00. Food was GREAT! Only complain was that most of the meals came without pasta. Think they should include pasta and raise the price to $60.00 or $65.00.

elena rodriguez

Counter person seemed bothered with our questions about the pizza flavors. Pizza was good but could have been a little hotter. The bartender was very nice!

Sue Laci

Haven't been back to this place in years. Dorothy our server was fabulous. We ordered pizza which was good. We ordered calamari as an appetizer, a little disappointed there was no tentacles. Lasagna was good but I like to see a nice square of lasagna. All in all I would go back. Just to see Dorothy and chat with her.

chris amas

I stopped by here for lunch. It is a decent place and the pizza is pretty good. A few things I would suggest is with the BBQ chicken pizza, use less sauce and more cheese. It was a little heavy on the sauce. Also when heating up the pizza, put it in for a little bit longer so the cheese melts. I plan to ask for ut to be extra hot next time I come. Other than that, it was great. The dough is one of the better tasting that I have had and will probably stop by next time I am in the area.

Jay Abra

I ordered delivery on the slice app. We got a coupon deal which was a large pie, wings, garlic knots and a 2 liter of soda for 31.95. The delivery was on time and the food was hot. The pizza and wings were pretty good. I was not a fan of the garlic knots, they were a little tough. Overall a good experience and I would order from again.

Pizza is below average.Go to Tony,s in Bayport, best in town.

I haven't been in years, someone told me it's being run by new owners. It's not as I remember it and just not as good. Expensive hero on lousy bread. The same really uncomfortable straight 90 degree booths, my God how much could it cost to replace them with modern comfortable benches?

I order their boneless barbeque wings they were Tyson wings out of the bag with barbeque sauce poured over them most discusting thing I ever tasted I will never order from here again the pizza not that good either

It's your average pizza place. I was hoping for more especially since this place is a staple in the Sayville community and there was such a buzz of excitement with the new ownership. We got the ala vodka pie and it was a soggy piece of bread with vodka sauce and cheese on it. The chicken parm was just okay. It was a bit mushy so maybe it was overcooked or sat in the container too long. Could be that this place just doesn't do take out that well. But it's probably a decent place to eat in for a quick slice or to get a pie for the kids.

delivery was quick but eggplant parm hero was tasteless. also the bread it was in wasn't toasted

I heard this establishment was under new owners so thought id give a carry out a try... My review is on the Pepperoni pizza alone. you can tell a lot about a pizza place through its Pepperoni pizza. The pizza was fair, however the taste of Pepperoni on the pizza was almost overpowering. Tasted like those frozen pizzas you can get at a supermarket with the Pepperoni ontop and the little Pepperoni squares in the sauce. Other then that the pizza ate like a pizza. Wouldn't recommend Pepperoni pizza here, but hey, what do I know.

found it strange that you're forced to sit down and get served by a waiter. the chicken on the salad was very bland rubbery and looked like it was microwaved from frozen. salad didn't have enough dressing, and was over priced. eggplant parm hero bread was soft and soggy. the pizza behind the counter looked decent but our experience was not good.

Dini Moorhouse

Sayville is darling and charming place. Sayville Pizza has a nice and welcoming staff. Very friendly. Needed Gluten Free Pizza. Happened to be across street so we went in. I mean, we’re in New York so we figured any pizza will be good pizza. Not so. Unfortunately, I cannot say anything good about the Gluten Free Pizza. It was baked to order so I was bewildered when the toppings were barely warm - as was the rest of the pizza. Toppings pre-made and “warmed?” to put on pizza. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Still trying to figure it out. Daughter didn’t love her fresh, hot, regular pizza. Hoping it was just an off day for them. Based on this trip I cannot recommend Sayville Pizza.

Sorry one of the worst sauces I have ever had it was so watered down I just moved into the neighborhood so I wanted to try it never again no flavor at all.

They got my delivery wrong, called them up and they said it was my problem. Kind of rude. Plus the pizza is mediocre, so I just order from another shoppe now.

Your pizza tastes like sweat :(

Went to grab some pizza and the guy making pies didn't even acknowledge me for like 5 minutes and eventually when he seemed annoyed that he had to serve me so I left. Plenty of food choices.

WORST EXPERIENCE EVER! Ordered take out from this place, the delivery man called me yelling as he couldn’t get in my apartment (I could easily buzz him in). I went outside to get the food from him, he proceeded to yell and curse at me and then THROW THE FOOD ON THE GROUND!! What a disgrace. Would never buy from again.

While I appreciate the quick delivery. I noticed a hair on my pie as soon as the box was opened. I will no longer be ordering from this pizza store.

Worst pizza I have ever had. Loaded with pepper...black pepper and sauce tastes worse than Ragu. Disgusting and more expensive than better places in town.

Dirty floors and tables . Managers cursed at staff in front if my children and store full of teenagers. Pizza decent but terrible atmosphere. Will never go again.

Changed hands to new inexperienced pizza makers. Under construction forever. Definitely a place to avoid. Umbertos or Sals!!

Ugh! The only reason I gave any star was because the girls (staff ) were super sweet and worked hard. The specialty pizza was awful, we got 4 different specialty pieces and all were terrible. The garlic knot crusted pizza was burnt on the bottom, definitely would not recommend it.

Do not order from these people. They will take your money, then give you the run around for an hour before telling you that the store is closed at 5pm and there's nothing they can do for you. They honestly expect us to believe that the store was closed at 5pm, despite the order being confirmed AND money being withdrawn from my account. We've been ordering from them on and off for years and it's never been anything but a headache. The pizzas also mediocre at best. Don't waste your time or money or patience on these people. Edit to add: since the owner would like to reply with bullcrap excuses that I can't reply to.. I live in West Sayville. Internet been fine all day long and no one else I know in Sayville has had a problem at all. Matter of fact, I used my internet to order from them. Then they took money from my account through the internet, and CONFIRMED MY ORDER through the internet! So, try again, bud. Now we know you're a liar as well as a thief. Cool.

The people here are extremely rude and cannot follow simple instructions. An ingredient was specifically requested not to be on a pizza but they put it on it anyway. They refused to take it back, replace it, or even apologize. They could have gotten one of their customers sick and they don't care. When a business doesn't care if they kill their own customers, and expect them to pay for the pleasure, you should stay away. Do yourself a favor and find a pizza place to order from that isn't evil.

young girl working counter has horrible attitude and eye rolling for no reason. 3 customers in the store and her and another staff member can't seem to serve everyone correct order. Pizza all looked gross and looks like its been sitting out since the night before. Threw my pizza out was incorrect. Will NEVER come back to this place

Mary Agnes

This is your meatball parm sandwich with a store with several hours before closing. Pathetic. The chicken parm a little better. I had this one in the past and today there is more bread and cheese than meat and only 1/2 the normal portion weight. Not good. Felt cheated. Update: Owner claims a phone call was made which never happened as my phone live & working, my order app shows no phone number attemps nor any adjustments nor did i receive 3 calzones so unless the delivery driver kept a calzone or you are talking about another customer, we only got 2 calzones and 2 subpar heroes. Your story claiming that you contacted us because you didn't have no meatballs falls apart since the photos show a subpar meatball parm sandwich.

Scott Sferrazza

Using Crisco for your focaccia bread and God knows what else gross cheap and not Italian or healthy

Abigail Lenihan

Decent food but delivery takes way too long. The first time I ordered it look almost 2 hours and called the store to ask and got a sassy answer (I’ve seen a lot of responses from the store owner on reviews, I did try to call and speak with someone before posting this review), decided to give the benefit of the doubt and order again, second time the food came over an hour later and cold. Both times I ordered through their website.