Sayville Pizza

Donna Johnson

Sayville pizza is my families first stop when we come back to Sayville! They have the best tasting pizza and the best service!

Timothy Laffin

Order came in time and it was correct. The delivery instructions were followed perfectly.

Robert R

The place is small and you have to walk through a bar to get to the pizzaria . Besides that it is very expensive but the pizza was very good. had good flavor and has taste

George Church

I ordered their special of 10 meals for $50.00. Food was GREAT! Only complain was that most of the meals came without pasta. Think they should include pasta and raise the price to $60.00 or $65.00.

elena rodriguez

Counter person seemed bothered with our questions about the pizza flavors. Pizza was good but could have been a little hotter. The bartender was very nice!

Sue Laci

Haven't been back to this place in years. Dorothy our server was fabulous. We ordered pizza which was good. We ordered calamari as an appetizer, a little disappointed there was no tentacles. Lasagna was good but I like to see a nice square of lasagna. All in all I would go back. Just to see Dorothy and chat with her.

chris amas

I stopped by here for lunch. It is a decent place and the pizza is pretty good. A few things I would suggest is with the BBQ chicken pizza, use less sauce and more cheese. It was a little heavy on the sauce. Also when heating up the pizza, put it in for a little bit longer so the cheese melts. I plan to ask for ut to be extra hot next time I come. Other than that, it was great. The dough is one of the better tasting that I have had and will probably stop by next time I am in the area.

Jay Abra

I ordered delivery on the slice app. We got a coupon deal which was a large pie, wings, garlic knots and a 2 liter of soda for 31.95. The delivery was on time and the food was hot. The pizza and wings were pretty good. I was not a fan of the garlic knots, they were a little tough. Overall a good experience and I would order from again.

delivery was quick but eggplant parm hero was tasteless. also the bread it was in wasn't toasted

Dini Moorhouse

Sayville is darling and charming place. Sayville Pizza has a nice and welcoming staff. Very friendly. Needed Gluten Free Pizza. Happened to be across street so we went in. I mean, we’re in New York so we figured any pizza will be good pizza. Not so. Unfortunately, I cannot say anything good about the Gluten Free Pizza. It was baked to order so I was bewildered when the toppings were barely warm - as was the rest of the pizza. Toppings pre-made and “warmed?” to put on pizza. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Still trying to figure it out. Daughter didn’t love her fresh, hot, regular pizza. Hoping it was just an off day for them. Based on this trip I cannot recommend Sayville Pizza.

Mary Agnes

This is your meatball parm sandwich with a store with several hours before closing. Pathetic. The chicken parm a little better. I had this one in the past and today there is more bread and cheese than meat and only 1/2 the normal portion weight. Not good. Felt cheated. Update: Owner claims a phone call was made which never happened as my phone live & working, my order app shows no phone number attemps nor any adjustments nor did i receive 3 calzones so unless the delivery driver kept a calzone or you are talking about another customer, we only got 2 calzones and 2 subpar heroes. Your story claiming that you contacted us because you didn't have no meatballs falls apart since the photos show a subpar meatball parm sandwich.

Scott Sferrazza

Using Crisco for your focaccia bread and God knows what else gross cheap and not Italian or healthy

Abigail Lenihan

Decent food but delivery takes way too long. The first time I ordered it look almost 2 hours and called the store to ask and got a sassy answer (I’ve seen a lot of responses from the store owner on reviews, I did try to call and speak with someone before posting this review), decided to give the benefit of the doubt and order again, second time the food came over an hour later and cold. Both times I ordered through their website.