H2O: Seafood & Sushi

Food was totally amazing. Very tasteful, I had the flounder which was so good and a nice size. My wife had the salmon also very tasty but much smaller portion. Shrimp cocktail was large and very very fresh. The shrimp and lobster wontons were amazing. The brussel sprouts were a perfect side dish for two. Drinks were average for that kind of establishment. Staff was very helpful friendly and very happy.

Best Happy Hour in town! Our server Jackie was amazing! She recommended several dishes on the happy hour menu that were soo delicious! The Ahi Tuna nachos!! The best! A meal in themselves! Great cocktails too!! Soo reasonable! We sat outside by the fireplaces! Soo cozy! Highly recommend!!

Thanksgiving dinner service and food was excellent. The holiday menu had many options and was priced right. Highly recommend.

H2O Seafood & Sushi is a culinary haven that had us grinning from ear to ear. From the first spoonful of their New England clam chowder, we knew we were in for a treat. Creamy, brimming with tender clams and savory applewood bacon, it was like a warm hug on a chilly evening. The duck tacos, the special of the day, were a revelation! Succulent duck meat danced inside crispy taco shells, a fusion of flavors that burst with every bite. The mango and cilantro toppings were the perfect partners, elevating this dish to culinary genius. And then there was the Starr Roll, a sushi creation that left us dazzled. It was a masterpiece, every bite a tantalizing journey of freshness. The creamy avocado, delicate salmon, and just-right tempura crunch with spicy mayo combined for a symphony of flavors that lingered long after the plate was cleared. The wasabi delivers a powerful, invigorating kick that elevates every bite to a flavor explosion! Our dining experience was made all the more exceptional by our server, Nick. His attentiveness and friendly demeanor added a personal touch that we greatly appreciated. H2O Seafood & Sushi is more than a restaurant; it's a celebration of flavors, an experience to remember. If you're in the mood for the best clam chowder, inventive specials, and sushi that wows, this is your place. A huge thank you to Nick and the entire team for an unforgettable evening!

I am incredibly grateful for this restaurant and the amazing people they employ. My fiancé and I frequent this restaurant with our daughter. The quality and service never waivers. This past Saturday, my bridal shower was held here. It was nothing short of perfect. Everyone raved about the menu and the attention from the staff. Tracey, the manager, made the planning process seamless. On the day of Michael and Sam provided exceptional service with many guests commenting that they seemed like family and earned an invite to the wedding! My bridal shower was perfect because of them. All 3 courses were exceptional. The Bohlsen Restaurant Group is very lucky to employ such wonderful people.

The food here is fantastic. I try and get in here at least once a week. I have never been disappointed with anything. The staff is great, very thoughtful and attentive. Smithtown has some great restaurants but this place is unwavering. I always leave extremely satisfied

We sat at a table in the bar area during Restaurant Week, and despite how busy it was, the bartender Brittney was attentive, friendly, and completely on top of things. She made excellent food recommendations that helped us navigate the Restaurant Week menu, and every suggestion was spot-on. Even with a busy restaurant, service never felt rushed or forgotten. Drinks were great, timing was perfect, and the overall experience was elevated because of their professionalism and genuine hospitality. A standout bartender who made a hectic night feel smooth and enjoyable.

5 stars shouldn't be given lightly 4 of 5 stars should be given when the food is delicious, a little mysterious and leaves you wanting more. 5 of 5 stars should be that good of an culinary experience plus service, service where there is attention to detail and service that makes you feel looked after and important. My cousin dropped his chop stick, it was kicked 3 times and never picked up. Empty plates were ignored and were originally slow to come. Service people were nice and polite but unprofessional. There isn't any coordination, direction, or clear leadership. There is uniformity, in their uniforms, kind of. The decor is nice, the place is clean, the food is good, on par with 2017 New York and what you think it would be. But where is the charm? Where is the extra mile? Where is the service and professionalism of a restaurant striving for 5 of 5 stars It is not clear or present. I don't see it. It's a scene, a cool place to be and maybe the people here don't know any better but their money should go further. My money should go further. Good place to eat on a Friday night but for the money and for the effort, next Friday I will try another place, territory new. Be your own judge, experience your own meal and taste your own drinks and lobster. Life is meant to be lived. Meals are meant to be shared. Figure out how you can make them count and make the most out of them. For without family and food, what is life?

It's been a long time since I've last been here, things have changed and not for the better. The food is decent, but NOT worth the absurd prices. Everything is less than what it used to be and more expensive than it was. Popovers were freely given not to long ago, now $3 each?? Give me a break, man. My husband thought his food was "just alright". The prices they charge for what they produce are scam worthy. Oh, and it was my birthday and all I got was an awkward "happy birthday" by the hostess. Last time I was here it was for my birthday and they gave me a free dessert and a gift card of like 20 bucks. It is safe to say that I got this place out of my system. There's really no reason to return when there are so many better options. If you're rich and have money to burn over mediocre food and service, this is the place for you.

I like the flavor of my food, but the service was really slow. Guy was sincere but he took forever to get drinks. My biggest concern I found two bones in my fish, and they didn’t compensate me even in the smallest way for it. For the price point they have improvement but the flavor of the food was good. They also nickel and dimed me for everything which didn’t impress me. Might give one more chance but it’s an interesting place to try once. Next day: Gave me diarrhea not happy!!!