Long Island Mike's Pizza

The only place outside of NY that has good pizza. The quality is great. Prices and great and they deliver for cheap too. They delivered to my house 3 times however, the last time they told me I was to far to deliver which is upsetting and weird because they did twice before. I still get it whenever I'm in the area which isn't to often but the pizza is always good. Give it a try

Amazing customer service & amazing pizza! We tried a few pizzas along with their lasagna and it was delicious!! It’s a family owned business that goes out of their way to satisfy their customers! Highly recommended! Will be back again! 10/10!! ⭐️

They are now offering individual pizzas. I had the Marguerite pizza and it was delicious! And for dessert I had the cannolis which were also very good. My order was ready when I was told it would be, and the staff are very nice! I use to go in for the slices, but the individual pizza was even better. I will be going more often. I hope they continue the individual pizzas even after the covid lockdown is over.

I absolutely love this place! Their service is so friendly and their pizza and wings are so good. The crust is a legit New York style pizza crust with the extra flour and everything and the wings are perfectly cooked every time. I would highly recommend this place

Incredible customer service! This place goes above & beyond to make sure their customers are happy. On top of that, their ny style pizzas & garlic knots are really tasty!! I’d go out of my way to get pizza here.

Been living in casa-de-oro for 19 years and this is the best pizza I’ve had here yet. The dough and sauce they use is especially good. Would highly recommend! Any of the other reviews that gave 1-2 stars were probably just salty cause they had a bad day or something and they took it out ok Mike’s so go ahead and disregard their review.

Great pizza, just like back on Long Island

This is our go to place for Italian take out. We normally stick to getting the lasagna and/or the grandma’s pie (usually on cauliflower crust) although we have gotten other items and it’s always been great! The garlic cheese bread is AMAZING too. The service is great and I always recommend this place to anyone looking for Italian in east county!

I Am EXTREMELY surprised by the fact th at this place isn’t busy 24 hours and 7 days a week. The pizza is absolutely top tier. Deserves awards and deserves the recognition. I’ve trekked every slice of their pies and they’re all amazing.

We love this place and it’s been our “go to” pizza place for years! The house pie is incredible and they’re always quick, friendly and consistently excellent. The dough and ingredients always taste fresh in any pie we get. Plus no matter what we get, the times they tell for delivery/pick up are always accurate. Great food and customer service at fair prices. What more could you want?!

It's now my favorite pizza place. It has a very good flavor and the sauce is very delicious. I highly recommend this place.

Delicious New York Style Pizza. Not as good as Bronx Pizza. But definitely one of the best around.

The large cheese pizza was enough to feed the kids, and then some. Rave reviews- they dug the super-thin style crust and flavours.

Very good pizza . Completely forgot to take a picture first . My wife loves her NY pizza and she gave this place the thumbs up. Will be back soon!

This pizza is AMAZING! The specialty 🍕 pies all sound soo good. I ordered the margarita today and it was the 💣

Brennan Whitson

This is our go to place for Italian take out. We normally stick to getting the lasagna and/or the grandma’s pie (usually on cauliflower crust) although we have gotten other items and it’s always been great! The garlic cheese bread is AMAZING too. The service is great and I always recommend this place to anyone looking for Italian in east county!

Aurelio Diaz

I Am EXTREMELY surprised by the fact th at this place isn’t busy 24 hours and 7 days a week. The pizza is absolutely top tier. Deserves awards and deserves the recognition. I’ve trekked every slice of their pies and they’re all amazing.

Henry Strong

We love this place and it’s been our “go to” pizza place for years! The house pie is incredible and they’re always quick, friendly and consistently excellent. The dough and ingredients always taste fresh in any pie we get. Plus no matter what we get, the times they tell for delivery/pick up are always accurate. Great food and customer service at fair prices. What more could you want?!

BETILLO619

It's now my favorite pizza place. It has a very good flavor and the sauce is very delicious. I highly recommend this place.

Gregg O'Connell

Delicious New York Style Pizza. Not as good as Bronx Pizza. But definitely one of the best around.

Alyssa Hansen

The large cheese pizza was enough to feed the kids, and then some. Rave reviews- they dug the super-thin style crust and flavours.

Alexander Adame

Very good pizza . Completely forgot to take a picture first . My wife loves her NY pizza and she gave this place the thumbs up. Will be back soon!

Henry & B Lani

This pizza is AMAZING! The specialty 🍕 pies all sound soo good. I ordered the margarita today and it was the 💣

Some of the best New York style pies in town! Super friendly staff who make the pies quick. The white pizza options are all very good, especially the grandma and the pesto pizzas. They have a great meat lovers pizza too with a great red sauce. Our go to pizza place! Family owned with a real friendly owner. Check them out!

I ordered a 28-inch pizza with half pepperoni and sausage, and the other half Canadian bacon with pineapple, for a 3:30 PM pickup. When I arrived, the pizza was hot, fresh, and made exactly to my specifications. This was my third time ordering from this location, and each time my order has been ready right on time. I drive from Pepper Drive in El Cajon just to get this pizza because it's consistently delicious and comes very close to a traditional New York-style pie. Great job to the owner and his team.

Great place to eat and relax. Bring the family have a good time. The pizza is always hot and taste Amazing. They put the extra effort into the presentation and quality. The hot subs are great. Very filling. The Garlic Parmesan Bread has lots of flavor and is not super greasy which is just the way I like it!

We ordered pizza to go. The Deluxe was absolutely the best we’ve had in a long time. Our new favorite pizza place

Love the food and staff at the Campo Rd Long Island Mikes! Everyone is super friendly and efficient. Dinner times can be a bit busier, but I’ve never had an issue getting my pizza on time. There’s not really much atmosphere here, we usually just care about the food though and do takeout. House pie is great, love the Mushroom Mama and the Grandmas as well! Great quality pizza, pricing is well worth it compared to “mainstream” pizza brands. Garlic knots also delicious! So glad to have this restaurant near us.

Stopped by for some pizza to fill in some time... wow.. great thin sliced pizza!! And they have a pool table. Great find !!

great pizza. Honest people. I ordered a XL pizza. and only because the guy had ruined the dough alittle bit, he made another one. He gave us two for the price of one. We told him we didnt mind if the dough got ruined, but he insisted. Great people. Pizza is the best in all Spring Valley.

I picked up some pizza's for dinner not expecting what I was getting. But when the family got into it, they loved it. Try it out for yourself and be your own judge. Thank you Long Island Mike's Pizza.

Dylan Sandelin

Some of the best New York style pies in town! Super friendly staff who make the pies quick. The white pizza options are all very good, especially the grandma and the pesto pizzas. They have a great meat lovers pizza too with a great red sauce. Our go to pizza place! Family owned with a real friendly owner. Check them out!

Paul Steppler

I ordered a 28-inch pizza with half pepperoni and sausage, and the other half Canadian bacon with pineapple, for a 3:30 PM pickup. When I arrived, the pizza was hot, fresh, and made exactly to my specifications. This was my third time ordering from this location, and each time my order has been ready right on time. I drive from Pepper Drive in El Cajon just to get this pizza because it's consistently delicious and comes very close to a traditional New York-style pie. Great job to the owner and his team.

Sandy Waters

Stopped by for some pizza to fill in some time... wow.. great thin sliced pizza!! And they have a pool table. Great find !!

Judy M

We ordered pizza to go. The Deluxe was absolutely the best we’ve had in a long time. Our new favorite pizza place

Michael Tucker

Great place to eat and relax. Bring the family have a good time. The pizza is always hot and taste Amazing. They put the extra effort into the presentation and quality. The hot subs are great. Very filling. The Garlic Parmesan Bread has lots of flavor and is not super greasy which is just the way I like it!

Caroline Roberti

Love the food and staff at the Campo Rd Long Island Mikes! Everyone is super friendly and efficient. Dinner times can be a bit busier, but I’ve never had an issue getting my pizza on time. There’s not really much atmosphere here, we usually just care about the food though and do takeout. House pie is great, love the Mushroom Mama and the Grandmas as well! Great quality pizza, pricing is well worth it compared to “mainstream” pizza brands. Garlic knots also delicious! So glad to have this restaurant near us.

Armando

great pizza. Honest people. I ordered a XL pizza. and only because the guy had ruined the dough alittle bit, he made another one. He gave us two for the price of one. We told him we didnt mind if the dough got ruined, but he insisted. Great people. Pizza is the best in all Spring Valley.

Me and husband tried this pizza for the first time and we were fully satisficed. Best Pizza we've had in a long time, Big NY slices, soo good. Definitely going back for more soon but this time 2 boxes .

Meatball sandwich was good. Different sauce preference.

I'm from Brooklyn so I know new York pizza and I do have to say they come as close as it gets. So yeah for the pizza it's worth it. Reason for the 4 stars is because I got the sausage calzone and it was not that good. But the pizza 5 stars

First time here, usually the kids want Little Caesars across the street. It usually leaves me feeling bloated and regretful for eating a slice. This pizza is the opposite! I ordered a meat lovers for the adults and a regular pepperoni for the kids. We really enjoyed the meat lovers, nice thin crust with good natural flavors. True pizza lovers understand what makes a great pizza: most importantly it’s the crust, then the sauce and finally the toppings. This place hits the marks in the right order. I got a large and medium and it’s was about $3 more than 2 pizzas at little Caesars. Way worth the $, you won’t come away disappointed. And the kids enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. Finally I can share a pizza with the kids!

Quetzal Coatl

First time here, usually the kids want Little Caesars across the street. It usually leaves me feeling bloated and regretful for eating a slice. This pizza is the opposite! I ordered a meat lovers for the adults and a regular pepperoni for the kids. We really enjoyed the meat lovers, nice thin crust with good natural flavors. True pizza lovers understand what makes a great pizza: most importantly it’s the crust, then the sauce and finally the toppings. This place hits the marks in the right order. I got a large and medium and it’s was about $3 more than 2 pizzas at little Caesars. Way worth the $, you won’t come away disappointed. And the kids enjoyed the pepperoni pizza. Finally I can share a pizza with the kids!

Good quality pizza. It just didn't blow my mind, so it's not a 5 star. I would serve this to my family and at parties though. Take out was pretty easy to set up and let me select time slots to schedule the pickup. The pizza was ready on time, and they sent me a text message when it was done. I was already pulling into the lot, so I got it piping hot out of the oven.

Noah Johnston

Good quality pizza. It just didn't blow my mind, so it's not a 5 star. I would serve this to my family and at parties though. Take out was pretty easy to set up and let me select time slots to schedule the pickup. The pizza was ready on time, and they sent me a text message when it was done. I was already pulling into the lot, so I got it piping hot out of the oven.

Pizza was ok, not a fan of the bland crust. The dessert calzone was not good, the filling tasted slightly burnt and the dough was plain and chewy. The cannolis however were very good.

I have mixed feelings about this place. Although the food is good, I've faced a couple of issues. Firstly, their business hours are not updated on Google and most of the time they close early. Secondly, even when they are open during business hours, if I call 30 minutes before they close, they often come up with excuses such as running out of dough. They never try to accommodate us. I'm trying to be fair since we are spending our money here otherwise it's a great pizza.

The pizza is OK, but not my favorite. The crust didn’t have my favorite doughy flavor and the meats were just OK. I had the Meat Lover’s pizza. The spinach salad was also just OK. It had feta, which I don’t like, and the bacon tasted a little unusual - a strange smokey flavor. I didn’t love the dressing, either. Garlic knots were ok but again, the dough wasn’t my favorite and they didn’t have a strong garlic flavor.

This place has the best gluten free pizza. However I’ve been ordering for about 6 years and the last 2 years once in a while when I or my husband has called to order there is one lady that says they can’t do split pies on gluten free pies. Which is a lie because I’ve been ordering like this for 6 years. In usually order the Italian Flag and Deluxe or Veg. This has made us not want to even call and order when we would totally order probably more often. They are loosing out on business because of this. Please train all staff to have consistency. I gave a 3 star because of the service situation. The gluten free pizza is the best though when it comes to take out. I’ll be happy to change this to 5 star when some consistency happens. Or actually put it on the menu so it’s clear that you don’t offer this or put it on there that you do. So we can show the staff.

Laura Lemus

This place has the best gluten free pizza. However I’ve been ordering for about 6 years and the last 2 years once in a while when I or my husband has called to order there is one lady that says they can’t do split pies on gluten free pies. Which is a lie because I’ve been ordering like this for 6 years. In usually order the Italian Flag and Deluxe or Veg. This has made us not want to even call and order when we would totally order probably more often. They are loosing out on business because of this. Please train all staff to have consistency. I gave a 3 star because of the service situation. The gluten free pizza is the best though when it comes to take out. I’ll be happy to change this to 5 star when some consistency happens. Or actually put it on the menu so it’s clear that you don’t offer this or put it on there that you do. So we can show the staff.

I ordered in advance through the Yelp app, but it did not go through to the store. Needless to say, the pizzas were not ready. I had employees and customers waiting and it wasn’t a good outcome.

Steven Boysan Kane

I ordered in advance through the Yelp app, but it did not go through to the store. Needless to say, the pizzas were not ready. I had employees and customers waiting and it wasn’t a good outcome.

I had seen the Casa De Oro location in passing a few times, and finally decided to put in an order for a large deluxe. Called in at 4PM before starting to drive home, was told 20-25 minutes. Cool, it should be ready by the time I get there. I get there 40 minutes later, and discover that the order was never printed, so nothing has even been started. Not cool. Cashier says, 'You wouldn't mind waiting for it to be ready, right?' 'So... ANOTHER half hour?' 'Nah, like, 20-25 minutes...' That's a half hour on top of the 40 minutes already wasted, for a total of almost an hour and a half for a pizza that was supposed to take 20 minutes. I cancelled my order and left after that. I don't recommend going here unless you have spare time for the restaurant to waste.

Craved a slice of pizza, when I Googled places this place was the 1st place recommended. Drove 5 miles, only to be told that's an old menu. Sorry! How am I supposed to know this is an old menu when it's on the internet. Google the next place less than 2 miles from my house Yay! They had slices. I called first

I had an order worth up to 100 dollars and let me tell you that everyone should avoid this place. The dessert calzone was so horrible and rubbery, garlic knots were so flavorless, and the pizza tasted really bad. Their version of a Margherita pizza is a disgrace to a real Margherita pizza. Meatball sub was good tho. Wasted a 100 here and will never see it again.

Today I went there and got two pies. The lady at the front was rude and charged me $19.00 per pie instead of $18.00 like the menu on the wall said. I tried to politely explain that you have to charge the advertised price but she told me that she charged what her "system" tells her to. I got frustrated and raised my voice becoming agitated by her not understanding where I was coming from. A man making the pizza heard this and came from around back, telling her to refund the difference. I don't like being the bad guy, and she shouldn't have made me push the issue. Otherwise the order was fast and pizza was good. Please update your menu prices to avoid this situation. Went there again, same story, over charged me and I went through the same back a forth about being fair and charging the price on the menu. They are ridiculous, rude and fraudulent.Don't shop here, buy pizza at Gaetanos, at least they will charge you the menu price and the pizza will be better.

Im sorry, i ordered 1 peperoni, 1 cheese pizza and chicken wings, the wings were not bad but the pizza wasn't very good, the whole crust was soggy, cheese was very salty, I'm not trying to be mean, just truthful

Not at all what I expected after reading their ratings. The pizza thin and greasy. I could have got better at Little Cesar's and paid $15.00 less. I do not recommend this place. If you want a good pizza go to either Felipe's or La Bellas.

This place is ran by a family. Really good pizza. I get the gluten free crust. Great taste, fresh.

Deanna Rickrode

This place is ran by a family. Really good pizza. I get the gluten free crust. Great taste, fresh.