Freshly made, you can taste the quality. The service was fast and the food was great, Will be my spot whenever in the area. I had a gluten-free pizza with grilled chicken, amazing!

Rosa Cicero

I just placed an order for dinner for the family, hands down the best panini‘s we’ve ever eaten in our lives! Amazing food! Thank you Palermo pizza!!

Steven N

Ordered here last week for a family dinner, got a variety of entrees from pizza, salad, soup and sandwiches. Everything was hot and fresh, I would definitely go back and try some of their pasta and pizza options. If you need a reliable quick bite so far this pizzeria seems like the go to in the area. Will be visiting again soon thank you!

Patrick Rooney

They have some great pizza here and I had one of the best sausage Parmesan heroes I’ve ever had in my life ! I just updated my review. I’m sitting with one of the best plates of calamari I’ve ever had It’s hard to get this right and Angelica just hit another home run but she hit the ball out of the park with this one !!!! October 3 2025 tried the mussels and linguine a pallet extravaganza, unbelievable sauce probably the best I’ve ever had ! I have a lot of reviews on Google but I have to keep updating this one because it just keeps getting better and better this was an absolutely amazing meal !!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

+1

surgical reconstruction

Just did my 3rd catering order from Palermo’s on Page Ave, Staten Island. The food is ridiculous. Everytime, my guests raved over the food. Did 3 foot hero’s of chicken cutlet with vodka sauce and their grilled chicken with pesto. The Frutta di Mar is a must have. There’s so much succulent seafood in that dish that they have to Saran Wrap it, for fear it’ll pop out. First time I’ve ever found myself eating Caesar's Salad like I’m eating a steak. Outrageously delicious. One gripe - no meat dishes for catering. Was hoping for a steak pizzaiola. I get it, keeping steak on the menu is expensive, and may not be worth it business wise. But I could only imagine how delicious a steak pizzaiola would be if you made it! This place is by far the best to cater from on the south shore….and I’ve ordered from so many. Really amazing food.

Phil Gill

Our dining experience at Palermo Pizza was absolutely outstanding from start to finish! What began as a visit to a pizza place turned into a full culinary adventure that surpassed all expectations. We started with their delicious pasta fazool soup - a perfect blend of beans, pasta, and savory broth that set the tone for the meal. The appetizers were incredible - both the fried ravioli and calamari were crispy on the outside and tender inside, perfectly executed and seasoned. That summer salad deserves its own paragraph! It was so amazing we nearly had a friendly dispute over who would get the last bite. I ultimately let my friend, who owns FC CHAOS BOXING, have the final taste - sometimes it's wise to be generous, especially with someone in the boxing business! For main courses, we enjoyed the signature Sal Special sandwich with its amazing combination of fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers finished with a balsamic glaze. The lasagna was perfection - layers of pasta, cheese, and sauce in perfect harmony. We also tried their rica ball special (a delightful surprise) and believe it or not, a cheeseburger that would make dedicated burger joints jealous! Who would think a pizza place could excel at so many different dishes? The service matched the quality of the food, and the atmosphere was inviting and comfortable throughout our visit. Palermo Pizza isn't just a pizza place - it's a destination for food lovers looking for authentic Italian cuisine and unexpected delights. Can't wait to return!

+37

Francine Laura

I heard a lot of good things about Palermo Pizza in Tottenville so I had to check it out for myself! As the name suggests, they are Sicilian and they serve some of my favorite Sicilian specialties like panelle (chickpea fritters), arancine (rice balls) and sfincione (a specialty pizza, to die for). They started us off with a basket of their focaccia - which we were not expecting! We ordered the Palermo Antipasto platter (panelle, arancine & potato croquettes) and then shared the Grandma Pie with a sesame crust. Everything was delicious! And we have leftovers (which always makes me happy). We will definitely be going back. I must have the sfincione….and the Nutella zeppole!

+5

Kim R. Salik

Absolutely the "best" Italian Restaurant that we've ever ordered from! We never had the pleasure of dining in the restaurant, but we stop by and order take out, everytime we're in Staten Island. The atmosphere is a beautiful Italian setting, which sets just the right mood. The service is excellent, whether dining in or taking out. All the staff are very professional and courteous and they service their guests as a V.I.P.. The food is plentiful, of great taste and seasoned with authentic Italian ingredients, that goes beyond satisfying your taste buds! Truly The "Best" Place To Visit! We Definitely Recommend!

harvey bird

Took my son, daughter, and about 15 of their friends there to eat for their birthday after going to Fastbreak. I called the day before to let them know we were planning on coming there to eat. The tables were all set up when they got their and the staff was very helpful and patient. The pizza and wings were very good. My wife and I ordered a salad and a grilled chicken with vegetables platter. The salad was huge, and the chicken amd veggies were cooked perfectly. We really enjoyed the experience. We were there for two hours, and we never once felt rushed or like we were overstaying our welcome.

Robin B

I ordered a hero platter for our Super Bowl party, and it was absolutely delicious! The sandwiches were fresh, packed with flavor, and generously filled. Everyone at the party kept raving about how good they were! The presentation was great, and the order was ready on time. Highly recommend for any gathering—will definitely be ordering again!