Wagon Wheel

Perfect, classic pizza. The kind (and price!) you remember from childhood.

Great old school pizza joint, great pizza, what else do you want?

Peter is great! Food was amazing service was great also! Must try pie shop.

love this place. great food (pizza, subs, etc). friendly owner. no complaints at all.

Amazing pizza. Pete is the warmest host. Wappingers gem!

It is the closest thing to Westchester / Bronx style pizza in dutchess county. Thin crust pizza is amazing.

Pizza was mad good. Guy was super friendly. 10/10 would eat again

Great place!!! I highly recommend. Pete's literally the best human ever!

Best pizza in town! So happy to have found this place

This is real tasting pizza!!! It was delicious Owner was very nice.

Hands down the best pizza in town!! Reasonably priced as well

Super friendly owner with great food, compfy and low key :))

Amazing pizza! Chicken cutlet pizza, all the way!

Pizza has that old New York taste really the best around

Great Pizza the crust the sauce delicious old school Italian pizzeria

Best slices in Dutchess County!

I promise you you won’t find a better plain pie in town. 10/10

Best Pizza in the Village. Period!!

Great pizza!!! I highly recommend!

Best local pizza in the Wappinger area

Gotta be the best pizza around here.

Best pizza in the village. It’s the only place my kids want to go for pizza. He makes a decent salad. I usually order the eggplant parm sandwich and I’d say it’s the best eggplant parm that I’ve had since I moved to New York in 2018.

Folks moved us to W.F. when I was born in '73. Grew up from then on with Wagon Wheel as a family staple of what pizza/Italian dishes should be- best around. Move back here in my late 40's- hasn't changed, the sauce & dough👍. Still the best around and wouldn't go anywhere else, cuz pizza.

This is a staple in the Village of Wapp. Awesome pizza and the nostalgic atmosphere of an 80's pizzeria. Dine in or take out. Great prices.

Great food, especially the pizza crust and tomato sauce. Great welcoming atmosphere; tons of comedic signs on the walls. And great customer service.

Great pizza, great prices and the owner is a solid , good guy from what I can tell . I usually eat here 2-3 times a month If not more. If I had one criticism it would be that they need to sell soda /drinks by the bottle I believe there is only fountain drinks available.

Undoubtedly the best local pizza with that classic-old school pizza place vibe to it. The pizza was amazing & the owner is a real nice guy!

Great local place. I've been going there since I was a kid. Best fresh baked pizza around. Fresh ingredients, Not frozen or extremely processed. The owner makes every pie.

The past month I've eaten at 14 different pizzerias from fishkill,east fishkill,beacon, wappingers and poughkeepsie. None compare to this. Pizza has the right amount of crisp. No FLOP. It's not oily and dripping everywhere. Oh and I only paid $11.50 for a large cheese pie.

We stopped by for slices on a Friday night at around 10pm. The pizza was pretty good and the dough was perfect! The owner was very friendly and accommodating

I have sampled all the pizza nearest me, except Eddies Gourmet Pizza, and of all the pizza joints I’ve been to, Wagon Wheel has the best pizza near me. I love the crust. I love the sauce. Wagon Wheel has the best pizza in Wappingers. Hands down!!!!!

As long as I've had money I've gone to wagon wheel pizzaria. I don't even live here anymore, but when I visit I make sure to stop in for a pizza. The owner and the attitude that comes with him has also been a proud product of this state's tradition. It was the only spot open when the power went out; with a lantern and the gas oven going. If you're a yuppy, go to Frank's. Wagon wheel is more than New York pizza, it's the pizza of New York.

Pizza is priced well but cash only. Owner is chill nice to speak with. Doesn't look like much when you walk in, but it's very tasty.

Great pizza, great owner! I come from out of town because it’s that good!

Such a classic landmark pizza joint that is always so good. Always crispy and great sauce. I have been going in here since I was little!

Really good pizza!!!!!!!! Affordable, friendly, straight up!! Nice quiet place to hang out for a minute. One of my favorite things about living in Wappingers Falls!

Delicious pizza, friendly staff, family run for 50+ years!

Love Wagon Wheel, one of my favorite pizza places as a kid and have to get Wagon Wheel every time I come back to visit. The pizza is as great now as it was then

Stop in after cornhole game. Pizza was amazing!! I’m a Bronx girl and been up here 15 years…can’t believe I didn’t try sooner!!

Will always be my favorite pizza shop. The owner is great and the pizza is amazing.

Everything about this pizza is delicious. The dough, cheese and sauce. It’s like eating a slice from Brooklyn. I love this place.

Actually had the pizza at "Coup" the champagne bar next door. There is a pass thru in the wall for pizza. Great atmosphere.

Love this place owner Pete is awesome Pizza is fantastic would highly recommend and very reasonably priced they have other things besides pizza and they have take out.

Great pizza!! Thin crust, tasty sauce..old school Brooklyn style. Highly recommend!

Great pizza and dinners, too. Owner very pleasant and friendly. Nice homey neighborhood feeling. Great value.

Our go-to pizza spot. Friendly service, and great price. Comparable to the so-famous NYC pizza.

ive been coming here for the past 25years .best pizza ever

I just moved to Wappingers from the city. I moved from the bronx and I needed a pizza place to provide that home feeling. Wagon Wheel Pizza is that place. Awesome pizza. Delicioso.

Amazing owner. Foods greet, and the prices are better than most of the pizza places in the area.

I've only had plain pies from here and never anything else on the menu but I would definitely say this place makes some good pizza. Cooked perfectly and the sauce was great. Give this place a try !

I love the village feel of the place. Plus Pete is just a real stand up guy. Food is always hot, not greasy, exceptional value! Just wish he'd make me a calzone 😆.

Pleasantly surprised! Discovered the Wagon Wheel on my way to another (unnamed) pizza place. Pizza was flavorful, the crust was nice and crispy. Definitely will return.

First time eating here and OMG!!! The Sicilian with extra cheese was AWESOME!!! The cheese was REAL GOOEY TASTY CHEESE!!! Not that cheese that looks translucent especially when it gets cold!!! The dough was so tasty!! I usually throw the crust away because it’s dry or hard or burnt!!! BUT NOT this crust!!! It was AMAZING!!! crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside.. very very tasty!!! Will definitely be back for another pie!!!

I don’t know why, but the kids wanted to try Dominos Pizza; I haven’t had it myself in 20 years and said OK. Well, it was a mistake. Afterwards everyone agreed Wagon Wheel makes the best old school pizza.

The Wagon Wheel restaurant has been in downtown Wappingers Falls for a very long time. This landmark is a classic no frills restaurant that gets straight to the point. The owner Pete makes really good pizza. Simple, not gourmet pizza, the way they used to make it and still do 40 years later. The crust is crispy, not soggy like the other place that's across the street. His pizza sauce has just the right amount of herbs, sweetness and tang. He is not shy with the toppings either. The prices for his pizza are extremely affordable so you'll get more than your monies worth. The Wagon Wheel also makes delicious pastas that you'll need a box to take the rest home. Generous portions from an owner with a generous heart to serve the best pizza and pasta to his loyal and new customers. Pete's mission is to give his customers the best quality food for the best price. Stop in and try the best pizza anywhere. You'll be glad you did. When I'm back in Wappingers Falls I'll be headed to Wagon Wheel pizza for a walk down memory lane. Until next time.

Great prices, friendly, but most importantly, fantastic food! Best pizza I've had in the area. Meatball wedge was also amazing.

Sean Motise

The Wagon Wheel restaurant has been in downtown Wappingers Falls for a very long time. This landmark is a classic no frills restaurant that gets straight to the point. The owner Pete makes really good pizza. Simple, not gourmet pizza, the way they used to make it and still do 40 years later. The crust is crispy, not soggy like the other place that's across the street. His pizza sauce has just the right amount of herbs, sweetness and tang. He is not shy with the toppings either. The prices for his pizza are extremely affordable so you'll get more than your monies worth. The Wagon Wheel also makes delicious pastas that you'll need a box to take the rest home. Generous portions from an owner with a generous heart to serve the best pizza and pasta to his loyal and new customers. Pete's mission is to give his customers the best quality food for the best price. Stop in and try the best pizza anywhere. You'll be glad you did. When I'm back in Wappingers Falls I'll be headed to Wagon Wheel pizza for a walk down memory lane. Until next time.

J McQ

Great prices, friendly, but most importantly, fantastic food! Best pizza I've had in the area. Meatball wedge was also amazing.

By far the best pizza in town nice crispy crust with flavorful sauce and good cheese. Owner is super friendly. I highly recommend ….prices are great also.☺️

This was our first time at Wagon Wheel, but it was definitely the best pizza in the region! Crust was perfect, sauce was homemade and not too spicy, high-quality ingredients and all for a great price. Pete offered great, personal service and the restaurant is family friendly. Bring cash; no credit cards. Great pizza, Pete! We will definitely be back.

Peter is the man. Haven’t had this great of a pizza in many years. We came in and Peter had a perfect pepperoni pizza ready within 20 mins. Perfect crisp, perfect thickness, perfect sauce and cheese. I highly recommend this place. I would come here again. Thanks Pete !!!!

Hands down the best pizza in Wappinger. Pete is a great guy who runs a clean, well-organized shop and takes pride in serving consistently delicious pizza. Fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and friendly service make this place a local favorite.

Awesome pizza, every slice is guaranteed to be delicious. Great prices. The owner, Pete is such a great guy. Hands down, best pizza in Wappingers.

Multi generation real deal quality Pizza that only existed long ago! The owner makes his own dough and sauce each morning. Not the oily cardboard stuff we've learned to accept. Tastes amazing!!! Can't get enough...

The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order. We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste. They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.

I went here with my uncle about 7 years ago & I still haven't stopped telling people how this place had the best pizza I ever had & how awsome the owner was! I hope to visit yall again sooner than later!

The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!

Cheers to Wagon Wheel Pizza and Pete the owner who couldn't have been nicer when we placed a large order for our wedding after party. He worked with us to revise our order a few times and kept us updated on its status. Needless to say it is the best pizza in the area. Our only problem is we should have ordered more!

We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.

I am in my 50's and remember my mom bringing me to the Wagon Wheel as a very young boy after she made her trip to the Mid Hudson Savings Bank on Mill St. I think the interior has remained the same through the years. Pete makes excellent pizza. You can also purchase fresh pizza dough to make at home (also excellent!)

Now his pizza is the Best. Every Pizza is really good but his is different has a unique style with lots of good toppings my favorite is pepperoni it's really good and delicious yum... My 9 year old Ramsey

HANDS DOWN AMAZING PIZZA! When you walk into the place your like um what the heck did I walk into....... One pizza oven, one guy, pizza made to order this isn't gonna be good BUT let me say I've eaten at many pizzerias up and down the east coast. Wagon Wheel Pizza is easily in top 3 if not the BEST!!! I was literally in shock and blown away by how good it was. I'll be back here many many times!!! Keep it up Pete!!!

No other pizzeria could compare! This family run place is always kind and welcoming to customers new and old. The pizza itself is so fresh, and made right in front of you. The crust is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and the sauce is nothing like other places. Would highly recommend coming here! Heads up: cash-only! Yes, atm is available.

Best pizza in Dutchess County

What a find! Our group was in town for a cross country meet and after reading the great reviews we decided to give Wagon Wheel a try. First, the owner (Pete) is extremely kind, professional and went above and beyond for us. When I went in to place the order it was so nice to learn it was a multi generation business and his father handmade all of the tables and booths. We ordered 10 pizzas and probably should have ordered 20 since it was some of the best we have ever had. Thank You! We look forward to coming back the next time we are in town.

Alice Mauch

By far the best pizza in town nice crispy crust with flavorful sauce and good cheese. Owner is super friendly. I highly recommend ….prices are great also.☺️

Anita S

What a find! Our group was in town for a cross country meet and after reading the great reviews we decided to give Wagon Wheel a try. First, the owner (Pete) is extremely kind, professional and went above and beyond for us. When I went in to place the order it was so nice to learn it was a multi generation business and his father handmade all of the tables and booths. We ordered 10 pizzas and probably should have ordered 20 since it was some of the best we have ever had. Thank You! We look forward to coming back the next time we are in town.

John Gomez

Peter is the man. Haven’t had this great of a pizza in many years. We came in and Peter had a perfect pepperoni pizza ready within 20 mins. Perfect crisp, perfect thickness, perfect sauce and cheese. I highly recommend this place. I would come here again. Thanks Pete !!!!

Dave Scott

This was our first time at Wagon Wheel, but it was definitely the best pizza in the region! Crust was perfect, sauce was homemade and not too spicy, high-quality ingredients and all for a great price. Pete offered great, personal service and the restaurant is family friendly. Bring cash; no credit cards. Great pizza, Pete! We will definitely be back.

Daniel Horwith

Awesome pizza, every slice is guaranteed to be delicious. Great prices. The owner, Pete is such a great guy. Hands down, best pizza in Wappingers.

John Ciccone

Hands down the best pizza in Wappinger. Pete is a great guy who runs a clean, well-organized shop and takes pride in serving consistently delicious pizza. Fresh ingredients, perfect crust, and friendly service make this place a local favorite.

Arcadia

I went here with my uncle about 7 years ago & I still haven't stopped telling people how this place had the best pizza I ever had & how awsome the owner was! I hope to visit yall again sooner than later!

Alex Basile

Multi generation real deal quality Pizza that only existed long ago! The owner makes his own dough and sauce each morning. Not the oily cardboard stuff we've learned to accept. Tastes amazing!!! Can't get enough...

Bronx Bomer Pito !!

Now his pizza is the Best. Every Pizza is really good but his is different has a unique style with lots of good toppings my favorite is pepperoni it's really good and delicious yum... My 9 year old Ramsey

Maddalena Petrillo

I love the village feel of the place. Plus Pete is just a real stand up guy. Food is always hot, not greasy, exceptional value! Just wish he'd make me a calzone 😆.

Jacob Rheinstein

Cheers to Wagon Wheel Pizza and Pete the owner who couldn't have been nicer when we placed a large order for our wedding after party. He worked with us to revise our order a few times and kept us updated on its status. Needless to say it is the best pizza in the area. Our only problem is we should have ordered more!

Daryl Thorpe

Pleasantly surprised! Discovered the Wagon Wheel on my way to another (unnamed) pizza place. Pizza was flavorful, the crust was nice and crispy. Definitely will return.

Julie Truncali

The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!

Fernando DaCunha

We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.

DaDa

The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order. We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste. They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.

Louis Jansen

HANDS DOWN AMAZING PIZZA! When you walk into the place your like um what the heck did I walk into....... One pizza oven, one guy, pizza made to order this isn't gonna be good BUT let me say I've eaten at many pizzerias up and down the east coast. Wagon Wheel Pizza is easily in top 3 if not the BEST!!! I was literally in shock and blown away by how good it was. I'll be back here many many times!!! Keep it up Pete!!!

Robert Stoffel

I am in my 50's and remember my mom bringing me to the Wagon Wheel as a very young boy after she made her trip to the Mid Hudson Savings Bank on Mill St. I think the interior has remained the same through the years. Pete makes excellent pizza. You can also purchase fresh pizza dough to make at home (also excellent!)

I local Pizza place good prices and good pizza

Good food, good prices.

Love this pizza. Great flavor and prices. Not to mention their pizzas are ready quick!!

Awesome local spot for a good slice. Prices are unmatched, 4.5 stars if I could. Keep it up!

Delicious toppings and pizza. Real food, not like the typical artificial chain food factories: Papa John's, Applebee's, McDogfood...

Good pizza, good flavor. And the owner is very pleasant and offers good conversation.

Great pizza and great cheesy garlic bread. I wish they took credit cards though.

If you're craving thin-crust pizza reminiscent of Bronx pizza shops, Wagon Wheel has a Pie for you. Decor inside looks like a time machine back to early 80's and the Pizza is no-nonsense with the perfect crisp, snap when you take a bite. Prices are also some of the best around. My large Pie was $10. Lastly, Wagon Wheel is Cash-Only.

The pizza was worthy of the Bronx truly old school pizza place you can watch them make the pizza and toss it in front of you while you sit at the counter or at your booth. The night we went it was just the owner and he did it all made the pizza and waited the tables. The pizza was delicious and sauce had nice flavor, the crust was crispy and not to thick nor to thing and folded perfectly.

Ralph Tony Francisco

The pizza was worthy of the Bronx truly old school pizza place you can watch them make the pizza and toss it in front of you while you sit at the counter or at your booth. The night we went it was just the owner and he did it all made the pizza and waited the tables. The pizza was delicious and sauce had nice flavor, the crust was crispy and not to thick nor to thing and folded perfectly.

Good pizza, great people

good pizza and owner is nice too.

The owner Pete is so nice my daughter and I wanted a couple slices each and he made a fresh pie for us just four slices thanks Pete

Cheap Pizza and you get what you pay for. It's like he doesn't care if he stays in business.

wasemt open when they close. when they want to

Terrible pizza awful service

Just don’t make any food it’s taste nasty never gone back it’s really makes me sick closed the place down

I just tried to make it order and the owner was very rude. The website says they close at 11p and I tried to make it order at 9:30. When I said I'd like to make a order for pickup and want a square pizza, he was short and said they were closing in 10 minutes and he's not making a square pizza. Extremely short and rude. Bad experience