Menü
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Webster

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

★★★★ 4.0 · 100 reseñas

Bienvenidos a Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, vuestro rincón italiano en Webster. Aquí encontraréis pizzas creativas con una infinidad de ingredientes frescos, alitas deliciosas y auténticos bocadillos italianos, todo preparado con cariño y siguiendo recetas tradicionales. Os...

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Pizza · Webster

4.0 · 398 Bewertungen Google
www.salvatores.com

Über Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Bienvenidos a Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, vuestro rincón italiano en Webster. Aquí encontraréis pizzas creativas con una infinidad de ingredientes frescos, alitas deliciosas y auténticos bocadillos italianos, todo preparado con cariño y siguiendo recetas tradicionales. Os invitamos a disfrut...

Bienvenidos a Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, vuestro rincón italiano en Webster. Aquí encontraréis pizzas creativas con una infinidad de ingredientes frescos, alitas deliciosas y auténticos bocadillos italianos, todo preparado con cariño y siguiendo recetas tradicionales. Os invitamos a disfrutar de una experiencia culinaria única en un ambiente cálido y familiar.

Was Kunden über Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria sagen

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Webster is known for its flavorful pizza, generous toppings, and friendly staff. Customers rave about the pizza sauce and Italian sausage. Some have experienced issues with dry wings and inconsistent quality.

Beliebte Gerichte

pizza (11) wings (5) fish and chips Calzone meatball sub eggplant parmesan sub

Ideal für

Familien Gruppen Einheimische Zwanglos Schnell

Tip: Tip the staff in cash as there is no tip option on the credit card machine.

Services

🌳 Terrasse 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner 🥗 Vegetarian
🎯 Casual 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Sehenswürdigkeiten in der Nähe

Webster Grange No. 436
Kulturerbe
A 546m

Webster Grange No. 436

edificio

Details ansehen

Daten von Wikidata

Häufig gestellte Fragen zu Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria befindet sich in 195 North Ave, Webster, NY 14580, Webster.
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria bietet pizza Küche.
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria hat regelmäßige Öffnungszeiten. Aktuelle Zeiten finden Sie im Profil.
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria bietet folgende Dienste: vor Ort essen, zum Mitnehmen, Lieferung.
Die am meisten empfohlenen Gerichte bei Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria laut Kundenbewertungen sind: pizza, wings, fish and chips, Calzone, meatball sub.
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria ist ideal für Familien, Gruppen, Einheimische, Zwangloses Essen, Schnell essen.
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Webster is known for its flavorful pizza, generous toppings, and friendly staff. Customers rave about the pizza sauce and Italian sausage. Some have experienced issues with dry wings and inconsistent quality.
Tip the staff in cash as there is no tip option on the credit card machine.
398
Bewertungen

Bewertungen von Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Webster

4.0
398
5★
55%
4★
21%
3★
8%
2★
7%
1★
9%
Bewertungen (100)
J
James Petro

Kudos for doing what you do for the community and now honoring our Veterans. Thank you. Your service is exceptional as well as your food and quality. Your establishments are clean and inviting.

N
Natalie Tome

Absolutely amazing food and service. The employees are all so friendly. If I dine in, pick up, or get delivery everything is always great and fast.

E
Elthros

The sheet pizza is always perfect, and it even tastes good when re-heated the next day, nice and crunchy. The only pizza that re-heats good, great place!

B
Benjamin Hauser

Staff is friendly. Food is great and always get fast delivery when I can't go pick it up. Bar is nice of you want a drink and to watch a game on the tv

M
Melissa Gurney

Their gluten free pizza is sooo good! Love that I could pick up something delicious for both me and my husband who is not gluten free.

A
Anita C

Delicious pizza! Happy cashier! Clean!

A
Allen Pickard

Had a chicken Charly slice of pizza, very good, alot of varieties, that u can choose from at lunch time.

d
dale griswold

Love ordering from this location. The food is always hot and ready. The service is fantastic and the people are always welcoming and smiling.

P
Peter Satter

You can't go wrong the pies are amazing try the chicken charlie or the meat head you can't go wrong. 😋 Yum

j
jordan leavitt

Great pizza and wings and a nice atmosphere. They're even expanding their bar, big parking lot and lots of seating, all around a good experience.

C
Clare Schreiber

I brought my granddaughter to Webster’s store and the cook brought out 2 heart shaped cheese pizzas! Wonderful service and great pizza!

M
Michael Kennedy

Love Salvatore's Pizza! The best is the New York 19 in with cup and Char pepperoni. best pizza ever!

J
JWR

Very nice slices for lunch, highly recommended.

L
Leah Petronio

I go here a lot and order food for pickup. They are always on time when I pick up my food. Everything I've ordered is great. The garlic bread is amazing. Great gluten free pizza.

S
Susan Woods

Absolutely love the food, and service. Parking is easy, choices are good, as with any pizza place now, prices are high as they are everywhere. But I go there frequently and will continue to do so.

D
Dave Hergert

Our go-to pizza place in Fairport. Sure we try other pizza places to change it up, but Salvatore's is the most consistent one we choose. I use the online ordering exclusively and it works really well, can easily apply pizza perks to get free stuff.

J
John Yanklowski

The last time we went the pizza was great, they have beers on tap, a great place to eat! This time we ordered subs to go and they were great as well!

M
Michael Welych

Really nice place. Prices were moderate and the staff very friendly and also helpful. Food was very good too. Cool thing was for the month of March, a percentage of the price was donated to breast can er research.

S
Steve R.

Great pizza and you can't beat the sheet. Thick-edged soft crust, large generous toppings, plentious cheese, tasty sauce, repeatedly timely delivery, and at a very good price ($20 as of December 2016 for the mozarella & sauce sheet, plus $3 for regular toppings, e.g. pepperoni and $6 for premium toppings, e.g. supreme, plus to-go 2-liter 'No Coke. Pepsi.' products at $2.69 each). I was also pleasantly surprised to find my large nearby company received an additional 10% courtesy discount. Staff is helpful. This is a nice location in the village of Webster with ample parking, decorative outdoor lighting and a full-service 8 seat bar to complement their 15 table dining room and seasonally available outdoor seating.

C
Chris Thiel

This is one of the nicer Salvatore locations. Love the vibe inside. We grabbed some great fresh pizza slices, and like usual they were huge 1/4 slices.

M
M G

Huge slices and was in and out in 4 mins ..

B
Ben

This is my local Salvatore's, I have been going here for years and have never received bad service or bad food. Everybody is always very friendly and they have great selection of food as well as a fully stocked bar.

J
Jon C

Clean facility, good seating, and pretty good pizza. Not brick oven Their pre-made panini italian sandwich (that is like a pizza slice) is AMAZING! Meathead pizza slice is VG as well! They do know how to charge $ tho

D
Daniel Amos

Home of the Super Slice. Man can it get any better. In my opinion Salvatores is the best pizza around. And this location supercedes even that. Topping pour off your slice to where your full even before you take your first bite. Keep up the awesome work

B
Bryan Terry

Pizza was well cooked. Wings were great too. Great place. I'll definitely be back. This is my new go-to pizza and wings place in Webster. I enjoyed a beer while I waited. Good on tap selection.

s
sherry Brown

We are in town for a short visit and decided to stay in so we ordered delivery. We both had fish. It was delicious! We usually don't have dessert well we did the peanut butter pie and the cheesecake was to die for! Thank you for the great experience!

N
Nick Benge

The pizza and subs are always great! This location always looks very neat and clean! Definitely a good manager and crew here.

J
Joe Glover

The Steak Boomba Pizza tasted amazing! Thank you!

C
C D

I get delivery every time I order. Never have they been late and the pizza is perfectly cooked as always. Love this place.

J
Jess

i love this place! awesome pizza and an even more awesome staff. they so many different options so there is definitely something for everyone. they even have a full bar!🍺 also amazing white pizza—the best in town— (made with fresh ingredients-you can taste it!) even the cheeseburger at this PIZZA pub is delicious!😋 definitely a must-try next time you’re in the area!!

C
Cheryl Thomas

Quick service and always delicious!

S
Suzanna Prong

In know pizza is subjective, but the Salvatore's Super Slice is exactly the way I like my pizza. This location is always clean, inside and out; and the staff is friendly. It is accessible.

I
I AM A SURVIVOR

Met to have a slice and was pleasantly surprised the Magic guy was there. Our 1-1/2yr old grandaughter was a bit too young to understand but loved the balloon animal he made her. And as usual the pizza was great.

Rachel C
Rachel C

This review is for the Salvatore's ONTARIO location! This location is 5-STARS, HANDS DOWN! I work at a local company that frequents this location for week to week delivery and we have received nothing but QUALITY SERVICE and QUALITY FOOD! Ben (delivery driver and in-house employee) has taken our standard and specialty orders every week, always delivering them with thoroughness, sincere appreciation for our business, and great attitude. One time I could not order online, and Ben CALLED OUR BUSINESS to check-in, because he had not seen an order come through on the website. He then set us up with a standing order, and made sure to put a note in the system to check in with us, if an order was not received on our usual days. When ordering specialty menu items, Ben has made sure that all instructions are followed to a 'T'! I don't' personally trust a lot of restaurants, as I am a stickler for cleanliness and service, and I will tell you that I wholeheartedly trust Ben, and the team at the Salvatore's location in Ontario! Thank you for taking food handling seriously, and making sure that we are taken care of!

Julie
Julie

Very very good pizza! Sauce is so flavorful and good! Taste homemade. The sausage on the pizza is real Italian sausage lol. I never eat the crust off a slice but today I did! Very friendly staff and clean restaurant. Will be back. I ate the pizza before I could snap a pic!

Rob Zuber
Rob Zuber

Definitely my favorite place in Webster to get pizza and wings. This Salvatore’s location is always generous with their pizza toppings! I have never ordered from here and been disappointed. I’m always impressed with the quality and quantity of what they put on their pizzas! The chicken wings here are also very good. Never small in size. They are always cooked perfectly!

Outdoor Lighting Perspectives of Rochester
Outdoor Lighting Perspectives of Rochester

I love the pizzas, but this time went for some Arthur Treachers. The fish and chips were tasty, and I’ll buy it again, but I’m still usually getting one of the awesome pizzas. The staff were GREAT!

Jerry Ippy
Jerry Ippy

A enjoyable overall experience in the Village of Webster. The menu is extensive, and the quality and service were superb. We ordered a large pizza, Sicilian style, (thick crust) with the works, and garlic chicken wings. And, the number of large TV screens were well placed. We enjoyed watching the Buffalo Bills Mafia football game. Decorated for Christmas, and a very nice Christmas tree, with ornaments for picture taking. Server was exceptional, and their Christmas Eve delivery service, and pick up orders was busy, especially with the Bills football game being played.

Bryan Vasquez
Bryan Vasquez

Right off the highway and around the corner, Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria offers you a wide selection of food! Pizza is out ready to choose from. I ordered the meatball sub that was layered with meatballs and soaked with pasta sauce, cheese added! The bread was cooked to a crisp perfection! There’s no way I would ever be back in Rochester and miss out on this beauty of a restaurant!

Anthony Devitt
Anthony Devitt

This place is excellent and very recommend if you happen to be in town👍👍......food was excellent and the staff nothing short of expectations. I live 200 miles away roughly and am super glad I took the chance and stopped in. Pizza selection is amazing!!! I sampled the Manhattan......supreme....chicken bacon ranch....cheese and the old fashioned. My God I would've had more could If I could've fit it in lol........VERY GOOD PLACE

P Lem
P Lem

Great Calzone. Categorize this in the top five in all my travels. It was so big, we split it. Highly recommend and will definitely go back. They don't have a tip option on their credit card machine. Tip them in cash for the great job.

R
Rick Steinhilber

Great lunch stop! Large selection of slices and always fresh and delicious. Love the Webdter Norrth Ave location. Service is fantastic.

B
Benjamin Alexander

Good pizza, large slices. Go for the lunch specials for pozza and drink. If you order actual full soze pizzas make sure you have a coupon tho.

W
Wyatt Beardsley

Definitley the real Salvatore experience, I enjoyed it. Great feel. Plenty of televisions with many things to watch, had a lot more on the menu than a typical Salvatore. However I have one bone to pick with all Salvatores. I dislike the sauce on the pizza, it tastes alright. However I would much rather have any pizza place when it comes to the sauce.

D
Donna Deffenbaugh

I love their online ordering, simple for same day orders. Pizza and subs are good, with lots of options. I habe used at least 6 different locations and Candace at SCOTTSVILLE and her kitchen staff are amazing, with great service and delivery.

R
Robert

Went for Arthur Treachers Fish and Chips. Was mainly for nostalgia, but was pleasantly surprised. Their pizza is good too. Not my favorite, but among my top 3.

P
P Bradford

Crust was a little to thick this time but still the best pizza

H
Hans Romplestahmper

Service and prices are great, the Salvatore 's special pizza was a bit oily but tasted great. The crust was quite chewy but that's ok. Every pizza has its own personality and that was this one's. Speed was another plus, it was ready in 20 minutes .

J
John

I think their pizza is the best in Webster. I usually get banana peppers, onions and sausage. I have had their country sweet chicken charlie pizza as well which is very good. The service is hit or miss. There are a lot of young employees that work the register and they're not always attentive.

D
Dave “Doodles” Newman

20 minutes for a salad... not busy. Said they forgot about my order. The Cajun chicken salad was excellent anyway! The chicken had the consistency of a blackened sea bass, delicious! 5 stars if they didn't forget me, a little pricey tho

R
R L.

Pizza is good! Was slightly greasier than average. Delivery was slow though took about an hour even though close by.

Beth Burlap
Beth Burlap

The cauliflower crust pizza is not as good as it used to be, but everything else is delicious. I'm assuming they switched which cauliflower crust they use. Salvatores was my go-to anytime I ordered pizza and wings for my family, but we kind of prefer Mark's at this point, sinxe the cauliflower crust changed. I do appreciate that they cater to people with gluten allergies, it just isn't as good as it originally was.

Karen Allen
Karen Allen

We love the pizza here and order it often. I won’t be ordering the fish dinner again. Very disappointed! The batter on the fish was like rubber. The proportion of batter to fish was way too little fish. I ordered pickup and the meal was just thrown haphazardly into a box. I liked the coleslaw.

M
Matt S

I reiterate another reviewers comment about consistency. Salvatore's makes some amazing food, but 50% of the time it's not great. The times when it is amazing is enough to warrant 3 stars, but the other 50% would yield a 1 star. I hope you all get to experience the 6 star Salvatore's.

P
PETER PACILIO

Employees don't get order right Especially if allergies are involved. This was the 2nd time this has happened there. They don't check the finished product to be sure order was right before serving the food to patrons. Employees are friendly and courteous on the plus side.

D
David Lewis

Normally we have a good experience here and often order the Arthur Treacher's fish & chips. This evening (Sunday, 10/23), the fish was different and not of the usual quality. It was as if they shopped at Tops and got an off brand frozen filet. Yuch!

J
Jake Pat

It's excellent for unique pizzas and quick lunchtime bite. The service is quite spotty. Bar however is excellent. Bartenders are surprisingly knowledgeable and a good selection of liquor

T
Thomas Lynch

Pizza taste was mediocre. They sliced a round pizza into little squares and mini triangles, very strange, never saw anything like it, not a fan. The bbq wings were very good, cooked nice and crispy. judging by what I ordered and what I saw others ordering, pizza is not what people go there for. I will return to try other foods, other food looked good.

A
Alyssa Jewell

I went into the place and was waiting to order. There was already someone ahead of me that was placing a large order, so I was hoping someone else would use the other register to take my order or at least acknowledge me and ensure me that they would be right with me or something. Nope, none of that. Even after the person ahead of me finished ordering the staff that took his order began grabbing drinks and preparing the large order still without acknowledging me- that's the least they could do if they're busy at the moment (which is totally understandable). Eventually someone came up to the register and asked me if I had been helped and they took my order. I was probably standing there for about 5-8 minutes before being helped.

Steve M.
Steve M.

If the restaurant puts garlic butter and seasoning all over the calzone it should be listed on the menu. Wish I had known.

Alyssa Z
Alyssa Z

I haven't had Salvatore's in a while but I remember their pizza being a little thicker and fluffier than most. I wanted Salvatores but not so fluffy today so I ordered the thin. I did not expect it to be this thin. I guess that's my fault because when I went back to look at what I ordered I then saw that it said "thin thin." I thought it was just a misprint. Either way there was almost no bread to this and I couldn't help but laugh at this as I felt so dumb and was so hungry and did not expect there to be so little pizza to my pizza. I typically like thin pizza, and am no stranger to nyc pizza, but this is next level. Like this pizza was holding on for dear life. I mean the pizza was okay but I was just disappointed and wanted something small but filling. So unless you want a pizza flat enough for Flat Stanley, just order a normal pizza.

Peter Minchak
Peter Minchak

Got a medium eggplant parmesan sub with fries for lunch. Food was hot when it came out, which is great, but the eggplant parm sub was so greasy that it was hard to eat without it falling out of the sub roll. Not sure how it was prepped, but there was more grease on the sub than sauce. It tasted good, just very messy to eat.

Roxii Love
Roxii Love

Food came at a reasonable time. No utensils for salads. Had to wait over 20 min for someone to return with them. Salad containers too small to put dressing on salad/close, & shake. Ended up barely enough salad dressing for 2 bites of salad. Literally only vegan option. It's 2025, you should have several by now that are NOT SALAD. My son liked the chicken wings. Tried to order online but website didn't offer a place to leave credit card info. Called, instead.

B
Becky Abbey

Received a text that my order was on the way.....35 minutes later it was still not here. Staff said they think they have a glitch in their system. When the pizza finally got here...cold. Delivery staff's excuse..... Well we have been busy.

F
Fred Bertoni

The meatball sub was good the service left me with a bad taste. Sub was basically thrown on the table on top of a cookie she left never asked if we were ok and never came back. Service was not very good.

D
Doug McKnight

Medium Steak Sub and Five Mozzarella Sticks, $25...common folks 😞

S
Sally Baumann

The food was great, but the speakers were blaring static. Very annoying, when I asked staff about it, they said they knew how bad it was and have complained too. Really, owners need to fix this now!

J
Jon Eagley

Overpriced for a medium sandwich. The roll tasted great, the chicken was not very good. Won't go back again.

B
Bob P

Not quite what was expected They have dining in - but had to wait on ourselves. Order at the counter (beer/food) - no wait staff at all - despite there being at least 2 people up front

B
Brett Lowden

Ordered 2 steak subs. Mostly bread. Have gotten them at other locations that were great. Like taking 30 bucks and throwing it in the street. Very unhappy.

E
Eugene Yeo

Been ordering for better than a year, they've got the laziest delivery drivers I've ever seen. They've got one who actually does his job. The rest will happily go to the wrong entrance to your building and just stand there for twenty minutes without letting you know they're there. And keep away from the fish. They have their frier on too hot and they don't leave it in long enough. You'll wind up with a burned outside and an uncooked inside.

A
Alan Conrow

I ordered a Supreme Pizza at the Webster location for my Mother and I waited for it to be made . It had no pizza sauce very thin pizza crust 1mm thick, negative pizza sauce , no real cheese negative mozzarella cheese, sauce patties cut up for sausage . Only two rows if circles or pepperoni on outside none in the middle.Pepers and Onions and Mushrooms sliced paper thin Dumped in middle to hide lie lack of pepperoni and cheese a real conspiracy theory there how anyone was really trained or if trained in making athentic Salvatore's Pizza. Savatores Pizza corner of Empire Blvd at Doughnuts Delite really better made and tastes fresher and a lot better authentic Italian real Pizza . My family will Probably not order any from Webster store no more sorry to say . Very Bitter over all bad really bad after taste .

D
DM Mag

I've spent close to $100 a month at this place for years, so to say I have sampled their menu and experienced the rotation of service between turnover on employees and cooks and everything they have to offer is an understatement. I'll be frank: I go here because the places I favor for pizza or wings don't accept CC over website order setups. There's better pizza, there's better wings, and there's better subs out there. My situation of limited cash on hand makes me go here. This said, a review. Cost: Overpriced. Even in today's economy, I can save 20% going to Rhino's if I have cash on hand. Overpriced. The jump to adding $1 to damn near everything's cost and $4 for delivery fee in the last year has made me halve my spending here. So, the cost increase has made me go from a once a week buy to a once or twice a month buy instead. Meaning they need to sell roughly 35-45 orders more monthly in order to make up the difference in sales just from me. I hope that was worth it. Order Preparation: Decent, just never order a salad unless you want to play with it with a new bowl, and a knife. Even an explicit "Bite sized lettuce ffs" on the ticket will get you lettuce the size of your head folded and stuffed into the container. My suggestion: Stop ordering salads altogether, I've been ordering for years, and whomever is in charge has an IQ of 12 and doesn't understand that in order to fit bits of lettuce into your mouth they can't be bigger than his head. Quality: Decent, nothing special. The subs are better than marks, the pizza is better than gas station pizza, the wings are better than Rhinos's, worse than Marks and the salads are the biggest since Zaz's was sold and run into the ground. Overall, nothing special, but a place to go if you have a mixed order to please multiple people that delivers day and night. Pizza: Worse than (In webster) Pontillo's, Guida's , Rhino's, Domino's, Pizza hut, better than Marks, and Martino's. In order. Wings: Worse than (in webster) Martino's, Marks, Pontillo's, Guida's, better than Rhino's, Pizza Hut, Domino's. In order. Subs: Worse than (in webster) Rhino's; Better than: Guida's, Martino's, Domino's, Pizza Hut, Pontillo's, Mark's for sandwich items in Webster. If you need a steak sub and some pizza and hot wings that gets delivered on time and have $50+ on hand: This is your place to go. If you want something else, or on a budget: Stay away.

W
Wendy Marchner

I use to Love Salvatores. Just picked up the worse sub ever. Took a picture but can't post. Had to take meat from one half to put on the other half. Ham n swiss ! You really have to skimp on the meat?! Go to Hegedorns for a sub. Good grief

A
A Oliver

I regularly order chicken tenders and fries from Salvatore's. I've never been to this location before, until today. My chicken fingers were all thin, small, and burnt on the edges. The French fries were a joke. They were also semi burnt, all very small left over pieces and everything was very salty. For $18 I'm very disappointed. Won't be ordering this again. I'll travel to a different location.

A
Adam White

I got a slice of pepperoni today. One bite everyone knows the rules. Sauce is too sweet Crust had zero crunch. Tastes premade or frozen. Cafeteria crust. Sloppy and greasy as can be. 4.8.

W
Warren Yeager

When you walk in the place looks nice, but it's not a value lunch at all. $5 for a slice is ridiculous, and $7 for a combo lunch is not a value. The pizza is not that great and looks like its been sitting there for a while. The slices are not that big, or not big enough to justify its price. The menu looks nice, but the prices are a bit high. I am judging this on lunch alone.

M
Mark Newton

Oh my stars! I was so excited to see an Arthur Treacher's that I couldn't hardly wait. It been so long since I've had their fish and chips that it was a done deal. I did think it a little odd that an Italian pizza place sold Arthur Treacher's, but oh well, I was going for it. My excitement was short lived. The batter on the fish was like rubber, and once you got through it the fish was over cooked and tough. The chips were over cooked and crunchy, and the coleslaw was nasty. The only thing edible was the hush puppies and even they were over cooked. Overall, probably the worst fish and chips I've ever had. Sorry... Don't waist your time.

Bob Doodie
Bob Doodie

Pizza is good when they put in the effort. Don't order garlic parm wings though. All it is is garlic and oil. Little to no parm and no parsley. Go to bay rd. They at least give a crap!

H
Harry Gorrell

When you order a large “round” pizza you do not expect it to be cut into squares and rounded triangles. Then to top it off it’s very undercooked. Waste of time and money.

B
Brad Pensgen

Never order cailzones from here. Me and my friends bought 6 of them and they were all screwed up a 100 dollars wasted. Not one order was right and all very undercooked.

G
GET T

Since I can't rate 0......This place has disappointed over and over.....trying to order for pick up and couldn't even do that.....Had a few delivery orders that were just horrendous in mix ups, people not knowing where their going to, etc...incorrect orders.... would not recommend AT ALL. This place is obviously poorly managed and the food is bad.

M
Mike Hyson

Certainly not worth the high prices they charge. Calamari was spongy and looked nothing like the picture they portreid . Disappointed

S
Sarah Ely

So angry. We called to see what time they delivered to. We were on our way to our campground. They said they delivered there all the time and to order by 9pm. I called back at 9 once we pulled in. They said 30 minutes. I paid the 89.00 with my credit card over the phone The driver called twice for directions. I explained this was my first time to the area and gave him the address once again. 10:30 came NO FOOD 6 hungry kids and 2 adults with nothing to eat. We tried calling the delivery guy and he kept pressing ignore😡. Out food and money.

T
Tallgirlsroc

Salvatore‘s pizza is the best in Rochester ! ❣️ But we decided to try Salvatores subs. I ordered the Italian assorted sub. There were 4 skinny pieces of meat. My boyfriend ordered the roast beaf which had a bit more meat. Won’t be ordering subs again.

p
pat fuller

Ordered med . Pizza, supreme well done ( as stated on receipt) pizza came doughy and like warm. All I got was “sorry”.

A
Anthony Toman

Every salvatores has fresh slices...except for this one!! Always old to the point the cheese looks congealed...kinda sad because salvatores is my favorite pizza stop but I have to go out of my way to another one just to get fresh food for lunch....how do you not have fresh slices during lunch time? Also asked if they had any new ones coming out soon and the manager said no 🤦‍♂️ they dont even plan on making fresh pizza and dont care to hide it either..

E
Eulie V

Friendly neighborhood pizza place right? But when I pulled up into curbside and asked if I could have a couple slices and some drinks for my daughter and I because I couldn't come in they proceeded to tell me that I could only use credit card when I had cash on me with a nice tip. I will never in my life give money to salvators again that was ridiculous. Oh wait I'm sorry attempt to try and give them money ✌🏻

D
David C

Cut circular pizza square. What kind of impractical gimmicky bs is this? Also don't call it ny style when it's an inch thick.

K
Kirnpreet Singh

Called to order pizza and asked for curbside pickup, only because I had a sleeping toddler in the car. The guy said the don’t do curbside and he’s never heard of them doing it. Even though I asked why is there a sign outside and parking spots for it. I even told him I’ll pay for the pizza right now and if he can just bring it to my car. He refused and said they don’t do that.

H
Honest

I don't leave poor reviews on an establishment unless there have been multiple issues. The food at this Salvatore's (in the past) has been excellent. Always a good product. This review is not pertaining to their food. This review is focusing on their service. I pre-ordered our dinner on the website for a pickup time of 6pm (I placed the order in the morning). When I arrived at 6pm, my sheet pizza was not even made. I was told the "order ticket wasn't put up." or whatever that means. So, I had to scramble to find alternate dinner plans for the 4 teenage boys my son had over for a study session. As stated previously, I do not write poor reviews based on one error. This particular Salvatore's Pizzeria has messed up my order in some way two other times - but I understand that mistakes are made. But this was the third strike and it was a big mistake. This shouldn't happen - especially when the order is literally sent in by the customer (meaning, no errors unless the customer entered it in wrong). Sorry Salvatore's, you lost a customer today.

J
J P

I ordered from them a few times the pizza the pizza was great but this last time the pizza tasted and looked kinda old very disappointed

E
Emad Chibli

Good pizza, terrible service. Such a shame we will never order from there again, over an hour for delivery multiple times and when you call they just lie about the status.

E
Emily Perkins

Didn't even want to give one star. I have ordered 2 times from this location. The first time the pizza was undercooked and gooey. Second time I also ordered 10 wings. They were horrible. I also only got 9 wings not 10. The pizza was once again gross. Not really under cooked but just tasted like frozen reheated pizza. Everything was also cold. Trying another location. I have also ordered from fairport they were always great.

P
Pat Font

We ordered the worst pizza ever from Salvatore’s on route 250 in Webster. Of course it was the Super Bowl on Feb 2,2020 and they were swamped. We were given a 5:00 pick up time. As soon as I opened the box I saw an almost totally black, overdone pizza. To say the least it was like cardboard. The cheese was glued to the crust and the bottom was black. We really looked forward to our annual Super Bowl pizz and we were totally disappointed. Friends ordered their pizza, from Wegmans and for $10. Received a piping hot pizza delivered to their door. Salvatore’s if you can’t handle the Super Bowl volume- don’t even try. You have lost my business

Anthony Galante
Anthony Galante

We ordered a large order on 11/07 & called to inform them that we had issues with it & it was inedible. They offered to credit our card, which was very nice & more than we were looking for. We just went to order again & realized they never applied the credit. When we called to let them know, they were suddenly unable to find our info. We have ordered from them 101 times that WE were able to find in our card history. Won’t use them again.

Patty Nortz
Patty Nortz

We called and ordered 3 pizzas for a 5:30 delivery on 10/26/2025. The girl who took the information read back the order to ensure it was correct. When it was almost 30 minutes late, we called and were told it would be delivered soon. The girl wasn't sure if the delivery driver had the pizza or if they needed to go back to the restaurant to pick it up. When it was 45 minutes late we drove to the restaurant to check on the pizza order status because we had 10 people waiting to eat dinner. The 2 girls at the front counter said it was on the way. I asked if they had a delivery time because we were told this earlier. She went out back and got a guy who initially said something about 21 minutes, which I think meant they didn't process our order on time. He said it was on the way and I again asked if he knew when we could expect delivery. I told him I didn't live far and told him my street name. He abruptly replied "I know where you live! It should be at your house by now." I called my husband and it had not been delivered yet. My son in law requested a refund for the delivery charges for our inconvenience, which was honored. By the time we got home the delivery driver was in our driveway. However, they only had 2 pizzas, not 3 as ordered. The driver apologized. Since the 3rd pizza was ordered due to dietary restrictions, my son in law went back to pick up a slice of a specific type of pizza. The same male employee we had spoken to was still at the front counter. When he was told we were missing a pizza the male employee said.... "If you had ordered that pizza, it would have been delivered to you!" My son in law was frustrated with his rudeness and told him he didn't say much to him earlier but was shocked by his attitude and couldn't believe he hadn't apologized for the inconvenience we were experiencing. They discussed getting a slice of pizza to replace the whole pizza not supplied. All was done in an unfriendly manner with no apology given. If a mistake was made, admit it, apologize and make your customer feel valued. None of this was done.

Steven McAlpin
Steven McAlpin

VERY disappointed with chicken wings. One of our former go-to spots. Twice in a row wings were so dry we threw them away. Of three orders of 10 wings, they only compensated us for one. Not what we expect from our neighborhood restaurant. 😒

Kathryn Diprojetto
Kathryn Diprojetto

This was the pizza we received tonight. We order from this location every single weekend spending 80-100$ each time and have never had this crappy of delivery. Kids were disappointed to say the least.

E
E

Got pasta with meatballs, and some bread with cheese in it. Sauce from a jar, pasta not homemade, 2 small meat balls. It's huge, but for the money I should have went with a small sandwich, more meat in that.

Anmelden, um eine Bewertung zu schreiben

Anmelden
👑 Gehört es Ihnen? GRATIS beanspruchen!

Werbung entfernen und Menü verwalten

Entdecke deine Gegend

Mehr Restaurants in Webster →
📸

22 Fotos

Entdecke Fotos von Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
+17 Mehr
📍

Informationen über Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Anfahrt

195 North Ave, Webster, NY 14580

Karte wird geladen...
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Tippen für Wegbeschreibung

Highlights

Gute Bewertung
4.0/5 Sterne
💬
Viele Bewertungen
398 Bewertungen
💰
Moderater Preis
Preisniveau
👨‍🍳
pizza
Küchenart

Dienstleistungen

🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Mittagessen
🍾 Abendessen
🍰 Desserts
🥗 Vegetarische Optionen
🥡 Zum Mitnehmen
🚚 Lieferung
🍴 Vor Ort Essen
🚗 Abholung am Bordstein

Speisemöglichkeiten

🍽️ Vor Ort Essen
🥡 Zum Mitnehmen
🚚 Lieferung
🚗 Abholung am Bordstein

Restaurant-Infos

Status
Vom Inhaber verifiziert
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-9PM
Bewertung
4.0/5
💬 Bewertungen
398
💰 Preisniveau
$$
📞 Telefon
+1 585-872-2210
🌐 Webseite
salvatores.com

Ausstattung

🅿️ Parkplatz
🌿 Außenbereich
Rollstuhlgerecht
🚻 Toilette
💳 Kreditkarten
📱 Mobile Zahlungen
🏘️

Die Nachbarschaft

Standort

195 North Ave, Webster, NY 14580

Webster Grange No. 436 Kulturerbe

historic building in Webster, New York, United States

A 546m
🎮

Spiele

🎮 Sammle Punkte beim Entdecken!

Spiele Find Me und löse Punkte gegen Rabatte bei Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria und anderen Restaurants ein

🎮

Sammle Punkte bei Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria!

Spiele Find Me und löse Belohnungen hier ein

Sammle Extrapunkte und löse sie gegen Belohnungen von Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria ein

🏆 Belohnungen von Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

💰

10% Rabatt

Bei Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

1000 pts
Verfügbar
🍽️

Gratis Vorspeise

Bei deinem nächsten Besuch

2500 pts
Begrenzt
👑

VIP-Tisch

Premium-Erlebnis

5000 pts
Exklusiv

um Belohnungen einzulösen und Punkte zu sammeln

📋 Wie funktionieren die Belohnungen?

1

Spiele Find Me

Alle 100 Scorepunkte = 1 Belohnungspunkt

2

Sammle Punkte

Worker erhalten 2x Punkte pro Spiel

3

Löse Belohnungen ein

Rabatte, Gratis-Essen und VIP-Erlebnisse

Anrufen
Bewertung auf Google hinterlassen
👑

Gehört es Ihnen? GRATIS beanspruchen!

Werbung entfernen und Menü verwalten

Anmelden & Spielen

Überprüfe deine E-Mail!

Kein Passwort nötig — wir senden dir einen Link per E-Mail

Wir haben dir einen Zugangslink gesendet

Prüfe deinen Spam-Ordner, falls du ihn nicht siehst