One Pie Pizza Co.
Pizza · Amherst
About One Pie Pizza Co.
Located in Amherst, One Pie Pizza Co. offers a warm culinary experience centered on authentic comfort food. Customers consistently praise the incredible crust, which features an airy texture with a crisp undercarriage, paired with a signature sauce that balances sweetness perfectly without overpower...
Located in Amherst, One Pie Pizza Co. offers a warm culinary experience centered on authentic comfort food. Customers consistently praise the incredible crust, which features an airy texture with a crisp undercarriage, paired with a signature sauce that balances sweetness perfectly without overpowering fresh toppings. The restaurant is renowned for its high-quality ingredients, including hand-cut pepperoni, fresh vegetables, and homemade blue cheese served alongside slices for traditional Buffalo-style dipping. Beyond standard offerings, the pizzeria excels in inclusivity with exceptional gluten-free options, soft vegan pizzas, and reliable no-contact delivery. Whether enjoying a quick lunch or a hearty dinner, guests appreciate the careful preparation that avoids canned items and excess grease, making every visit a memorable taste of excellence.
What Customers Say About One Pie Pizza Co.
One Pie Pizza Co. is highly praised for its fresh, high-quality ingredients and unique pizza creations like the Three Little Pigs and Cherry Bomb. Customers rave about the sweet sauce, cup and char pepperoni, and homemade blue cheese. Service is friendly and accommodating.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If you like spice, try the Cherry Bomb Pizza. Consider ordering extra sauce for an even more flavorful experience.
Features
Frequently asked questions about One Pie Pizza Co.
One Pie Pizza Co. Amherst Reviews
Tried the pizza here recently and it’s a new family favorite. We have been hooked on the Hot Honey Ricotta with light sauce. It’s so good. So is the breakfast pizza and 3 little pigs. Great service too always ready when they say it will be done , hot and tasty. Cannoli is pretty good too.
One of the best in buffalo. Very unique recipe for regular cheese and pep, made to go with the Bleu cheese! Always ready on time, has great specials for sides
Best pizza in WNY. Top quality ingredients and consistent product every purchase. Never disappointed. Clean establishment and friendly staff.
20/10 on the gluten-free crust!! On my gluten-free journey, I am always eager to want to try pizza from a lot of different places. Im not settling on the flat thin crust or cauliflower. It’s good yeah, but when you think of pizza that is just not it. If I could order just the dough with the garlic butter on it I could eat just that. Just wow 🤤
The Three Little Pigs pie is fantastic. We tried The Cover 1 Allen Goat and liked it just as much. Can't wait to try all the pizzas on the menu.
Now that was a great pizza! Incredible quality and the sweeter sauce hit just perfect with the cup and char pepperonis. We will certainly be back!
Great pizza and great service! Ordered online in the morning and forgot to change the time for lunch. When we picked it up, after the pie was sitting for a few hours, they felt bad and made us a fresh one to enjoy. My mistake entirely and they took care of us. Will probably become my new go-to!
This is the best vegan pizza I have ever had in my entire life. Mere words cannot convey how amazing it was. The sauce is the perfect amount of sweetness and the crust is soft on top and crisp on the bottom. They did not skimp on the dairy free cheese either. My God. I am a better person after having eaten this masterpiece. 10000000/10!!! Def ordering again :)
Visiting the One Pie Pizza Co. is a must when we go to Buffalo for Sabres games. This is for sure the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. I’d be here a few times a week if I didn’t live so far away. I’ve had the pepperoni pie and the pepperoni/ricotta/hot honey. Both solid choices in their own way and both cooked perfectly. The edges of the cup n char pepperoni are crispy. Dough is amazing. Sauce is perfect. Wish there was table service or even better options for seating if you want to eat in. There’s one small table for 2 in the corner and a counter to sit at but seating is very limited. 10/10 Would repeat!
Some of the best and most original pizza I have had in a long time. Sweet sauce is not too sweet and has great taste. Crust, cheese and pep were fantastic too. Really good job guys. Will definitely be ordering again!
I was very reluctant to try this pizza because it says it has sweet sauce and I hate sweet sauce. The first order I got a cheese and pepperoni pizza with half mushroom and half cherry peppers. First let me say that this is a high quality pizza, it's very flavorful and everything is made from scratch. The cherry peppers were delicious!!!, and the flavor and heat from them drastically cut the sweetness of the sauce... As does the flavor and spice of the pepperoni. I guess it depends on the toppings you get if you really pick up on the sweetness of it. I enjoyed the pizza and would suggest for others to give it a try even if they don't like sweet sauce because it is quite flavorful and the sauce still has enough of a savory profile that you're not overwhelmed with sweetness. The homemade blue cheese that comes with the pizza was also really good. I also love that they use fresh mushrooms and not canned. Update* ordered many times since, those cherry peppers are addicting!
Just tried the upside down pizza last night. May be my new favorite slice in Buffalo. They’ve managed to make the perfect combination of sauce, cheese, and flavor. I will definitely be ordering this a lot in the future!
Wow. What more can I say than that? This is by far one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The crust was incredible, the sauce was unbelievable, and the pepperoni was perfect. No dine in option, but that's okay because it's that good. One tip I would add is that I'll get extra sauce next time. It was a decent amount, but by the time I got home over an hour away the crust had soaked up some of the sauce. I obviously had a slice there when I picked it up, so I could tell a difference.
First timer. Friend recommended. Very good. Cooked very well. Sauce was semi sweet and delicious great cup n char. Great cheese. Looks like it could have been overcooked but the dough and crust was perfect for my taste. Little bit on the softer side. Ordered online. Picked up at the desired time
First time ever having their pizza and I was amazed on the quality ingredients and service, legit perfect definitely found my new favorite pizza place to order from. It was so good I had to eat 4 slices in one sitting lol.
If you are stopping into Buffalo for your first time then i definitely recommend this place. My girlfriend and I love spice so we got the Cherry Bomb Pizza which was AMAZING and hot. Gotta love the blue cheese best i’ve ever had! Pricey btw but very good quality!
I love this place. Nothing comes from a can. It’s all fresh cut vegetables and toppings, fresh sauce, and homemade blue cheese on the side for the Buffalo people who just gotta dip that slice! I also highly enjoy the square style pizza they do. This is a really high quality pizza place in Buffalo. Never have had a bad pie here.
Delicious! Classic Buffalo pie but tightened up. Fresh ingredients, hand-cut pepperoni, airy crust with a nicely done crisp undercarriage. No slop, undercooked dough, or excess grease. They have a reward program for repeat customers. Very clean inside and friendly service. I will be back. Check it out.
Had their March special of the month, Rueben pizza and a traditional cheese pepp, added onions and banana peppers - everything was delicious
I got the pickle pizza and i have two critiques: thinner slices of pickles, and dill instead of bread and butter to contrast the sweetness of the bbq sauce. Otherwise DELICIOUS!
First time trying pizza. Bought 1 slice, cheese and pepperoni was really good. They give a blue cheese with it. If I like doughy style slice was it. Sauce very tasty and delicious. Another customer asked them run his slice through twice to make it crisper. Notice they use a conveyer belt oven.
I paid $22 for a pizza, plus $19 in fees getting it delivered to find a very lack luster pie. The sauce is sickeningly sweet for some reason. I won't be ordering from here again. Way overcharged and way under delivered. Weak pizza.
As someone who has worked in the pizza industry for around 26 years when I order a pie for a certain time I don’t expect to get there early and see my order come out of a hot box pizza was good after I had to reheat it but will not be back I’ll go where I get a fresh pie
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Tim Hortons
King Crab Juicy Seafood
House of China
Hydraulic Hearth
Kornerstone Cafe & Juice Bar
Aloha Krab Cajun Seafood & Bar
Wendy's Drive-Thru
The Blackthorn Restaurant & Pub
Wendy's
Texas De Brazil
19 Photos
Explore One Pie Pizza Co.'s photos
About One Pie Pizza Co.
How to get there
2185 Clinton St, West Seneca, NY 14206
Amherst, NY 14206
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at One Pie Pizza Co. and other restaurants
Earn Points at One Pie Pizza Co.!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at One Pie Pizza Co.
🏆 Rewards at One Pie Pizza Co.
10% Discount
At One Pie Pizza Co.
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu