James Wernicke Sr.

Excellent restaurant with very good food and service. I had the seafood casserole while my wife enjoyed the filet mignon. I recommend both. We had the Caesar salad and while it only came with 1 anchovy our waitress was nice enough to get us a few more. Too full for dessert so no comments.

Pam Eschler

We had a bridal shower for my daughter today. Raindancer restaurant was wonderful! The setting was so nice. Alexis and Walter assisted with the planning, Alexis was so sweet and helpful, and our waitress Samantha was nothing short of amazing. She handled 20 guests by herself without breaking a sweat. She was calm and efficient and so accommodating. We all loved her and everyone commented on what a good waitress she was! The food was excellent and the room we were in was so cozy and intimate. Thank you Raindancer for a memorable experience.

Forks Anonymous

Today we stopped in Amsterdam, NY (because we thought the name was cool lol) and we found this absolute gem! This place is amazing. The staff is super welcoming and friendly. Becky helped us out today and she is the best! The food is incredible! And the portions are hefty. Take it from us... we've never lead you astray.

+3

Jones

Made a reservation as it was my first time here. Greeted and seated from friendly staff. Eddie our server was prompt and on point. I wanted for nothing and took care of whatever I needed. Food was great and the look and feel of the place was pretty good... I'll be back!!

Their Early, Sunset Menu, 3 courses for $29, cannot be beat. Choose a Caesar or garden salad. An entree of fish, steak, or chicken dishes. A choice of desserts. My favorite is filet mignon tips a…

Their Early, Sunset Menu, 3 courses for $29, cannot be beat. Choose a Caesar or garden salad. An entree of fish, steak, or chicken dishes. A choice of desserts. My favorite is filet mignon tips au …

Great fresh food und friendly service . I had the steak and blue salad and it was excellent

Great fresh food und friendly service . I had the steak and blue salad and it was excellent

This restaurant was recommended by the hotel. I wanted a good steak and they did not disappoint me at all. The server was courteous and gracious. The grilled asparagus was wonderful and seasoned ex…

I've been to the Raindancer a few times now and I enjoy that the place is bigger than it looks from the outside and that you don't always need reservations. However if you have more than two people I…

I've been to the Raindancer a few times now and I enjoy that the place is bigger than it looks from the outside and that you don't always need reservations. However if you have more than two people…

After hearing about the Raindancer for so many years, we finally made it there! We were a group of fourteen who had reservations on a Saturday night. Our server was outstanding! We had the prime…

We were a party of 10 and I have to tell you, all of us had a wonderful meal. 7 of us had the prime rib special, 2 had the filet mignon and 1 had a strip steak. And I can tell you everyone was …

We were a party of 10 and I have to tell you, all of us had a wonderful meal. 7 of us had the prime rib special, 2 had the filet mignon and 1 had a strip steak. And I can tell you everyone was …

My family and I celebrated a birthday dinner last night and had an amazing time. I’ve been going to Raindancer my whole life and would absolutely recommend it. We ordered the French onion soup, a Caesar wrap, chicken wings, salmon, and the penne alla vodka. Everything was delicious. Our waitress (Alison or Alisha) was wonderful and very attentive. While the prices have definitely gone up, it’s still well worth it in my opinion. The cozy decor really adds to the experience as well. It’s a must visit in Amsterdam! 🌯🥙🥂

Harry Downing

3 old friends went for late lunch, 2:00 PM. We were not allowed into the front area where there are windows, even though we had a reservation, and were seated in the dark, confined area with no natural light. We all had the long bone rib steak ($49.99). The meat was cooked as asked, but the quality was poor, much grizzle, fat, unedible material. The waiter was excellent. The chairs were reasonably comfortable. We do not drink alcoholic beverages, and the bill was $250.00 for 3 with a 20% gratuity.

Patty Freeman

What a cute and cozy place. Our waitress was very attentive.

Deana M

New to the area- we gave it a try and was not disappointed. Wish they served Coca Cola but other than that, great atmosphere, wonderful staff, good food. We will be back!

MJ W

Four of my friends and I went for $5 all you can eat wing night. Bad part you have to sit at bar to get the special deal. People who just want a social drink now have to deal with people hovering over them waiting for a seat at the bar. We had people just staring at us constantly turning a great night with old friends into a awkward atmosphere over seating. Let people drink and eat in peace open a wing only section not at the bar please.

Linda Heintze

A large group of us went for the early bird menu and the food was really good. I had the prime rib. For $5.00 more, you got a salad that was much bigger than expected, coffee and dessert. Great deal. The waitress was exceptional. She handled our large group with ease and grace. Great personality. Sorry I forgot to take pictures!

krazy ISH

Visiting family in Amsterdam NY & they recommended this place. We’ve been traveling for 2 days and wanted something nice to eat. Atmosphere and service was the best, my whiskey was plentiful & full bodied. Our server was quick, friendly & helpful. Food was a mix bag: OMG! garlic bread was to die for. Pork was amazing, steak salad was just good because the steak was overcooked, salmon & rice were dry and the calamari tasted burnt. We would definitely go back though.

+1

food was good, and service was lovely! it's a nice little place to get a bite. we even had a little fireplace by our table!

food was good, and service was lovely! it's a nice little place to get a bite. we even had a little fireplace by our table!

food was good, and service was lovely! it's a nice little place to get a bite. we even had a little fireplace by our table!

Over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...this was…

Over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...this w…

Over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...this w…

over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...th…

Over priced ...long long wait for our food and ultimately minimal portions for the price ...out waitress was in denial about how long we waited while other much large parties came and went...th…

The food here has been good with good portions in the past. It has never been inexpensive but the value was within reason. The menu recently changed and we couldn't believe the prices. The salad …

The food here has been good with good portions in the past. It has never been inexpensive but the value was within reason. The menu recently changed and we couldn't believe the prices. The salad op…

Our family had made reservations for a bereavement luncheon and was given a menu with prices. After the event it was noticed that the prices were much higher than what was on our menu. After talk…

Our family had made reservations for a bereavement luncheon and was given a menu with prices. After the event it was noticed that the prices were much higher than what was on our menu. After talkin…

Sadly disappointed in this establishment. If you don't have a reservation, even on a week night such as a Tuesday, well don't expect to be getting a table. We were told the wait without a reservati…

Sadly disappointed in this establishment. If you don't have a reservation, even on a week night such as a Tuesday, well don't expect to be getting a table. We were told the wait without a reservat…

We loved the special 21 dollar prime rib deal! Perfectly done according to your order with good idea dish choices, and including salad and dessert and coffee! I rated a 4 instead of a 5 as the old …

We loved the special 21 dollar prime rib deal! Perfectly done according to your order with good idea dish choices, and including salad and dessert and coffee! I rated a 4 instead of a 5 as th…

We loved the special 21 dollar prime rib deal! Perfectly done according to your order with good idea dish choices, and including salad and dessert and coffee! I rated a 4 instead of a 5 as the old …

We loved the special 21 dollar prime rib deal! Perfectly done according to your order with good idea dish choices, and including salad and dessert and coffee! I rated a 4 instead of a 5 as the ol…

Good steaks for our party. Cooked exactly as we ordered. Service was very good. Gave us a nice presentation on the night’s specials. Would return.

Good steaks for our party. Cooked exactly as we ordered. service was very good. Gave us a nice presentation on the night’s specials. Would return.

This place was recommended by our hotel. The food was ok taste wise. Portions were big. A lot of beer choices . Great decor and atmosphere. Menu is huge and overwhelming. I wish they would minimize…

This has always been our favorite restaurant in this area. The last 2 times has been disappointing. Service was terrible. Never got my drink and after we got our food never came back to ask if all was ok. I said never got my drink didn’t say sorry or anything. I asked for check and that was that. That was in November. Tonight we made sure we made early reservations as Valentine’s Day. Same thing took forever to get service and dinner about one hour. The server never I mean never came back to see if we needed anything while waiting and then when we got our food never came back once. We stopped her ask her for to go container and she gave us them and check. Never asked if we wanted dessert or coffee. Very disappointed. We always bragged about this restaurant to others before but I don’t know now. It is expensive but use to be worth it but not now poor service and food is not like it use to be.

First - our server Kim was amazing! She was so personable and patient!\nIt's been a while since we've been and I was surprised to see the menu has changed completely. I was disappointed to see the …

Our waitress was great. Friendly and attentive. The food was ok. I had the broiled seafood dinner. 4 scallops, 3 shrimp and a very small thin piece of haddock. There was very little seasoning on it…

For some time now I have been wanting to have the prime rib from the Raindancer Rest. as it was really the best around. So both of Barb's grandkids have worked there and had a lot of trouble w…

I apologize for never writing a review prior to this, because in the past we've always been overjoyed coming here. I'm always recommending the place to everyone who wants a good steak. So for Valentine's Day I booked a reservation over a month prior for 7pm for us and two of our friends for a double date. We actually got seated right away, got our drinks and apps reasonably fast. My wife and I ordered the prime rib for two sweetheart special. Over an hour after we ordered the main course came out. I see the steak and immediately realize it doesn't look right. Definitely not a prime rib, that's because they brought us the heart shaped ribeye. Overcooked no less. Everything was cooked wrong for the table. My wife was eating the seafood portion of the special and I was getting the prime rib. It's the only reason I chose it. So I mention it to the waitress who was insistent (off of memory) I ordered the ribeye. I make mistakes occasionally and I'm soft spoken so I might have said the wrong thing or wasn't clear enough. Then I realized they brought au jus...iykyk. A few moments later she comes back and says I did order the prime rib and they were out of it. 🫩🙄 Ok. So I ate the mashed potatoes. They gave us half off and offered a free dessert. Which they ran out of that also. The place was completely booked, how do you not have enough for a 7pm reservation. We'll be back, but without encouragement it's going to be a long time. Very disappointed. And I'll withhold my recommendations until I'm sure they are in a good place again, because last night ruined it for me.

John Stark

We have going to this establishment for many years unfortunately this is the third time and last time we will be going! The recent menu changes and cold food and the salt that is being used is beyond daily limits!!!! It’s unfortunate that it has to come to this because obviously the owner didn’t care that he is causing so many lips cracking and needing to get hooked up to a fire hose to quench the salt 🧂!! The soup was just plain broth with salt and flavoring!! Maybe they ran out of onions! Well I hope that was the case!

Alyssa

I was refraining from writing this review but after two recent poor experiences I feel as if it is warranted. The recent menu changes were a poor idea. They removed sides from dinners and made the meals more expensive. We ordered two, chicken penne ala vodka meals and two salads (additional for the sides and for the chicken) and our total came out to $75! The meal wasn’t even flavorful and the salads were skimpy. When we went in to eat a month ago, the young hostess was rude when I asked if we could wait to sit at a booth because we were waiting for friends. She said it would be a long wait so instead we were sat in the back corner of the restaurant where it was so quiet that we didn’t even feel comfortable having a conversation. I asked if we could be moved to a booth near the bar, even if it meant waiting an hour and she was extremely rude with us. Her shortness of words, grabbing of the menus, and actions spoke volumes. Between these two events, I am having a hard time supporting a business that is so close to home.

Maggie Ordway

I'm not sure what's happened but our recent experience wasn't the best. The menu has changed and although prices went up the dinners no longer include a salad/soup and roll. The banana cream pie was awful and we threw it away (used to be good ) . The banana was served on the side in the dirty old peel to go ?? What the heck. Probably won't be our go to any longer.

We used to LOVE this place. We haven't been in quite a while. We ordered for pick up last night and no one had anything positive to say. I see they are cutting corners and no longer concerned with qu…

Walked in with my wife and my mother to have a nice lunch. Parking lot had MAYBE five cars in it. waited to be seated by the hostess who was VERY condescending and rude.Turned around and walked rig…

I came into this restaurant blind sighted and I was not impressed to say the least. I got the New York strip steak, a caesar salad, and a side of mashed potatoes. The steak was absolutely horrible,…

This was the worst dining experience I have from the food to the service from the bartender ever had and would never ever go back.

This was the worst dining experience I have from the food to the service from the bartender ever had and would never ever go back.

This was the worst dining experience I have from the food to the service from the bartender ever had and would never ever go back.

We’ve came here for years, but the last few visits have been awful. Today I got a chicken Caesar wrap, for a $21 wrap I’m expecting it to be pretty good. There’s maybe a tablespoon of dressing on the entire thing, and it’s just thinly spread onto the tortilla. The lettuce, croutons and chicken are completely dry. I’d expect a little more effort for these prices. I could’ve made a better wrap at home. Our waitress also never came back for a quality check and wasn’t particularly pleasant. Unfortunately as long time customers, we won’t be back.

Anastasi & co.

3 out of 4 people in my party had the prime rib with a baked potato, although the flavor of the prime rib was outstanding it would have been magnificent if it was not stone cold. The potato was also cold. Our waiter was disengaged from the task at hand, let's just say a 2 on a scale of 1 to 10. This was an extremely disappointing experience.

Marisa Howlan

I went for a birthday dinner on Thursday 10/23. I ordered the southwest chicken wrap with crispy chicken, and my friend ordered a chicken salad. My wrap came out with grilled chicken instead, and I waited for my waiter to come back over to tell him of the mistake. He apologized and took it back to get fixed. We waited over 20 minutes for them to come back with the correct wrap, and the waiter's excuse was "it's the busy dinner rush." I explained mine should have been taken care of before making other's meals. He again apologized. At that point my friend's chicken was cold because she did not want to eat without me having my meal. My wrap was probably the worst wrap I have ever eaten and was definitely not a "southwest" wrap (they want you to dip it in the ranch); not sure what has happened to Raindancer but it has gone down hill. The chicken tenders were rubbery and not crispy, and the fries were undercooked and tasteless. I ended up eating only half the wrap because it was gross. They did end up not charging me for my wrap (which I appreciated), but regardless of the food taking way too long, the meal was horrible. I will not be going back just because of the food alone.