Menu
Papa John's
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Papa John's
Photos

Papa John's

Pizza · Arcadia

3.6 · 153 reviews Google
locations.papajohns.com

About Papa John's

At Papa John's Arcadia, we're dedicated to serving up classic pizzas with a personal touch. We offer a variety of specialty pizzas, wings, sides, and desserts to satisfy every craving. Our guests rave about our mouth-watering dishes, from the signature square cut pizza to our crispy, flavorful wings...

At Papa John's Arcadia, we're dedicated to serving up classic pizzas with a personal touch. We offer a variety of specialty pizzas, wings, sides, and desserts to satisfy every craving. Our guests rave about our mouth-watering dishes, from the signature square cut pizza to our crispy, flavorful wings. In an intimate setting, you can enjoy our pizzas in the cozy Arcadia location at 1312 S Baldwin Ave. We're proud to have built a loyal following of customers who appreciate our focus on quality ingredients and attentive service.

What Customers Say About Papa John's

Papa John's in Arcadia receives mixed reviews. While some customers praise the pizza quality, generous cheese, and manager Miguel's service recovery, many report issues with rude staff, poor customer service, and order inaccuracies. Delivery limitations to Pasadena are also a concern.

Popular Dishes

pizza (11) cheese pizza wings lemon pepper spicy wings breadsticks

Best For

Families Quick Bite Casual

Tip: Download the Papa John's application for better pricing and options compared to other food delivery apps.

Features

🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner
🎯 Casual

What to see nearby

Fairview Avenue Park
A 525m

Fairview Avenue Park

parque

View details
Tripolis Park
A 704m

Tripolis Park

parque

View details
Our Lady of the Angels Church
A 908m

Our Lady of the Angels Church

iglesia

View details

Data from Wikidata

Explore the area around Papa John's

Papa John's is located in Arcadia, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.

Religious Buildings

  • Our Lady of the Angels Church (A 908m) — church in Arcadia, California

Parks & Gardens

  • Fairview Avenue Park (A 525m) — park in Los Angeles County, California, United States of America
  • Tripolis Park (A 704m) — park in the United States of America

Data from Wikidata

Frequently asked questions about Papa John's

Papa John's is located at 1312 S Baldwin Ave, Arcadia, CA 91007, Arcadia.
Near Papa John's you can find points of interest such as Fairview Avenue Park, Tripolis Park, Our Lady of the Angels Church.
Papa John's offers pizza cuisine.
Papa John's has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Papa John's offers the following services: takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Papa John's based on customer reviews are: pizza, cheese pizza, wings, lemon pepper spicy wings, breadsticks.
Papa John's is ideal for families, quick bites, casual dining.
Papa John's in Arcadia receives mixed reviews. While some customers praise the pizza quality, generous cheese, and manager Miguel's service recovery, many report issues with rude staff, poor customer service, and order inaccuracies. Delivery limitations to Pasadena are also a concern.
Download the Papa John's application for better pricing and options compared to other food delivery apps.
153
Reviews

Papa John's Arcadia Reviews

3.6
153
5★
46%
4★
15%
3★
10%
2★
7%
1★
22%
Reviews (40)
C
Craig McKenna

Great experience. Big improvement in food and service than it was a year ago. It is becoming my families go to place for Saturday pizza+wings and movie night at home

R
Ruth Kolta

Great pizza. Great price. On-time order called in.

E
Elias Assaf

You can't go wrong with Papa John's. I recommend downloading the application instead of ordering via any other food app delivery for much better pricing and options.

T
Travis Compton

Long time fan of Papa John's. First time customer at this location. Initially I had an issue with my order but the manager Miguel quickly made the situation right. Really satisfied with my experience here and will be back

N
Nadia Wei

We only order pizzas from this Papa John store. Never had any issues with the order. Always extra soft and lots of cheese on our cheese pizza!

R
RACHELLE RODRIGUEZ

This is by far the best pizza to go to. I ordered the heart shaped pizza and it was too cute. My son dug in before I could take a picture. This place is better then dominoes.

Ruth Kolta
Ruth Kolta

Great pizza. Great price. On-time order called in.

Craig McKenna
Craig McKenna

Great experience. Big improvement in food and service than it was a year ago. It is becoming my families go to place for Saturday pizza+wings and movie night at home

Elias Assaf
Elias Assaf

You can't go wrong with Papa John's. I recommend downloading the application instead of ordering via any other food app delivery for much better pricing and options.

Nadia Wei
Nadia Wei

We only order pizzas from this Papa John store. Never had any issues with the order. Always extra soft and lots of cheese on our cheese pizza!

Travis Compton
Travis Compton

Long time fan of Papa John's. First time customer at this location. Initially I had an issue with my order but the manager Miguel quickly made the situation right. Really satisfied with my experience here and will be back

C
Camille Rios

The food is delicious, but today they didn't put a pepperoncini on the side of the pizza like they usually do. They also only give one small sauce for 8 large breadsticks. Other than that, the service was quick and staff were friendly and the waiting area was clean. I'd recommend this place for yummy pizza.

Camille Rios
Camille Rios

The food is delicious, but today they didn't put a pepperoncini on the side of the pizza like they usually do. They also only give one small sauce for 8 large breadsticks. Other than that, the service was quick and staff were friendly and the waiting area was clean. I'd recommend this place for yummy pizza.

p
patrick ruddell

Don't worry folks, there's light at the end of the tunnel. I live in Pasadena and they said they can't deliver to me because of the distance, twice, on two different occasions. I called again recently, and they said the same old thing. Little do they know, I called them out on the distance between other Papa Johns. It turns out, they are, they are in fact the closest...1.2 miles?... It was delivered just fine. Call em out people. The pizzas great, the employees, well, not so great

patrick ruddell
patrick ruddell

Don't worry folks, there's light at the end of the tunnel. I live in Pasadena and they said they can't deliver to me because of the distance, twice, on two different occasions. I called again recently, and they said the same old thing. Little do they know, I called them out on the distance between other Papa Johns. It turns out, they are, they are in fact the closest...1.2 miles?... It was delivered just fine. Call em out people. The pizzas great, the employees, well, not so great

麦田

Last week my wife ordered a pizza, used a coupon, and paid a $3.00 tip. When picking up the food, the staff was very indifferent and even rude. This was a very unpleasant experience. We will never order pizza from this store again.

A
Alejandro Martinez

Pizza is good. But customer service is no good. You can tell the guy the guy that takes your money doesn’t like to work there . They close at 9pm . I ordered my pizza at 8 pm . It was ready in 15 min . I get there and I am going to lay with my atm and he tells me we are closed . Only cash after 8. HES like the lady on the phone didn’t tell you and I said no. So I had to go to the bank to take out the money . I asked him when did they start that and he couldn’t answer it. The guy was just lazy straight out .

Lisa Chang
Lisa Chang

You ever feel like you're invisible? The staff at this Papa John's will make sure you feel that way. You can stand at their counter for 15 minutes and not a single employee will realize you're there. If you're thinking, "Oh, they're busy, they'll help me eventually when they have time." Don't. Because they will not notice you.

麦田
麦田

Last week my wife ordered a pizza, used a coupon, and paid a $3.00 tip. When picking up the food, the staff was very indifferent and even rude. This was a very unpleasant experience. We will never order pizza from this store again.

Alejandro Martinez
Alejandro Martinez

Pizza is good. But customer service is no good. You can tell the guy the guy that takes your money doesn’t like to work there . They close at 9pm . I ordered my pizza at 8 pm . It was ready in 15 min . I get there and I am going to lay with my atm and he tells me we are closed . Only cash after 8. HES like the lady on the phone didn’t tell you and I said no. So I had to go to the bank to take out the money . I asked him when did they start that and he couldn’t answer it. The guy was just lazy straight out .

D
Donghee Lee

This is what we got for a $30 pizza. We didn’t even get the philly cheesesteak topping (we added mushrooms, pineapple, green pepper & Philly cheesesteak), and can barely see the mushrooms. The store didn’t pick up when we tried to call.

A
Afrina Sharmin

I got a hair in it. I wish I could go back or open it when I was there. I hope they will be more professional in service. I have never given any negative review! But this time I couldn’t stop myself. Please try to pay more attention while making and serving it. I may not go there again. I know it was a mistake but in this competitive food business industry you must have to be more careful about your customer service. They have so many options so customer retention is important.

P
Pete C

I had a terrible experience here. The person working at the register seemed upset the moment I walked in. I kindly mentioned I had placed an order through Uber Eats, provided my order details, and showed him the screen with my name as he requested. Then, he insisted on verifying my phone number, which I knew wasn’t necessary for Uber Eats orders. When I pointed this out, he became visibly annoyed and started making loud, dramatic noises with the pizza boxes. The whole situation felt unnecessarily confrontational and unprofessional. This place isn’t worth the drama. I’d recommend taking your business elsewhere.

Donghee Lee
Donghee Lee

This is what we got for a $30 pizza. We didn’t even get the philly cheesesteak topping (we added mushrooms, pineapple, green pepper & Philly cheesesteak), and can barely see the mushrooms. The store didn’t pick up when we tried to call.

Afrina Sharmin
Afrina Sharmin

I got a hair in it. I wish I could go back or open it when I was there. I hope they will be more professional in service. I have never given any negative review! But this time I couldn’t stop myself. Please try to pay more attention while making and serving it. I may not go there again. I know it was a mistake but in this competitive food business industry you must have to be more careful about your customer service. They have so many options so customer retention is important.

Pete C
Pete C

I had a terrible experience here. The person working at the register seemed upset the moment I walked in. I kindly mentioned I had placed an order through Uber Eats, provided my order details, and showed him the screen with my name as he requested. Then, he insisted on verifying my phone number, which I knew wasn’t necessary for Uber Eats orders. When I pointed this out, he became visibly annoyed and started making loud, dramatic noises with the pizza boxes. The whole situation felt unnecessarily confrontational and unprofessional. This place isn’t worth the drama. I’d recommend taking your business elsewhere.

E
Earl Hsu

It is an end of an era. I used to only ever buy my pizza at this Papa John's, no Pizza Hut, no Little Caesars, no Blazin Pizza. I dedicated myself to this specific Papa John's for 15+ years of my life living in Arcadia. Recently, apparently they changed management, and all the changes came with it. The weak flavored battery acid pizza sauce, the sparce amount of Canadian ham and pineapple on my Hawaiian Pizza. I used to look forward to Pizza nights, but now I don't care much for it, because the Pizza just didn't taste as good as before, when it was made by the special needs workers that the local Papa John's hired. I hope the special needs workers weren't fired and instead found a better job, but I will always miss your fantastic pizzas. I will be supporting my local Lil Caesars from now on, RIP Papa John's Arcadia.

R
Robert W. Gilliam

Last night I placed an order for (1) eight piece lemon pepper spicy wings. The wings had a very small amount of the sauce across all eight wings. I had to add my own sauce upon arriving home. NOTHING compared as advertised in the current commercial. Not impressed at all by the advertised product or the customer service at this Papa Johns location. I’m not going to give up on Papa Johns just yet. I hope to have better luck at different location.

J
Jojo Tutu

whoever was on the line, manager or whatever keeps hanging up on me without proper confirmation of what i needed help on. first time hung up on me as i was explaining the situation so i wasn’t sure he heard me. second time, he hung up when i only said i needed to cancel my order. third time, he yelled at me that it was cancelled when i just needed to confirm if he needed an order number. IF HE LISTENED TO ME THE FIRST PHONE CALL WITHOUT ENDING THE CALL AFTER 1 MINUTE, he wouldn’t need to hear me call back. very rude old man and probably miserable. i can’t believe i still said thank you to him. not even a you’re welcome. it could have been in his grumpy crusty tone too. he should at least finish his job. he really chose war in the morning. :P

S
Susan Mansoori

Very rude workers here. I hope they didn’t spit in my pizza because I asked for two red pepper packets and they were upset about me not paying 10 cents each.

J
Jai'Shawn Brown

The store manager "Richard" I believe that's his name. Store number #1829 is one of the nastiest rudest managers I've ever spoken to in my life. I was calling to place a new order, but I also wanted to let him know about a pervious order. He got so rude and disrespectful with me to were I wanted to go to the store and confront him. The say he handle the call was sooooo unprofessional. I need help with this issue!!!

y
yufang hao

This place’s staff was so rude!!!!! I’m an Uber driver and received two orders from this store this night around 7pm. I went there right away, when I got there the front door was closed but the light was on. I called the store and a staff came to the front of the door. I told him I came for pickup, he look at my phone and said they are closed in a very rude manner and ask me to cancel the orders... then he closed the light..... When I get back to my car and canceled I saw he turn on the light again... I’m like if you don’t want to work just resign please, or close your Uber service. Don’t waste others time............

A
Adriana Antonio

This is the worst pizza store because customer service is so bad. Michael was the person who attended my phone call, he was so rude, he was not polite and when l tried to tell him stop for being so rude and l asked for the store manager he told me he was and he asked me to go to another store. Do you think this is a good manner to deal with customers? It is not fair.

Earl Hsu
Earl Hsu

It is an end of an era. I used to only ever buy my pizza at this Papa John's, no Pizza Hut, no Little Caesars, no Blazin Pizza. I dedicated myself to this specific Papa John's for 15+ years of my life living in Arcadia. Recently, apparently they changed management, and all the changes came with it. The weak flavored battery acid pizza sauce, the sparce amount of Canadian ham and pineapple on my Hawaiian Pizza. I used to look forward to Pizza nights, but now I don't care much for it, because the Pizza just didn't taste as good as before, when it was made by the special needs workers that the local Papa John's hired. I hope the special needs workers weren't fired and instead found a better job, but I will always miss your fantastic pizzas. I will be supporting my local Lil Caesars from now on, RIP Papa John's Arcadia.

Susan Mansoori
Susan Mansoori

Very rude workers here. I hope they didn’t spit in my pizza because I asked for two red pepper packets and they were upset about me not paying 10 cents each.

Jojo Tutu
Jojo Tutu

whoever was on the line, manager or whatever keeps hanging up on me without proper confirmation of what i needed help on. first time hung up on me as i was explaining the situation so i wasn’t sure he heard me. second time, he hung up when i only said i needed to cancel my order. third time, he yelled at me that it was cancelled when i just needed to confirm if he needed an order number. IF HE LISTENED TO ME THE FIRST PHONE CALL WITHOUT ENDING THE CALL AFTER 1 MINUTE, he wouldn’t need to hear me call back. very rude old man and probably miserable. i can’t believe i still said thank you to him. not even a you’re welcome. it could have been in his grumpy crusty tone too. he should at least finish his job. he really chose war in the morning. :P

Robert W. Gilliam
Robert W. Gilliam

Last night I placed an order for (1) eight piece lemon pepper spicy wings. The wings had a very small amount of the sauce across all eight wings. I had to add my own sauce upon arriving home. NOTHING compared as advertised in the current commercial. Not impressed at all by the advertised product or the customer service at this Papa Johns location. I’m not going to give up on Papa Johns just yet. I hope to have better luck at different location.

Jai'Shawn Brown
Jai'Shawn Brown

The store manager "Richard" I believe that's his name. Store number #1829 is one of the nastiest rudest managers I've ever spoken to in my life. I was calling to place a new order, but I also wanted to let him know about a pervious order. He got so rude and disrespectful with me to were I wanted to go to the store and confront him. The say he handle the call was sooooo unprofessional. I need help with this issue!!!

Adriana Antonio
Adriana Antonio

This is the worst pizza store because customer service is so bad. Michael was the person who attended my phone call, he was so rude, he was not polite and when l tried to tell him stop for being so rude and l asked for the store manager he told me he was and he asked me to go to another store. Do you think this is a good manner to deal with customers? It is not fair.

yufang hao
yufang hao

This place’s staff was so rude!!!!! I’m an Uber driver and received two orders from this store this night around 7pm. I went there right away, when I got there the front door was closed but the light was on. I called the store and a staff came to the front of the door. I told him I came for pickup, he look at my phone and said they are closed in a very rude manner and ask me to cancel the orders... then he closed the light..... When I get back to my car and canceled I saw he turn on the light again... I’m like if you don’t want to work just resign please, or close your Uber service. Don’t waste others time............

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Arcadia →
📸

Gallery

📸

No photos available

Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places

📍

About Papa John's

How to get there

1312 S Baldwin Ave, Arcadia, CA 91007

Loading map...
Papa John's
Tap for directions

Highlights

💬
Many Reviews
153 reviews
💰
Budget Friendly
Price level
👨‍🍳
pizza
Cuisine type

Services

🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
🍰 Desserts
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Dining Options

🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11AM-2AM
Rating
3.6/5
💬 Reviews
153
💰 Price Level
$
⏱️ Typical Visit
People typically spend 5 min to 1 hr here
📞 Phone
+1 626-445-6262
🌐 Website
locations.papajohns.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

🅿️ Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Fairview Avenue Park

park in Los Angeles County, California, United States of America

A 525m
Tripolis Park

park in the United States of America

A 704m
Our Lady of the Angels Church

church in Arcadia, California

A 908m
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Papa John's and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Papa John's!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Papa John's

🏆 Rewards at Papa John's

💰

10% Discount

At Papa John's

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it